View Poll Results: Please vote yay or nay to the following motions:

Voters
17. This poll is closed
  • Edict 12.1: Yes

    15 88.24%
  • Edict 12.1: No

    1 5.88%
  • Edict 12.2: Yes

    8 47.06%
  • Edict 12.2: No

    8 47.06%
  • Edict 12.3: Yes

    10 58.82%
  • Edict 12.3: No

    7 41.18%
  • Edict 12.4: Yes

    8 47.06%
  • Edict 12.4: No

    8 47.06%
  • CA 12.1: Yes

    15 88.24%
  • CA 12.1: No

    2 11.76%
  • CA 12.2: Yes

    4 23.53%
  • CA 12.2: No

    11 64.71%
  • CA 12.3: Yes

    17 100.00%
  • CA 12.3: No

    0 0%
  • CA 12.6: Yes

    15 88.24%
  • CA 12.6: No

    2 11.76%
  • CA 12.7: Yes

    9 52.94%
  • CA 12.7: No

    6 35.29%
  • CA 12.8: Yes

    16 94.12%
  • CA 12.8: No

    1 5.88%
  • CA 12.9: Yes

    14 82.35%
  • CA 12.9: No

    3 17.65%
  • I abstain on all motions

    0 0%
Multiple Choice Poll.
Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: 12th Diet Edicts and CAs poll

  1. #1
    Senior Member Senior Member econ21's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2002
    Posts
    9,651

    Default 12th Diet Edicts and CAs poll

    This poll is for players in the King of the Romans PBM only.

    The text of the proposed laws is as follows:

    *Edict 12.1: The Chancellor must do all in his power to conquer the towns of Naples and Palermo, thus re-unifying Italy and striking a heavy blow at the Kingdom of Sicily.
    Proposed: Friedrich Karolinger
    Seconded: Peter von Kastilien, Hans

    *Edict 12.2: Any army of the Reich is authorized to conquer the Polish fortress of Vilnius. If an army is unavailable, one shall be created.
    Proposed: Peter von Kastilien
    Seconded: Hans, Jan von Hamburg

    *Edict 12.3:The House of Swabia Army is authorized to take Caen from the French to stop further French invasions, to pressure the Danes from a second front, and to allow resupply at a closer region.
    Proposed: Hans
    Seconded: Jens Hümmel, Friedrich Scherer

    Edict 12.4: "The Scots are to be approached with an offer of an alliance. No more than 5,000 florins may be exchanged in order to bring this about."
    Proposed: Wolfgang Hummel
    Seconded: Gerhard Steffen; Lothar Steffen

    *Charter Amendment 12.1: The province of Bran is to be incorporated formally into the Holy Roman Empire.
    Proposed: Arnold
    Seconded: Jan von Hamburg, Hans

    *Charter Amendment 12.2: Anyone found to be excessively over-complicating simple legal matters is to be banned from the Diet until they publicly apologize. Repeated violations will result in longer bans.
    Proposed: Jens Hummel
    Seconded: Arnold, Peter von Kastilien

    *Charter Ammendment 12.3:
    The section reading:
    "Dukes may propose one personal Edict per Diet session, but also control three additional House Edict proposals per Diet session. These proposals are no different than any other Edicts, but they must have the pre-secured backing of at least two seconders from inside the Duke’s House."
    is to be amended to read:
    "Dukes may propose one personal Edict per Diet session, but also control three additional House Edict proposals per Diet session. These proposals are no different than any other Edicts, but they must have the pre-secured backing of at least two seconders from inside the Duke’s House. In the case where there are only 1 or 2 electors in total in a Duke's House, a House edict may still be put forward to the diet requiring only the number of possible seconding electors in the House as seconders."
    Proposed: Hans
    Seconded: Jan von Hamburg, Matthias Steffen

    *Charter Amendment 12.6: (1) Each House will have TWO standing Household Armies. They will operate according to CA5.1 in all respects, but have separate commanders appointed by the Duke.
    (2) Outremer will have two standing armies. They will operate in accordance with CA9.1, but have separate commanders appointed by the King.
    (3) The Kaiser and Prinz will each command standing Imperial armies, of the guideline size given in CA5.1. The Kaiser and Prinz can each give orders for their army during full Diet sessions. They are expected to personally command their own armies but can nominate a replacement commander at any time if they are too busy attending to civil matters. The Chancellor and the Kaiser/Prinz are expected to liase closely over the use of the deployment of the Kaiser/Prinz's army.

