Poll: Posit: the well educated man must be a virtuous man.

Be advised that this is a public poll: other users can see the choice(s) you selected.

Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 30 of 78

Thread: The well educated and the virtuous

  1. #1
    Master of the Horse Senior Member Pindar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    The base of Yggdrasil
    Posts
    3,710

    Default The well educated and the virtuous

    Posit: the well educated man must be a virtuous man.

    "We are lovers of beauty without extravagance and of learning without loss of vigor." -Thucydides

    "The secret of Happiness is Freedom, and the secret of Freedom, Courage." -Thucydides

  2. #2
    A Member Member Conradus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    Going to the land where men walk without footprints.
    Posts
    948

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Is this educated in Socrates' sense of 'he who knows what is good, will act good' or educated as in learned, scholared?

    I never agreed with Socrates' statement, and not with this one either, I believe even the well educated can be bastards.

  3. #3
    Headless Senior Member Pannonian's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Posts
    7,978

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by Pindar
    Posit: the well educated man must be a virtuous man.
    Have you seen this gem in the News of the Weird thread?

    Quote Originally Posted by Husar
    65 million $ for missing pants wants a lawyer from a cleaning company.

  4. #4
    Jillian & Allison's Daddy Senior Member Don Corleone's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    Athens, GA
    Posts
    7,588

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by Pindar
    Posit: the well educated man must be a virtuous man.
    In the spirit of True or False (correct the false statement to make it true) that was such a hit for professors in my educational days..

    Posit: The well educated man must should be a virtuous man.

    With the benefits of education should come a realization how privileged one's role is and with this, should come gratitude, and a sense of responsibility to contribute back to that society which has acted as benefactor to the educated man. Therefore, the virtuous life, if for no other reason, should be pursued out of a sense of obligation.Unfortunately, there is nothing compulsory regarding this relationship of the educated within society, and many choose to use their education to benefit themselves solely, with or without virtue.

    Now this stinks. I can't use the strikethrough text or the spoiler text tags. More basic HTML tags, such as bold and underline seem to work okay. Okay, instead of lining out, I'll just underline.
    Last edited by Don Corleone; 04-30-2007 at 21:05.
    "A man who doesn't spend time with his family can never be a real man."
    Don Vito Corleone: The Godfather, Part 1.

    "Then wait for them and swear to God in heaven that if they spew that bull to you or your family again you will cave there heads in with a sledgehammer"
    Strike for the South

  5. #5
    Enlightened Despot Member Vladimir's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    In ur nun, causing a bloody schism!
    Posts
    7,906

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    What are the virtues of a well educated man?
    Last edited by Vladimir; 04-30-2007 at 21:57.


    Reinvent the British and you get a global finance center, edible food and better service. Reinvent the French and you may just get more Germans.
    Quote Originally Posted by Evil_Maniac From Mars
    How do you motivate your employees? Waterboarding, of course.
    Ik hou van ferme grieten en dikke pinten
    Down with dried flowers!
    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 



  6. #6
    Master of the Horse Senior Member Pindar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    The base of Yggdrasil
    Posts
    3,710

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by Conradus
    Is this educated in Socrates' sense of 'he who knows what is good, will act good' or educated as in learned, scholared?
    Educated refers to its etymological base: to draw, lead or bring out or up.

    "We are lovers of beauty without extravagance and of learning without loss of vigor." -Thucydides

    "The secret of Happiness is Freedom, and the secret of Freedom, Courage." -Thucydides

  7. #7
    The Black Senior Member Papewaio's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2001
    Location
    Sydney, Australia
    Posts
    15,677

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    So if 'the well educated man must be a virtuous man' is true does this make ignorance a vice?

    I think ignorance will be a vice before all educated men are virtuous. A quick scan of history tends to lead to those in power have knowledge above most others and they use that power for self more often then not. Look at the bible...Solomon.. he didn't exactly wine and dine his brothers and his fathers supporters until they let him take the throne, no the wise exterminated all those who opposed him and keptit for himself.
    Our genes maybe in the basement but it does not stop us chosing our point of view from the top.
    Quote Originally Posted by Louis VI the Fat
    Pape for global overlord!!
    Quote Originally Posted by English assassin
    Squid sources report that scientists taste "sort of like chicken"
    Quote Originally Posted by frogbeastegg View Post
    The rest is either as average as advertised or, in the case of the missionary, disappointing.

