The Spinache Pie Conspiracy [Concluded]

[Kommodus]

Also, what's with this business of everyone saying I revealed? I never revealed anything...

Sure ya did.

The same thing happened in Mafia III. I was mafia; and Crazed Rabbit, the detective, had just been killed. He knew I was guilty, but was forbidden by the rules from actually saying "I'm the detective and I know Kommodus is guilty." So instead he simply said "Lynch Kommodus; I'm certain of his guilt for reasons I can't explain."

So when you say, after three rounds:

Everyone, lynch Omanes. I cannot state exactly why, you will have to trust me. For the same reason, do not lynch Roadkill or Gibson.

It really makes it obvious what your role is, and what your reasons are for asking the town to lynch Omanes while ignoring the other two. You're the detective, revealing your results. The fact that you didn't state it in so many words is virtually irrelevant.

(Although apparently someone didn't pick up on this very obvious fact.)

Having been on the receiving end of this ploy in the past, I think it's a bit of an exploit, cleverly circumventing the letter of the law while violating its spirit. That's why I'm more or less OK with the mafia taking this one.

[Andres]

Night 5 : Conclusion

After the lynching of gibson, Omanes walked carefully and slowly towards Zain. He possessed an antagonistic grin, filled with with pure malice. Zain somehow failed to notice.

"I see that we lynched yet another guard. I consider his noble sacrifice a confirmation of his innocence"

"I still stand by what I said" Zain responded, "despite the nobility of it all, I am convinced we removed a pie heretic today."

"Let's just agree to disagree" Omanes replied. "I have had strong evidence, ever since the attacks began, to suggest his mind was free of such anti-spinach thoughts"

"What was this evidence? Why did you fail to share it to save all this brutality?"

Zain sounded, and was, rather confused.

"I've known who was performing these anti-conspiracy attacks all this"

"Well, who was it?"

"I'll let you into a little secret Zain"

Omanes toned his voice down to a harsh yet mysterious whisper.

"It was me!"

Zain was still absorbing this abrupt and unexpected shock, when Omanes threw a large overcooked spinach pie at his head. Zain was knocked out instantaneously by the hard crust, and unceremoniously hit the concrete floor.

"Ruddy conspirators - deserve all they get!"

Zain however wasn't dead and he ran away. He was agonised. He was hiding in the main stairwell now. He decided to stay somewhere where there are no spinach-related implements to cause his death. But suddenly, he hears a whistling sound behind him. He turns just in time to see a can of spinach hurtling toward his head. The can hits him right in the nose, sending him toppling down 10 flights of stairs to land at the bottom, his neck broken from the fall.

Meanwhile, Roadkill is patrolling the facility. He's rather nervous about how few people are left, then he notices a light coming from the kitchens.

Curious, but wary, he slowly moves in to investigate. He sees a boiling pot on the stove, and moves in get a closer look. As he takes the top off the pot, he realizes it's a pot of.... boiling spinach. Suddenly, he's hit from behind and knocked toward the pot. Someone grabs him by the head and forces him into the pot, drowning him in water and spinach.

The last thing he heard was the hysterical laugh of Brave Sir Robin.

Alive: (2)

Omanes - Pop
Brave Sir Robin - Pie

Killed (6)
shlin28
Kommodus
Warmaster Horus
greaterkhaan - detective
Roadkill
Zain

Lynched (4)

Beefy187
CountArach
Stig
gibsonsg91921

WoG/suicide (0)


RESULT : TOTAL MAFIA VICTORY !


Congratulations mafia! Great game!

[Warmaster Horus]

Nice game evil mafiosi! Congratulations!

Thanks Andres for hosting this!

[Stig]

Oh, it was so obvious that Omanes was mafia, and that GK even revealed, how could some townies not see that?

[Kommodus]

Oh, it was so obvious that Omanes was mafia, and that GK even revealed, how could some townies not see that?

