I'm back, and I'm looking for someone to kill [Concluded]

[pevergreen]

rightio. Im still alive.

Kommo, if you could post results at some time, or at least point us in the right direction a bit.

Out of the alive people:
AndrestheCunning
WarMaster Horus
Sasaki Kojiro
GBB
CF
RoadKill
pevergreen
BlackAxe
CountArach
rdeče.jabolko

I am suspicious of:
AndrestheCunning
WarMaster Horus
Sasaki Kojiro
GBB
CF
RoadKill
BlackAxe
rdeče.jabolko

If i had to cut it down:
AndrestheCunning
CF
RoadKill
BlackAxe
rdeče.jabolko

rdeče.jabolko i havent seen much from you...

Anyone elses take?

Sasaki, you arent attacking as much as usual, im putting it down to lack of time/enthusiasim.

Ill re-read.

[pevergreen]

right.

Im thinking one mafia is experienced as CR was killed night one. Takes away his power to be believed by not lieing.

The accusation of a newbie frame on blackaxe by sasaki, rings true for what he would do.

Why the hurry then?You know some people cant came here for timezones...
Also, you poster an hour ago.Again, why the hurry

This is unusual.

Blackaxe points out he is a noob. But too over the top.


Most likely mafia:
Blackaxe
CF


makes sense, as these two i can see not sending in kill write ups.

Most likely detctive:
Kommo

Nothing posted results wise after death.

Most likely GF:
Sasaki

not attacking people like he normally does, plus the charade with blackaxe looks faked to me.
Thats all IMO of course.

(edit: added descriptions in)

[Stig]

Sasaki would choose experienced mafia as his helpers. I wouldn't choose Kommo or GH (or maybe only 1 of them), as they are highly suspicious. After that you get a whole range of players with 5 or more games who are pretty good at this game (but most of them aren't in this game)

[Andres]

Still Alive:
AndrestheCunning
Sasaki Kojiro
CF
RoadKill
pevergreen
BlackAxe
CountArach
rdeče.jabolko

Killed:
CR
Motep
HughTower
Dutch_guy
GH
Kommodus
WarMaster Horus
GBB

Lynched:
Omanes
Stig
OldSchool

Suicide:
DoH

WoGed:
Ignoramus

With 8 still alive, I think it's time to reveal:

You have been selected as the detective in my mafia game. Your role is to PM me every night phase with someone you want to investigate. You may not reveal after death, and you must reveal to everyone in the thread no revealing to individuals. Good luck, and enjoy the game!

Ichigo

My investigations:

Night one: GH - innocent
Night two: Kommodus - innocent
Night three: Sasaki - innocent
Night four: pevergreen - innocent

A PM-conversation I had with Ichigo:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

[QUOTE=Ichigo]

You have been selected as the detective in my mafia game. Your role is to PM me every night phase with someone you want to investigate. You may not reveal after death, and you must reveal to everyone in the thread no revealing to individuals. Good luck, and enjoy the game!

Ichigo

Well, never had the honor of being the detective...

Thank you Ichigo In return, I'll try to let the town lynch you in the next mafia game you participate in

Some questions: 1) do I get the role of the player I investigate (if I am lucky and pick the GF, will I know he is GF, or will you only tell me "guilty" or "not guilty"?, in the latter case, I have an additional question, is the GF "guilty" or not (I knew in capo GF's turned out innocent when investigated); 2) mafia always has two kills? If the two mafioso are dead but GF still alive, the GF can kill?; 3) does the GF have special abilities like investigating or protecting someone from something?

As for my first investigation: it doesn't always have to be Sasaki... so: Investigate : GeneralHankerchief

Ciao,

Andres.

1. No, you don't get there role you only get innocent or guilty. The GF will be innocent if you investigate him, but his henchmen will come up guilty.

2. Yes, that reminds me I forgot to address that in the thread.

3. No, I didn't give the GF any special abilities.

A little tip if you PM you investigation before the mafia PM's who they want to kill, then you will get your investigations back before the kills.

Ichigo

So, my investigations only learned us that Sasaki and pevergreen are not the henchman of the GF.

Anyway, this means at least two of these are mafia:

CF
RoadKill
BlackAxe
CountArach
rdeče.jabolko


Another intresting conversation I had:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

I know it's very early, but what do you think? Would this be a good time to reveal?

Well you've investigated two big people Kommo and GH. Why do you ask?

I'm feeling a bit uncomfortable in this detective role. Actually, I'm trying to look a bit scummy, to attract some votes and thus avoiding to get killed by the mafia (i hope they are clever and experienced enough not to kill those who are likely to get lynched), but I'm getting a feeling that I'm beginning to look a bit too suspicious...

When does the voting period stop (and what's that in GMT +1?).

It's clear that I would reveal if I'm about to get lynched let's say 30 minutes before the voting period closes, but if the voting period ends while I'm asleep, I can't do that.

Is there some way for you to reveal my role in case I get lynched? It's obvious I won't reveal until it's 100 % that I'm going to get lynched.

But as for now, it seems like Stig is going to die, so maybe I was just panicking at the time I pm'ed you.

Gah, different timezones suck.

Andres.

Smart move. It'll close in 3 and a half hours.

I doubt you'll get lynched, but if you do get ahead reveal there's a role that might be able to save you from the mafia

If your lynched I'll probably somehow work it into the write-up.

