The fight for Inishmore [Concluded]

[El Diablo]

I am confused as people are claiming roles and as I don't know the story I am not sure why people
(like Reink) we not lynched last round.

[White_eyes:D]

I am confused as people are claiming roles and as I don't know the story I am not sure why people
(like Reink) we not lynched last round.

Because Reenk is just being Reenk (His playstyle, when townie is very "I want to be lynched/or killed WIFOM style") Town should not waste that lynch....if they did that in Godfather 3....me and Beefy would have won

[Thermal]

sooooo....


Hello

[Reenk Roink]

Because Reenk is just being Reenk (His playstyle, when townie is very "I want to be lynched/or killed WIFOM style") Town should not waste that lynch....if they did that in Godfather 3....me and Beefy would have won

This man is very wise.

[pevergreen]

WoGs and suicide are taking place at the end of this phase, in 7 hours.

[Askthepizzaguy]

This man is very wise.

Just a minor point; that play style is effective in hiding being a mafia. So just because one employs the tactic in one game as a townie, that means nothing. It's the very argument used against me in round one of this game. Reenk has a consistent strategy which is very ambiguous to me, and I tend to think of myself as a good behavioral analyzer. But I don't have a case I wish to make at this time. Waiting for day phase.

[White_eyes:D]

Every game I played with Reenk, where he had a vanilla townie role.....he always would get himself killed or lynched. He just hates not having a Pro-town or Mafia role..(but he is hosting a game right now....)

[Askthepizzaguy]

Not to make too big a stink over it; we learn in every mafia game that past performance is no indication of future results. Just because Reenk did A and B in previous game C, that does not mean when Reenk does A and B in current game D that he must be a townie. In fact, I believe that is everyone's main gripe with SkyNet, and it is why I mostly retired that puppy.

[Reenk Roink]

Someone please kill Atpg. I would, but I'm going to be occupied with something else and don't want to look bad. I think Atpg is gunning for me and he needs to be eliminated.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Is my questioning of you making you nervous? I don't see why that would be. If this is some kind of bait attempt to get me to murder you, I'm afraid I don't have such powers. A good attempt though. I don't mind being questioned, but you're not even doing that, and as such I have nothing to respond to.

[White_eyes:D]

Is my questioning of you making you nervous? I don't see why that would be. If this is some kind of bait attempt to get me to murder you, I'm afraid I don't have such powers. A good attempt though. I don't mind being questioned, but you're not even doing that, and as such I have nothing to respond to.

Don't do it ATPG last time I pressured Reenk in a game he was Mafia, it went badly.....but he never did any WIFOM stuff, I just got lynched check "Whispers in the night" but I had a "gut feeling" he was up to something that game. (which oddly enough I was right....when it comes to Reenk.....I can tell if he is being ballsy or just plain odd....)

[pevergreen]

CountArach walked in to Mcdoogals and ordered a pint of ale. Brendan was there and he turned to Countarach and said good day. Countarach turned to him and said arent you the guy that has been killing people in this bar? Brendan said yes I am but I have a reason. I fight for Ireland do you? Countarach said yes but not like a terrorist. He grabbed a wiskey bottle and hit Brendan in the face with it. This knocked out Brendans tooth. But Brendan took out a gun and shot him dead right there at Mcdoogals. Then he stood over Countarach and said this is a shame I need fighters like you to join the cause. Brendan left a card and it said Two Blind Mice.

Alexander the Pretty Good left the pub drunk to the gills and headed for home, quickly leaving the hustle and bustle of main street behind him. He gradually ascended for half a mile, and then found himself at the top of a considerable eminence, where the wood ceased, and the eye was instantly caught by his house, situated on the opposite side of a valley, into which the road, with some abruptness, wound. It was a large, handsome, stone building, standing well on rising ground, and backed by a ridge of high woody hills;—and in front, a stream of some natural importance was swelled into greater, but without any artificial appearance. Its banks were neither formal, nor falsely adorned.