They did, except for Zain, who I think was too upset about being accused along with Omanes to notice.

Anyway, GG Omanes and Brave_Sir_Robin! And Andres, nice job with the hosting! Thanks!

[Zain]

I told you all I wasn't the mafia.

Either way, this round was a learning experience, I was almost certain Omanes was innocent until after I got Gibson lynched.

[seireikhaan]

Aww, gg, mafia. Unfortunately, I did bring some of this upon myself. I investigated Omanes in round two, but decided to go for the double whammy and try to snag both mafioso. Unfortunately, I pushed my luck exactly one round too far. I had planned on ratting Omanes out, along with confirming the other's innocence, the round that I was unfortunately killed on.

Also, Zain, what made you think Omanes was innocent?

[Stig]

I simply put pressure on Omanes after Kommo got killed, just to test him. I acted as if I were detective, accusing him of killing Kommo, and I can tell you Omanes, you must work on it. You can't stand pressure, you started evading my questions and you were obviously hiding something.

[Zain]

When he was victimized like myself, I felt pity for him. I won't do that again though.

[seireikhaan]

When he was victimized like myself, I felt pity for him. I won't do that again though.

Aye, you have now learned one of the basics of mafia 101: never sympathize with anyone, because it can be played by the mafia with ease.

[Zain]

Yep, I'm ready for another one to get going.

These don't last as long as I thought. I've already been in 3, although I was lynched in the first round in my second game...

Either way, next one opens up, be ready to fight for a slot

[Tratorix]

Woo! My first ever mafia victory!

Thanks for hosting Andres!

[gibsonsg91921]

I thought it was Omanes and Zain, nicely played BSR

[Zain]

Might I ask, why did you suspect me?

[gibsonsg91921]

i really have no idea. bsr was that good.

[Zain]

BSR never did much.

He's not too active.

Plus, I think I didn't cast one vote for Omanes the whole time, now that I go back and check...

[Tratorix]

BSR never did much.

He's not too active.

Plus, I think I didn't cast one vote for Omanes the whole time, now that I go back and check...

Theres something to be said for not being that active. I never garnered any suspicion throughout the game. True, it would have worked less well in a larger game, but it served my purposes here.

[Zain]

Theres something to be said for not being that active. I never garnered any suspicion throughout the game. True, it would have worked less well in a larger game, but it served my purposes here.

True that.

Well played.

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

Thanks for hosting Andres!

I really wasn't expecting to survive after Stig's merciless attack, but for some reason the town were unfortunate enough to not detect my guilt - Stig's actions in a way cloaked it.

Anyhow, I think a congratulations is in order for Stig and for greaterkhaan for being the only ones who managed to actually pin me in the earlier game.

[Warmaster Horus]

I simply put pressure on Omanes after Kommo got killed, just to test him. I acted as if I were detective, accusing him of killing Kommo, and I can tell you Omanes, you must work on it. You can't stand pressure, you started evading my questions and you were obviously hiding something.

Yeah, seing it from this POV it's alright, but when we don't have too much time to determine the mafiosi, well...
You can attack anyone, and if they crumble, they aren't necessarily mafiosi, just "weak" (I'm not trying to insult anyone here) in their defence.

However, what I think should be done is this: lynch Stig (in this situation) and then Omanes. That way, if Stig was right then it's good, if Stig was wrong, well... Third on the bandwagon, anyone?

[shlin28]

Good Game, from a viewer's perspectie... Just dont kill me again

[CountArach]

Hmmm...

I say ban them all.

Thanks for hosting this on Andres! I ignored it after I got lynched for quite possibly the worst reason imaginable, but it looks like a pretty good conclusion.

[pevergreen]

Teh Ban! Teh Ban!

[Beefy187]

Every single time someone calls my vote "random" i get it right. In farmtown i got Roadkill vote right. In this one I got BSR right... Maybe you should start trustin my gut feelings.