The Golden Rule [Concluded]

[shlin28]

You didn't say you have the explosives

Anyhoo... care to explain this?

Who's the dirty rat that killed my brother?

If not, I may just shoot you

[Yoyoma1910]

First off, you can call me Louis 7 Fingers. That should tell you what my job here is.

Suppose I could have been more obvious.

Who's the dirty rat that killed my brother?

That was my best James Cagney.

[shlin28]

Gah! I just know how to shoot guns and can't read... sorry...

Still keeping my vote on you though.

[Yoyoma1910]

No problem. I wouldn't expect less from an ex cop.

[Thermal]

Supposed Roles


explosives expert - Yoyoma 1910 ?
ex-SWAT - Shlin 28
false diplomat - Quintus JC
forgery expert - 777 Ares 777
Armored truck driver - White Eyes
Tanker Hijacker - El Diablo
communications expert - 187Beefyz
computer engineer - General Hankerchief
security guard -
plastic surgeon - Seirei khaan
accountant -
foreign liason - Woad & Fangs
mastermind - Tevash Szat
ex-marine - YLC

Tally, alphabetical and vote ordered

WhiteEyes: 2 (woad&fangs, El Diablo)
YLC: 2 (Beefy, Khaan)

Ares: 1 (GH)
Beefy: 1 (Chaotix)
El Diablo: 1 (Tevash)
GeneralHankerchief: 1 (YLC)
Tevash: 1 (Yoyoma)
woad&fangs: 1 (white eyes)
Yoyoma: 1 (Shlin)

[Yoyoma1910]

Ahem.



I make things go boom.

[ULC]

*drums fingers* Not much to say, not much going on...Ex-Marine here though.

*begins idly cleaning M590* I do hope people will start speaking up soon, it's getting rather boring around here, and were not getting anywhere. So, how does the CO of this operation handle ties?

[Thermal]

Well i haven't voted yet for those precised reasons, and i'd like a lead before i vote, which is differcult to get presently lets look through the roles....



explosives expert - agent material? i doubt it FBI and spies would be more tactful IMO

ex SWAT - special weapons and tactics, hmmmm, that sounds like a spy to me (though i'm not accusing yet, just trying to piece it together)

false diplomat - so-so, doubt it but still a tad suspicious

forgery expert - in my eyes a forgery expert doesn't make FBI material

Armoured truck driver - i imagine if any an accomplish to the head guy, though i think it's probably an innocent role

Tanker Hi-Jacker - The most suspicion IMHO, He would work in the same way as a gold hi jacker, there was ment to be a greedy guy on board, thats putting FBI out of the equation

communications expert - again quite suspicious, a spy could communicate with the FBI in various ways

computer engineer - have his uses, though i doubt he's agent material

security guard - security for the gang or for the bank? if for the gang then he's probably innocent

Plastic surgeon - again, can't see mafia here, just a feeling, cosmetics hardly makes for a traitorous killer

accountant - this guy could easily get his hands on the money, maybe not the main culprit but still along the lines of a traitor

foreign liason - could be crafty, but probably good

mastermind - i would say a mastermind is the gang leader, kind of, in such a way i would think there innocent

ex-marine - sounds to insignificant to be dangerous, not suspicious yet....


Please bare in mind i only considered the roles, not the players, i don't want to accuse anyone

out of them the most guilty i think are:

Ex SWAT
Tanker Hi-Jacker
Communications expert
Accountant

would anyone agree that these four sound more shifty?

Seeing as the accountant and communications expert haven't come forward, from the players who haven't claimed a role, we can piece together who they are, and if they don't reveal who they are, then we should lynch them i think, though you all have your say if you disagree

[woad&fangs]

Foreign Liason.

Also, remember that this game was originally designed for 13 players. That means 1 role had to of been come up with at the last second. This role is probably blander than the original 13 and is most likely innocent.

edit: ex-marine is most likely the additional role. So YLC is probably innocent.

[Beefy187]

I would vote for Aries just be all spiteful and stuff, but I pretty much just got him lynched in Fillet Royale, unless Reenk Roink saves him. So... I'll let him off easy for these first couple'a rounds.

Vote: Beefy

What's with the name change on you two? It could be a secret code...

I saw Aries changed his name (So he did change before me.) And I went.. "Wow cool! You can change names? Then I shall change mine to 187Beefyz so it looks like theres 187 of me... They shall fear me rawl!!!" Then I found out that I cannot change it back to my original name... So im stuck with this for now..

I am the Communication expert. My job is to hide somewhere, and report to you guys if there is anything suspicious coming in your way. If you seen "Bank Job" im that guy who hides on top of the roof.

[Thermal]

explosives expert - Yoyoma 1910 ?
ex-SWAT - Shlin 28
false diplomat - Quintus JC
forgery expert - 777 Ares 777
Armored truck driver - White Eyes
Tanker Hijacker - El Diablo
communications expert - 187Beefyz
computer engineer - General Hankerchief
security guard -
plastic surgeon - Seirei khaan
accountant -
foreign liason - Woad & Fangs
mastermind - Tevash Szat
ex-marine - YLC


Reenk Roink is yet to reveal, i'm thinking the accountant will get my vote


any ideas guys? i feel alone discussing with myself

[Beefy187]

explosives expert - Yoyoma 1910 ?
ex-SWAT - Shlin 28
false diplomat - Quintus JC
forgery expert - 777 Ares 777
Armored truck driver - White Eyes
Tanker Hijacker - El Diablo
communications expert - 187Beefyz
computer engineer - General Hankerchief
security guard -
plastic surgeon - Seirei khaan
accountant -
foreign liason - Woad & Fangs
mastermind - Tevash Szat
ex-marine - YLC


