XCOM Mafia [Concluded]

[Csargo]

I also want to go back and look at WH's votes on Manasi and see what's there.

[El Barto]

what're the odds that auto actually starts posting

After Day Four the odds tend to go up.

The only thing stopping me from voting you Walrein, is the fact that Manasi voted Dp101 on Day 1, which would give me pause on thinking you are scum. That really doesn't amount to much in the grand scheme of things, because I'm pretty sure she called novice scummy or something like that. Otherwise I would have already lodged my vote considering I wasn't a huge fan of Dp101 from the beginning. I've not seen much from you to make me reconsider my previous intuition about Dp101.

If it weren't for the bolded I wouldn't have proposed the Dp101/Fredwood alternative.

I plan on going back and looking at D1/D2 to see if anything sticks out to me.

And…?

I'm Here, kind of agree that POE is down to me, you, Nips and Auto, I guess,....I know I'm not scum, and I'm not convinced Auto is scum either, so I will vote either you or Nips if none of us are scum town loses for lock towning, so rip anyway. I can argue myself in and out of literally every point and counterpoint on you two though, so it will probably come down to gut feels.

‘You’ is Csargo?

I also want to go back and look at WH's votes on Manasi and see what's there.

Anything?

[El Barto]

what're the odds that auto actually starts posting

After Day Four the odds tend to go up.

The only thing stopping me from voting you Walrein, is the fact that Manasi voted Dp101 on Day 1, which would give me pause on thinking you are scum. That really doesn't amount to much in the grand scheme of things, because I'm pretty sure she called novice scummy or something like that. Otherwise I would have already lodged my vote considering I wasn't a huge fan of Dp101 from the beginning. I've not seen much from you to make me reconsider my previous intuition about Dp101.

If it weren't for the bolded I wouldn't have proposed the Dp101/Fredwood alternative.

I plan on going back and looking at D1/D2 to see if anything sticks out to me.

And…?

I'm Here, kind of agree that POE is down to me, you, Nips and Auto, I guess,....I know I'm not scum, and I'm not convinced Auto is scum either, so I will vote either you or Nips if none of us are scum town loses for lock towning, so rip anyway. I can argue myself in and out of literally every point and counterpoint on you two though, so it will probably come down to gut feels.

‘You’ is Csargo?

I also want to go back and look at WH's votes on Manasi and see what's there.

Anything?

[El Barto]

wtf double post

[Csargo]

After Day Four the odds tend to go up.

If it weren't for the bolded I wouldn't have proposed the Dp101/Fredwood alternative.

And…?

‘You’ is Csargo?

Anything?

Pretty sure he was referring to Walrein.

And I haven't looked yet, because I'm lazy Barto.

[Csargo]

Yes! That was an interesting intervention by him. He had never posted anything related to you or to novice (either to justify lynching you for yourself or as a byproduct of saving novice whom he'd be townreading). He's only made sociable posts. Even my Day One posts have had more game-related content than his. But the clearness of his vote belies his claimed drunkenness/hangover.

Blatant lies itt. I missed this before.

[Csargo]

Isoed Winston still think his posts are townie. He seems to have genuine progression and trying to solve. He had a clear progression on numerous people and Manasi it appears to me. I'd still clear that spot imo, because I don't see anything terribly scummy in the iso.

[Csargo]

Manasi was around for the entirety of EoD 1, which means she could have easily moved her vote if Dp101 was actually in danger of being lynched that day. I don't see that as particularly clearing.

[Csargo]

El Barto you scum son? Your posts don't give me a warm and fuzzy feeling. I should iso you as well, paranoia feels great.

[El Barto]

She tried to pocket me as well.

Blatant lies itt. I missed this before.

Oh, Monty called me out on my claim that my D1 posts have substance not long after I made that post.

[autolycus]

Could you specify on the bolded?

I can try, but I haven't had that much time for this game so my thought continuity is weak. I think it was largely the drop-off in participation after day 1 (which may be NAI), and his circling around voting jowy before he did it, which felt like the hedging of scum because they know they're lynching town.

[El Barto]

Hmmm. It seems that a rereading of D1 is in order for tomorrow afternoon, then.

[Nippleman]

Sorry,

I am still working on the reread. Weekends are always pretty shotty for me to post. I am still reading along in my spare time. Issue is that there is a pre-release for Magic and I am a judge for that :p.

[Zack]

Official Tally as of #2113

----

Day 6 ends in:

----

2 Walrein (autolycus, El Barto)

1 autolycus (Walrein)

----

Not Voting: Csargo, Fredwood, Nippleman

----

If you notice anything wrong, PM me.

[El Barto]

I think it is wrong, by now, that so many players (3/6) are not voting in a game that has seen a 24-hour extension and where there is no majority lynch rule in force.

Issue is that there is a pre-release for Magic and I am a judge for that.

If you swung us a few booster packs we could come to a satisfactory arrangement.

[Csargo]

Vote:Walrein

[El Barto]

Manasi was around for the entirety of EoD 1, which means she could have easily moved her vote if Dp101 was actually in danger of being lynched that day. I don't see that as particularly clearing.

