Pirate Ninja Robot Zombie Mafia IN SPACE [Concluded]

[wideyedwanderer]

Vote: Space Whale and Vote: SalmonSoil.

[atheotes]

I'd just like to point out that I technically didn't sign up for this game or consent to playing it.

that doesnt mean we shouldnt kill you you shouldnt be killed!

lets get the space whale

vote: Dcmort93

[Jolt]

Lots of Uranium sounds dangerous.

Vote: Asteroid

Since we have no idea who is who, starting to kill innocent people left and right isn't the best course of action.

Vote: No Lynch/Abstain
No Lynch if possible, Abstain if I can't.

[Visor]

Lots of Uranium sounds dangerous.

Vote: Asteroid

Since we have no idea who is who, starting to kill innocent people left and right isn't the best course of action.

Vote: No Lynch/Abstain
No Lynch if possible, Abstain if I can't.

Yet you voted for a lynch yesterday?

Unvote; Vote: Jolt

[Jolt]

Yet you voted for a lynch yesterday?

Unvote; Vote: Jolt

First of all, the votes were about going outside the ship to paint the name of the ship. There was no direct mention that it was a lynch. Do you care to explain why many people voted for themselves then? I voted jokingly at the end of the phase on someone that hadn't been mentioned or suspected, and my arguments were humorous and obviously not intended to make for a serious push for ATPG. Do you honestly expected me to create a bandwagon against ATPG?

Secondly, your entire argument in voting for me is that I can't change my mind?

Unvote, Vote: Visorslash

Sorry, but fishing for arguments to lynch people doesn't work with me.

[Visor]

First of all, the votes were about going outside the ship to paint the name of the ship. There was no direct mention that it was a lynch. Do you care to explain why many people voted for themselves then? I voted jokingly at the end of the phase on someone that hadn't been mentioned or suspected, and my arguments were humorous and obviously not intended to make for a serious push for ATPG. Do you honestly expected me to create a bandwagon against ATPG?

Secondly, your entire argument in voting for me is that I can't change my mind?

Unvote, Vote: Visorslash

Sorry, but fishing for arguments to lynch people doesn't work with me.

You didn't read the obviously sarcastic posts about the gravity then?

I'm voting you because you thought it fine to vote for someone D1, but then you decide to No Lynch on D2, which doesn't make sense. Besides the fact that the town's only weapon (besides the few power roles we have) is the lynch, and you are seeking to deny it to us? How do you expect to win the game as a townie like that? Your voting doesn't make sense and it seems scummy to you, and your thinly-veiled OMGUS is a lame attempt to lynch someone who suspects you. Time to go to space jail.

[Montmorency]

How do you expect to win the game as a townie like that?

Leave the dirty work to the space experts. They've already solved half the problem.

[Major Robert Dump]

Gotta vote: Jolt for this one

Also, go for the asteroids, not the whale, haven't you people ever read Moby Dick??

[Arjos]

Vote: Montmorency

We don't want fancy men with fancy words here on the Galactic Chutzpah!

Vote: Follow the Space Whale

[Chaotix]

Lots of Uranium sounds dangerous.

Vote: Asteroid

Since we have no idea who is who, starting to kill innocent people left and right isn't the best course of action.

Vote: No Lynch/Abstain
No Lynch if possible, Abstain if I can't.

Forgot about that rule. No Lynch is NOT allowed.

[Montmorency]

In that case, Vote: Arjos

[Jolt]

You didn't read the obviously sarcastic posts about the gravity then?

No, I didn't. Otherwise I would know what you're be talking about.

I'm voting you because you thought it fine to vote for someone D1, but then you decide to No Lynch on D2, which doesn't make sense.

I explained why I voted in the previous day. My vote was late, was jokingly and had absolutely no bearing on what was going to happen. It does not demonstrate or prove in any way that I am mafioso, quite the contrary. As such, I want you to explain why I decided to vote for ATPG so late in the day when the votes had been decided to Zaccivo. I also want you to explain why people were voting for themselves as well then.

Besides the fact that the town's only weapon (besides the few power roles we have)

What? I'm afraid your logic is the one that isn't make sense here. To give you the example of Rubicon where I won for the town (A game where even most power roles were not exclusively town related!), the very best thing the town did in the whole game was not starting to lynch in the first rounds and allowing power roles to start gathering information so that the lynchs could be better used later on in the game. In the beginning of the game, it is merely a Russian roulette, where you're far more likely to hit a townie than a mafioso. It only becomes the town's weapon if we have information on who to hit with it and why.

What you're wanting to do is lynching at random, and reducing the number of people that the mafia has to kill. I, on the other hand, prefer to keep everyone alive so that there's more townies left for the end game. You do not want that.

And where did you read the amount of power roles we have in the game?

Your voting doesn't make sense and it seems scummy to you, and your thinly-veiled OMGUS is a lame attempt to lynch someone who suspects you. Time to go to space jail.

You saying my voting doesn't make sense, doesn't make it so. Your logic for my lynching, however, makes no sense. You are trying to poke holes in my logic, which simply isn't working. And the fact that you are very clearly endorsing the random killing of townies shows why I am voting for you.

EDIT:

Gotta vote: Jolt for this one

Also, go for the asteroids, not the whale, haven't you people ever read Moby Dick??

This is ridiculous.

Unvote, Vote: Jolt

Have fun guys.

[Chaotix]

Gonna have to re-do that vote. Can't edit a vote change into a post.

That's another one I forgot. I'm gonna put both of these into the first post.

[Visor]

You and I have different perspectives on lynching it seems. What happens if the mafia kills off the power roles early? What then? I never said I was random lynching either.