  8. #8
    Texan Member BigTex's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Arlington, Texas, United States of America.
    Posts
    1,187

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Not completely sure I understand your question.

    I'll disagree with the statement though. Very few educated men are virtuous. Most have had to learn to survive in acedamia for quite awhile and become more and more passive agressive. Lawyers and politicians are excellent examples.

    Quote Originally Posted by Don Corleone
    Posit: The well educated man must should be a virtuous man.
    I'll agree with this. But so should everyman regardless of education strive to be virtuous.
    Wine is a bit different, as I am sure even kids will like it.
    BigTex
    "Hilary Clinton is the devil"
    ~Texas proverb

  9. #9
    American since 2012 Senior Member AntiochusIII's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Lalaland
    Posts
    3,125

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    What context is this "must" in?

    Does this "must" equate to the well educated man should strive to be virtuous?

    Or is this "must" simply an agreement, i.e. the well educated man is by default virtuous?

  10. #10
    Sovereign Oppressor Member TIE Fighter Shooter Champion, Turkey Shoot Champion, Juggler Champion Kralizec's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Location
    Netherlands
    Posts
    5,812

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by Pindar
    Educated refers to its etymological base: to draw, lead or bring out or up.
    I believe bad upbringing is a major cause of antisocial behaviour and crime, or if you prefer, "vice".
    But even if every child was brought up carefully and responsibly, that still wouldn't eliminate antisocial behaviour. There simply are too many factors beyond parents' control and there's of course, nature besides nurture.

    So well educated does not necessarily lead to virtuous behaviour.

  11. #11
    Master of the Horse Senior Member Pindar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    The base of Yggdrasil
    Posts
    3,710

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by AntiochusIII
    What context is this "must" in?

    Does this "must" equate to the well educated man should strive to be virtuous?
    No.

    Or is this "must" simply an agreement, i.e. the well educated man is by default virtuous?
    Correct. The posit is: to merit the label 'well educated' requires the inculcation of virtue.

    "We are lovers of beauty without extravagance and of learning without loss of vigor." -Thucydides

    "The secret of Happiness is Freedom, and the secret of Freedom, Courage." -Thucydides

  12. #12
    Mystic Bard Member Soulforged's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    Another Skald
    Posts
    2,138

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by Pindar
    Posit: the well educated man must be a virtuous man.
    If you use the word "well" in a moral sense, then I'll tend to agree. But a man makes his own decisions, and so his education could influence him, but not determine him.
    Born On The Flames

  13. #13
    Hope guides me Senior Member Hosakawa Tito's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2000
    Location
    Western New Yuck
    Posts
    7,914

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    There are no absolutes, however I believe that the simple man is more apt to be virtuous...
    "He is no fool who gives what he cannot keep to gain that which he cannot lose." *Jim Elliot*

  14. #14
    Master of Few Words Senior Member KukriKhan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2001
    Posts
    10,415

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    I understand 'must' as irresistably compelling, as: breathing.

    The posit seemingly sits on the definitions of virtue (prudence, justice, fortitude and temperance), and educate(d) "the lead out", the instructed, informed.

    However, the "well" qualifier introduces a qualitative and subjective measure to the position.

    Will you yield "well" and let the remainder of the posit stand on its own? Or is "well" necessary?
    Be well. Do good. Keep in touch.

  15. #15
    Enlightened Despot Member Vladimir's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    In ur nun, causing a bloody schism!
    Posts
    7,906

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by Hosakawa Tito
    There are no absolutes, however I believe that the simple man is more apt to be virtuous...
    There are absolutely no absolutes.


