Citadel of Alamut [Concluded]

[Orb]

Write-ups given to the killer and the killed. I feared that one would give too much information as to whether the killer was a vigilante townie or spy.

The lyrics were largely a 'for the hell of it'/fleshing out the post addition, so it gets more noticed.

[Caius]

Vote:Abstain

Try #1 to get more discusion

[Warmaster Horus]

Write-ups given to the killer and the killed. I feared that one would give too much information as to whether the killer was a vigilante townie or spy.

The lyrics were largely a 'for the hell of it'/fleshing out the post addition, so it gets more noticed.

So, what would stop Redleg from posting it? Or sending it to someone trustworthy?
And, must I understand the lyrics are no clue whatsoever? If that's the case, dang.
I checked, King Crimson is a progressive rock/ jazz rock/ proto progressive metal group. Dates: 1969–1974, 1981–1984, 1994–present. Of course, it seems useless now.

[Seamus Fermanagh]

A Gameroom "fixture" convinced me that wagons are the way to roll in the early rounds for the town to win. In that spirit:

Vote: Sasaki

Tally:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Sasaki = 2 (Seamus, Stig)
Abstain = 1 (Caius) ... here we go again

Choose: Backroom

Tally:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Backroom = 3 (Seamus, Tran, War-H)

[Stig]

lol Seamus, you're taking my vote seriously?


On a more serious note tho, Sasaki will mostlikely be WoG'ed, seeing that he can't post as he has no internet (so he claims).

And I'll join with that backroom thing

Choose: Backroom

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Add your tally sir!

Sasaki is off-line? I may have to withdraw my vote then. I was having a little ironic fun since Sasaki was the "fixture" who's the lead advocate for that strategy.

I'll check back tomorrow if not sooner.

[Stig]

Sasaki is off-line?

He posted in KungFu Mafia that he had no internet, so I doubt he will be active ... but then, he's only one of many

[Warmaster Horus]

Lynching Sasaki while he has no means to defend himself seems ... cruel, for an exagerated term.
Actually, lynching anybody in that case is cruel.

[pevergreen]

I think the choosing is a trick question, Im going to choose do nothing.
no vote its first day phase

Backroom = 4 (Seamus, Tran, War-H, stig)
Nothing = 1 (pevergreen)

[CountArach]

Select: Backroom

Vote: Caius Flaminius - Voting for no lynch will not help us.

Backroom = 5 (Seamus, Tran, War-H, stig, CountArach)
Nothing = 1 (pevergreen)

Sasaki = 2 (Seamus, Stig)
Caius = 1 (CountArach)
Abstain = 1 (Caius)

[Twilightblade]

I agree with CA Vote: Caius
Also this will keep the votes even for the moment

Backroom = 5 (Seamus, Tran, War-H, stig, CountArach)
Nothing = 1 (pevergreen)

Sasaki = 2 (Seamus, Stig)
Caius = 2 (CountArach,TB)
Abstain = 1 (Caius

[Warluster]

Didn't realise this had started,sorry.

Why would we want to choose backroom? The Spies/mafia can still kill,even if they hate eachother.

Wouldn't it be btter to take them out,then they can't kill!

I have no suspicions so far.

And just a little inquiry about Sasaki having no internet, how can he post on the internet when he has no internet?

[Orb]

So, what would stop Redleg from posting it? Or sending it to someone trustworthy?

The rules. Can't PM game-related material when dead.

And, must I understand the lyrics are no clue whatsoever? If that's the case, dang.

Yep.

I checked, King Crimson is a progressive rock/ jazz rock/ proto progressive metal group. Dates: 1969–1974, 1981–1984, 1994–present. Of course, it seems useless now.

Yep.

[Warmaster Horus]

Thanks Orb. I guess.
Warluster, SK can post from work, I think.

[Caius]

FoS:CA and Twilight.

How can you vote someone if the game just started?

Also,

Unvote:Abstain
Vote:TwlightBlade

Bandwagoning without a own reason.
EDIT:Also, he wrote wrong my name.

