Pirate Ship Mafia III [Concluded]

[Lissa]

Eh, I had no intention not can I kill by myself. I simply have had no time and attempting to kill is the easiest way to show that I'm not doing anything nefarious.

Nothing against atpg or anything.

My inclination is to not buy this.

[Lissa]

vote: sprig

[Visor]

unvote; vote: lissa

[Montmorency]

Gaius, what is your report?

Golden, what's going on?

Andres attack was a matter of numbers, a secondary target based on whoever was available to do it. Somehow, organization was very difficult last night. BTW, thanks for not stealing from me, Andres.

Visor, cut that out.

This is a difficult day: no reveals just yet, but no easy bets either. May merit an extension (though if everyone takes it easy then it just wastes time...).

[El Barto]

Again as yesterday, highest bidder gets me vote. Yarr!

[Montmorency]

Become my permanent understudy.

Though you lose your soul, you win the world.

[Lissa]

I don't think sending in a kill order alone as a townie makes sense as something that he would have done.

Like, it seems like an odd thing to think of doing.

[Csargo]

Sprig's unlikely anything other than townie considering the factors. Seems suicidal attacking someone like that on a night that had what? A 25% chance of failure for actions? I'm inclined to believe him. It's also the first solo attack on someone. All the others have appeared to be vigilante hits imo, considering the number of attackers and low mortality rate. I highly doubt the French would have chosen last night to take a shot at someone.

After looking over the night after Kage's election as captain and the next day when the mutiny occurred, I'd implore you all to go back and look over Visor/Zack's posts during that time period and comment on what you think. My opinion would be, considering everything that I'm aware of, they're contradictory and scummy. Starts around post #111 and goes until Double A's election. Just to see whether or not I'm being overly paranoid of the two. My first instinct is to vote mutiny and Visor, but I may just be salty about the American football game from tonight.

[Lissa]

I guess I could be missing something mechanical about it.

[Montmorency]

I've done it before as town.

Sometimes I've even offered the host my own writeups of the event.

[Zack]

I mean it makes zero sense if he's not town

I feel only a townie would be okay wasting their time like that

[Lissa]

I don't understand why his name was outed.

The attempting people have never been outed before. Would he have known that'd happen if he tried to kill alone?

[Lissa]

I might just be completely derping about mechanics but I don't get why it would certainly be from town.

[Lissa]

If he was french he wouldn't know it'd fail?

[Zack]

If he was french he wouldn't know it'd fail?

french have to kill with a buddy, and it would seem ridiculous for them to get publicly revealed for a failed attack

I don't know if pirate ship games have specifically had this mechanic, but I know capo-like games have had a chance of attackers' names being revealed in a failed attack.

[Lissa]

french have to kill with a buddy, and it would seem ridiculous for them to get publicly revealed for a failed attack

I don't know if pirate ship games have specifically had this mechanic, but I know capo-like games have had a chance of attackers' names being revealed in a failed attack.

ok, yeah, I'm derping about mechanics then

unvote

[Lissa]

I wasn't thinking about the french having to kill with a buddy, whoops

I think that does make him town then

[Csargo]

french have to kill with a buddy, and it would seem ridiculous for them to get publicly revealed for a failed attack

I don't know if pirate ship games have specifically had this mechanic, but I know capo-like games have had a chance of attackers' names being revealed in a failed attack.

???? I don't see that anywhere in the description of their roles. It's not specific about that particular point.

[Zack]

???? I don't see that anywhere in the description of their roles. It's not specific about that particular point.

That's how it worked in pirate ship 2, I assume it's the same here, though I guess it isn't necessarily the case (I'd think it is however - the frenchman being super powerful makes me think it's unlikely that his subordinates would also be more powerful than their spanish counterparts in the last game).

If the french are capable of solo kills, don't know why such a kill would fail in this instance, or why it would reveal the name of the attacker, the latter part especially would seem broken.

[spaceman98]

Whatever happened with the Sprig kill, it is NOT normal as Sprig claims.

1: Sprig was revealed. No one's name was revealed in the writeup like that before. Of course, that could be Sprig-related, or Pizza-related.

2: Is Sprig really the first person to send an order to vig someone and have no-one work with them? If you have had this experience before, now would be a good time to step forward. In any case, this is the first "lone assailent" writeup.