    Reinvent the British and you get a global finance center, edible food and better service. Reinvent the French and you may just get more Germans.
    Quote Originally Posted by Evil_Maniac From Mars
    How do you motivate your employees? Waterboarding, of course.
    Ik hou van ferme grieten en dikke pinten
    Down with dried flowers!
    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 



  16. #16
    Master of the Horse Senior Member Pindar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    The base of Yggdrasil
    Posts
    3,710

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by KukriKhan
    I understand 'must' as irresistably compelling, as: breathing.

    The posit seemingly sits on the definitions of virtue (prudence, justice, fortitude and temperance), and educate(d) "the lead out", the instructed, informed.
    Educate is taken as its base meaning: to lead out and virtue is moral standing.

    However, the "well" qualifier introduces a qualitative and subjective measure to the position. Will you yield "well" and let the remainder of the posit stand on its own? Or is "well" necessary?
    I will not yield 'well'. It is essential to the posit. The adverb is being used as: proper or sufficient.

    Whether one has attained this quality may be subjective, but the relation of well educated to virtue can be evaluated independent of a subject.

    "We are lovers of beauty without extravagance and of learning without loss of vigor." -Thucydides

    "The secret of Happiness is Freedom, and the secret of Freedom, Courage." -Thucydides

  17. #17
    Iron Fist Senior Member Husar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2003
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    15,617

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Oh, a grammar thread.
    Maybe I voted too early then, I just had the thought of a simple man(despite my good education) that you meant a good education means a man(or woman, don't forget about the women!) will turn out good, but we had quite a lot of bad people from good schools to prove that this is not necessarily the case I think.


    "Topic is tired and needs a nap." - Tosa Inu

  18. #18
    Enlightened Despot Member Vladimir's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    In ur nun, causing a bloody schism!
    Posts
    7,906

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    So no ruling on what virtues they're supposed to have huh?


    Reinvent the British and you get a global finance center, edible food and better service. Reinvent the French and you may just get more Germans.
    Quote Originally Posted by Evil_Maniac From Mars
    How do you motivate your employees? Waterboarding, of course.
    Ik hou van ferme grieten en dikke pinten
    Down with dried flowers!
    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 



  19. #19
    A very, very Senior Member Adrian II's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    9,748

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by Pindar
    Posit: the well educated man must be a virtuous man.
    Agreed. Well educated implies virtue inculcated.*

    * Children are born little bastards; their egoism, egocentrism and desire for instant gratification must be beaten out of them
    The bloody trouble is we are only alive when we’re half dead trying to get a paragraph right. - Paul Scott

  20. #20
    Second-hand chariot salesman Senior Member macsen rufus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    Ratae Corieltauvorum
    Posts
    2,481

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    I think you're treading close to circular reasoning now or do I mean it's a truism? There is a sense in which you can define 'well-educated' as being virtuous (because if virtue is absent, how could the education have been good?) The more pedantic your definitions, and the further removed from common usage, the truer the position becomes. In the common parlance sense of "does learning make people good" -- which was the basis on which I voted -- unequivocally NO. Some will use their learning to foul ends.
    ANCIENT: TW

    A mod for Medieval:TW (with VI)

    Discussion forum thread

    Download A Game of Thrones Mod v1.4

  21. #21
    Nobody expects the Senior Member Lemur's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    Wisconsin Death Trip
    Posts
    15,754

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by macsen rufus
    The more pedantic your definitions, and the further removed from common usage, the truer the position becomes. In the common parlance sense of "does learning make people good" -- which was the basis on which I voted -- unequivocally NO. Some will use their learning to foul ends.
    In other words, the formulation is its own refutation.

    Lawyers are quite educated, no?
    Last edited by Lemur; 05-01-2007 at 18:13.

  22. #22
    Master of the Horse Senior Member Pindar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    The base of Yggdrasil
    Posts
    3,710

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by Husar
    Oh, a grammar thread.
    Partially.

    Maybe I voted too early then, I just had the thought of a simple man(despite my good education) that you meant a good education means a man(or woman, don't forget about the women!) will turn out good, but we had quite a lot of bad people from good schools to prove that this is not necessarily the case I think.
    How people initially responded to the posit was part of the idea being looked at.

