Vanilla Mafia Game- signups!

[TheFlax]

Wants to vote me, then decides to vote someone else.

I wanted to vote for someone inactive and you certainly didn't fit the bill.

Makes sure there isnt a tie

Again, I wanted to lynch someone inactive, so why not prevent the tie? (In the first round I wanted to see how certain people would react, that was not my aim in the second day phase)

Immediately gives the town 3-4 suspects that we can waste days chasing.

I was hoping to start a discussion and had a vain hope that absentees would show up. If I'm not supposed to try give suspects, what am I supposed to do? Did you want me to narrow it down between all the inactives? Its kind of hard when posting wise they have little difference.

People complaining about no activity and saying this and that person...put some votes on.

I know this isn't aimed at me, but that's what I've been doing and you want me lynched for it. Maybe that's why they do nothing.

For reasons explained above Vote: TheFlax

Fair enough.

[Riedquat]

Again, why don't you do something?

People complaining about no activity and saying this and that person...put some votes on.

How rude! I swear I'm doing a lot, I'm running around the room like a headless chicken while panicking!

The thing is anybody can be scum but I don't see any active not killing the second night using it as tactic, in my view it is possible but not probable, so I agree halfway with Visor, at least 1 scum is totally inactive, why not start hunting there and avoid playing a boring zombie game?

If you expect more from me at this game's stage you will be seriously disappointed!

[Laboratory Mouse]

Can anyone tell me why it's illegal for people to edit their post in a Mafioso game?

[Riedquat]

Can anyone tell me why it's illegal for people to edit their post in a Mafioso game?

Regular posts, because some hosts like to mess with us, poor players. IMHO its very discriminative against the people like me that uses google translator to write in Spanglish! :P

Posts with votes, because if the vote is edited it mess with every-bodies tallies, and could create a bigger argument, if there is another reason I don't know. So if you want to correct a typo or something in a post with a vote, just cast your definitive vote in another clear post.

[Visor]

Vote: Fox

I'd prefer a Fox lynch over Flax.

[TheFlax]

Tally:
2 FoxLeLay: TheFlax, Visorslash
1 TheFlax: TheElusiveSniper

Now that's just sad... I'm especially looking at you people who posted and didn't vote!

[El Barto]

One hour remaining…

[Riedquat]

Sorry, feeling sick today if my late vote is allowed, I'm in agreement with Flax and Visor Vote: FoxLeLay

[El Barto]

Well, it doesn't change the result, Fox dies anyway. The forum went down yesterday at the time I was supposed to do the update and it came back only when I was unable to post.

DAY THREE

FoxLeLay was killed. He was a member of the mafia!

2 FoxLeLay: TheFlax, Visorslash
1 TheFlax: TheElusiveSniper

Belated vote: Riedquat
Not voting: Lex-Kat, Kagemusha, Laboratory Mouse
Voting for nonexistent player: Double A

1. edse killed on Night One, town.
2. Lex-Kat
3. Kagemusha
4. Riedquat
5. The Flax
6. Visorslash
7. Askthepizzaguy lynched on Day One, town
8. Double A
9. rickinator9 lynched on Day Two, town
10. FoxLeLay lynched on Day Three, mafia
11. Laboratory Mouse
12. TheElusiveSniper

This phase will last ~24 hours.
Time remaining:

[TheFlax]

Good!

[Laboratory Mouse]

We got a Mafia kill, which is good. But I get the feeling we're just blindly voting people out. That's not how the game is played.

[El Barto]

Can anyone tell me why it's illegal for people to edit their post in a Mafioso game?

Because you can vote for someone and then sneak in a vote, which can cause all sorts of havoc. For example, it confuses the GM when the tiebreaker for tied votes is the order in which the leading candidates arrived at that position.

[El Barto]

NIGHT THREE

No one was killed tonight.