3: Visor, who did you block tonight? Assuming Zack is correct, it is possible that Sprig was planning to attack with a buddy, and aforementioned buddy was your block target. Certainly if one of them turns up scum, then its an angle worth investigating.

4: I checked in the writeup and I couldn't find any references to the buddy-killing thing. Ordinarily, I would agree with CSargo and see that as PIS. Since I wasn't in the last two games though, is it standard practice that mafia kill in pairs? If so, then why haven't we seen ANY mafia kills over the first few nights, until the Sprig wierdness tonight.

For that matter, where are the promised third parties?

[Zack]

4: I checked in the writeup and I couldn't find any references to the buddy-killing thing. Ordinarily, I would agree with CSargo and see that as PIS. Since I wasn't in the last two games though, is it standard practice that mafia kill in pairs? If so, then why haven't we seen ANY mafia kills over the first few nights, until the Sprig wierdness tonight.

It's in the rules for Pirate Ship Mafia 2, which I played in, it's not PIS lol. I don't think there were any mafia kills in that game either. I assume the mafia are focused on infiltrating townie groups and gathering recruits, there's no real need to use the mafia kill.

[Andres]

Interesting Sprig. You got a lot further than most would in killing someone solely by yourself... perhaps you were working with a French partner?

Odd reasoning for yer vote.

Vote : Visorslash

Verstuurd vanaf mijn SM-G357FZ met Tapatalk

[Montmorency]

Odder reasoning for your vote.

Vote: Andres

[Sprig]

Spaceman, your first statement is false.

It was with in Normal game mechanics.

Nothing to do with me or pizza.

It wasn't really a solo kill attempts since that Is not possible, simple the other three people on my order had no idea what I did. In hindsight I should have cc'd but I'm on mobile and it would confuse things anyway.

Buddy thing? What's your point?

[Ituralde]

Arr, this has been one hell of a weekend. I'm still alive, we sailed through a storm, private duels in the Crow's Nest. This be feeling like a real pirate ship to me!

It may be missed because of all the counting during the last day, but who did our First Mate investigate? Last night and the night before?

Public Duels when only one person attempt to murder, sound like a thing I should try to do tonight!

[Visor]

el barto what did you do night 2?

[Askthepizzaguy]

To the fresher-faced folk on this fine vessel-

I heard a tale once set oh a couple hundred years from now, about a man called the "Neutral Avenger". He'd claim he wasn't working for anyone, naught but for himself, and be getting revenge against all the penny-pinching ungenerous folk who be disrespectful to the folk workin' fer em.

He'd deliberately not be trying to kill anyone, but make his presence known. In plain terms, he be doin' it just to give himself a plausible alibi for the evenin'.

Later, when others grew bored with his story, they'd focus elsewhere. And then, he'd strike.

But what I'm gettin' at with me ramblin' is that Sprig could have just been tryin' to attack me solo for the explicit purpose of failure. I imagine you still get some gold for the failed action. (2 gold)

That said, he's not clear. Just not recruitin' or whatnot last night.

Oh, NotJim, I have 6 of yer gold pieces. Just sayin' lad. No one had the balls to steal from me last night either, so once again, my predictions came true.

This ship be full of men who ain't got the jimmies required to be pirates. Next time it won't be a paltry 6 gold either, yarr.

[Askthepizzaguy]

A friendly suggestion: Maybe you fine folk should hire Andres to guard yer gold. If you don't, I just might. That way I can steal from you every single night and brag about it every single morning.

How's that?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Vote: Spaceman Spiff

But I could also vote for TheFlax. He seems like another tasty option at this point.

[Sprig]

To the fresher-faced folk on this fine vessel-

I heard a tale once set oh a couple hundred years from now, about a man called the "Neutral Avenger". He'd claim he wasn't working for anyone, naught but for himself, and be getting revenge against all the penny-pinching ungenerous folk who be disrespectful to the folk workin' fer em.

He'd deliberately not be trying to kill anyone, but make his presence known. In plain terms, he be doin' it just to give himself a plausible alibi for the evenin'.

Yup I would have claimed it was me regardless of reveal. In this particular case, the group I have performed actions with previously hadn't organised anything in my absence. Could have stolen something, done protection for the 10 gold or protected my gold. I just decided to do the only thing that is visible. I mean, why change what I have been doing?


Anyways i dislike the venomous swift judgement of Vote: El Barto, he caught my attention previously and done so again. Feels like the overreaction that scum do when there a whiff of a mislynch in the air.