Mafia v. Cult [Concluded]

[Zack]

csargo and landlubber are lock town far as i'm concerned

[Kennigit]

vote: GeneralHankerchief

I didn't like your posting yesterday and don't like it today. This is a strange criticism but it really felt to me like you had some reason to vote golden1knight lined up but no one asked you to elaborate (I mean, you did do a 1-post-with-vote and then when jarrema did the same question him). This on top of a forced post about who voted innocents so far.


it's like you're the cult leader and failed to convert a mafia and just BEGGING to prove your innocence. "LET ME LYNCH A MAFIA GUYS, ITS MY GUT FEELING"

[Askthepizzaguy]

I mean, I guess I should have expected this. The Org is the least friendly board for claims that aren't town.

[Raith Kemmler]

Logically, it makes more sense to go after the cult first and then deal with the mafia afterwards, yet ATPG clearly showed more concern about the mafia, because he's the cult leader.

Cult would definitely be harder to track thanks to conversion headaches. Although there must be something to balance out the battle royal aspect. But okay, let's see where this hypothesis goes.

Vote:Askthepizzaguy

[Askthepizzaguy]

Even if all that EVIDENCE doesn't convince you, I am asking you to ignore my claim then and focus on my tone/words/etc.

Do I sound like I am coming from a position of perfect information? Do I sound guilty?

I am doing my utmost firstly to get these terrible votes off me - next will come the examination of the players as they stand so far. But that will happen tonight, I'm taking a break for now.

[Kennigit]

i don't understand, are you actually making a third party claim?

[Askthepizzaguy]

10. Askthepizzaguy, Town

[Raith Kemmler]

Hmm. I think my last vote is null since I didn't unvote.

After glancing quickly through the thread, I'm not really feeling the scum thing on Pizza, but I'm kind of hazy for reads with the previous round of multi-voting.

Unvote

No new vote till I've got a bit of time to try to make sense of things.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I am vanilla townie

[landlubber]

i don't understand, are you actually making a third party claim?

He's still quoting from the game where Visor was third-party. I think he's just screwing with us.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I already did make a case, but everyone assumed it was a joke and disregarded it. Logically, it makes more sense to go after the cult first and then deal with the mafia afterwards, yet ATPG clearly showed more concern about the mafia, because he's the cult leader.

Vote: Askthepizzaguy

In the end, I think you got too caught up in trivial matters and ended up missing the forest for the trees.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Vote: Landlubber










Member thankful for this post:

Double A

[Askthepizzaguy]

ATPG not showing up is minorly troublesome, but probably because he randed town IMO.

Remember to bold your votes.

[seireikhaan]

Vote: Kennegit

A) Don't touch my honeybun on day 2

B) The post... tweaks my scumdar. Gut instinct. You doth protest too much.

You all should vote for Kennegit.

[Jarema]

Vote: Landlubber

why?

[Zack]

Cult would definitely be harder to track thanks to conversion headaches. Although there must be something to balance out the battle royal aspect. But okay, let's see where this hypothesis goes.

Vote:Askthepizzaguy

No conversion headaches on d1 when pizza made that post lol. hmmm I don't like the tone of this post. It feels like you're taunting me because you know pizza is not actually the cult leader, and you want to see me embarrassed by the result. reeks of pis

unvote, vote: Raith Kemmler

[Zack]

In the end, I think you got too caught up in trivial matters and ended up missing the forest for the trees.

I tried so hard and got so far.

[Zack]

No conversion headaches on d1 when pizza made that post lol. hmmm I don't like the tone of this post. It feels like you're taunting me because you know pizza is not actually the cult leader, and you want to see me embarrassed by the result. reeks of pis

unvote, vote: Raith Kemmler

REEKS for gods sake

[Zack]

I really don't think Zack is mafia.

vote:ATPG for counterwagon.

BUT DO YOU THINK AM I CULT OH LOVER OF LAND???

[Askthepizzaguy]

Anyway, Raith, I see you joined here for this game as well? Might as well target the obvious competition first, it's a fair tactic :3
Vote: Raith Kemmler

[Askthepizzaguy]

I already did make a case, but everyone assumed it was a joke and disregarded it. Logically, it makes more sense to go after the cult first and then deal with the mafia afterwards, yet ATPG clearly showed more concern about the mafia, because

ATPG is literally quoting

from multiple sources

from games in the recent past

isn't part of his role description. Seems like it would be something

him

would do to mess with

you all

ouch. I missed it at top of your post - it seemed to me as if it started with quotation

[Zack]

oh pis is perfect information syndrome for the uninitiated

Perfect Information Syndrome: When a mafioso accidentally reveals he knows more than the average uninformed townie really should, either through directly declaring such information while talking about something else, or through their voting patterns.

[Al Sipsclar]

Not sure if that's the site culture thing, but .Org Zack feels scummier than CFC Zack based on the tone. Probably it was not a good idea to sign for 2 games on the different sites at the same time. I think the only game I played here (ROTSC) had a lot of outside players, so it's not representative of the site culture.

I want more Pizza, so not voting him.
Raith seems indecisive enough to be town.
Visor seems town: clearing townies, voting around, even though he's claiming conversion powers.
GH is scumhunting, good.

Need to read up on the rest.

Vote: Zack

[Zack]

Scummy in what way.

[Al Sipsclar]

Scummy in what way.

On general tone. I was just reading ISO's on CFC, then switched here and felt the contrast. You are more reasonable, helpful and solvey there, and more fluffy and careless here. ALL CAPS and stuff. Calling out GH for the forced post was good, though.

Jarema seems a bit wordy than in ROTSC, but less wordy than in the CFC game where he was town nevertheless. I really don't like his meta, that is actually forcing him to be a lurker when town. I'd like to encourage him to post more.

Choxorn had like a single non-fluff post, voting GH for forcing. Might be a joke, might be lazy or opportunistic. Slight scum.

Sooh as well has a single YOLO vote. Slight scum.

Kennigit feels good, solvey.

[Zack]

Talking about a currently running game is skirting a line I feel.

[Visor]

Talking about a currently running game is skirting a line I feel.

Yep, was about to say this.

Should never talk about an ongoing game.

[Al Sipsclar]

Talking about a currently running game is skirting a line I feel.

Hmm, didn't think that it might be a problem. Sorry.

[Al Sipsclar]

Town:
Visorslash
GeneralHankerchief

Slight town:
Askthepizzaguy
Raith Kemmler
Pelican, pushing for serious game
Kennigit

Neutral:
Jarema
landlubber, votes ATPG over Zack. Making choices is good.
seireikhaan. If he voted Kennigit just for his GH vote, that'd be null. The additional point he makes about his scumdar - not sure. Neutral to very slight scum lean.

Slight scum:
Zack
Choxorn
Sooh
Cuthillius, voted Scarlett and votes Visor without a reason

Unresolved:
Golden1Knight
Csargo
Zain
SeveringViper

The last group needs to post more.

[El Barto]

Voting's closed, I'm doing the update.