He descended the hill, crossed the bridge, went through the front door, and entered the dining-parlour. It was a large, well-proportioned room, handsomely fitted up. Alexander, after slightly surveying it, went to a window to enjoy its prospect. The hill, crowned with wood, from which he had descended, receiving increased abruptness from the distance, was a beautiful object. Every disposition of the ground was good; and he looked on the whole scene—the river, the trees scattered on its banks, and the winding of the valley, as far as he could trace it—with the pride of ownership.

Across the valley, a considerably more sober Oswald took in the same view Alexander had enjoyed earlier. He so admired the general stonework of the house that he took a closer look through the scope of his rifle, and in doing so just happened to catch sight of the man standing at the window, smugly surveying his property. With a gentle squeeze of the trigger, all that was left of Alexander's head was a Pretty Good mess on the floor.

Polemists and gaelic cowboy have been wog'd. Pyschonaut has suicided. No more please.


As the town gathered once again, pevergreen just looked around and sighed. Come on guys, their right in front of us! Lets just get these guys already...Theres only 23 of us left and who knows how many terrorists and british...

Alive:
Andres
Captain Blackadder
Askthepizzaguy
shlin28
LittleGrizzly
Reenk Roink
GeneralHankerchief
Sasaki Kojiro
Lord Winter
White Eyes
Seamus
Factionheir
serierkhaan
777ares777
yoyoma1910
Diana Abnoba
boudica
Sigurd
greyblades
Ituralde
El Diablo
YLC

Dead:
Publius Aelius Hadrianus
A Very Super Market
Jolt
taka
Polemists
gaelic cowboy
Alexander the Pretty Good
CountArach
Psychonaut

Lynched:
Beefy187
F.C is the bees knees

It is now Day 4.

[Captain Blackadder]

Did the WOGS have any roles?

[Ituralde]

I'm back from the weekend. Seems some interesting developments have happened.

What's up with Seamus? We know he has a named role, but he refuses to talk more about it. How come?

Vote: Seamus

[Beefy187]

Donneys my favorite. Don't bully him

[Askthepizzaguy]

line edited out.

Ituralde: I believe it's been established that Seamus is a pro-town, if I am not mistaken. As such, I really have to question why you want him lynched. He's a named character who was protected, possibly by a mason defender, or simply Brendan was role blocked.

vote: boudica

Last post was on 3-19 and I know she's active right now.

[boudica]

It seems like the sub-plot / pro-town roles are all but deaded. Apologies for lack of participation over the weekend. While I voted Reenk on day 2, I think it was for his 'usual'?? antics I shall now vote: Askthepizzaguy. - reason: gut instinct.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Err... how do you figure? Aren't there at least 3 pro-town roles and what is it, 2 other roles? By my count, there are still more.


Edit: filling in the blanks now with the summary thread.

Dead:

Publius Aelius Hadrianus- nonplayer, no role, dead
A Very Super Market- Padraic, serial killer confessed, dead.
Jolt- normal townie, dead.
taka- no in-game name.
Polemists- WOG, dead. Role?
gaelic cowboy- WOG, dead. Role?
Alexander the Pretty Good- normal townie, dead.
CountArach- normal townie, dead.
Psychonaut- suicide, townie?
Beefy187- normal townie, confirmed, dead.
F.C is the bees knees- normal townie, dead.

I only count one role dead. Did I miss anyone?




Alive:

Seamus Fermanagh: Donney
Mairead: Seamus' protector, still at large
Brendan: Irish mafia
Oswald: English mafia
Joey: no info at present.
Christy: no info at present.
James: no info at present.
Davey: no info at present.

[pevergreen]

Please do not read the post by gaelic cowboy(its probably too late )

I have asked for it to be deleted.

[boudica]

Ituralde: I believe it's been established that Seamus is a pro-town, if I am not mistaken. As such, I really have to question why you want him lynched. He's a named character who was protected, possibly by a mason defender, or simply Brendan was role blocked.

vote: boudica

Last post was on 3-19 and I know she's active right now.

I went offline after I'd apparently cross-posted with you. Funny we suspected each other simultaneously. I assumed you'd have made a reply to my voting you by now so checked back only to find you had somehow managed to squeeze your vote for me in before mine for you!

