Quote Originally Posted by AndresTheCunning
Well, Dutch and I agreed at the beginning of the game that he would lurk, since he never posts alot in mafia games. I would be the noisy one, the "innocent" townie, prosecuting whoever seemed suspicious, making sure a townie would get lynched every round.

We started to kill off the lurkers for 2 reasons: 1) the detective might be lurking ; 2) let the quarelling townies lynch each other.

At the beginning of the game, I was convinced the detective was either Sigurd (who got lynched, yeeha!) or Destroyer of Hope (replaced by faust), so Orb was a very lucky kill.

Our tactic worked quite well, until Kommodus came up with 'holmes'.

I wasn't aware that my posting habits would get me detected by 'holmes' (heck, I didn't even know about the existence of such an evil tool). I was pretty convinced that I was acting rather normal compared to other games. So I started to throw accusations at him, casting doubts, trying the best I could to make that sound reasonable, and it seemed to work. Meanwhile, it was good to hear that Dutch was considered to be very very innocent.

Sasaki's absence in the thread came as a gift. I was very happy that the annoying Sasaki would get lynched, so we didn't have to murder him.

After that, we entered a crucial phase. CR's lurking and posting in other threads was another gift, so it seemed. But than he screams 'I'm not mafia'. I thought: 'Hahaha, thank you CR, that will get you lynched'. Alas, I didn't know CR's reputation of 'the honest, never lying player'.

And Dutch got lynched instead with the narrow margin of one vote... He did a helluva job defending himself, but unfortunately my buddy got lynched.

Afterwards, I saw the post which Kommodus deleted quickly to avoid giving clues to the mafia. I pm'd it to Dutch and we had a little discussion about it. We decided to kill Ichigo, since I was under the impression (from our conversation in the chat) that he didn't trust me at all and I feared he would turn against me. CA was very willing to follow Kommodus, so we decided to kill him as well.

I would try to go after CR. If that wouldn't work, I would let me 'convince' by his innocence and turn my arrows at Kommodus. When you all seemed 100 % sure that it had to be me or Stig (I didn't expect that to happen), I had to think about an explanation why I believed it wasn't Kommodus or CR (and that hurted so bad, deep in my heart, I wanted to see that annoying Kommodus lynched by the mob). I tried to frame Stig, and it almost worked: CR unvoted and voted abstain, Kage popped up and voted Stig... At that time we were soooo close. I was hoping CR wouldn't get online in time to cast his vote and would get WoG'ed for voting abstain, resulting in a tie --> night phase --> three kills=mafia victory.

Alas, CR came back in time, I wasn't here in that last couple of hours because of real life, I came back and noticed it was over...

Great game. Had alot of fun. Thank you, (evil) GH
If you wouldn't of killed me you would have most likely have won. Cause I thought Stig was guilty.