However, you're selfvoting when so little time in the phase has passed and you are only ahead my two votes over te nearest target? Why?

(I think lynching is better then not lynching in almost every case.)

[Ibn-Khaldun]

Vote: Follow the Space Whale

and

Vote: Abstain (at the moment)

[SalmonSoil]

What? I'm afraid your logic is the one that isn't make sense here. To give you the example of Rubicon where I won for the town (A game where even most power roles were not exclusively town related!), the very best thing the town did in the whole game was not starting to lynch in the first rounds and allowing power roles to start gathering information so that the lynchs could be better used later on in the game. In the beginning of the game, it is merely a Russian roulette, where you're far more likely to hit a townie than a mafioso. It only becomes the town's weapon if we have information on who to hit with it and why.

What you're wanting to do is lynching at random, and reducing the number of people that the mafia has to kill. I, on the other hand, prefer to keep everyone alive so that there's more townies left for the end game. You do not want that.

Incorrect. A lynch is more likely to kill a townie, true, but in a standard game it is infinitly more likely to kill mafia than a mafia night kill, and a greater lynch to night kill ratio is therefore more likely to create a town victory. Also the threat of lynching is a great way to trigger sometimes incriminating reactions from players and creates a voting record which is useful in the later rounds.

Your alternative, relying on power roles to find information for us, is dangerous as it relies on the existence of investigative power roles and on them not being killed by scum.

Of course this game will be a little different. I believe we have 4 different mafia teams (if this is true at least one of the teams must have night actions other than killing, or we would expect more night kills?), which can each kill each other. However because none of these teams is going to kill themselves our lynches are still more likely to bag us a scum than abstaining.

And where did you read the amount of power roles we have in the game?

I think he assumed we have a few power roles because town normally has a few power roles.

To me this doesn't seem like an attempt to misguide the town and is instead just a case of genuine lack of knowledge, but I don't like that self vote and I don't see a better option.

vote: Jolt

[Visor]

I actually asked Chaotix when he sent the invitiation PM how vanilla it was, and he said it had a few power roles, so that's where that comes from.

[Chaotix]

I actually asked Chaotix when he sent the invitiation PM how vanilla it was, and he said it had a few power roles, so that's where that comes from.

In the interest of fairness, these were my exact words:

There will be a few special roles and mechanics, but nothing on the level that the Pokemon game was going to have.

[Visor]

In the interest of fairness, these were my exact words:

Paraphrasing.

[Jolt]

You and I have different perspectives on lynching it seems. What happens if the mafia kills off the power roles early? What then?

In the off chance that Mafia gets uber lucky and manages to kill off every single important power roll, then the town hopefully still has enough people to attrition kill the mafia. Mind you, that's only on the best possible night actions that the Mafia can do. On a normal game, then the Mafia will be more likely to spend their first rounds either investigating if they can or killing randomly. If there's more than one Mafia, then the town odds improve since there's the chance that the mafias kill each other (As was in Rubicon, for example). In this game, we apparently have 4 different mafia groups (Composed of 1 person, I guess, which means 1 is already dead killed by another mafia). And the fact that you are voting for me based on no evidence whatsoever, only leads credence that you are indeed randomly lynching.

However, you're selfvoting when so little time in the phase has passed and you are only ahead my two votes over te nearest target? Why?

Because I'm sick of getting lynched for no reason, as I'll show here:

Incorrect. A lynch is more likely to kill a townie, true, but in a standard game it is infinitly more likely to kill mafia than a mafia night kill, and a greater lynch to night kill ratio is therefore more likely to create a town victory. Also the threat of lynching is a great way to trigger sometimes incriminating reactions from players and creates a voting record which is useful in the later rounds. Of course this game will be a little different. I believe we have 4 different mafia teams.

So here we have a player with a theory that was so far disproven by the game (A Ninja killed a Zombie) and admitted himself that his own theory isn't that correct (As this is not a standard game). Nevertheless, he still votes for me.

This is what I'm talking about getting sick of being lynched for no reason.

I got my own points across. Lynching in the beginning at random (For me) is silly. I already 4 votes based on me actually not wanting to lynch randomly (2 of them without any reason at all, but I am past caring).

I'm already tired of defending myself when there's nothing to defend. Came back to try and have fun in this game and I'm already sick of it.

[Jolt]

Unvote, Vote: Jolt

[woad&fangs]

Vote: Visorslash for voting for Jolt. A zombie/pirate/ninja/robot would be paying enough attention to realize from Chaotix's writing that painting the ship's name would result in certain and unavoidable space whale consumption. Jolt did not realize this. Therefore Jolt is not likely a zombie/pirate/ninja/robot. Thus I am voting for the space cadet who is voting for innocent space cadet Jolt.

Also, vote: Space Whale

[Zack]

Follow the Space Whale. It is the cousin of I, Zaccino, immortal, ruler of the mind of Space Whale.

[BSmith]

Vote: Space Whale
vote: The King Abstaining doesn’t help anybody.

[classical_hero]

Vote:Space Whale
Vote:Chaotix for forgetting some basic rules. Just kidding. My real vote is vote:Jolt

[Seon]

Vote: Xehh

Because I want to.

Vote: FOLLLOW THE DAMN RADIOACTIVE SPACE monkey WHALE.

I wonder what it poops out.

[DaveShack]

Vote: Salmonsoil for the unbolded vote.

Vote: Follow the space whale

[Ibn-Khaldun]

Unvote; Vote: BSmith I did say "at the moment" back there? Now did I not?

[Major Robert Dump]

Unvote; Vote: BSmith

I believe this ties Jolt and BSmith, and I am a big fan of space duels.

[BSmith]

If it does I'd rather not die today. unvote; vote jolt.