Hey, TWFanatic; a moment of your time, if you will:
In your description of the mod, you mention that without it hoplites "break formation and charge like unorganized rabble", and with it "they stay in a tight, orderly formation and slam into the enemy as one..."
So, apparently, it is almost impossible for a phalanx to maintain cohesion during a charge, and they didn't organize back into a line until the back rows had caught up with the front. That means that the old style of charge was actually correct.
And, to be clear, I'm talking about regular hoplites, not phalangites.
Bookmarks