Large Simpsons Mafia Game- The Treehouse of Horror [Concluded]

[Jolt]

pever and Captain B both had their roles shown after death. Why wouldn't LG's if he was mafia? It wouldn't make sense if it didn't.

Under different situations. pever was a normal lynch while Cpt B was killed in what apparently made fixiwee win. I'm not saying I'm pretty sure LG is Mafia. I just wouldn't rule him out. In the Scourge of Ephesus, Sigurd was also mistakenly taken for a townie due to his death write-up when he was Mafia.

[LittleGrizzly]

Khaan merely choose which one of the tied players to lynch... which means... wait for it.... i was lynched...which means... and this ones the killer... wait for it.... my mafia role would show up if i was mafia!

Logic wins again!

[ULC]

Yay, a most productive round!

What have we learned class?

[Olavi]

Vote: Yoyoma
Random.org said so.

[Beaver]

Random.org? You really don't have anything else to go on?
I seems you're lurking. Maybe you're mafia and don't want to draw attention to yourself?
Vote the lurkers someone said.
Unvote: Jolt, Vote: Olavi

[shlin28]

Vote: Boudica

[Greyblades]

Vote: olavi

[Beaver]

You're lurking too, aren't you?
(Aimed at shlin28)

[White_eyes:D]

Unvote:Jolt Vote:Olavi

[Olavi]

Only reason I went there was I have no time to read all posts and point good reason to vote someone. Of course I could have jumped to a bandwagon but I'm not doing that. If I'd vote again abstain you would say I'm lurking.
And if you ask from me Beaver is just trying to draw the attention away from him. He has made 5 posts in thread and 3 this day. 1 in start and 1 in random phase. It looks like you are lurking too.

And sorry for my inactivity cause RL is really making things hard.

[boudica]

Vote: Boudica

You're voting me because I made a half-assed effort to teach you how to read?

[LittleGrizzly]

Ohh... is it lynch the lurkers time already ?!

Yay!!

You're voting me because I made a half-assed effort to teach you how to read?

To some kids... thats a fate worse than death...

[ULC]

Why on earth is Olavi being bandwagonned on? Seriously people, use better reasoning then you are now.

Vote: Thermal Mercury

AD brought up an interesting point, and I'd like TM to respond.

[Splitpersonality]

Vote: Abstain

I see no evidence to vote anyone right now...

Well that and I'm a wee bit behind on reading :P

[Chaotix]

Vote: GH

I'd like an elaboration on how exactly you knew that Blackadder was mafia...

[Greyblades]

He's dead...

[Chaotix]

He's dead...

Ah. That could be a problem. This is what happens when you spend too much time doing write-ups for your own game.

Unvote: Nonsense

I'll go with a different pressure vote, then.

Vote: Ares/Thermal

[Greyblades]

Oh I dont know, we might persuade ATPG to let us destroy his corpse.

[Thermal]

This post raised my suspicions already last day phase and now, that we know that Fixiwee was Marge, it does raise the question: was it a random guess or did TM actually know the identity of some mafia members? Thus,

Vote: Thermal Mercury

Why do you all find this suspicious? I pick out the mafia for you guys, get it right and you want to get rid of me? I've told you who mafia are and I was right, in this instance, shouldn't you see me as an asset instead of bandwagon material?

[Thermal]

Vote: YLC

easily swayed, following aggonyduck's reasoning, if I was a mafia I really wouldn't blatently read my teammates names out like that.....

[ULC]

Vote: YLC

easily swayed, following aggonyduck's reasoning, if I was a mafia I really wouldn't blatently read my teammates names out like that.....

If I was easily swayed, please, oh please point it out.

Vote for Jolt, because he's suspicious of LG? Ew, cmon, obvious he is after LG because the two are ALWAYS after each other, and to bring up a dead person's status like he has only brings out undue attention.

Vote for Olavi, because he can't come to a conclusion? Random votes like he made don't makes sense - it's unhelpful, but honestly it's not as scummy as the people who eagerly jumped on the opportunity to vote for him make it out to be.

Vote for Boudica it must be! But wait, whats the case against her again? Does anyone actually remember, and does it actually still hold water? Hmmm...gotta think on that one, but I'd go with a "no".

But, you make a good vote in my opinion - why? Simple, ATPG has basically said and showed that everyone can have individual goals even if mafia (especially so), and that it's possible you'd throw names out in the hopes that a rival gets lynched or killed, thus fulfilling your new goal. How else do you explain Marge "retiring filthy rich"?

Just as well, why vote me specifically, why not Aggony Duck? Your not making sense, your vote doesn't even really fall under retaliation.