Reenk Roink and Tevash szat are yet to reveal, i'm thinking the accountant will get my vote, so i'm sure they'll both claim to be a security guard with that knowledge


any ideas guys? i feel alone discussing with myself

Tevash is the mastermind.
So its Reenk and someone else

[Thermal]

Tevash is the mastermind.
So its Reenk and someone else

i see sorry tevash, but i looked at the op, who else?

for now

vote: reenk roink
and at least i've tried to be logical about it ok?

edit: tally

WhiteEyes: 2 (woad&fangs, El Diablo)
YLC: 2 (Beefy, Khaan)

Ares: 1 (GH)
Beefy: 1 (Chaotix)
El Diablo: 1 (Tevash)
GeneralHankerchief: 1 (YLC)
Reenk Roink (Ares)
Tevash: 1 (Yoyoma)
woad&fangs: 1 (white eyes)
Yoyoma: 1 (Shlin)

[Thermal]

I realise the rule is not to edit posts with votes in, i confirm vote: reenk roink

[Chaotix]

Well, if you wanted to vote for the accountant, Aries, then you can vote for me. Because that's who I am.

However, I believe that voting solely based on the character roles is unreliable- if ATPG based his traitor and government agent upon the fake roles that they had, it would indeed be far too easy to find the two.

Also- with me in the mix this leaves one person without a role! Are you sure you copied all of them, Aries? If not, they we may have one of our traitors pretending to be a different role.

EDIT: Oh, I saw your edit- nix on that last point, there.

[White_eyes:D]

Well, if you wanted to vote for the accountant, Aries, then you can vote for me. Because that's who I am.

However, I believe that voting solely based on the character roles is unreliable- if ATPG based his traitor and government agent upon the fake roles that they had, it would indeed be far too easy to find the two.

Also- with me in the mix this leaves one person without a role! Are you sure you copied all of them, Aries? If not, they we may have one of our traitors pretending to be a different role.

EDIT: Oh, I saw your edit- nix on that last point, there.

No, there are fourteen roles there.....so, cover roles is the key word of the day....
We need to think on which role's are likely to be Mafia......but ATPG is random and I think it may take a while to find out who.....(as we have no clues, apart from are roles...)

[Thermal]

im aware assuming a role is bad isnt reliable, though its far more reliable than meatballing, anything is more reliable than that, i'll stick with reenk roink then, the security guard until he speak, hes the only one who hasnt, if he does though i may change my mind

[GeneralHankerchief]

Just because I haven't played with a bunch of people before, can anyone confirm if Ares is always like this?

[Thermal]

Just because I haven't played with a bunch of people before, can anyone confirm if Ares is always like this?

sometimes i spam sometimes i really delve into it and investigate, my playing style is quite varied, though i realize your not asking me

[Beefy187]

Just because I haven't played with a bunch of people before, can anyone confirm if Ares is always like this?

His a forum spammer, who can be quite good with analysis and taking leading ship as he have sharp observation. When he dies, he often attempts to come back as zombies

As for lynching by the role, I think its not that bad idea, as we are pretty much blind on round one and we won't feel as bad if we lynch someone important.

I would make the mastermind the mafia but ATPG done those tricks before in Futurama. I doubt he will do it again.

[Yoyoma1910]

forgery expert - in my eyes a forgery expert doesn't make FBI material

You have no idea what the FBI does, do you?


Forgery expert is classic FBI material.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Rule change.

Andres told me that the rules state that a 3 day long day phase is too long, and I'm still waiting on his response to my explanation.

Until then, days will be 2 days long, I'm afraid.

[Reenk Roink]

Why is everyone revealing their roles? Mafia has changed so much with you kids from the good old days...

Anyway, I'm the security guard and I abstain, courteously .

[GeneralHankerchief]

Well, where we're at now is everyone claiming a legitimate role, leaving it to pretty much total guesswork as to find which one is the one that ATPG made the traitor.

Alternatively, we could assume that things were done randomly and try a different, more precise route, but of course that would be too easy.

[Askthepizzaguy]

*rubs his hands together evilly*

[Reenk Roink]

I think the roles are smoke and mirrors. However, they give good material for role playing.

I'm watching you...

[Yoyoma1910]

I would make the mastermind the mafia but ATPG done those tricks before in Futurama. I doubt he will do it again.

I don't know... He might do it again just to throw everyone off, because no one would expect him to repeat himself. Oh, the wine that sits before me.


The only idea I have is that he probably wouldn't pick 'Khaan, because he might feel that was too obvious of a mafia choice. But that's just a hunch, and might be completely wrong.




Then again, he might have picked all the roles at random...

[Beefy187]

Then again, he might have picked all the roles at random...

That would be a safe choice for a host to avoid favoritism.

Still going by the characters aren't bad for round one

[shlin28]

Oh hurry up with the voting thingy, me wanty to shooty someone.

[Thermal]

You have no idea what the FBI does, do you?


Forgery expert is classic FBI material.

honestly? No i'm not up to date with FBI info, but i doubt a forgery expert would kill, more on the crafty side if anything

El Diablo: 2 (Tevash, Ares)
WhiteEyes: 2 (woad&fangs, El Diablo)
YLC: 2 (Beefy, Khaan)

Ares: 1 (GH)
Beefy: 1 (Chaotix)
GeneralHankerchief: 1 (YLC)
Tevash: 1 (Yoyoma)
woad&fangs: 1 (white eyes)
Yoyoma: 1 (Shlin)

i will change my vote because reenk roink turned up, and i hope i don't get lynched for being active like i was on fillet royale, me not happy about that

unvote: reenk roink
vote: el diablo

the most suspicion sound role in my eyes, with a dodgy username as a back up

just to make the top of the board more interesting, and give YLC and white eyes company up there