The Inquisition [Concluded]

[Kagemusha]

The town is infested with mafia. I was in contact with rather limited set of people, but who knows whom they talked with. Thanks for the game everyone!

[Sooh]

I know I was where I was supposed to be last night GH, just like I have been previous nights.

I thought 3 was supposed to be enough to protect someone, but here there were a group of three and a group of two, and yet two scum seemed to just be able to nullify it?

[GeneralHankerchief]

I thought 3 was supposed to be enough to protect someone

It most certainly should.

Why do you think the protection failed?

[Sooh]

I don't know.

Perhaps if two scums attack it's not enough?

I don't know what we should do then though.

[edse]

Were both protection groups Shanahk? I said earlier that you were too many and that you had been infiltrated.

Vote: Sooh

[Sooh]

Were both protection groups Shanahk? I said earlier that you were too many and that you had been infiltrated.

Vote: Sooh

You buy what GH says just like that at face value?

Seems opportunistic.

[edse]

Well, I think the failed three person group is our best lead, and GH shot first.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Full disclosure: I was the one who recommended that my group protect Kage. However, I had no idea of his role, I simply believed him to be innocent via his posting behavior.

[edse]

Full disclosure: I was the one who recommended that my group protect Kage. However, I had no idea of his role, I simply believed him to be innocent via his posting behavior.

Have your group (you, Sooh and a third person?) performed a successful group protection before?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Since this is the first round I've really been able to contribute to in over a week (due to RL stuff), can someone who's followed it closer than me clear up the following things:

1) If there has ever been a situation with two teamed-up attackers before
2) If single attackers bearing similarities to this description have fared well

[Myrddraal]

1) No
2) Actually, I'm not sure we've had people with this description attack before. As of last round, all attackers seemed to fit into a pattern of representing one of the religions (one of them smelt 'musty' (Underworld), the other 'briny' (Sea) and the third seemed to float and wore a golden mask (Sky).

The 'man with flowing, white hair and a white robe that seemed to glitter in the darkness. ' is certainly new, and his accomplice has 'A short, wavy mop of black hair' under his hood.

[Myrddraal]

If it is the case that two Mafia can overcome a protection group, then that makes it seem very likely that that Mafia knew that Kage had the power role. Why bother with a double attack if targeting townies at random. To the best of my knowledge, very few people knew of his role for sure (3 that I know of, including me).

It's also very interesting that one of the protection groups clearly failed due to lack of numbers. GH has confirmed that his group all cc'd orders. Can the other group confirm the same (in public or private?)