Tokens of My Confection [Concluded]

[Askthepizzaguy]

It was in March-April of this year, should still be on the first page, depending on threads displayed per page.

[GeneralHankerchief]

GH scum on day one, got a wagon on him, defended his lack of scum hunting as it's day one, scum hunting doesn't work.

It is day 3 in this game and he's not doing anything.

There's still a day left in the day, so I'm looking forward to him demonstrating that I'm not good at catching him out of the blue repeatedly and then letting him go for no real reason.

Vote: Pizza

[novice]

Well that didn't take long. Not much of substance from GH so far.

Okay this is stupid, let's start to consolidate.

Vote: Montmorency

FWIW this is effectively the start of the Monty wagon. Dp and I were voting him already, but a bunch of other guys also had two votes.

Zack - fine
Al Sips - discussed
Cuth - feel more confident reading him later on

That leaves Monty.

This is his reasoning. Was there noone with 1 vote on them worth considering?.

The only attempt at case building I could find:

This is actually a really good point, let me go back and see if khaan was hinting anything further.

Pizza is right, he's not doing anything.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Vote: Generalhankerchief

[GeneralHankerchief]

To elaborate:

Selective memory going on here, Pizza knows as well as anyone that the overall tone of .Org games has changed since then, and he's also aware that my playstyle has evolved since my three games offsite over the summer.

[Askthepizzaguy]

let's make sure it counts.

Unvote: Scarlett Aria
Vote: Generalhankerchief

I'll be willing to push SA or DP as alternatives, but in the meantime, quite happy with this vote.

Check in again tomorrow.

[novice]

To elaborate:

Selective memory going on here, Pizza knows as well as anyone that the overall tone of .Org games has changed since then, and he's also aware that my playstyle has evolved since my three games offsite over the summer.

What is your playstyle then?

[Sooh]

Sooh, you were one of the earliest people to look at Scarlett. Are you still in?

I need to re-examine, definitely. That goes for most people though. Everyone needs a second look imo.

[Dp101]

Vote: Generalhankerchief with severe trepidations, last time Pizza used past games as evidence we lost.

[Sooh]

GH, can you give me the names of your most probable townies and most probable scums? I want to see where your head is at. Even if you're still getting the lay of the land you've been able to vote earlier this game, so you should have an idea.

[GeneralHankerchief]

What is your playstyle then?

At this stage in my mafia career?

Whatever I damn well want it to be. Get off my lawn!

[Askthepizzaguy]

It's a lot to assume I know what your playstyle is now if you've decided to change it.

You could start with saying why you think this is better for town.

[GeneralHankerchief]

GH, can you give me the names of your most probable townies and most probable scums? I want to see where your head is at. Even if you're still getting the lay of the land you've been able to vote earlier this game, so you should have an idea.

Just saw this post, give me a bit.

[GeneralHankerchief]

GH, can you give me the names of your most probable townies and most probable scums? I want to see where your head is at. Even if you're still getting the lay of the land you've been able to vote earlier this game, so you should have an idea.

Towns:
NotACop - nobody has his D1 when scum
novice - seems natural
Cuthilius - I tried to compare his posts here with his Futurama posts - didn't get very far but didn't see much variance

Scums:
El Barto - odd D1, very very extremely light chance of khaan actually hitting him - also, quiet today thusfar
DP101 - just not quite as flow-y as he was last game
Pizza - see conversation

[El Barto]

I need to reevaluate my previous assessments about Barto then...:/

Khaan accused and voted him because not acting vanilla... vote: El Barto?

Yeah, no, it doesn't work that way.

2. @El Barto- I have to iso and think.

I'll be intermittently available to answer all your puny queries.

For the lynch:
9. @GeneralHankerchief
3. @Dp101
14. @Newyn
15. @Scarlett Aria

Pick em.

See below.

What is your playstyle then?

At this stage in my mafia career?

Whatever I damn well want it to be. Get off my lawn!

Non-contributive answer.

vote: GeneralHankerchief

[Riedquat]

El Barto - odd D1, very very extremely light chance of khaan actually hitting him - also, quiet today thusfar
DP101 - just not quite as flow-y as he was last game
Pizza - see conversation

What is the oddity from day 1? And what about day two? You noticed something on him yesterday, what was that?

[El Barto]

He's trying to get someone to vote for me so that he can join on the waggon. He could be trying to save Scarlett Aria for all that we know.

[Sooh]

Towns:
NotACop - nobody has his D1 when scum
novice - seems natural
Cuthilius - I tried to compare his posts here with his Futurama posts - didn't get very far but didn't see much variance

Scums:
El Barto - odd D1, very very extremely light chance of khaan actually hitting him - also, quiet today thusfar
DP101 - just not quite as flow-y as he was last game
Pizza - see conversation

Can you describe more DP's flow last game compared to now? I don't know what that was like, so please show me.

