Omertà: A small Mafia [Concluded]

[Greyblades]

After about 5-6 games I have found that the most funny posts are because of the blind finger pointing.
But what the heck vote: no lynch.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I know that, I asked why you seemed to think that.

Wait, he's avoiding the question, he must be mafia!

I was pointing out the contradiction inherent in your analysis.

Do we, SplitPersonality? Do we?

[/Sasaki]

Is this a cod?

[FactionHeir]

So, can we lynch Pizza as usual if we get no suspects?

Sasaki, can you explain why you want to lynch Navarro? That seems rather far-fetched to me since he hasn't even posted (and a few others haven't either )

[Sasaki Kojiro]

So, can we lynch Pizza as usual if we get no suspects?

Sasaki, can you explain why you want to lynch Navarro? That seems rather far-fetched to me since he hasn't even posted (and a few others haven't either )

[FactionHeir]

My mistake, I missed the . Fact is, Pizza has yet to offer himself up this time around, which is suspicious. Navarro not even posting doesn't seem quite as suspicious to me.

[Beefy187]

I want to thank those who protected me from the hands of those dirty cops

[Sasaki Kojiro]

My mistake, I missed the . Fact is, Pizza has yet to offer himself up this time around, which is suspicious. Navarro not even posting doesn't seem quite as suspicious to me.

Navarro lurks all the time so he is a good lynch. Pizza gets himself lynched at inopportune moments so he is a good lynch.

[Splitpersonality]

Split has been killed off in every other game, so he is a good lynch

On an unrelated note, Navarro's post count is now 1337. Maybe that's why he's not posting. :P

[FactionHeir]

So is Sasaki a good lynch for the mafia rules and I a good lynch because I like to analyze night actions?
Or rather, should we just all tie each other up with votes and get lynched together so that only our Don survives?

And why do I think that you are PK all the time....

[Beefy187]

So is Sasaki a good lynch for the mafia rules and I a good lynch because I like to analyze night actions?
Or rather, should we just all tie each other up with votes and get lynched together so that only our Don survives?

And why do I think that you are PK all the time....

Hey yea! They do have the same avater

[Tratorix]

Hopefully Beefy surviving will be a good omen for this game. Now we have a second player who is pretty much confirmed innocent.

Vote: Shinseikhaan

I don't like abstaining.

[Captain Blackadder]

Hopefully Beefy surviving will be a good omen for this game. Now we have a second player who is pretty much confirmed innocent.

Vote: Shinseikhaan

I don't like abstaining.

Beefy is not necessarily innocent there are many games where the Mafia target themselves for example in tree house of horror I was attacked night one and i was one of the biggest Mafia figures in the game. So whilst I won't vote for beefy this round at some point he should be lynched unless we are given more evidence to his innocence then just being attacked.

vote no lynch

[FactionHeir]

Are you trying to finish the job you didn't succeed on like that?

[Askthepizzaguy]

I believe I "offered myself up for a lynch" when I signed up for the game. Game would get awfully boring if I did the same thing every game, if we all did. First lynch: Pizzaguy, because that's what he wants. Second lynch: Sasaki, because the rules say so. Third lynch: Beefy, because he's been mafia a lot lately. Fourth lynch: Boudica, if she were playing, because she's always mafia. Fifth... And so on, so that way, in future games we can recruit henchmen and know they will survive. And best of all, we don't have to think, we just automatically go with historical precedent.

"Didn't offer himself up for a lynch..." Well to be fair, you didn't get the message because I didn't send it to you, FactionHeir. But yes, indeed I already offered myself up for a lynch to the only person whose opinion matters to me at the moment, as I "always" do.

Cheers.

[White_eyes:D]

Hmmm......Vote:no lynch I am going to wait and see....

[Beefy187]

Beefy is not necessarily innocent there are many games where the Mafia target themselves for example in tree house of horror I was attacked night one and i was one of the biggest Mafia figures in the game. So whilst I won't vote for beefy this round at some point he should be lynched unless we are given more evidence to his innocence then just being attacked.

vote no lynch

As long as lynching me doesn't happen like next round, or the round after, I'm fine with that.

I am confident that I could provide enough evidence that I didn't fake the attack in few rounds time.

Vote: Abstain

For now.

