I guess someone did a mistake...

Tally:
Not voting: 9 (Chugg, Dutch, Fenring, Ignoramus, JimBob, Kommodus, Lord Motep, pever, Warluster)

Xiahou : 6 (ByzantineKnight, CountA, Sasaki, Sigurd, Stig, Xiahou)
Sigurd : 5 (Andres, Kage, Pannonian, Redleg, Seamus)
Kommodus: 1 (CR)
Reenk: 1 (Faust)
Pannoninan: 1 (Ichigo)
Sasaki: 1 (Reenk)


Apparently we should not have this revote...

But should the narrator not consider this, Vote:Sigurd

Reply

But he won't, & you can pretend it was all a grand mistake. How Machiavellian!

Reply

It was not my mistake... and there is no pretending. A mistake is a mistake and I caught it. Should I not have brought this to GH's attention?

Reply

Of course you should bring it GH's attention. You're Mafia & you should want to stay alive. The re-vote looks like it might go against you so it is in your interests that this mistake is brought to light.

Just like when you put your vote back on Xiahou when it looked like you were to going to be lynched.........

Reply

No you are were Mafia... and we lynched you.

Why should we listen to a lynched player? You have not been proven innocent.

Reply

You've not been proven innocent either. My lynching is irrelevant. Why are you so concerned about my contribution to the thread?

The evidence against you is stacking up. This game you have been guilty of:

1. Bandwagonning
2. Deliberately illogical reasoning
3. Retaliation voting
4. Demonstrating a suspicious attachment to staying alive
5. Lurking for significant periods of the game
6. Questioning the need for open & honest debate

Dutch guy - I think we're arguing the same, but differently here. In short, if that vote tally is correct, then Xiahou should be lynched. I think it unlikely GH will decide otherwise without very good reason.

I do think (as you do, it appears) that Sigurd is showing an unhealthy devotion to staying alive, & that it does indeed 'brand him as a mafioso'.

EDIT: I posted at the same time as Andres, so I'm not ignoring his call for silence by posting. I will, however, now shut up.

Reply

His behavior convinced me he was mafia in TGFII...turns out he was town. In my experience he's a lot more careful as mafia.

There's no hurry.

Reply

If that mistake is truthfully a mistake, then I daresay bringing that to GH's attention would immediately brand him as a mafioso. If GH confirms this as a valid mistake, I'll vote Xiahou since it' d be quite unfair to lynch someone in a revote when he would have missed out on that revote had the count been correct.

Reply