Also, what in particular is it about the conversation with Pizza that makes you think he's scum? The fact that he's comparing this game to an old game? I hate to tell you, but Pot, meet Kettle.

Is there more to it?

[NotACop]

Just checking in to recommend watching Hacksaw Ridge. Great movie!
I'll get around to catch up and lead us to victory sometime tomorrow

[El Barto]

Non-contributive answer.

vote: GeneralHankerchief

Just checking in to recommend watching Hacksaw Ridge. Great movie!
I'll get around to catch up and lead us to victory sometime tomorrow

[El Barto]

FFos: NotaCop

[Cuthillius]

I think Pizza's town

I don't think DP is w/w with gh

vote: generalhankerchief

I also don't think gh would be together with takh

[Riedquat]

He's trying to get someone to vote for me so that he can join on the waggon. He could be trying to save Scarlett Aria for all that we know.

Someone else apart of me do you mean? And trying to save Scarlett sacrificing himself? Also he don't seem to be trying anything really, he just could give a more categorical opinion from khaan's interaction with you... still something is off but can't point my finger to it...

Also, what in particular is it about the conversation with Pizza that makes you think he's scum?

Was meant to ask the same in the previous post but had someone at the door...

BTW... I keep confusing your posts with Atpg's ones... must be the darkish avatar...

About Dp, previous game was his first game and you could say from a mile away he was 100% townie around second day, he was transparent in every aspect, in this game retrospectively he seems a bit less transparent or a bit more cynic I don't know, perhaps he is trying to play differently to get a different approach or result than the other game, or he is not vanilla or he is scum.

[Dp101]

Slight correction, it was my second game. I'm being less transparent probably because my transparency caused me to be too trusting and also seems to be one of the factors in my lynch in the hydra game I played.

[Riedquat]

Dang!!!! The forum is infuriating me with freaking token expiring!!!!

Slight correction, it was my second game. I'm being less transparent probably because my transparency caused me to be too trusting and also seems to be one of the factors in my lynch in the hydra game I played.

Was saying before the forum ate my post, this is not the path you want to follow, just keep being transparent and if you are scum the more the merrier!

[Al Sipsclar]

I like GH's wagon, but don't want it to become a runaway one.

Incidentally, yesterday Cuth had exactly 3 posts, dead set on lynching Zack.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

he always gets lynched for ~no reason

the easiest lhfiest day 1 lynch

either way

vote: zack

he's not v/v with monty

his reaction to my voting him was bad as far as meta

he's a little bit... lacking

I am still of the opinion that Zack's response to being voted is scummy.

He's trying to hushy hushy it up, and sort of push it out of the way, such as the post wrt ignoring me and the interaction with dp

ime zack, like visor, doesn't respond in that way as town as much

when town he's not afraid to just say hey that's idiotic go commit suicide

when scum he tends to do this less often

and right now he's trying to stay out of the center of attention

meh

boils down to

zack>meta>scum

Today is one:

I think Pizza's town

I don't think DP is w/w with gh

vote: generalhankerchief

I also don't think gh would be together with takh

Vote: Cuthillius What's up with that unwavering certainty?

[Al Sipsclar]

Vote: Al Sips

I really haven't felt great about him and his posts are fairly neutral.

If you (or anyone) ever see a non-neutral post from me, please let me know. I'd like to understand the difference.

[Newyn]

Back to Vote: Cuth.
Like I said, I don't intend on joining any GH wagon.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Back to Vote: Cuth.
Like I said, I don't intend on joining any GH wagon.

What is it about GH that makes you think he's town? Can you show your process?

Also, are you still open to pushing Aria or dp today?

[novice]

Unofficial tally as of post 629:

Lynch votes
4 votes: GeneralHankerchief (Askthepizzaguy, Dp101, El Barto, Cuthillius)
2 votes: Cuthillius (Al Sipsclar, Newyn)
1 votes: El Barto (Riedquat)
1 votes: Al Sipsclar (Scarlett Aria)
1 votes: BSmith (novice)
1 votes: Scarlett Aria (BSmith)
1 votes: Askthepizzaguy (GeneralHankerchief)

Voting history:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Cuthillius

El Barto

Al Sipsclar

Newyn

BSmith

Scarlett Aria

Scarlett Aria

Scarlett Aria

Askthepizzaguy

GeneralHankerchief

GeneralHankerchief

GeneralHankerchief

GeneralHankerchief

GeneralHankerchief

Cuthillius

Cuthillius