[White_eyes:D]

I am going to speak in ATPG-like clues.....it makes it funny to see the stitch's struggle
Did you tip the Pizza guy?<-----directed at Sasaki

[Sasaki Kojiro]

So is Sasaki a good lynch for the mafia rules

Second lynch: Sasaki, because the rules say so.

This is a remarkable misreading of the rule.

I believe I "offered myself up for a lynch" when I signed up for the game. Game would get awfully boring if I did the same thing every game, if we all did. First lynch: Pizzaguy, because that's what he wants.

...

Third lynch: Beefy, because he's been mafia a lot lately. Fourth lynch: Boudica, if she were playing, because she's always mafia. Fifth... And so on, so that way, in future games we can recruit henchmen and know they will survive. And best of all, we don't have to think, we just automatically go with historical precedent.

"Didn't offer himself up for a lynch..." Well to be fair, you didn't get the message because I didn't send it to you, FactionHeir. But yes, indeed I already offered myself up for a lynch to the only person whose opinion matters to me at the moment, as I "always" do.

Cheers.

Unvote:Navarro
Vote:Askthepizzaguy

This reads a bit like a mafioso frustrated that his past tactics are coming back to bite him.

[atheotes]

Interesting start...

Beefy is not necessarily innocent there are many games where the Mafia target themselves for example in tree house of horror I was attacked night one and i was one of the biggest Mafia figures in the game. So whilst I won't vote for beefy this round at some point he should be lynched unless we are given more evidence to his innocence then just being attacked.

vote no lynch

I thought we now have 2 confirmed innocents ... if the mafia target themselves how can they survive? cant the mafia kill themselves?

i will abstain from voting for now.

[pevergreen]

It was the police raiding beefy, so he isnt the betrayor.

I think atpg is innocent, but


Vote: Atheotes

Hello there.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I think atpg is innocent, but

.

No specifics, apathetic shrug, this is round 1 evidence of you being atpg's partner.

[GeneralHankerchief]

The Stoolies call in the cops to make arrests.

[Greyblades]

Well why dont we all just stand at the front door and grin menacingly every time the cops come round and not let them take any of us?

[Askthepizzaguy]

No specifics, apathetic shrug, this is round 1 evidence of you being atpg's partner.

Yes, you're right. We are that incompetent as players. I admire your ability to vote for whomever you want and invent plausible reasoning as to why. I think I kind of know by now, Sasaki, that the more I talk, the more votes I get.

I do think it's odd pever thinks I am innocent, as I am a mafia scumbag who is loyal to the Don. However, if that's what he meant, he is right. I'm a pointless round one lynch, and we can't really afford to waste too many of them in a smaller game, but go right ahead.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I do think it's odd pever thinks I am innocent, as I am a mafia scumbag who is loyal to the Don. However, if that's what he meant, he is right. I'm a pointless round one lynch, and we can't really afford to waste too many of them in a smaller game, but go right ahead.

What? You do think it's odd that pever thinks you are innocent, but...he's right that you are a pointless round one lynch? You're only a pointless round one lynch if you are innocent, so we are back to square one, why does he think you're innocent?

[Askthepizzaguy]

What? You do think it's odd that pever thinks you are innocent, but...he's right that you are a pointless round one lynch? You're only a pointless round one lynch if you are innocent, so we are back to square one, why does he think you're innocent?

Because he's my mafia partner and your fantastic skills figured it out.

Edit: GG everyone.

[Northnovas]

Okay I see we are on our way with the usual first round analysis!
The first night action was targeting Beefy but he obviously had some protection that is why he wasn't taken away by the police. That looks favourable to him of not being a stoolie unless he set himself up knowing he had protection????
Us mafia guys can be sneaky.

It's only the first round I just can't give a vote. (yet)

Vote: Abstain

[navarro951]

Vote: Abstain

To early to tell

[FactionHeir]

This has got to be the mafia game with the most round 1 abstains I have ever seen

vote: no lynch

Don't want to accidentally lynch any mafia member, right?

Tally:
ATPG: Sasaki
Atheotes: pever
khaan: BSR
Abstain: Split, Beef, Northnovas, navarro
No lynch: Greyblades, Blackadder, WE, FH
Not voting: everyone else

[Askthepizzaguy]

The BSR bit had me confused. I've only ever known him as Tratorix. (stop reminding me I'm not nearly as veteran as you guys! )

Still waiting on a certain someone to post something.