Greetings, I am trying to figure out exactly about how most of the foreign policy and military-related decisions of both Soviet Union and the United States and also their principal doctrine on global scale, for most of the Cold War period. In other words, since the end of World War 2 both countries are trying to spread their influence across the globe, and they have very interesting different approaches. Please no blame and flame, let’s keep this thread civil with academic and intellectual discussion.
Firstly, I would like to draw comparisons of both countries, note that these are my thoughts and feel free to correct them:
United States of America:
- US ability to use direct military action against any nations (in other words, US is able to deploy troops) anywhere in the world (some examples: Dominica, Vietnam, Granada, Lebanon, Libya, Panama) except against NATO
- No military intervention against NATO members when there’s big issues in NATO members (Greek-Turkish conflict over Cyprus, Cod War between Iceland and UK, Portugal Carnation revolution led by leftist officers)
- Strong Washington-supported and CIA-backed coups (Guatemala, Iran, Indonesia, Chile, Nicaragua)
- Have military bases anywhere in the world, some are located in countries surrounding the USSR, this is especially true since late 1970s-later
Union of Soviet Socialist Republics:
- USSR use military action mostly against Warsaw Pact (East German riots 1950s, Hungarian uprising 1956, Czechoslovakian 1967) or nearby neighboring countries (Afghanistan, border skirmish with China)
- No direct military intervention anywhere other than what mentioned above (only advisers and sending crews) – only its ally Cuba actually send thousands of troops to Africa during 1970s to 1980s
- Often only half-hearted support leftist powers in many countries, some pro-Moscow countries received little and insignificant help when under threat. Also almost never support leftist coup or rise to power in many countries, even Cuba (Castro rise to power by his discontented countrymen support at the time, no USSR involvement, not significant if there’s any)
- No military bases outside of USSR and Warsaw Pact (with the exception of bases only in two friendly powers: Cuba and Vietnam)
And then list possible reasons for the differences:
Military:
- Near the end of World War 2, USA already has several hundreds, if not thousands,battleshipswarships in Pacific Ocean alone (including several aircraft carriers), when added with others located on Atlantic Ocean, Mediterranean, and anywhere else you will have the biggest navy in the world. Far more than Japanese Navy during its peak. While the USSR has small and very limited naval capability, none compared to the strength of US Navy at the time
- USSR theatres of war during WW2 most of the time are in ground, fighting directly on land against German or Japan in Korea. No island-hopping or amphibious operations like Western Allies
- Especially since late 1960s until end of the Cold War, USSR relied more and more in nuclear weapons (eventually USSR has more nuclear than USA) and believe can take out USA with just that, there’s no need for military bases far away from home outside neighboring countries, or even military intervention outside Europe and outside neighboring countries
Geography:
- Access to major oceans like Atlantic and Pacific Ocean are limited. Much of its naval strength is located on the Baltic Sea and Black Sea where many USSR naval ports are located. Soviet Navy has to pass “NATO domain” (Denmark and Turkey) to get out and reach the big oceans, therefore no free access, kept under constant watchful eye of NATO, and can’t just send big ships or troops to “intervene” without passing them
- Only in its Pacific fleet the Soviet Navy has free and direct access to Pacific Ocean, but then there are nearby military bases and watchful eyes of US, Japan, and South Korea, still limited, compared to USA
- Even without distant and foreign bases. US Navy still has more direct and free access to major oceans, and therefore easier to reach many countries in the world
- USA shared its borders only with two countries Canada and Mexico, which are friendly, therefore no direct ground threat. USSR has very width borders with numerous hostile and pro-US countries, and therefore has more to worry about homeland security and direct ground assault
Bookmarks