Kung Fu Mafia [Concluded]

[Csargo]

THE BANDWAGON SMILEI!!! WHO SHALL I VOTE FOR!!!????

Tran

[BlackAxe3001]

If you insist.

Vote: Tran

EDIT: Forgot the vote count again...

Ichigo: 1 (GH)
Andres: 1 (BK)
BK: 5 (Tran, Redleg, Stig, Omanes, greaterkhaan)
CR: 1 (Andres)
Stig : 1 (CA)
TwilightBlade : 1 (pevergreen)
Xehh: 1 (Xdeathfire)
no lynch: 1 (HughTower)
Tran: 6 (Kommo, Crazed Rabbit, Orb, Ichigo, Caius, BlackAxe)

[Sigurd]

Before I turn in tonight.. I too want to try out the duelling thing.

Challenge: Discovery1 .. let's see what you are made of.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Unvote: Ichigo
Instead, Vote: ByzantineKnight
Challenge: Ichigo

[discovery1]

Before I turn in tonight.. I too want to try out the duelling thing.

Challenge: Discovery1 .. let's see what you are made of.

Sigurd, what did I ever do to you?
Yes, I know the persian has a big nose

THE SMILIE COMMANDS IT!!
Vote: tran

[Caius]

Tally


Andres: 1 (BK)
BK: 6 (Tran, Redleg, Stig, Omanes, greaterkhaan, GH)
CR: 1 (Andres)
Stig : 1 (CA)
TwilightBlade : 1 (pevergreen)
Xehh: 1 (Xdeathfire)
no lynch: 1 (HughTower)
Tran: 7 (Kommo, Crazed Rabbit, Orb, Ichigo, Caius, BlackAxe, Discovery1)

[pevergreen]

Tran is lynched? (is 7 or 12 to lynch? or is that a different game?)

[Orb]

7 to lynch. Poor tran.

[pevergreen]

ToS: disco
Immediate Suspicion on disco. As much as we love bandwagons, lynching him was not the best idea.

[Caius]

Sasaki had gone and maybe he isnt able to reply to us.

[pevergreen]

Maybe Sasaki is alseep? Moderators sleep too

[Caius]

If you insist.

Vote: Tran

And this is a bandwagon too

[pevergreen]

All of the last few voters on Tran are suspicious

[Caius]

All of the last few voters on Tran are suspicious

May I ask why?

[pevergreen]

It was blatant bandwagon. Kommodus' reasoning was sound, but not solely deserving of a premature lynch.

[TevashSzat]

Yes. For the number of votes on Byzantine Knight, it was because he was acting kinda suspicious and the votes that were garnered were do so slowly. For tran, he got 7 votes in just 5 ot 6 hours which is pretty quick.

Of the 7 who voted for tran, discovery1, Orb, and Ichigo were kinda lurking which is kinda suspicious, but discovery1 is the most suspicious of them all given that he was the final voter and did not participate at all before. Orb got on early and had a half decent post that basically agreed with Ichigo making me doubt that he is mafia. Finally, Ichigo is pretty suspicous too given that he encouraged a bandwagon after he jumped on one.

Blackaxe and Caius jumped on the bandwagon, but Blackaxe is the most suspicious to me given that he voted and then unvoted Caius in less than 45min and then quickly jumped onto the tran bandwagon without any stated reason.

To me, the most likely players to be mafia given the votes for tran is discovery1, Ichigo, and Blackaxe

[discovery1]

ToS: disco
Immediate Suspicion on disco. As much as we love bandwagons, lynching him was not the best idea.

ToS? Is taht the same as challenge?

[Caius]

from the mafia FAQ

ToS: Toe of Suspicion

[Caius]

Unvote: Ichigo
Instead, Vote: ByzantineKnight
Challenge: Ichigo

Why the challenge on Ichigo?

[BlackAxe3001]

Of the 7 who voted for tran, discovery1, Orb, and Ichigo were kinda lurking which is kinda suspicious, but discovery1 is the most suspicious of them all given that he was the final voter and did not participate at all before. Orb got on early and had a half decent post that basically agreed with Ichigo making me doubt that he is mafia. Finally, Ichigo is pretty suspicous too given that he encouraged a bandwagon after he jumped on one.

Um... why should I have to say "I agree with all the above on tran". It's pretty obvious that there was a dang good case against him...

Blackaxe and Caius jumped on the bandwagon, but Blackaxe is the most suspicious to me given that he voted and then unvoted Caius in less than 45min and then quickly jumped onto the tran bandwagon without any stated reason.

Did you even read the all of the posts? I misread what Caius was saying and then unvoted him. Your suspicious for not reading all the posts and just tossing suspicion on the last people to vote.

It was blatant bandwagon. Kommodus' reasoning was sound, but not solely deserving of a premature lynch.

Who would you have lynched then? Also, maybe he is deserving of a lynch, how would you know?