My vote for you stands btw. - You don't seem to have offered yourself up for a lynch yet and that's just not normal for you in my experience.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I went offline after I'd apparently cross-posted with you. Funny we suspected each other simultaneously. I assumed you'd have made a reply to my voting you by now so checked back only to find you had somehow managed to squeeze your vote for me in before mine for you!

My vote for you stands btw. - You don't seem to have offered yourself up for a lynch yet and that's just not normal for you in my experience.

Uh....?

Were you not here for the first round? Let me see if I can find the quote.

Post 133:

Sasaki:

With this many people, you're just going to hit an innocent or a pro-town role. Even if you got close to catching a mafia, they would just manipulate the tally and avoid it.

As such, I'm volunteering to go first. I'd like any and all votes, please.

[LittleGrizzly]

Kinda hard to now not to read the post... i read it and then read your post telling me not to read it...

Im going to go with the pizza guy here and vote boudica possibly faking confusion to disguise a role ? asking helpful qustions but not much input... actually quite similar to my behaviour... did pizza guy do his usual suicidal offering first round... if he didn't he could be mafia...

EDIT: ok pizza did offer himself... im sure it didn't seem as committed as some of his recent suicidal crusades...

[Askthepizzaguy]

I am checking her activity for round one. I want to see if she's feigning not knowing, or if she could actually be telling the truth.

-edit- she was active that round, but not by much. Voted for GC, and that's about it. Possible she didn't read the thread.

[FactionHeir]

Or he would do it even if he was mafia to disguise that he is mafia?

Me thinks that since Donney and Maired are related, maybe that's an autoblock function. But I still think Maired is probably a SK.

[LittleGrizzly]

But I still think Maired is probably a SK.

It would be most unusual i think for an sk to be able to protect...

Im referring to ATPG's summary which had maired as possibly seamus's protector...

[Askthepizzaguy]

In the play, she was quite brutal, according to pevergreen's summary post 562. That being said, she does seem to have a defensive function here. Host's prerogative to determine the roles, I suppose.

[pevergreen]

Host's prerogative to determine the roles, I suppose.

Well, its a mafia game, not a play. Otherwise there would be no english and Padraic wouldn't be dead.

[boudica]

Ach - ok so you DID offer yourself up for the lynch I remember now actually mentioning it in a Psychomafia PM as well that you were trying to get lynched again...

My vote for you was based on the activity over the last few pages. Looking at it again, maybe I was swayed by the apparent conflict between you and Reenk...?

Well, what can I say but: I am town - plain and simple no-role boudica

I guess in one respect that I am not such a bad lynch option given that my contribution to this game has been slight and I can't see it getting much deeper. However I am an awful lynch option given my innocence, but you'll just have to either take me at my word, or wait for the write-up to confirm it.

With town's best interest in mind, I shall not unvote yet - but stand aside in order that perhaps more worthy lynch candidates might come centre stage.

[Ituralde]

line edited out.

Ituralde: I believe it's been established that Seamus is a pro-town, if I am not mistaken. As such, I really have to question why you want him lynched. He's a named character who was protected, possibly by a mason defender, or simply Brendan was role blocked.

vote: boudica

Last post was on 3-19 and I know she's active right now.

Established as in, we don't really now and just assume ist since he was protected? You are right if Mairead is some kind of doctor and also pro-town. But then judging from the play Mairead isn't the most friendly character either. What if she and Donney have some serial killer mechanic to be able to win that has nothing to do with the town's victory conditions? After all isn't Donney the father of Padraic, the mean IRA guy?

Also from the times I have been doctor in past Mafia games, I had the choice to protect one person each night, so the saving of Donney could just have been happenstance? Although it would seem likely that there is some connection between Mairead, Davey, Donney as the appear that way in the play.

All a bit strange, so unless there's some more information I'm not gonna automatically assume that Seamus is pro-town.

[Askthepizzaguy]

unvote: boudica
vote: ituralde

I believe that last post deserves a vote. If Seamus is claiming a role, then the mafia is bound to take another shot at him, whether he has a role or not. And if he makes it more than halfway through the game and hasn't accomplished something with his supposed role, we can pressure him or vote him off then.

I disagree with your assessment, and your strategy.