screwtype 07:04 03-24-2007
Originally Posted by Louis VI the Fat:
What, a woman gets beat up by a two hundred pound berserk beast and you're asking what she did wrong? Blaming the girl for provoking some poor defenseless guy without self control? Looking for the skirt that was too short?
No, I'm not
blaming her, but when someone is blind legless drunk it is wise to employ some tact. Now I thought I saw in some of that footage that she's sort of pushing and shoving at him before he loses his cool. Seems to me that's a very unwise thing to do.
Obviously the video shows something pretty ugly, I guess my concern was, what do we really know about this cop? Is this typical behaviour from him, or is it just one alcohol-soaked moment of loss of control in what might otherwise be a respectable career? Was he under any particular stress in order to get so very drunk, or is such drunkenness a pattern with him? I mean, it's easy to conclude from this video that the guy is some kind of monster, but how good would any of us look if our worst moment was caught on video?
They were my initial reactions, but then I guess one has to ask what kind of guy allows himself to get so smashed in the first place, and let's face it, it probably isn't the type of person you want wearing a badge. I think if he was a cop in
my town I'd want to see him out of the force, pronto.
Crazed Rabbit 08:16 03-24-2007
Originally Posted by screwtype:
Obviously the video shows something pretty ugly, I guess my concern was, what do we really know about this cop? Is this typical behaviour from him, or is it just one alcohol-soaked moment of loss of control in what might otherwise be a respectable career? Was he under any particular stress in order to get so very drunk, or is such drunkenness a pattern with him? I mean, it's easy to conclude from this video that the guy is some kind of monster, but how good would any of us look if our worst moment was caught on video?
This is Chicago, corrupt sewer of politicians and cops. He could have done this before and had his superiors know about it and still be on the force. He was arrested drunk driving two years before becoming a cop.
This is, most likely, not the exception to his behavior, but the rule. The only exception is this time a camera caught him.
I would hope all the cops in the US could say their worst moment is far better than this. In Chicago, though...
Crazed Rabbit
screwtype 09:13 03-24-2007
Originally Posted by Crazed Rabbit:
This is Chicago, corrupt sewer of politicians and cops. He could have done this before and had his superiors know about it and still be on the force. He was arrested drunk driving two years before becoming a cop.
This is, most likely, not the exception to his behavior, but the rule. The only exception is this time a camera caught him.
I would hope all the cops in the US could say their worst moment is far better than this. In Chicago, though...
Crazed Rabbit
Yeah, you're probably right. It's kind of unlikely this guy would be caught doing something like this on video if it wasn't an established pattern of behaviour.
Major Robert Dump 10:28 03-24-2007
he didn'ty know he was being taped.
and as far as her pushing him:
a)patrons arent allowed behind the bar without a liquor license
b)he had already assaulted the customer on the left earlier
someone should have broken a bottle and shanked him in his fat hamhock neck. you don't treat people like that, period, let alone a petite woman who is just trying to maintain order.
screwtype 16:38 03-24-2007
Originally Posted by Major Robert Dump:
someone should have broken a bottle and shanked him in his fat hamhock neck
Oh yes, let's just murder people who get drunk and behave like a-holes. That will do so much to improve social standards.
Originally Posted by Major Robert Dump:
he had already assaulted the customer on the left earlier
So why didn't the bartender just call the cops at that stage? Wouldn't that have been the sensible thing to do?
Pubs can get sued these days for failing to refuse alcohol to people who have clearly had too much. This guy was practically paralytic, why did the establishment wait so long before refusing to serve him?
And why was this petite bartender left to handle the guy all by herself? Wasn't there a bouncer, or some other male employees who could have helped her throw him out?
While the cop was clearly guilty of an assault here, it seems to me he may not have been the only party whose behaviour could be called into question.
I see nothing wrong with her behavior.
He tried to go behind the bar, she tried to stop him which she is suppose to do and he went berserk.
So nothing that really could be considered to be provoking except for a man who is hostile and aggressive in nature which is something she couldn't know before hand.
The bartender looks a lot better and that alone...
screwtype 17:52 03-24-2007
Originally Posted by TB666:
I see nothing wrong with her behavior
Okay, I guess what happened is that she refused to serve him more alcohol after he assaulted another customer, after which he got behind the bar to try to serve himself. She came back, tried to push him out from behind the bar, and he went nuts.
Her behaviour from that POV is understandable I guess, but why did she wait so long to stop serving him? And was it wise to start pushing a guy who had already shown a propensity for violence? I don't think she handled the situation well.
However, I do think at the very least that establishment should be looking at its policies concerning the serving of inebriated customers, and also be looking at enhancing security for its staff. That female bartender appeared to be looking after the bar all by herself, which is leaving her pretty vulnerable.
Crazed Rabbit 18:59 03-24-2007
Originally Posted by screwtype:
Oh yes, let's just murder people who get drunk and behave like a-holes. That will do so much to improve social standards.
So now, pummeling another person into the ground and stomping on them is just a-hole behavior? And besides, getting shanked doesn't necessarily kill you. I'm in total agreement with MRD here.
And you know what, I'm betting it definitely would improve social standards.
Originally Posted by :
This guy was practically paralytic, why did the establishment wait so long before refusing to serve him?
You're assuming an awful lot to support your view.
Crazed Rabbit
screwtype 07:41 03-25-2007
As I've already said, I'm not trying to excuse what this cop did. I'm simply saying I see a problem with a guy getting as sloshed as that in the first place.
My suspicion is that this place is a cheap dive that runs on minimum staff and has a policy of soaking customers to the last penny. That's my conclusion from this customer's state of inebriation and the apparent lack of security at the bar.
It doesn't the mean the cop must not be held responsible for his actions. But it might be argued that responsibility for this incident may at least to some extent be shared by an establishment that allowed him to reach such a state in the first place.
Single Sign On provided by
vBSSO