Quote Originally Posted by YLC View Post
After looking over the thread once more and rereading the write ups, I've come to a somewhat troubling conclusion - No one is the killer, yet someone is.

All of you are innocent, but one of you is unknowingly guilty, in the spirit of psycho mafia. This would mean it could be anyone yet again, but it would also strengthen the ties people have to their names - the names mean something and are our only clues as to each others alignment.

ATPG loves to insert himself in his games, and the only viable way to do it would be to do it the way it was done in psycho mafia, where whenever the psycho used his ability one someone else, he also attacked them.

So our unknowing mafioso is someone with a night ability, and used their ability on Diana last night. I know of one person it is not then besides myself, and if what DIY says is true, then it can't be him under this new theory.
Or someone is guilty and just hiding it well. If we keep making assumptions based on ATPG's previous games and your game rules, we're going to end up outsmarting ourselves. You can't conclusively know what you are saying, yet you're acting like these are hard facts.