Beefy in love [Concluded]

[Diamondeye]

When I read the first accusation against me, I honestly thought it was a joke. I don't see my actions as scummy at all. I was just being silly. It was the first day, for crying out loud. Honestly, it's pretty darn ridiculous to have one vote based on my actions, but three? Are you people serious?
As for the defense thing, I apologize if I go to school in a building where the only websites you can get on are educational ones. This is actually the first time I've been on any mafia websites today. Diamondeye's actions set off my alarm bells, and they're usually pretty darn quiet. This is ludicrous.
Vote:Diamondeye
FoS: DiY
FoS: ATPG

This post is scummy as hell and contains a vote that puts someone else solidly in front of yourself by bandwagoning.
Landlubber is scum

I've never heard of a pressure bandwagon, however, nor do I think it practical.

... But an OMGUS-bandwagon is okay? In a game of 14 (well, 12 alive) players, 3 votes for pressure is very reasonable.
I don't like the way you're bending under that pressure though.

This isn't helping your case. If you're a townie and being falsely accused, please fight it, at least a little. A self vote day two doesn't show us anything at all, at least not this early in the game, unless of coarse it's Pizza doing it...

Okay; unvote; vote:Landlubber
Putting my vote where it should never have left.

Who is Landlubber's partner? Autolycus seems like the best bid.

[Diamondeye]

Unofficial Tally:
Diamondeye: Landlubber
DiY: Diamondeye
ATPG: Landlubber
Romanic: DiY
Autolycus: Diamondeye
GE: DIY
Civplayah: Diamondeye
Landlubber: Diamondeye
pevergreen: Diamondeye
TheFlax: DiY
Skooma Addict: DiY
Seon: DiY

Diamondeye: 5
DiY: 5
Landlubber: 2


I could change my vote to DiY to save myself but I honestly believe the scum are landlubber and autolycus, so it would be pointless.

[Death is yonder]

IMO you are being way too definitive for the early game.

My votes were meant as a reaction probe, and yours (you claim) were pressure votes on landlubber.

I'm interested to know why this has transcended to certainty in your decision as evidenced by this line:

Who is Landlubber's partner? Autolycus seems like the best bid.

I'm sticking my vote here, both out of self preservation, and a re-gauging of priorities in that you are likelier than landlubber to be the guilty party.

[Diamondeye]

I believe Post #91 clarifies my opinion on why Landlubber is scum.

I don't about being too definitive, we need to lynch someone and I pressured Landlubber. His reaction didn't convince me that he wasn't scum. I'm not saying I'm certain he's scum, I'm saying it's the most likely case thus far.
I don't know, if I did as you and went self-preservation by changing my vote onto you instead of trying to root out scum, you'd be in the lead by now and probably be lynched. But I think you're just an off-course townie, so I won't.

[Beefy187]

Thanks for the tally Diamond Eye
I appreciate it.

Voting closed if someone breaks the tie.

[landlubber]

This post is scummy as hell and contains a vote that puts someone else solidly in front of yourself by bandwagoning.
Landlubber is scum

I don't get it. You asked for a defense with your opening post. As soon as my real life allows, I give you that defense, hoping to satisfy you. Now, you're saying that my defense was scummy. Your campaign has switched from pressure vote to scum vote, based on my defense.
I just don't get it.

[Diamondeye]

I don't get it. You asked for a defense with your opening post. As soon as my real life allows, I give you that defense, hoping to satisfy you. Now, you're saying that my defense was scummy. Your campaign has switched from pressure vote to scum vote, based on my defense.
I just don't get it.

What is it you don't get?
The "Defend yourself!" vote was simply a pressure vote. Saying "Defend yourself" doesn't mean I have any concrete evidence against you (how could I, so early?). It was just pressure, and you buckled under it. There's no reason not to follow up such a hunch when there are no better cases to chase.

Landlubber, who do you think is the mafia, then, if it isn't you?

[landlubber]

Well, you bandwagoneers are my first choice. I know all three of you can't be mafia, so one of you just got mixed up with the wrong crowd. Out of the three of you, I'd say you and ATPG are more suspicious and DiY was just influenced by peer pressure, or something. You for a "pressure vote" that turned into a smear campaign, and ATPG for still no explanation whatsoever on his vote.
I don't think anyone else sees me as scummy, DE. It's you who buckled under the pressure of a meaningless vote, which a couple people called you on, which you then tried to give meaning to by turning my everyday behavior as scummy. You're chasing ghosts here; that is, if you really believe I am mafia.

[Diamondeye]

... So the only one suspicious are the people accusing you? I'm not getting this angle off as very plausible.
Can you think of someone else? The latecomers on to either of the tied bandwagons, per example?

