
Originally Posted by
HoreTore
Anyways, the problem with the UN are not the dictatorships, it is the democracies...
This is so true.
Many, if not most shortcomings of the U.N. stem from a lack of cooperation between its democratic members. As the authors state, the potential for democracies to collectively shape world politics is there. But they fail to analyse why this potential rarely materializes. Their view on the nature of cooperation between democracies borders on the naive:
It works not only because its members have common interests and shared values, but also because they have established procedures for overcoming disagreement in ways that both meet the interests of the members and ensure timely and effective action. Democracies work well with each other, above all perhaps, because their shared commitment to the rule of law and government of, by and for the people enables them to trust one another’s leadership. There is no place for intimidation or coercion in inter-democratic interactions, whereas relations between democracies and non-democracies are invariably infused with suspicion and mistrust.
Do democracies have common interests? I think the constant hassle between the U.S. and the European Union over trade policy proves that they don't necessarily have common interests.
Do democracies shun coercion and intimidation? I think that the Iraq episode proves that they don't. The U.S. was pressuring democracies such as Chile into supporting its position in the Security Council, whilst France was intimidating other democracies (such as the new member states of the EU) to give up their support for the U.S. position.
Do democracies share values? Yes they do, in the sense that they share a commitment to the rule of law and government by the people within their own borders. History has shown time and again that democracies are willing to sacrifice democracy elsewhere in the interest of their own freedom, their own autonomy, their own safety and their own economic and diplomatic interests. Democracies are selfish, just like all countries have been throughout history.
Bookmarks