Oh, BTW Sasaki said he wouldn't be on until midnight since he would be driving all day... READ PEOPLE!!!

https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showp...&postcount=111

Very last line of his post...

[Tran]

Vote: Tran

For the following reasons:

1. His timing. He may have been watching the thread for a bit before casting this vote.

2. His "safe" voting and language. Saying as little as possible is an oft-used mafia tactic, as is voting for the most suspicious players.

3. His mildly accusatory tone in subsequent posts. Mafia like to appear to be trying to identify scum without angering anyone too much.

I'm not buying the arguments against BK; they look faulty to me. Making ignorant-sounding comments is frequently jumped on as suspicious, but it's not actually what mafia usually do.

- Tell me...why random vote is guilty? It's just a way to start the game...
- Why should I say much when obviously there's nothing I really have to say
- What do you really expect? You seems like a mafioso yourself...and like pever said, all the last voters on me are suspicious too, that made the following people very suspicious:
Kommodus
Ichigo
Caius
BlackAxe
Discovery1

[BlackAxe3001]

- Tell me...why random vote is guilty? It's just a way to start the game...
- Why should I say much when obviously there's nothing I really have to say
- What do you really expect? You seems like a mafioso yourself...and like pever said, all the last voters on me are suspicious too, that made the following people very suspicious:
Kommodus
Ichigo
Caius
BlackAxe
Discovery1

Why/how are we so suspicious than anyone else who voted? Explain.

[Tran]

If you insist.

Vote: Tran

EDIT: Forgot the vote count again...

Ichigo: 1 (GH)
Andres: 1 (BK)
BK: 5 (Tran, Redleg, Stig, Omanes, greaterkhaan)
CR: 1 (Andres)
Stig : 1 (CA)
TwilightBlade : 1 (pevergreen)
Xehh: 1 (Xdeathfire)
no lynch: 1 (HughTower)
Tran: 6 (Kommo, Crazed Rabbit, Orb, Ichigo, Caius, BlackAxe)

That, without reason, or like other people, voting using the "I agree with Kommodus" reason and nothing else, as an excuse to avoid being labelled as "bandwagon"...at least you can come up with better explanation yourself for voting me, but I see none.

[pevergreen]

This game does not require bandwagoning. I reccomend that everyone go to mafiascum.net and read at least one game. They play like this game, you get to -1 or -2 from lynch, and then they reveal.

[Csargo]

Unvote: Ichigo
Instead, Vote: ByzantineKnight
Challenge: Ichigo

Bring it.

Yes. For the number of votes on Byzantine Knight, it was because he was acting kinda suspicious and the votes that were garnered were do so slowly. For tran, he got 7 votes in just 5 ot 6 hours which is pretty quick.

Of the 7 who voted for tran, discovery1, Orb, and Ichigo were kinda lurking which is kinda suspicious, but discovery1 is the most suspicious of them all given that he was the final voter and did not participate at all before. Orb got on early and had a half decent post that basically agreed with Ichigo making me doubt that he is mafia. Finally, Ichigo is pretty suspicous too given that he encouraged a bandwagon after he jumped on one.

Blackaxe and Caius jumped on the bandwagon, but Blackaxe is the most suspicious to me given that he voted and then unvoted Caius in less than 45min and then quickly jumped onto the tran bandwagon without any stated reason.

To me, the most likely players to be mafia given the votes for tran is discovery1, Ichigo, and Blackaxe

[pevergreen]

yeah its a bit confusing. But the last voters on Tran are suspicious. We had no real reason to lynch anyone this early. One day phase, when played properly can take a week.

[Csargo]

yeah its a bit confusing. But the last voters on Tran are suspicious. We had no real reason to lynch anyone this early. One day phase, when played properly can take a week.

Wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy toooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo sloooooowwwwwwww

[pevergreen]

It is, but you only need to post once or twice a day.

Thats why i prefer here, as in the last two hours there been upwards of 20 posts.

The fact remains, you are suspicious Ichigo for being one of the last people to vote Tran.

The mafia can easily take someone out at -1 from lynch, which is why you stop voting, and talk it out. Anyone who votes and causes them to be lynched, is immediately suspicious. You talk it over as a group, and decide if they are guilty enough to be lynched.

[RoadKill]

Vote: No Lynch no suspicion.

[Csargo]

It is, but you only need to post once or twice a day.

Thats why i prefer here, as in the last two hours there been upwards of 20 posts.

The fact remains, you are suspicious Ichigo for being one of the last people to vote Tran.

The mafia can easily take someone out at -1 from lynch, which is why you stop voting, and talk it out. Anyone who votes and causes them to be lynched, is immediately suspicious. You talk it over as a group, and decide if they are guilty enough to be lynched.

Pssssht I'm always suspicious to over half the people playing. It's no big surprise

The way your all making it sound, everytime someone gets lynched you'll blame it on everyone who voted for them which isn't the greatest idea.