Vote:Nothing

Backroom = 5 (Seamus, Tran, War-H, stig, CountArach)
Nothing = 2 (pevergreen, Caius)

Sasaki = 2 (Seamus, Stig)
Caius = 2 (CountArach,TB)
TwilightBlade= 1 (Caius)

[Seamus Fermanagh]

By that logic, no one would ever vote for anybody since no one would want to vote early in the game, no pressure on anyone would build, and this "logic" would repeat itself while the mafia snickered. Bandwagons are the ONLY useful tool in the early game (aside from a mafia mistake).

Unvote: Sasaki -- if he can't interact, a pressure wagon is useless.

Vote: Caius

Defend yourself sir. My vote is changeable if your tone suggests you are worth saving.

Tally:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Sasaki = 1 (Stig)
Caius = 3 (Arach, Seamus,T'Blade)
TwilightBlade= 1 (Caius)

Choice:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Backroom = 5 (Seamus, Tran, War-H, stig, CountArach)
Nothing = 2 (pevergreen, Caius)

[seireikhaan]

Vote: Sapi.

Came to me role-fishing, while, in his odd sort of way, claiming that he may have a pro town role. Gave me no other reason as to trust him. Seems to me like a mafia tactic to find out who the role players are. Sapi, if you've got a pro town role, reveal it. The town can band together to protect you from the mafia. Otherwise, you're scum who needs to be lynched.

Also, I vote to do nothing in regards to the Mongol Champions. I've got this fear that sending them into the backroom will somehow end up backfiring rather badly. And I don't think we'll be able to kill one, considering that this is a Mongol Champion we're talking about.

Tallies:

Caius- 3(CountArach, Seamus, Twilightblade)
Sasaki- 1(Stig)
TwilightBlade- 1(Caius)
Sapi- 1(Greaterkhaan)

Backroom- 5(Seamus, Tran, Warmaster, Stig, CountArach)
Nothing- 3(Pevergreen, Caius, Greaterkhaan)

[Tran]

Vote: Sapi.

Came to me role-fishing, while, in his odd sort of way, claiming that he may have a pro town role. Gave me no other reason as to trust him. Seems to me like a mafia tactic to find out who the role players are. Sapi, if you've got a pro town role, reveal it. The town can band together to protect you from the mafia. Otherwise, you're scum who needs to be lynched.

Also, I vote to do nothing in regards to the Mongol Champions. I've got this fear that sending them into the backroom will somehow end up backfiring rather badly. And I don't think we'll be able to kill one, considering that this is a Mongol Champion we're talking about.

Tallies:

Caius- 3(CountArach, Seamus, Twilightblade)
Sasaki- 1(Stig)
TwilightBlade- 1(Caius)
Sapi- 1(Greaterkhaan)

Backroom- 5(Seamus, Tran, Warmaster, Stig, CountArach)
Nothing- 3(Pevergreen, Caius, Greaterkhaan)

In my (PM) conversation with him, sapi also showed suspicious behaviour. Either he's the Mongol spy or just some other bad guys role...

Vote: sapi

Tallies:

Caius- 3(CountArach, Seamus, Twilightblade)
Sasaki- 1(Stig)
TwilightBlade- 1(Caius)
Sapi- 2(Greaterkhaan, Tran)

Backroom- 5(Seamus, Tran, Warmaster, Stig, CountArach)
Nothing- 3(Pevergreen, Caius, Greaterkhaan)

Anyway, I'd like someone, preferably Seamus, to explain about our possibility/chance of success of using the backroom tactic...I just want to hear your voice on this

[sapi]

I am not a bad guy

gk is correct, however, in saying that I do need to reveal to have a chance of survival, now that he has unwittingly placed me in danger

I do have a pro-town role, and my PM exchange with gk (and others, sometimes through other means) was part of an attempt to find allies and the like.

To paraphrase my role (I cannot state it in full as to do so would be to put in danger my partner), I am a representative of the Mamluks, and am tasked to defend the townies, and in particular those with pro-town roles (some of whose identities I know, but will not reveal here).

I'm quite skilled with weapons (by my reckoning at worst the second best in the town), and would be a good choice to have around when the Mongol Champion arrives, seeing as my role is pretty much comprimsed already.