    Proposed: Elberhard
    Seconded: Hans, Matthias Steffen

    *Charter Amendment 12.7: Clause 6 of the Charter of Outremer (Charter Amendment 9.1) shall be amended as follows:
    6. Outremer’s provinces will be governed by Crusading Counts. These will also be appointed at every Diet, by the new King. The Dukes and the Emperor will set the build queue for any provinces without a Count which are allocated to their control.
    Proposed: Lothar Steffen
    Seconded: Arnold, Gerhard Steffen

    *Charter Amendment 12.8: Ajaccio and Cagliari are to be incorporated into the Reich. The Chancellor is directed to trade Cagliari to any foe if it can bring about a peace between our nations.
    Proposed: Lothar Steffen
    Seconded: Matthias Steffen, Gerhard Steffen

    *Charter Amendment 12.9:

    Clause 3.10 is amended to read as follows (changes in bold):
    3.10 Influential players get bonus votes (max +6 bonus)

    Appointed Influence (Max 4 points):
    Duke: +3
    King: +2
    Count: +1
    Chancellor, ex-Chancellor, or Prince: +1

    Stat Influence (Max 2 points):
    15 or more total stat points: +1 (I thought about a lower number, but all avatars are given a base 3 piety and base 5 loyalty, which means those points are freebies. So, 15 is only 7 from actual traits, plus the 8 piety and loyalty freebies)
    6 or more ranks in one stat: +1 (In the unlikely scenario where a character gets 6 or more in 2 stats without having 15 total, they get this +1 twice)

    The player who is Emperor gets bonus votes differently, being equal to his authority.
    Charter Amendment 11.6 is amended to read as follows (changes in strikeout):
    Charter Amendment 11.6: The position of King of Outremer is appointed by the emperor. This appointment lasts for the duration of the emperors reign or the Kings lifetime, whichever is shorter. The King of Outremer is permitted to resign, if the emperor is willing to accept the resignation, upon which a new King is appointed by the emperor. If the King of Outremer is deemed incapable of the assignment, he may be impeached by the emperor and 2 Dukes.
    Proposed: Jan von Hamburg
    Seconded: Matthias Steffen, Elberhard

  2. #2
    Senior Member Senior Member econ21's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2002
    Posts
    9,651

    Default Re: 12th Diet Edicts and CAs poll

    Results: all legislation passes, except CA 12.2.


    Details:

    Edict 12.1:
    Yes : AussieGiant (+5), Bob_the_great (+1), Cecil XIX (+1), econ21 (+4), FactionHeir (+4), gibsonsg91921 (+3), Ignoramus, Ituralde (+5), Northnovas (+3), OverKnight (+4), Privateerkev (+3), Stuperman (+5), Tamur (+3), TinCow (+3), Warmaster Horus (+1), GeneralHankerchief (+3)
    No :Kagemusha (+2)
    PASSES


    Edict 12.2:
    Yes :Bob_the_great (+1), Cecil XIX (+1), FactionHeir (+4), gibsonsg91921 (+3),
    Privateerkev (+3), Stig (+5), Stuperman (+5), Warmaster Horus (+1), GeneralHankerchief (+3)
    No :AussieGiant (+5), econ21 (+4), Ignoramus, Kagemusha (+2), Northnovas (+3),
    OverKnight (+4), Tamur (+3), TinCow (+3)
    PASSES 34 to 32


    Edict 12.3:
    Yes: Bob_the_great (+1), FactionHeir (+4), gibsonsg91921 (+3), Ignoramus,
    Northnovas (+3), OverKnight (+4), Privateerkev (+3), Stuperman (+5), Tamur (+3),
    Warmaster Horus (+1), GeneralHankerchief (+3), Xdeathfire (+5)
    No :AussieGiant (+5), Cecil XIX (+1), econ21 (+4), Ituralde (+5), Kagemusha (+2), Stig (+5), TinCow (+3)
    PASSES 45 to 32


