I tried it once. I liked the idea of not running out of arrows.

On the other hand, the battle starts immediately with no opportunity to deploy what you want where you want it. In other words, archers stand uselessly on the street while the enemy army marches around the corner of the wall, where normally I can whittle the enemy army down by 20%. Also, while the battle is going on, you have to march your units to where they will be useful. You cannot position them to the formations you wish before "start battle" is implemented.

I'll stick with the timer, and remount and reload between turns.

Strength and Honor

Celt Centurion