Heh, in fact, I've taken the trouble of going through that.
As you said yesterday:

The only thing stopping me from voting you Walrein, is the fact that Manasi voted Dp101 on Day 1, which would give me pause on thinking you are scum. That really doesn't amount to much in the grand scheme of things, because I'm pretty sure she called novice scummy or something like that. Otherwise I would have already lodged my vote considering I wasn't a huge fan of Dp101 from the beginning. I've not seen much from you to make me reconsider my previous intuition about Dp101.

I plan on going back and looking at D1/D2 to see if anything sticks out to me.

So, here we go, posts and timestamps (remember that the game phase ended at :30, not at :00):

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Zack plz count it

Vote DP101

Too many sites too many voting formats

:21, that vote is invalid. Why would a mafiosa make such a mistake?

Vote:Dp101

huehuehue

at :22

Vote: Jowy for self-preservation.

at :24

That is more like it.

Now tell me why Csargo tosses his own head into the fire like that as scum. For the record.

at :25

I don't know right now, I really have to go. I'll think about this overnight though.

(insta-reply also at :25; Dp101 flees the thread)

weaksauce.

(at 0:26)

Meanwhile, Zack has pointed out Manasi's vote is invalid. She has no qualms making the vote when Jowy's already on 4 votes

use "vote:"

I ctrl+f to find votes

Ugh. A colon on mobile is so hard.

Vote: dp101

At :27

and then tries, at :28, to call attention to the fact that I have disappeared:

Where did Barto disappear

I might be slightly paranoid by now.

[Zack]

On phone but i believe it's

3 walrein
1 auto

~44 minutes

[El Barto]

Popping in for the last time before EoD!

Yes, Zack, that's the right tally. autolycus, El Barto and Csargo voting for Walrein; Walrein voting for autolycus; the rest not voting.


So, I was going to post this when Zack made that post.

I hope that I've nailed it and that it's really Dp101/Walrein or Fredwood and that for once I've somehow managed to lead a town to victory.

But if we have this level of participation, with me left to try and figure things out by myself like this, mostly speaking to myself, we might not deserve a victory that well, even with the scum's blunders -their kills haven't been bad in any case. Here's hoping to a victory nonetheless.

[Ampharos]

30 minutes to dl

nice

hardclaim one-shot delayed vigilante, still unused. let's find a better lynch target pls

[Ampharos]

Vote: Fredwood

maybe this is more acceptable

[Ampharos]

my shot still goes off if i'm nightkilled so i'm not a total dumbass for claiming i swear

[Zack]

Official Tally as of #2122

----

Day 6 ends in:

----

3 Walrein (autolycus, El Barto, Csargo)

1 Fredwood (Walrein)

----

Not Voting: Fredwood, Nippleman

----

If you notice anything wrong, PM me.

[Zack]

:59 good

:00 bad

[Zack]

Official Tally as of #2122

----

Day 6 ends in:

----

3 Walrein (autolycus, El Barto, Csargo)

1 Fredwood (Walrein)

----

Not Voting: Fredwood, Nippleman

----

If you notice anything wrong, PM me.

DAY IS OVER, DO NOT POST.

[Zack]

End of Day 6.


Walrein was chosen to die this extra-long day, though some did not even bother accusing anyone. His desperate last-minute pleas went unheard.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Walrein was an Archon!

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

He was town!

-------

It is now Night Six.

Night 6 ends in:

-------

Living Players: 5

@autolycus
@Csargo
@El Barto
@Fredwood
@Nippleman

------

Dead Players: 12

Jowy - Faceless
crimson_snow - Muton
Askthepizzaguy - Sectoid
GeneralHankerchief - Sectoid
Manasi - Grenadier
Sooh - ADVENT Trooper
BSmith - Psi Operative
Montmorency - ADVENT Shieldbearer
novice - Sharpshooter
Logic - ADVENT Trooper
Cuth - Viper
Walrein - Archon

[Zack]

you can post

[Csargo]

Popping in for the last time before EoD!

Yes, Zack, that's the right tally. autolycus, El Barto and Csargo voting for Walrein; Walrein voting for autolycus; the rest not voting.


So, I was going to post this when Zack made that post.

I hope that I've nailed it and that it's really Dp101/Walrein or Fredwood and that for once I've somehow managed to lead a town to victory.

But if we have this level of participation, with me left to try and figure things out by myself like this, mostly speaking to myself, we might not deserve a victory that well, even with the scum's blunders -their kills haven't been bad in any case. Here's hoping to a victory nonetheless.

I'm sad. Wish I would have seen Walrein's post last night, would have voted Fredwood.

[El Barto]

30 minutes to dl

nice

hardclaim one-shot delayed vigilante, still unused. let's find a better lynch target pls

This… this is inexcusably bad play. You know we cleared a player mechanically with a similar delayed vigilante ability, I expressly told you so when you asked about relevant points. Why don't you just say the same thing, so that we look outside the pair of you instead of making us waste a day and a lynch?

[Fredwood]

Well, that claim. Sorry I missed the vote for some reason thought it was an hour later. (THink i got confused with another game)