1. edse killed on Night One, town.
2. Lex-Kat
3. Kagemusha
4. Riedquat
5. The Flax
6. Visorslash
7. Askthepizzaguy lynched on Day One, town
8. Double A
9. rickinator9 lynched on Day Two, town
10. FoxLeLay lynched on Day Three, mafia
11. Laboratory Mouse
12. TheElusiveSniper

This phase will last ~24 hours.
Time remaining:

[TheFlax]

We got a Mafia kill, which is good. But I get the feeling we're just blindly voting people out. That's not how the game is played.

Are you for real?

[TheFlax]

I've pondering this and there are just so many people I like for the next lynch. My mind in on Vote: Kagemusha (sorry my erstwhile Throne Room friend) to continue my vote for the D1 present / D2 absentee group. I have a feeling it would just be too easy though. I'm open to suggestions and more than willing to consider an alternative.

P.S.: I'm really hoping more people show up and vote. Especially that last part. Vote, vote, VOTE!!!!

[Laboratory Mouse]

Because you can vote for someone and then sneak in a vote, which can cause all sorts of havoc. For example, it confuses the GM when the tiebreaker for tied votes is the order in which the leading candidates arrived at that position.

. . . What?

Are you for real?

I am for real.

[Visor]

Kage is the last of the truly inactives I think.

AA/Lex/Sniper are the next lot

Lab Mouse is bizarre.

flax/quat/me are generally all here

[Kagemusha]

I am sorry about my absence. The May day screwed my online time pretty much. If i were any of you. Voting me would be a good option based how there are not any mafia kills the last night phase, but i am not mafia. I will Vote: Double A , as he seems to have been awal as well. Kind of anticlimatic, but it could be that we have this on wraps by that vote.

[Visor]

I've been staying up late last couple nights.

I'll be around for a bit to toss ideas - I want to look at some interactions (what minimal ones there are).

Anyone round to throw some balls at?

[Riedquat]

Kage is the last of the truly inactives I think.

AA/Lex/Sniper are the next lot

Lab Mouse is bizarre.

flax/quat/me are generally all here

Kage was... but I can't picture him going awol with a role, can picture Double A but him coming back with a voting joke to disappear again do not fit either.

I go vote: Lex-Kat

[Riedquat]

I've been staying up late last couple nights.

I'll be around for a bit to toss ideas - I want to look at some interactions (what minimal ones there are).

Anyone round to throw some balls at?

Balls... no, throw kumquats and I'll try! :P

[Visor]

I'm suspicious of Riedquat and Edse rickinator9.

Riedquat for casting the deciding vote, and then Edse dies. Edse was going to cast the deciding vote on Riedquat, but then dies that night. Now, this could be the villains attempt to throw further suspicion on him, by killing the player who tried to kill him. But, I've seen it where they intentionally do this, hoping that we'd see it as too obvious.

rickinator9, not sure yet. It's just an itch at the moment, that I can't scratch. It would have been Edse, but they're dead now.

Vote: Riedquat

Okay this is lex kats one and only real post

She goes for a basic level post, the thinking is straightforward yet almost never the case in practice. I'd like a followup to this opinion and whether it still holds

That move makes no sense Visor, why vote for me on TheFlax's behalf?

Vote: Lex-Kat

Something seems off.

Drop and run from this post.

There seems to be a trend to call out someone and vote for someone else.

Vote: Laboratory Mouse Come out, come out...

At this point we need more activity or we'll just be firing blindly.

Tally:
1 TheElusiveSniper : Visorslash
1 rickanator9: Riedquat
1 Riedquat: Lex-Kat
1 Lex-Kat: TheElusiveSniper
1 Laboratory Mouse: TheFlax

Flax fires at the inactives - its a tactic i love as scum, it makes you look good and puts heat on others. However, out of all the inactives he eventually chose fox, his own mafia partner when he could have conceivably voted for others. I think that makes Flax likely town.

Vote: FoxLeLay

Because we have the same avatar, therefore clearly one of us is an imposter.

And its not me, so it can only be you.