[Thermal]

If I was easily swayed, please, oh please point it out.

Vote for Jolt, because he's suspicious of LG? Ew, cmon, obvious he is after LG because the two are ALWAYS after each other, and to bring up a dead person's status like he has only brings out undue attention.

Vote for Olavi, because he can't come to a conclusion? Random votes like he made don't makes sense - it's unhelpful, but honestly it's not as scummy as the people who eagerly jumped on the opportunity to vote for him make it out to be.

Vote for Boudica it must be! But wait, whats the case against her again? Does anyone actually remember, and does it actually still hold water? Hmmm...gotta think on that one, but I'd go with a "no".

But, you make a good vote in my opinion - why? Simple, ATPG has basically said and showed that everyone can have individual goals even if mafia (especially so), and that it's possible you'd throw names out in the hopes that a rival gets lynched or killed, thus fulfilling your new goal. How else do you explain Marge "retiring filthy rich"?

Just as well, why vote me specifically, why not Aggony Duck? Your not making sense, your vote doesn't even really fall under retaliation.

Aggony Duck came up with the reasoning, you simply went in 110% and voted in sync, with no other reason, I respect those that try to solve it, and at least Chaotix validated his vote by saying it was to pressure me, though giving no specific reason.

Vote for Boudica? I have stuck up for Boudica in this game, that is not my wish

Vote for LG? go ahead

Olavi? maybe

Me? because I can remove mafia players for you? dam yes must be me sorry!

I like the way you only say 4 people before seeing me fit for the lynch, there are many playing the game, and many more suspect than the ones you pointed out.

[ULC]

Stop being unnecessarily defensive TM, it's OOC for you. I just find it interesting that once it's possible your life might be threatened, your quick to be defensive and aggressive - either a bad day or your slipping up.

And I went with his reasoning because I liked it - I thought it obvious at that point why someone would vote for you, and based on that, wasn't going to go in much depth as to why unless asked.

And I listed the 4 ones I have noticed, if there are others, list them, along with the reasoning why you listed them.

Go.

[navarro951]

VOTE: ABSTAIN

Wast out of town for the day and need to catch up real quick, im a bit confused by a couple things.

[LittleGrizzly]

Possibly not completely on topic...

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

because the two are ALWAYS after each other

Well I went after him first and in a game and he went back for me....

Funnily enough i was just being fairly lazy picking a lynch

the game after i don't think we placed a vote on each other (settlement) unless i was still alive and we lynched him after a guilty result

he came after me this game... i didn't really go after him... if you'll notice my post after was a sarcastic remark about his and ichigo's vote... it was only later on i got a little suspicious...

Vote for LG? go ahead

Im pretty much ok with that...

and to bring up a dead person's status like he has only brings out undue attention.

Maybe he got worried and tried to cover it?

[ULC]

Possibly not completely on topic...

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

because the two are ALWAYS after each other

Well I went after him first and in a game and he went back for me....

Funnily enough i was just being fairly lazy picking a lynch

the game after i don't think we placed a vote on each other (settlement) unless i was still alive and we lynched him after a guilty result

he came after me this game... i didn't really go after him... if you'll notice my post after was a sarcastic remark about his and ichigo's vote... it was only later on i got a little suspicious...

Vote for LG? go ahead

Im pretty much ok with that...

and to bring up a dead person's status like he has only brings out undue attention.

Maybe he got worried and tried to cover it?

I like how TM missed that your dead

But why would he be worried about it, I mean seriously, was anyone even looking at Jolt at the start of the round? No one suspected Jolt until he made himself a suspect, and even the WIFOM advantage can't cover that.

[El Diablo]

Vote Greyblades

Quick to get on the Olavi bandwagon. Reason's other than "lurking"?

[Diana Abnoba]

My 1st attempt at a tally, PLEASE recheck for me.

3- TM/Ares (Aggony Duck, YLC, Chaotix )

3- Olavi (Beaver, Greyblades, WE )

2- Boudica (Khazaar, Shlin )

2- Jolt (Ichigo, Jolt)

1- YLC (TM/Ares )

1- Yoyoma (Boudica )

1- Greyblades (Eldiablo)

1- Abstain (Split)

[taka]

vote: abstain

[Beefy187]

Vote: Greyblades


3- TM/Ares (Aggony Duck, YLC, Chaotix )

3- Olavi (Beaver, Greyblades, WE )

2- Boudica (Khazaar, Shlin )

2- Jolt (Ichigo, Jolt)

1- YLC (TM/Ares )

2- Yoyoma (Boudica, Olavi )

2- Greyblades (El Diablo, Beefy)

1- Abstain (Split)
__________________