I've played through four three-and-a-bit campaigns now, and I've been trying to play each faction individually and give each campaign some unique flavour. I've played as Scotland (226 turns), Venice (domination), France (long campaign), and Sicily (still playing). The list below is some of the most effective armies I've developed, just wondering how everyone else fought.
Scotland
Tried to roleplay the Scots by building Gaelic-style Highland armies in the early game based around a Highland charge, and then pike and spear armies later on, with some knights etc.
Early Game:
1x General's Bodyguard
2x Border Horse
5x Highland Nobles
8x Highlanders
4x Peasant / Highland Archers
Mid Game:
1x General's Bodyguard
2x Border Horse
3x Mailed / Feudal Knights
5x Spear Militia
5x Scots Pike Militia
4x Highland Noble Archers
Late Game:
1x General's Bodyguard
2x Border Horse
3x Feudal Knights
4x Dismounted Feudal Knights
4x Noble Pikemen
3x Highland Noble Archers
3x Mercenary Arquibusiers
Venice
I found that my Italian militia armies were deadly in the early game, but after a hundred turns or so I quickly realised that their time was running out after my militia army was defeated heavily by an army of armoured sergeants and dismounted knights. I was roleplaying the city state, so I didn't get a Castle till after that defeat, and only then did I realise what I was missing. Although its a city state, Venice gets some of the best castle infantry in the game. So I soon put these new units to use in my reformed armies.
Early Game:
1x General's Bodyguard
1x Carroccio Standard
2x Mercenary Frankish Knights
12x Italian Spear Militia
4x Pavise Crossbow Militia
Mid Game:
1x General's Bodyguard
1x Carroccio Standard
4x Mailed / Feudal Knights
4x Dismounted Feudal Knights
6x Italian Spear Militia
4x Pavise Crossbow Militia
Late Game:
1x General's Bodyguard
1x Carroccio Standard
2x Stradiots
2x Mounted Crossbowmen
2x Dismounted Feudal Knights
4x Venetian Heavy Infantry
4x Pavise Crossbow Militia
2x Venetian Archers
2x Arquebusiers / Musketeers
France
Tried to roleplay the classic feudal Kingdom by keeping plenty of castles and raising armies with a core of mounted knights with some levy footmen as backup. Enjoyed plenty of success throughout my whole campaign with these armies, although I was held back financially by my expensive knight units and my lack of cities in ratio to my castles.
Early Game:
1x General's Bodyguard
2x Mounted Sergeants
5x Mailed Knights
8x Sergeant Spearmen
2x Peasant Crossbowmen
2x Peasant Archers
Mid Game:
1x General's Bodyguard
2x Mounted Sergeants
5x Feudal Knights
3x Dismounted Feudal Knights
5x Armoured Sergeants
4x Crossbowmen
Late Game:
1x General's Bodyguard
2x French Mounted Archers
5x Chivalric Knights
3x Dismounted Chivalric Knights
3x Armoured Sergeants
2x Pikemen
2x Aventuriers
2x Scots Guard
Sicily
Here I've really been going for a feudal feel, and tried to raise top-notch cavalry armies in the true Norman spirit. I've had some great military success in this campaign, although the costs of maintaining an island empire in patched M2TW has proved really tough, I've had the Portuguese, Spanish, Moors, and even the Papacy (when island taken by Spanish) all going for my islands at Cagliari and Ajaccio. Combined with being attacked by Milanese and French at Milan and Marseille, and a besieging crusader state in Cordoba, I'm really struggling right now. Still, the military side of things have been going pretty well.
Early Game:
1x General's Bodyguard
2x Mounted Sergeants
10x Mailed Knights
4x Italian Spear Militia
4x Muslim Archers
Bookmarks