usually in one on one unit test this is the case but you must consider that a cav general is more powerful than a foot general and is worth several regular knights in his own right.
usually in multiplayer most players rarely have time to set up a good charge into a schiltrom but if they do they deserve the benefits but at the risk of ruining half the unit and snagging up a cav unit that could be used in the cav melee.
only a well lined up charge will smash a schiltrom and usually it can only do it in one charge if it has a general otherwise it can take several before they crack which is valuable time which could be spent doing something better with said unit.however even a well formed up charge by light horse can break spears.
but there are "other" formations of spearmen which have been found by some in other forum discussions that seem to work better versus cav but easily broken vs infantry.
Bookmarks