Tran's conversation with me was suspicious, hence me avoiding his questions; but seeing as I've been put in a bad position for the same thing, I'm not going to retaliate with my vote just now.

Vote: Abstain
Vote: Backroom << (trust me; I've been there - the spies will be dead in minutes )

Tallies:

Caius- 3(CountArach, Seamus, Twilightblade)
Sasaki- 1(Stig)
TwilightBlade- 1(Caius)
sapi- 2(Greaterkhaan, Tran)

Backroom- 6(Seamus, Tran, Warmaster, Stig, CountArach, sapi)
Nothing- 3(Pevergreen, Caius, Greaterkhaan)

[seireikhaan]

Unvote: Sapi. Sorry, but you came across extremely suspicious in that PM. I'll wait a little longer before recasting my vote.

[seireikhaan]

Did anyone do a protection last night? I'm wondering why there was only one kill. I can't imagine that there's only one mongol spy. If not, perhaps one of the mafia forgot to send in the PM?

Also, I forgot the tally from my last post.

Caius- 3(CountArach, Seamus, Twilightblade)
Sasaki- 1(Stig)
TwilightBlade- 1(Caius)
sapi- 1(Tran)

Backroom- 6(Seamus, Tran, Warmaster, Stig, CountArach, sapi)
Nothing- 3(Pevergreen, Caius, Greaterkhaan)

[Warluster]

Oh,btw, Choose:Nothing

Backroom- 6(Seamus, Tran, Warmaster, Stig, CountArach, sapi)
Nothing- 4(Pevergreen, Caius, Greaterkhaan,Warluster)

[Tran]

All right and apology I decided to trust sapi then, I will now just cast my vote to lurker / non-active player...Let's see...

Unvote: sapi
Vote: Xdeathfire

Hiding to save your skin? That doesn't work here!

Caius- 3(CountArach, Seamus, Twilightblade)
Sasaki- 1(Stig)
TwilightBlade- 1(Caius)
Xdeathfire- 1(Tran)

Backroom- 6(Seamus, Tran, Warmaster, Stig, CountArach, sapi)
Nothing- 3(Pevergreen, Caius, Greaterkhaan)

[Twilightblade]

I don't think that 2 votes is a bandwagon just a pressure vote
And seeing as your so sensitive about your name i fixed it
oh and I think that after reading the thread Unvote: Caius

Caius- 2(CountArach, Seamus)
Sasaki- 1(Stig)
TwilightBlade- 1(Caius)
Xdeathfire- 1(Tran)

Backroom- 6(Seamus, Tran, Warmaster, Stig, CountArach, sapi)
Nothing- 3(Pevergreen, Caius, Greaterkhaan)

[RoadKill]

Vote:Abstain
Vote:Crossbow

[Orb]

Given that the amount of discussion has not been particularly large, the voting deadline will stay open until about midday tomorrow (GMT)

[Stig]

Given that the amount of discussion has not been particularly large, the voting deadline will stay open until about midday tomorrow (GMT)

If I were host I would try to keep it alive myself if it seems to die. I'd simply make it quicker and really keep updating.
Of the last couple of mini mafia's mine was the only one that didn't die. Even if there is no input, make sure that those who give input keep paying attention.

[Caius]

Unvote:TB
Vote:Abstain

Defend yourself sir. My vote is changeable if your tone suggests you are worth saving.

Are townies worth saving?If you think yes, then change your vote, because I think the mafia is hiding here.
Abstain is, I admit, no good, but how can I vote the spies without getting discution going?

I want to hear RoadKill opinion, since he said nothing, he just voted and nothing more.

[Tran]

Here's my thought so far:

There's only 1 kill in the first night, which mean:
- The rest of the Mongol spies didn't active at that time and fail to send their orders
- Together they attempt to eliminate one target to increase such possibility

I believe the first possibility was more likely to happened...

[RoadKill]

I didn't discuss much becuase first of all, I had to quickly vote, becuase theres a huge festival at my town today, and I'm speniding most of my time there, but right now no ones catching my attention, to who is the mafia.