    Edict 12.4:
    Yes : AussieGiant (+5), gibsonsg91921 (+3), Ignoramus, Ituralde (+5), Northnovas (+3), Stig (+5), Stuperman (+5), TinCow (+3)
    No : Bob_the_great (+1), Cecil XIX (+1), econ21 (+4), FactionHeir (+4), Kagemusha (+2), OverKnight (+4), Tamur (+3), Warmaster, Horus (+1)
    PASSES 37 to 28


    CA 12.1:
    Yes :AussieGiant (+5), Bob_the_great (+1), Cecil XIX (+1), FactionHeir (+4), gibsonsg91921 (+3), Ituralde (+5), Kagemusha (+2), Northnovas (+3), OverKnight (+4), Privateerkev (+3), Stig (+5), Stuperman (+5), Tamur (+3), TinCow (+3),
    Warmaster Horus (+1), GeneralHankerchief (+3)
    No : econ21 (+4), Ignoramus
    PASSES 66 to 6 (2/3 majority)


    CA 12.2:
    Yes :Kagemusha (+2), Northnovas (+3), Stig (+5), Warmaster Horus (+1)
    No : AussieGiant (+5), Bob_the_great (+1), Cecil XIX (+1), econ21 (+4), FactionHeir (+4), Ignoramus, Ituralde (+5), OverKnight (+4), Privateerkev (+3), Stuperman (+5), Tamur (+3)
    FAILS


    CA 12.3:
    Yes : AussieGiant (+5), Bob_the_great (+1), Cecil XIX (+1), econ21 (+4), FactionHeir (+4), gibsonsg91921 (+3), Ignoramus, Ituralde (+5), Kagemusha (+2), Northnovas (+3), OverKnight (+4), Privateerkev (+3), Stig (+5), Stuperman (+5), Tamur (+3), TinCow (+3), Warmaster Horus (+1), GeneralHankerchief (+3)
    PASSES NEM CON


    CA 12.6:
    Yes : AussieGiant (+5), Bob_the_great (+1), econ21 (+4), FactionHeir (+4), gibsonsg91921 (+3), Ignoramus, Ituralde (+5), Kagemusha (+2), OverKnight (+4), Privateerkev (+3), Stig (+5), Stuperman (+5), Tamur (+3), TinCow (+3), Warmaster Horus (+1), GeneralHankerchief (+3)
    No : Cecil XIX (+1), Northnovas (+3)
    PASSES (2/3 majority)

    CA 12.7:
    Yes : AussieGiant (+5), FactionHeir (+4), Ituralde (+5), Kagemusha (+2), Northnovas (+3), Stig (+5), Stuperman (+5), TinCow (+3), Warmaster Horus (+1), GeneralHankerchief (+3)
    No : Bob_the_great (+1), Cecil XIX (+1), econ21 (+4), OverKnight (+4), Privateerkev (+3), Tamur (+3)
    PASSES 46 to 22 (2/3 majority)


    CA 12.8:
    Yes : AussieGiant (+5), Bob_the_great (+1), Cecil XIX (+1), econ21 (+4), FactionHeir (+4), gibsonsg91921 (+3), Ignoramus, Ituralde (+5), Northnovas (+3), OverKnight (+4), Privateerkev (+3), Stig (+5), Stuperman (+5), Tamur (+3), TinCow (+3), Warmaster Horus (+1), GeneralHankerchief (+3)
    No : Kagemusha (+2)
    PASSES (2/3 majority)


    CA 12.9:
    Yes : AussieGiant (+5), Bob_the_great (+1), Cecil XIX (+1), econ21 (+4), FactionHeir (+4), gibsonsg91921 (+3), Ituralde (+5), Northnovas (+3), OverKnight (+4), Privateerkev (+3), Stuperman (+5), Tamur (+3), TinCow (+3), Warmaster Horus (+1), GeneralHankerchief (+3)
    No : Ignoramus, Kagemusha (+2), Stig (+5)
    PASSES 63 to 10 (2/3 majority)

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO