The Secret Formula [Concluded]

[seireikhaan]

Come on guys, we do this every game, it seems. Woadsy, Beefy, and/or Shlin make some kind of mistake, or act 'scummily' and we end up lynching either an innocent towny or a pro-town role. Haven't we learned our lesson yet? FOS: Roadkill, for that last post.

Additionally, lynch Brave_Sir_Robin! Been lurking for a while, after trying to get someone lynched on totally absurd grounds.

[Beefy187]

sweet.. Can i be in hall of fame or something? for getting lynched 5 games in a row.

Woad & Fangs: Yea i might be lousy. But least im trying hard.. Im just observing how people are reacting to my lousy reason. Its creating discussion thats cool and I dont care if im dead as long as i get to take the mafias down with me.

Roadkill: I wouldnt mind living for another turn or two. But i suppose your not gonna change your mind.

EDIT: Let Sir Robin speak first.. Then ill decide

[Caius]

Shlin had a fairly valid reason to kill off Ichigo.

Thats enough for me to believe that his innocent.

So, killing is good, ah?

Unvote:shlin28
Vote:Beefy187

[Beefy187]

you vote for me just because i said "kill" instead of "lynch"?

thats worse then all my worthless logic and lame reason spamming all combined together. This is round two.. We need better reasoning then this

[Caius]

you vote for me just because i said "kill" instead of "lynch"?

I dont like the actitude of defending shlin28. Thats all. You are covering him like if he could be your partner.

[Tratorix]

Come on guys, we do this every game, it seems. Woadsy, Beefy, and/or Shlin make some kind of mistake, or act 'scummily' and we end up lynching either an innocent towny or a pro-town role. Haven't we learned our lesson yet? FOS: Roadkill, for that last post.

Additionally, lynch Brave_Sir_Robin! Been lurking for a while, after trying to get someone lynched on totally absurd grounds.

How have I been lurking for "a while"? This is round 2. Also, who am I trying to get lynched? I called beefy a mafioso (jokingly) after he made a post saying for no one to get paranoid over what he said. As far as I can tell, the only one trying to get someone lynched for no reason is you .

Well, looks like Beefy is getting lynched over nothing again. I really don't think he's guilty. He seems to be trying to give some opinions, and everyone is calling that suspicious.

[RoadKill]

you vote for me just because i said "kill" instead of "lynch"?

thats worse then all my worthless logic and lame reason spamming all combined together. This is round two.. We need better reasoning then this

Yes and no. This is only round two, I hope your not expecting any insanly detailed reasonings, as we almost have zero evidence of anyone being mafia right now. You are also taking great offense in Caius starting discussion on you, scummy?

[Beefy187]

Oh right.. Lets say if i am.. First ill get my self killed by getting attention. Then Shlin will get killed anyway next round or so. Very clever.

Then I would say this.. Which makes you think im innocent. Reverse phycology is extremely useful in mafia. Then ill just name two random players name. Those two get killed. People will go mafia is a noob. Thats the most obvious framing ever. then i might survive till the end killing every single one of you. Sounds like a plan.

If I am a mafia I will never tell you this. But then again I might be using reverse phycology. Hmm..So yea pretty much you guys only got three options
1. Lynch me just incase
2. Make a deal with me. Ill be quiet so let me live
3. Trust me im innocent

1 is the best. You got lots of people left anyway. Getting one lynch wrong wouldnt hurt much. 2 sounds good too. I got a feeling that im getting really annoying. I gotta go study anyway. 3 is a bit of gamble. But after accidently lynching me 5 games in a row, you could start trusting me a bit. Im only trying to help the town. Personally all the option is good. 1 and 2 makes my life easier. 3 makes me feel good. So i dont mind any options. Take your pick


EDITED
I prefer option 2. so i got something to do when i dont wanna study or when the test is over (Tuesday Australian time)

Lets talk more. We only got like 5 active players. If all of us gets killed we are doomed pretty much

[seireikhaan]

Also, who am I trying to get lynched? I called beefy a mafioso (jokingly) after he made a post saying for no one to get paranoid over what he said. As far as I can tell, the only one trying to get someone lynched for no reason is you .

You're asking him to prove a negative. That's bad logic. I don't like bad logic.

Vote:CountArach

Apparently you missed my earlier post? It was quite obvious that CA wasn't seriously asking Martok to prove his innocence, as CA is quite well aware that is impossible in the first round. And yet you turned in a vote against him over it?

[Tratorix]

I didn't realize he was joking.To me, his post sounded quite serious. I voted for him because of that. Besides, in the first round theres no evidence to go on anyway. I thought that was as good a reason as any.

[TevashSzat]

Oh right.. Lets say if i am.. First ill get my self killed by getting attention. Then Shlin will get killed anyway next round or so. Very clever.

Then I would say this.. Which makes you think im innocent. Reverse phycology is extremely useful in mafia. Then ill just name two random players name. Those two get killed. People will go mafia is a noob. Thats the most obvious framing ever. then i might survive till the end killing every single one of you. Sounds like a plan.

If I am a mafia I will never tell you this. But then again I might be using reverse phycology. Hmm..So yea pretty much you guys only got three options
1. Lynch me just incase
2. Make a deal with me. Ill be quiet so let me live
3. Trust me im innocent

1 is the best. You got lots of people left anyway. Getting one lynch wrong wouldnt hurt much. 2 sounds good too. I got a feeling that im getting really annoying. I gotta go study anyway. 3 is a bit of gamble. But after accidently lynching me 5 games in a row, you could start trusting me a bit. Im only trying to help the town. Personally all the option is good. 1 and 2 makes my life easier. 3 makes me feel good. So i dont mind any options. Take your pick


EDITED
I prefer option 2. so i got something to do when i dont wanna study or when the test is over (Tuesday Australian time)

Lets talk more. We only got like 5 active players. If all of us gets killed we are doomed pretty much

I believe that you are getting way too defensive here. Normal townies wouldn't be so analytical in defending themselves especially when you arent necessarily bandwagoned on already.

Unvote, Vote: Beefy

[Beefy187]

Heh the thing is mate.. Im not normal. I take pride in being strange

[GeneralHankerchief]

*sigh*

Come on, guys. We've all seen this before. How many times have we falsely lynched Beefy in the past?

[sapi]

Safer to falsely lynch than falsely leave alive

[RoadKill]

*sigh*

Come on, guys. We've all seen this before. How many times have we falsely lynched Beefy in the past?

Maybe we'll get him as mafia this time!

[Twilightblade]

Safer to falsely lynch than falsely leave alive

you have my complete support in this sapi

[Tiberius of the Drake]

how many times has beefy been lynched falsely...5 games in a row now...

I just realised how sad it is that my first death was that i was eaten by a cannibal....

[Beefy187]

You have my complete support too Sapi.

Thats normally my attitude of lynching.How ever the normal rule doesnt seem to apply to me.

Only time I was playing strange/ normal which was "walking dinner" that time i was playing mafia. Every single other time i follow the exact same pattern.. I do either joke vote or random reasoning, get FoS or 1 vote, overreact and get paranoid, then getting lynched.. Oh well i suppose ull have to use my death wisely. You better win townies.

[sapi]

You have my complete support too Sapi.

Thats normally my attitude of lynching.How ever the normal rule doesnt seem to apply to me.

Only time I was playing strange/ normal which was "walking dinner" that time i was playing mafia. Every single other time i follow the exact same pattern.. I do either joke vote or random reasoning, get FoS or 1 vote, overreact and get paranoid, then getting lynched.. Oh well i suppose ull have to use my death wisely. You better win townies.

Well, hopefully we'll eventually realise it's normal for you

[Beefy187]

Hmm i hope so too.. Its not very fun for me getting lynched in 3 games simultaneously just because i wanted to catch the mafia..

If I am innocent (I am too) im pretty sure at least one of the mafia is trying to be neutral on this case. Other mafia is rather quiet and he/she is going to stay quiet.

[Jubal_Barca]

Mafia Professional? You mean you can get paid for doing this?

I'm really mostly a good endgame or small game player, I'm afraid. THis is my largest ever game. Also, in the rules I use days can go on for up to a fortnight before a lynch which is way beter for analysis.

My hunch agianst woad is very minor;

The princess bride is a great movie. I really have to watch it again some time. The WIFOM involved with the two mafia kills is overwhelming and makes my head hurt. Vote: Sasaki A hunch.

My guess is that either this is a breadcrumb or something prearranged as a signal of some sort.

unvote woad


Hate this post from Xdeathfire;

I believe that you are getting way too defensive here. Normal townies wouldn't be so analytical in defending themselves especially when you arent necessarily bandwagoned on already.

Normal townies shouldn't be analytical? my friend.

vote xdeathfire

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

I don't believe that Beefy is who we are looking for. He always is eager to lynch and always does something which makes him look like a suspect, despite him actually being totally innocent. If you want to lynch him, do so when there is nothing else to go on - right now we have several good pieces of evidence upon shlin who is acting rather peculiarly.

[Beefy187]

Just read the article on "how to be a good townie" on yahoo answers....

Ill be good if you let me live

[Hepcat]

Hmm i hope so too.. Its not very fun for me getting lynched in 3 games simultaneously just because i wanted to catch the mafia..

If I am innocent (I am too) im pretty sure at least one of the mafia is trying to be neutral on this case. Other mafia is rather quiet and he/she is going to stay quiet.

I agree with Beefy, I think the Mafia are going to try sitting back not doing anything, but then I'm no expert on Mafia games.

[Beefy187]

Well the thing is.. after reading your post they will either get active if they are not experienced. Or stay cool if they are good. Or it could be you

[Csargo]

Shlin had a fairly valid reason to kill off Ichigo.

I wonder what a valid reason is in your opinion. "He's so guilty did you see him post that s???? MAFIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA"

[shlin28]

Unvote, Vote TwilightBlade (If you see this as a scummy behaviour please feel free to vote for me, but TwilightBlade's revenge vote against Pever in round 1 is very suspicious in my mind, as I said before.)

shlin28: 3(omanes, stig, ca)
beefy: 2 (inca, xdeath)
kingwarman: 1(gh)
Zain: 1(tran)
Sasaki: 1(woad)
brave robin: 1(greaterkhaan)
xdeathfire: 1(barca)
barca: 1(Warmaster Horus)
zorg: 1 (beefy)
twilight:1 (shlin28)

[Stig]

Then why did you not vote for him earlier? Because now, that people seem to be going after Beefy you might still be saved?

[Twilightblade]

If it seems suspicious to you thats fine with me

but pever never said how I was playing diffrently which was the said reason for his vote

[shlin28]

Then why did you not vote for him earlier? Because now, that people seem to be going after Beefy you might still be saved?

Why... does... everything... I do seems suspicious to you?

I first voted for myself because I am sure I'm gonna get lynched, but then people started to put random pressure votes on random people, so I might as well join in; and why did nobody follow my advice on voting Twilight?