Potential distancing - people love to do it day one. But this isn't his most interesting post.

Vote:ATPG

I can't eat pizza as much as I used to, I need to lose weight!

unfortunately this post only points to atpgs (now quite obvious) townitude.

[Visor]

Random vote, thats fine

Wants to vote me, then decides to vote someone else.

Makes sure there isnt a tie

Immediately gives the town 3-4 suspects that we can waste days chasing.


Instead of just protesting, why don't you do something? Holding kills has been done before. Not generally in this type of game setup, but with the rampant inactivity and the general state of the game, I'm not surprised.


Again, why don't you do something?

People complaining about no activity and saying this and that person...put some votes on.

For reasons explained above Vote: TheFlax

This vote on Flax over Fox is particularly damning IMO, not just because of the vote but the defence of fox.

Keeping the town on the wrong track is beneficial to scum and flax happening to guess right was probably not what Vote: sniper wanted

[Visor]

Balls... no, throw kumquats and I'll try! :P

alright let me know what you think

[Visor]

@Kagemusha
@Riedquat
@TheFlax
@TheElusiveSniper
@Lex-Kat
@Double A
@Laboratory Mouse

don't know if i'm missing anyone

Re lab mouse, you clearly are around, but don't seem to interested in catching mafia or placing votes.

[Riedquat]

alright let me know what you think

With Sniper, I really don't know, why he hasn't killed? He was yesterday around... we need more input from everybody that is for sure, now if you leave the fact of the lack of kills apart, well yes, it is possible.

Flax fires at the inactives - its a tactic i love as scum, it makes you look good and puts heat on others. However, out of all the inactives he eventually chose fox, his own mafia partner when he could have conceivably voted for others. I think that makes Flax likely town.

Again leaving apart the no kills, if he is scum he made what everybody wants when your scum partner goes AWOL!! I put him as townie just for day 1 tie and activity!

Now, I'm curious why you didn't analyze my scummy late post/vote from yesterday, in retrospective it is really scummy!

[Visor]

With Sniper, I really don't know, why he hasn't killed? He was yesterday around... we need more input from everybody that is for sure, now if you leave the fact of the lack of kills apart, well yes, it is possible.




Again leaving apart the no kills, if he is scum he made what everybody wants when your scum partner goes AWOL!! I put him as townie just for day 1 tie and activity!

Now, I'm curious why you didn't analyze my scummy late post/vote from yesterday, in retrospective it is really scummy!

It doesn't look scummy to me?

I know what you're like and I don't think you do that with fox as your mafia partner to be honest

[Visor]

If riedquat is mafia i don't think he decides to vote his mafia partner after the deadline

scumquat jumps on before the deadline to get credit

but thats reading too much into a beyond deadline post

your posting sounds town and your numbers are townquat like

you're a bit more free flowing and inquisitive as town, you know this

[TheFlax]

I am sorry about my absence. The May day screwed my online time pretty much. If i were any of you. Voting me would be a good option based how there are not any mafia kills the last night phase, but i am not mafia. I will Vote: Double A , as he seems to have been awal as well. Kind of anticlimatic, but it could be that we have this on wraps by that vote.

I'm going to trust you on this and change my vote for Double A (forgot to unvote... so rusty), another likely candidate. Depending on what happens, you might not be off the hook.

This vote on Flax over Fox is particularly damning IMO, not just because of the vote but the defence of fox.

Keeping the town on the wrong track is beneficial to scum and flax happening to guess right was probably not what Vote: sniper wanted

I don't believe TheElusiveSniper to be mafia, going after 1 of 3 active voters that day would have been far from easy. Besides, killing an inactive mafia partner would have been a great move to build some townie cred, while not losing that much. Not saying I have a better lead, just my opinion.

[TheFlax]

Unvote, Vote: Double A

Tally, while we are at it:

2 Double A: Kagemusha, TheFlax
1 Lex-Kat: Riedquat
1 TheElusiveSniper: Visorslash