AskThePizzaGuy explained his vote to my content (I even agreed with the reasoning behind), but I'm sure he will indulge in further explanations if you require so. I have for myself presented the case I found to be on you (if there are such things on day 2), so your arguments are not very well-founded.

So, you think both me and DiY is scummy - want me to move my vote to myself and get it over with? Or onto DiY and get rid of him?

[Kagemusha]

Diamondeye is asking a legimite question, landlubber, which one these two should go in your opinion?

[landlubber]

You do realized that I said I was going to give DiY the benefit of the doubt, right? I specifically said:
"Out of the three of you, I'd say you and ATPG are more suspicious and DiY was just influenced by peer pressure, or something."
I feel I have answered all your questions fairly, but this is getting us nowhere. I'm not trying to argue, just defend myself. I have no arguments, so I guess that's why they aren't very well-founded.
I just don't see how you could get definitive proof from a reaction. I don't think anyone besides ATPG (who's vote is still a question mark to me) sees it. So, my vote stands.

[landlubber]

Oh, his question was legit? I truthfully thought it sarcastic. Between the two, I would rather see Diamondeye lynched. I think DiY deserves another chance; like I said before, benefit of the doubt.

[Kagemusha]

Thank you for your answer.

[Diamondeye]

Unvote: Landlubber
Vote: Diamondeye

[civplayah]

Diamondeye isn't scum.

vote: landlubber

[Seon]

Err.... what?....

Edit: Why the sudden unvoting, DE?

[landlubber]

Ignore this, I was confused.

[Beefy187]

Diamond eyes vote was a tie breaker.
Diamondeye is lynched.

Write up is coming after breakfast

[Diamondeye]

I did what I felt was best to get the town moving moving again; me or DiY had to die, and I'm not very convinced that DiY is mafia. I made this move that we could get past this day phase without having to revisit this exact conflict later.

I still think a Landlubber/Autolycus mafia team is plausible, but Landlubber's reactions in the critical moments don't strike me as especially scummy.
I'd try to look between those people who jumped on the badnwagons when they were already rolling tomorrow. Of course, I can't tell who's going to die tonight, but pevergreen should be looked at. Skooma and Flax as well, perhaps.

[Beefy187]

Day 2 summery
After a long discussion, it was decided that Diamondeye was to go.
"Diamondeye. You are not only suspected, but you also volunteer to go.. How do you plead?"
"Not guilty. But someone must go. Might as well be me."

"Fair enough" said Molga. "Today I have a guest... Come in Commandwolf!"


"Eat him... But do not kill him."

With a fear some roar, Commandwolf swallowed Diamondeye.

"Now. Go prepare for the next operation!"

Start Night 2


List of alive players 11/14
Skooma Addict
pevergreen
TheFlax
Seon
Romanic
God Emperor
Death is Yonder
Landlubber
Civplayah
Askthepizzaguy
autolycus

Lynched 2/14
Beskar
Diamondeye

Killed 1/14
Kagemusha

[Askthepizzaguy]

I am wondering why this vote was so contentious this early. Surely there wasn't any reason why people could have very strong feelings on any candidate so soon, unless they know something I don't.

I would be intrigued to know landlubber's status.

[landlubber]

I'm not exactly following you. Status?

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'm not exactly following you. Status?

Guilty/innocent.

Someone seemed to be trying to spare you or Death is Yonder. There was something off about this vote.

[Kagemusha]

Guilty/innocent.

Someone seemed to be trying to spare you or Death is Yonder. There was something off about this vote.

Something to learn from?

[landlubber]

Well, I honestly don't know. To me, it's kind of a toss-up. He could be either. I'm leaning towards guilty, but I'm really not 100% sure.
I'll post more thoughts tomorrow. It's bedtime for me.

[Diamondeye]

I don't know... I haven't gotten a very scummy impression of Death Is Yonder, but it seems like others have.

I think it's safe to assume that if Death is Yonder is mafia, his partner was in the "Diamondeye" bandwagon.
Of those guys, I'd say pevergreen looks most suspicious.

Oh, and y'all owe me something if it actually turns out it's Landlubber and Autolycus.

[Beskar]

I already said it is Landlubber, kill him already.

[landlubber]

What makes you so sure? I honestly don't see the evidence against me.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Sometimes people pretend to be certain, and that puts more pressure on someone and gets them to crack. You've reacted a lot for someone with only a couple votes on them.

[Diamondeye]

Sometimes people pretend to be certain, and that puts more pressure on someone and gets them to crack. You've reacted a lot for someone with only a couple votes on them.

Thank you for precisely and adequately explaining the reasoning behind my Sasaki-like vote at the beginning of day 2