Re: Gemma's Favorite Music Mafia
i mentioned this and kinda why i think it outs taffy as just 3p. the role if 3p sorta serves as gated KP for wolves while also offering some EV for town in certain situations, but not to the lengths that it makes sense as a town role?Originally Posted by ladd
either way taffy cannot be a wolf mechanically unless this game is some level of bastard so we don't really need to worry about it for now. if we can't kill wolves before taffy's wincon kicks in then we failed in other ways
audrey got her black belt btw! proud papa.
some random musings:
- idk why arctic thinks I have to think lissa looks uninformed for her overnight drunkposting only if I think he is flipping town? i truly can't make any sense of that
- i think waza's reaction to arctic being 'outed wolf' overnight is near lock clearing? volunteering as the elim for his 'abhorrent wolfsiding' fhpov so arctic can be ignited just doesn't seem like how a wolf reacts to the news, whether its real or fake?
- i thought of some other posts dya made earlier yesterday and i'm more conflicted on them again. the way they reaffirmed how lissa was reading ladd rang really true to me and a classic v!dya read/thought. and overall i think dya is in an odd position to be trying to push out miselims on the likes of sunbae/ladd while also being so absent all game, but without really being wolfy when they have time and are around?
- some mild caveats to the above bullet point: i do think the way dya didn't talk about ladd all day 1 and entered the d2 'relieved' about his posting after he found them around eod1 is still a bit wolfy. i think the later elaboration about how ladd was missing something is more in line with how i'd expect dya to read him, but the fact that the early sod2 read seemed so fickle, i can't really scratch that itch. and its weird in a way that i feel like gives ladd/dya equity as a team more than it does for them to be v/w with him.
- i know i made the point above but taffy's posts stink d2 lol. they had a post calling arctic outed wolf that just rings sorta overinflated for how they talik about arctic earlier in the post. and i don't really have any idea what other thoughts they have + their posting d1 about being more available d2 and wanting to mason with someone and it just really ending up in Taffy (15) while they should be basically 'clear' ftpov is just kinda meh
- i think visor's read on the game sucks. besides maybe where he's at on dya. if he's town he's ingesting all the bullshit that doesn't matter and ignoring the things that do IMHO
- yall should kill manti on day 4 when their claim still illcits nothing of value for town
- i've read eod again and i legit think its just all town on rask with a minor chance of a visor or lissa bus. i agree with stett that we very likely don't live in a 2-wolves-stacked world, but there's a chance one did
- i just think its way more likely between the postcap and actions around wagons that villagers were the ones causing chaos and it ended well. of the active players at eod, any number of them could have settled for v/v/v wagons and not put anything at risk. the opportunity cost just doesn't seem there to me unless a wolf was wagoned and in serious contention that wasn't rask
- if ender is a wolf the opportunity cost could be there for a team like ender/lissa i suppose but i'm struggling to see if for any team besides that? idk ill ruminate more
courtesy vote count and postcap checker
Turby Org Vote Counter v1.0
Day 2 - Votes from post 671 through 1053
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks