Swords in the Moon [Concluded]

**Yoyoma1910** · 05-10-2009, 19:28

Originally Posted by Beskar

It is because he is dead and Kagemesha winked, he is mafia.

I didn't ask you, did I?

**woad&fangs** · 05-10-2009, 23:16

I do not believe the ninjas would challenge unless they had to.

GH- Is a "confirmed" innocent and he has challenged frequently.

Kage- He is either messing with us or he truly didn't realize that Shingen was dead. I believe it is the latter and I also believe that Kage would have noticed if he was a ninja.

Yoyoma1910- The haikus could be an easy way to mask mafia behavior but the only time I've seen him as a mafioso he was rather serious. His challenger died during the night.

Ichigo- He has fought in two duels and does not appear guilty to me based on either the duel descriptions or his in-game behavior.

Rhyfelwyr- He was in the early abstain bandwagon. He had retaliatory/defensive votes against Tincow and LittleGrizzly. In his favor, the kill choices seem more like that of a veteran. Also, GH survived through the night despite challenging Rhyf.

vote: Yoyoma1910

Rhyf, if you look at previous games I have played, you will see that this is just my style. For reference, Taormina is a large game in which I was a townie and Netherworld is a large game in which I was mafioso. I have played in other games and I encourage you to look at them too.

**KukriKhan** · 05-10-2009, 23:30

Alive (6):
GeneralHankerchief
Ichigo
Rhyfelwyr
Kagemusha
Yoyoma1910
woad&fangs

With so little of substance to go on, I leave it to chance to decide. I pull the Ace through 6 of Spades from a deck of cards, and say whoever gets 4, 5, or 6 is mafia. My able assistant certifies that I have not looked at the cards since shuffling. Lets see how I do guessing, using the cards:

GeneralHankerchief - 4
Ichigo - 5
Rhyfelwyr - 3
Kagemusha - 2
Yoyoma1910 - A
woad&fangs - 6

The cards and I make w&f, Ichigo & GH guilty.

**woad&fangs** · 05-10-2009, 23:44

Okay, I've tracked down 2 more games in which Yoyo was a baddie. These are Murder Manor II and Filet Royale. In both of those games he had a much more playful tone than in the Golden Rule. I now feel more confident about my vote on him.

**Sasaki Kojiro** · 05-10-2009, 23:58

I keep thinking I'll do a reread but I can't find the time. I would say that woad and GH are almost certainly mafia. GH should be lynched and woad challenged.

**atheotes** · 05-11-2009, 01:02

Originally Posted by KukriKhan

Alive (6):
GeneralHankerchief
Ichigo
Rhyfelwyr
Kagemusha
Yoyoma1910
woad&fangs

With so little of substance to go on, I leave it to chance to decide. I pull the Ace through 6 of Spades from a deck of cards, and say whoever gets 4, 5, or 6 is mafia. My able assistant certifies that I have not looked at the cards since shuffling. Lets see how I do guessing, using the cards:

GeneralHankerchief - 4
Ichigo - 5
Rhyfelwyr - 3
Kagemusha - 2
Yoyoma1910 - A
woad&fangs - 6

The cards and I make w&f, Ichigo & GH guilty.

i believe there are a maximum of 2 ninjas still alive.... even if we lynch the correct person, 3 will be killed in the night..leaving 2 people alive and a mafia victory...so we need to get the duels right as well...i believe someone pointed this out already...

actually my hope is that there is only one ninja alive and the town can win with the correct lynch target... but this seems far stretched...

the mafia has played us well... we have absolutely no case against anyone...

all we have is gut feelings and suspicions.... for my part i still think rhyf is mafia...he has been lurking for quite sometime and suddenly jumped on woad... maybe he wasnt able to maintain his silence with victory so close?