So, apparantly there is/was somebody else with a pro-town role. GH stated firmly that CF was innocent, so maybe GH was the one with the special role. Let's assume GH is 100 % sure about CF, we have these guys left:

RoadKill
BlackAxe
CountArach
rdeče.jabolko

Let's see how rdeče.jabolko responds when there is some real pressure on him:

Vote : rdeče.jabolko

And remember, if we lynch the right one today, the town still has a chance to win this:

Some other things I forgot to mention. If one of the henchmen is killed there will only be one kill afterwards. If both henchmen are dead then there will still be one kill by the GF.

[Warmaster Horus]

What? What happened? Why me? Who could have done this?
GAH!
At least it makes people forget about my stupidity.

[pevergreen]

RoadKill
BlackAxe
CountArach
rdeče.jabolko

Are possible Henchmen,

RoadKill
BlackAxe
CountArach
rdeče.jabolko
pevergreen
Sasaki
are possible GF's

I obviously presume I am innocent, which leaves

RoadKill
BlackAxe
CountArach
rdeče.jabolko
Sasaki

Will put my opinions out after everyone on that list posts.

[HughTower]

Nice reveal, Andres.

On that basis then, rdeče.jabolko should definitely be targeted with a lynch. He's shown himself to be happy to put himself about in his first few Mafia games & the Mafia's victims (until this round) have all been (relatively) experienced & logical players.

On that logical basis, I would make the assumption that BlackAxe & Roadkill are his henchman.

[scotchedpommes]

I am surprised at the willingness to follow Pever and initiate a bandwagon,
when it looks to me like a possible attempt to immediately deflect
attention from himself, as he too remains a suspect.

Nice reveal, Andres.

On that basis then, rdeče.jabolko should definitely be targeted with a lynch. He's shown himself to be happy to put himself about in his first few Mafia games & the Mafia's victims (until this round) have all been (relatively) experienced & logical players.

On that logical basis, I would make the assumption that BlackAxe & Roadkill are his henchman.

I'm taken aback by this, also. Given that you weren't here for my first few mafia
games this strikes me as a flawed observation. Then, as now, I was busy with
other things away from here; more recently moving out of my previous
accommodation. While I'm not going to go to the lengths Stig did, I will say I
was content in the previous rounds to catch up whenever I came online,
[posting in my regular frontroom thread, yes] and I'm disappointed some of you
would throw away crucial votes at this point.


In light of Pever's initial vote, I feel compelled to vote for him, regardless of
opinions on open retaliation, he is still a candidate for 'scum'.

Vote: Pervegrun

In honour of your unique butchery.

[Caius]

What? What happened? Why me? Who could have done this?
GAH!
At least it makes people forget about my stupidity.

I know It sucks Warmaster, but you were very active.
The mafia needs less discussion, as there is a posibilty they make a mistake.

Andres,I should go for BlackAxe.

But you will be sooner or later dead.The mafia will try to kill you.

Unless you have something useful for say

Vote:BlackAxe

[Warmaster Horus]

For some reason, I don't see who could have wanted me dead... Good luck town! You're gonna need it!

[RoadKill]

@hugh
How could I possibly be a henchmen? This is one of my first mafia games and i doubt I will be picked as a henchmen, besides that fact why would I have been protecting GH when he is obviously innocent? Therefore taking myself off the list rakejia, blackaxe, and countarch have to be possible henchmens therefore I vote Vote: CountArch What do you have to say on your defence?

[Andres]

Why are you guys voting pevergreen???

My investigation revealed he is innocent. Ok, there is still the possibility that he is the Godfather, but shouldn't it be better to concentrate on these people:

RoadKill
BlackAxe
CountArach
rdeče.jabolko

If we lynch a henchman, the mafia has only one kill per night left. If we lynch a townie, we have lost the game.

If we pick one of these four, we have 1/2 chance that we lynch a henchman, which will buy us time to win the game.

This round we need to lynch a mafioso. Concentrate on those four and we'll probably have one. Afterwards, the kills and the voting pattern in this round, will give us more clues and we can go looking for the godfather.

Unvote : rdeče.jabolko
Vote : CountArach


Tally:

CA: 1 (AndresTheCunning)
jabolko : 1 (BlackAxe)
Abstain : 1 (CF)
pevergreen: 3 (Sasaki, jabolko, Roadkill)
Roadkill: 2 (CountArach, pevergreen)

[Csargo]

Thanks Andres. I owe you one.

[RoadKill]

I don't know what to say, but looks like town loses then, if you guys lynch me, I don't know waht you want me to say but I am not a henchmen, I don't know how you guys want me to prove it.
EDIT: Spelling

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I don't know what to say, but looks like town loses then, if you guys lynch me, I don't know waht you want me to say but I am not a henchmen, I don't know how you guys want me to prove it.
EDIT: Spelling

Roadkill you only have a couple votes. You're not even in the lead. You seem really anxious here?


Andres, our odds going for godfather are about the same (1/3). And if we lynch a henchman tomorrow we have to lynch again the next day without an improvement in odds.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Sasaki, you arent attacking as much as usual, im putting it down to lack of time/enthusiasim.

Ill re-read.

I disagree. You haven't been around much though?

[pevergreen]

I had exam week, then SPWND. (www.spwnd.com)

Im on holidays now though.

[Andres]

I had exam week, then SPWND. (www.spwnd.com)

Im on holidays now though.

That didn't hold you from posting frequently at the Org

[pevergreen]

i got nothing from that link.

[Andres]

i got nothing from that link.

In the thread, click on you username, select the option "find more posts by pevergreen".

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Interesting. Pever, you never answered my question from earlier.