    There are at least two issues at work. One is the verbiage. Educate as "to lead out" and educated meaning 'to have been led out' entails a moral aspect in and through the relation and assumption of leading. "Well" reinforces the distinction between simply studied and the root meaning of educated. Virtue of course is also a moral designate. Therefore the posit could be taken as tautological.

    The second issue is connected to the traditional notion of education that dictated pedagogy. Classically this can be seen not only in say the Greek sense of education "paideia" where moral inculcation was part and parcel of the concept, but can also be illustrated in core philosophical texts. A simple example would be Plato's Alcibiades I. The dialogue occurs between Socrates and Alcibiades* when the later considers himself as ready to enter into political life. The dialogue turns on Socrates stressing that Alcibiades must first know himself and the good before attempting a leaders' role. Alcibiades resists this idea and shows himself to constantly misunderstand core notions. In the dialogue he ultimately relents, but the historical record shows him to turn again to his impulses. Alcibiades is often seen as having been a creature of self interest often switching sides during the coarse of the Peloponnesian War etc.

    The responses seem to indicate that the traditional notion of education has passed.


    *Alcibiades was a handsome, wealthy, intelligent, aristocrat of Athens.

    "We are lovers of beauty without extravagance and of learning without loss of vigor." -Thucydides

    "The secret of Happiness is Freedom, and the secret of Freedom, Courage." -Thucydides

  23. #23
    A very, very Senior Member Adrian II's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    9,748

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by macsen rufus
    IN the common parlance sense of "does learning make people good" -- which was the basis on which I voted -- unequivocally NO. Some will use their learning to foul ends.
    Alright, but how do people become virtuous if not through education?
    The bloody trouble is we are only alive when we’re half dead trying to get a paragraph right. - Paul Scott

  24. #24
    Master of the Horse Senior Member Pindar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    The base of Yggdrasil
    Posts
    3,710

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by Vladimir
    So no ruling on what virtues they're supposed to have huh?
    No. Particular virtues are not relevant to the idea of whether virtue itself is necessarily tied to being well educated.

    "We are lovers of beauty without extravagance and of learning without loss of vigor." -Thucydides

    "The secret of Happiness is Freedom, and the secret of Freedom, Courage." -Thucydides

  25. #25
    The very model of a modern Moderator Xiahou's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2002
    Location
    in the cloud.
    Posts
    9,007

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by Adrian II
    Alright, but how do people become virtuous if not through education?
    Now there's a question for ya.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pindar
    The dialogue occurs between Socrates and Alcibiades* when the later considers himself as ready to enter into political life. The dialogue turns on Socrates stressing that Alcibiades must first know himself and the good before attempting a leaders' role. Alcibiades resists this idea and shows himself to constantly misunderstand core notions. In the dialogue he ultimately relents, but the historical record shows him to turn again to his impulses. Alcibiades is often seen as having been a creature of self interest often switching sides during the coarse of the Peloponnesian War etc.
    Isn't he currently serving in the US Congress?
    "Don't believe everything you read online."
    -Abraham Lincoln

  26. #26
    Jillian & Allison's Daddy Senior Member Don Corleone's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    Athens, GA
    Posts
    7,588

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    I think this thread has been more about where we lie on the epistimological scale (traditional, core meaning or modern, generally accepted meaning) and less on our views of morality/virtue among political leaders (or even among educated people in general).

    You are referring to education in the classical sense. In many ways, an education back then was an event, not a process. Upon completion of one's time at the academy, one ascended to membership among the ruling class (as opposed to the plebians), correct?

    I thought one of the hallmarks of our society was that there was no such litmus test. Theoretically, a ditch-digger could be president in our society. Education in our society is about knowledge, not status, at least not theoretically.

    If what you really intended was the use of the term educated in the sense of improved or civilized, then might I suggest you put forth the same posit, but substitute the term 'enlightened' for educated.
    "A man who doesn't spend time with his family can never be a real man."
    Don Vito Corleone: The Godfather, Part 1.

