Guild offered in the wrong place

[DVX BELLORVM]

I don't think that refusing (or excepting) a guild in one settlement lowers a chance of getting it in another. Each settlement has a independent score for each guild type, and when you accumulated enough points, you receive an offer to build a guild.

You will find more information in this excellent Daveybaby's Guide to guilds

[Hermann the Lombard]

The time I regretted accepting a guild offer was the first offer I ever got. I was so pleased to get it that I grabbed it, but it was a Thieves Guild in Venice and later I realized that (A) I would be offered many Thieves Guilds and (B) I would oh-so-much rather have a Merchants Guild there!

In my HRE game I am persistently offered guilds where I don't want them, especially Thieves Guilds and an Assassins Guild.

[DVX BELLORVM]

The time I regretted accepting a guild offer was the first offer I ever got. I was so pleased to get it that I grabbed it, but it was a Thieves Guild in Venice and later I realized that (A) I would be offered many Thieves Guilds and (B) I would oh-so-much rather have a Merchants Guild there!

In my HRE game I am persistently offered guilds where I don't want them, especially Thieves Guilds and an Assassins Guild.

You can destroy unwanted guilds without any major consequences. You will loose 100 points in that settlement and 20 in all the others, but only for that guild type.

I also made the similar mistake in my first campaign, building every guild that was offered, without making any plans. So I ended up with more thieves guilds than I actually needed, not to mention the ones I captured.
Since I lacked Woodsman and Alchemist guilds, I decided to blow up two thieves guilds, and started to build archers in one, and canons and arquebusiers in other settlement, in order to gain some points. And after a few turns I did it!

[Philbert]

Thing is, I had only just conquered Rennes, so I had no opportunity whatsoever to gain SM guild points there. Why was I offered one there?

I have read the guide you guys refer to, and it explicitly mentioned that for most guilds you can get settlement points and global points.

[DVX BELLORVM]

Thing is, I had only just conquered Rennes, so I had no opportunity whatsoever to gain SM guild points there. Why was I offered one there?

That's because the points accumulated by the previous owner of the settlement are not lost when you capture it. It is also possible that the settlement had that guild before your occupation, but was destroyed during the siege.

I have read the guide you guys refer to, and it explicitly mentioned that for most guilds you can get settlement points and global points.

That's right, if you destroy a guild you loose 100 points in this settlement, and 20 points in all the others.

[Hermann the Lombard]

You can destroy unwanted guilds without any major consequences. You will loose points only in that settlement, and only for that guild type.

[later]

That's right, if you destroy a guild you loose 100 points in this settlement, and 20 points in all the others.

Aren't those contradictory? With some guilds wouldn't the loss of 20 points be prohibitive? Anyway, you've convinced me to send the wreckers to the Thieves Guild in Venice since I have another in Milan. [The wreckers wouldn't *dare* try that with an Assassins Guild!]

[DVX BELLORVM]

Aren't those contradictory?

Indeed they are
The second statement was written after better reading of the above mentioned guide... in the meantime I forgot about the first one
I've edited my original post and corrected the mistake. Thanks.

With some guilds wouldn't the loss of 20 points be prohibitive?

IMO, no. Anyway, I was mainly referring to thieve's guild, I have many of them (or rather had many of them ), and I won't miss them if I never get another opportunity to build another one. Besides, each spy trained gives you 10 points, so loosing 20 points is not a problem. This is the case with most guild types, as training of a unit that gains points usualy adds 10-15 points.

I think the only guild type that could suffer that loss are the Crusader Knight's Chapter Houses.

[Kobal2fr]

Dvx is right. Each city/castle has its own tally, and refusing guilds doesn't cost you any points : destroying built guilds does.