Swords in the Moon [Concluded]

[Prince Cobra]

Actually, I believe BQ is innocent. For some strange reason.

If Quintius is Hisao, I see little problem for BG.

[AggonyDuck]

BQ, how many investigations can you make per night?

[Beskar]

This will be an interesting night phase for sure.

[Banquo's Ghost]

BG, since you already claimed the role of the shinobi, I ask you to show your PM immediately. Why did you not show your PM in the first post? According to you your identity has already been exposed, now you've revealed in public there is really no reason to hold anything back from town now.

Vote: Banquo's ghost

here's my PM.

The serpent twists round.

This is an impossible request to consider. Firstly, my duties mean that I have information about my Lord Takeda which would be revealed to such as you and endanger him. This may been seen as convenient, but thus it must be, even if it results in suspicion of me.

Secondly, such a revelation would be useless. It is unlikely that there is any comparator, so I could write anything and you would be none the wiser.

I note that you changed your vote, made first in a fit of anger against me, to aim your venom at the only samurai that might still garner enough votes to save your neck. I can be killed in the night as you realised (or were directed). Persuading the town to consider Generalhankerchief for execution is your last desperate ploy.

There is an interesting note in BQ's post -
Gamo Ujisato as possible ninja master, but the Ninja Master is called Kato Danzo.

I am aware of who Kato Danzo is. There are several who masquerade under false names - do you think the master of ninjas would not be one of them? As I said, KukriKhan has provided me with no direct evidence of his guilt, but the investigation of him, whilst identifying him as innocent, gave clues completely different from the rest of my investigations which all yielded the same result.

BQ, how many investigations can you make per night?

I do not believe I am at liberty to say this. Nor should I, for it would give our enemies respite and succour. One might argue that they can work it out from my list of innocents, but I have not revealed all, for there are those on whom I have knowledge but not surety.

[AggonyDuck]

I do not believe I am at liberty to say this. Nor should I, for it would give our enemies respite and succour. One might argue that they can work it out from my list of innocents, but I have not revealed all, for there are those on whom I have knowledge but not surety.

Alright, I can figure it out from here myself. Seems like the number adds up to what it should be if we account for those you do not wish to reveal.

[KukriKhan]

I am aware of who Kato Danzo is. There are several who masquerade under false names - do you think the master of ninjas would not be one of them? As I said, KukriKhan has provided me with no direct evidence of his guilt, but the investigation of him, whilst identifying him as innocent, gave clues completely different from the rest of my investigations which all yielded the same result.

That's interesting. And flattering. But incorrect. I am merely Veteran Samurai. But, as promised by the others, my old sword will avenge a wrongful death, if you have led us astray.

unvote: Banquo's Ghost
vote: Quintus.JC

[Quintus.JC]

That's interesting. And flattering. But incorrect. I am merely Veteran Samurai. But, as promised by the others, my old sword will avenge a wrongful death, if you have led us astray.

That's all I can ask. As by tradition, if the detective claimer get it wrong, he should by lynched next round straight, no questions asked.

Well, it is only my regret that I cannot serve my lord further from this point. Good luck town.

[TinCow]

Interesting that after a moment of panic, Quintus' posts become complacent and accepting. Especially since this coincides with KukriKhan's similarly complacent response. BG's statements seem to have hit the mark, and the response has been a forced passivity on the response of the accused in an attempt to appear innocent. I expect good results from the next few rounds.

[Beefy187]

This post you just made may be proof that you are mafia.
However maybe it isn't proof.

So there is a 50 percent chance of you being mafia...

But me doing WIFOMs are nothing new. Besides what kind of weak mafia loses a duel?

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Unvote:Seamus
Vote:Quintus


I agree--Kukri tomorrow. Maybe ichigo...

[woad&fangs]

unvote: abstain; Vote: QuintusJC
BQs reveal and Quintus' subsequent posts make this one a no brainer. Thank you for revealing, BQ. This will make analyzing the remaining unconfirmed much easier.

[Yoyoma1910]

unvote:AggonyDuck
Vote:Quintus JC

[Peasant Phill]

Vote: Quintus JC

[Dutch_guy]

I believe BG, doesn't strike me as a fake reveal at all:

Unvote:GH

Vote: Quintus JC

[Kagemusha]

Vote: Quintus JC.

[woad&fangs]

So the killers were bold enough to kill the Pevers, most of whom were in the spotlight, and would probably be lynched and killed off soon.

The killers can't be newbies, I just don't think they would kill people who are must likely to get the attention and help other people to hide themselves.
FoS: The people who publicly made threats to the Pevers.

red coloring is mine.

FoS: All the newbies

[White_eyes:D]

Unvote:woad&fangs Vote:Quintus I warn you guys.....we have no way of telling if BQ is telling the truth..... and the mafia will likely drop to two kills tonight....(In Godfather three....me and beefy agreed it was a good idea early on) If BQ survives tonight....we need to lynch him....or otherwise he might just have been protecting GH....

[Prince Cobra]

Unvote:woad&fangs Vote:Quintus I warn you guys.....we have no way of telling if BQ is telling the truth..... and the mafia will likely drop to two kills tonight....(In Godfather three....me and beefy agreed it was a good idea early on) If BQ survives tonight....we need to lynch him....or otherwise he might just have been protecting GH....

If he is right about the Quintius name there is high chance of telling the truth, I think.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Vote: Quintus

Time will tell if Banquo has been leading us in the right direction or not.

thanks for saving my behind though.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Oh, and Challenge: Beskar.

[Banquo's Ghost]

Oh, and Challenge: Beskar.

Why would you do that?

If you believe me, both Beskar and you are innocent. To challenge him means that there is a chance you will duel, and we will lose another loyal samurai for no reason.

Pride can be satisfied after we find the traitors.

[Dutch_guy]

Oh, and Challenge: Beskar.

So you're doing this even after Banquo named him as an innocent ?

[GeneralHankerchief]

I'm doing it to stay suspicious enough so I don't get nightkilled.

[White_eyes:D]

I'm doing it to stay suspicious enough so I don't get nightkilled.

But I already tossed your name up there??? your clearly up to something GH

[Prince Cobra]

I'm doing it to stay suspicious enough so I don't get nightkilled.

Hmm, it is possible that he was just resting in his room. Not all of the assassins are engaged with killing. Of course, the others are priority but we should not exclude automatically anybody. So I do respect your decision GH

[atheotes]

For now i believe BQ' reveal is true...
Vote: Quintus.JC

[Banquo's Ghost]

Of course, the others are priority but we should not exclude automatically anybody. So I do respect your decision GH

Indeed not. There are those that are immune from my investigations.

Quintus.JC is a priority because I know he is ninja. KukriKhan must be examined very carefully. But wilfully damaging acts such as Generalhankerchief's might just have betrayed more than he wished. My investigation of him gave exactly the same result as other innocents, whereas Kukri's stood out, but it is an act of idiocy - or disregard for Lord Takeda's safety - to put pride or indeed personal security in the way of a Takeda victory. Coincidentally, it also undermines my claims, which threatens our master further.

[Rhyfelwyr]

Vote: Quintus JC

[Beskar]

You know, Stephen Asen would just try to kill me even if the God of Mafia-roles revealed his identity. Your evil tricks won't work Stephen, I will get you before you get me.

Also, Steven is the better name.

[atheotes]

If he is right about the Quintius name there is high chance of telling the truth, I think.

Yes... the name claim has given us the possibility of more evidence... if Quintus hadnt claimed a different name we might be unsure about BG's claim even after the lynch writeup...