    "Then wait for them and swear to God in heaven that if they spew that bull to you or your family again you will cave there heads in with a sledgehammer"
    Strike for the South

  27. #27
    Iron Fist Senior Member Husar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2003
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    15,617

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Just imagine two people go to the same physics lesson about nuclear devices, one of them then goes home and builds a nuclear reactor for the poor people in Africa and the other one goes home and builds a nuke to nuke the people in Africa...
    The deciding factors are likely parents, friends and the general public/culture someone lives in, plus probably some biological/genetical factors.
    Education in general has nothing to do with that, however moral education can.
    I feel like I'm contradicting myself now, but somewhere deep in my brain I do have a point to make I think.
    In school we often learned that violence is not an answer and issues should be discussed and not solved with violence but I cannot really say how that influenced me and others.
    I do know that I adopted values from my parents but that fits the contradictory interpretation of the initial posit.
    I think I have the usual blackout when it comes to such philosophical questions, I can find arguments for almost every thesis and all seem fine on their own but are contradictory as a whole. The answer is dependant on so many circumstances.

    For example high-ranking Nazis were rather well educated IIRC but I wouldn't exactly call them virtuous. On the other hand there are thousands of people who are well educated and virtuous. But some of them are not virtuous again, they become arrogant and self-centered because their good education makes them think they are just better than others.


    "Topic is tired and needs a nap." - Tosa Inu

  28. #28
    Master of the Horse Senior Member Pindar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    The base of Yggdrasil
    Posts
    3,710

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by Don Corleone
    You are referring to education in the classical sense. In many ways, an education back then was an event, not a process. Upon completion of one's time at the academy, one ascended to membership among the ruling class (as opposed to the plebians), correct?
    The question does not look at economics or social stratification per say, but the meaning of to be educated. The notion of education necessarily entailing and informed by the moral is the traditional model that served until quite recently. This is one reason university (to turn as one)* is the word opted for to describe higher education.

    *This of coarse makes for an interesting notion when one sees the current fad of university diversity.

    "We are lovers of beauty without extravagance and of learning without loss of vigor." -Thucydides

    "The secret of Happiness is Freedom, and the secret of Freedom, Courage." -Thucydides

  29. #29
    Enlightened Despot Member Vladimir's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    In ur nun, causing a bloody schism!
    Posts
    7,906

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    Quote Originally Posted by Pindar
    No. Particular virtues are not relevant to the idea of whether virtue itself is necessarily tied to being well educated.
    What I was angling at is demonstrated in the patricide scene in Gladiator. Two men, both educated, with wildly differing virtues. Your posit relies on a lot of relativistic language. What virtues must a man have to be considered well educated? Is there any doubt that both men in that scene are well educated?


    Reinvent the British and you get a global finance center, edible food and better service. Reinvent the French and you may just get more Germans.
    Quote Originally Posted by Evil_Maniac From Mars
    How do you motivate your employees? Waterboarding, of course.
    Ik hou van ferme grieten en dikke pinten
    Down with dried flowers!
    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 



  30. #30
    Part-Time Polemic Senior Member ICantSpellDawg's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2002
    Location
    U.S.
    Posts
    7,237

    Default Re: The well educated and the virtuous

    I think it is a double edged sword. You must learn what it means to be virtuous. I believe that virtue is taught in different ways than advanced shcholarship. On the one hand, I believe that an educated person is apt to be MORE virtuous or LESS virtuous than the average due to the (supposed)ability to avoid conflicting concepts. Therefore, the educated man is more like a tempered instrument of Virtue, Vice or callous indifference.
    "That rifle hanging on the wall of the working-class flat or labourer's cottage is the symbol of democracy. It is our job to see that it stays there."
    -Eric "George Orwell" Blair

    "If the policy of the government, upon vital questions affecting the whole people, is to be irrevocably fixed by decisions of the Supreme Court...the people will have ceased to be their own rulers, having to that extent practically resigned the government into the hands of that eminent tribunal."
    (Lincoln's First Inaugural Address, 1861).
    ΜΟΛΩΝ ΛΑΒΕ

Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO