Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

**Tratorix** · 10-07-2009, 23:55

Originally Posted by Centurion1

Tratorix i mean i suspect innocence but a formal result would be ice. no offense i think your reasoning is weak. How is the fact he plans your protections dirty, even if you die it is not likely he has anything to do with it

**Yaropolk** · 10-07-2009, 23:57

unvote vote: jolt

**Centurion1** · 10-08-2009, 00:00

well i vote: jolt, why would atpg lie, he is now confirmed pro town

**TinCow** · 10-08-2009, 00:07

I am satisfied with the situation regarding CDF. However, after today's ridiculous antics, I refuse to have anything to do with an ATPG hearsay bandwagon. Instead I will

Unvote; Vote: Reenk, courteously

I will explain my vote in the same manner he does:

**Tratorix** · 10-08-2009, 00:13

Originally Posted by Centurion1

well i vote: jolt, why would atpg lie, he is now confirmed pro town

**scottishranger** · 10-08-2009, 00:28

I havent been able to keep up lately, as Im preparing for a major baseball scout showcase in Florida. Ill be gone till next monday, with fairly scanty contact on the web. Ill still trying to read, but in all events, i havent even seen any evidence against anybody until this round.

**scottishranger** · 10-08-2009, 00:30

Vote: Jolt btw. I trust ATPG

**CountArach** · 10-08-2009, 00:31

Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy

unvote, vote: Jolt

Yarrrr.... I have Jolt telling me privately that he wishes to become a british or a Maven, that he refuses to do protection groups, and that he would rather kill anyone I point my finger at. This smells of a traitorous townie, serial killer, or mafia, to me. I request that we make him walk the plank.

Given that I still don't think any of the other ideas in this thread are particularly worth following (At least not without some more work on my part), then I believe we should at least get rid of a bad townie who has expressed interest in going over to the other side.

Unvote: Reenk
Vote: Jolt

I still would like a response from Reenk as to why he hasn't be spammy.

Originally Posted by Centurion1

Sasaki, I hope you admit you were wrong about little grizzly. Dead wrong, but my gut says your innocent, so i trust you.

Avoiding making a powerful enemy... Seems a little scummy to me.

**Chaotix** · 10-08-2009, 00:36

Vote: ACIN

Not a single troll post from him in the last few rounds. Something's up, he's trying to stay low-key instead of drawing attention to himself as usual.

I honestly don't care about the other candidates right now because I have no time to read everything and they all look like terrible candidates. Unless ATPG has some hard proof that Jolt really sent him PMs (i.e., post the PMs in-thread), I'm not buying it.

We can force ATPG and Andres to leave the boat tonight. Then they won't be recruited, and they will still be townie, irrevocably. Win-win situation. If they don't leave within two phases, then we assume they are converted and lynch them. Easy as pie.

**Jolt** · 10-08-2009, 00:39

What the??? I never said that..? Said privately? Ugh?

Unvote, Vote: ATPG

Clearly something's fishy with him to make such blatant lies when I haven't even spoken to him about becoming British, Maven or otherwise. This trumped up accusation came completely out of blue for no apparent reason.

And isn't a little bit strange that everyone seems to be blindly following ATPG when his misconstrued theory that I, who am neither Maven nor British, and even if I spoke about wishing to become either Mafia group, I would still have to deal with the secret "tendency" value, I would be the greatest threat to all? Isn't it VERY OBVIOUS ATPG is playing us all for some obscure purpose?

FOS: Centurion1, Yaropolk, Subotan, Jooray, scottishranger, CountArach

Subotan, SMELLS GUILTY? You mean I smell guilty by having said nothing of the sort to ATPG, I'm not sure I follow your line of thought? This is nothing short of ridiculous.

Yaropolk, nice reasoning for the vote, no doubt.
Centurion1, can you give me a slight hint why would it occur to me telling ATPG that I want to join the Maven or the British?
VERY VERY CLEARLY we got a bucketload of people joining on my bandwagon which are Mafia. This is completely ridiculous.

**Tratorix** · 10-08-2009, 00:51

Originally Posted by Jolt

words

Doesn't matter, dude. ATPG said you said you're guilty and that's good enough for everyone here, apparently.

**Diana Abnoba** · 10-08-2009, 00:55

Vote: Jolt

**Jolt** · 10-08-2009, 01:00

Originally Posted by Diana Abnoba

Vote: Jolt

Ah, but of course. Somehow I can sense what ATPG's arguments might be.

**Sasaki Kojiro** · 10-08-2009, 01:05

Hmm, it's possible that Jolt told pizza that so that he could claim in the thread that pizza was lying. I don't think he would confess that if he was really going all out anti-town (it's moot anyway). And that's not really any more lynch worthy than claiming you should be lynched to get yourself promoted to officer...

There isn't any point in lynching townies who want to become mafia. It's not something you can choose. You're basically just lynching a townie...

**Diana Abnoba** · 10-08-2009, 01:23

Good point Sasaki, but trusting a proven (by investigation) townie, over one whom has stated that he wants to become mafia, and refuses to do protections, is better in my book. Unless anyone has a better lynch suspect in mind, with more proof, my vote stands. Although I will admit, none of the lynch possibilities have been without some question. We have no REAL proof of a mafia this round.

**Sasaki Kojiro** · 10-08-2009, 01:26

Originally Posted by Diana Abnoba

Good point Sasaki, but trusting a proven (by investigation) townie, over one whom has stated that he wants to become mafia, and refuses to do protections, is better in my book. Unless anyone has a better lynch suspect in mind, with more proof, my vote stands. Although I will admit, none of the lynch possibilities have been without some question. We have no REAL proof of a mafia this round.

It's not logical though. A proven townie you can perhaps trust not to lie, but that in no way means that who he says should be lynched should actually be lynched. In this case, he's saying "lynch this guy, he's a townie. The only evidence against jolt also includes him being a townie.

So shlin is more likely to be mafia than jolt

**Diana Abnoba** · 10-08-2009, 01:43

What is the evidence on Shlin, why do you think he is mafia?

**Sasaki Kojiro** · 10-08-2009, 01:52

Originally Posted by Diana Abnoba

What is the evidence on Shlin, why do you think he is mafia?

My gut instinct, based on his response to being called out for having a low post count. His posts show a desire to not be suspected based on being a lurker. That's good townie play, but something mafia do a higher percentage of the time than townies do.

**Crazed Rabbit** · 10-08-2009, 01:53

Ahoy!

I'm sorry that due to events that were very briefly in my control and are now far beyond it, I had to skim read today. But discussion is good, so keep that up. I'll be able to read and communicate more soon, though. First thing will be communications with my officers and various roles who've contacted me.

Also, to those who requested avatars, I must contritely say I can't fulfill the orders until Monday.

Thanks,
CR

**ricera10** · 10-08-2009, 02:02

I trust pizzaguy! As for the people who just lurk, they're probably going to end up as targets for night actions sooner or later.

Vote: Jolt

**Diana Abnoba** · 10-08-2009, 02:04

Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro

My gut instinct, based on his response to being called out for having a low post count. His posts show a desire to not be suspected based on being a lurker. That's good townie play, but something mafia do a higher percentage of the time than townies do.

Well based on that, we have several suspects (see my post from last lynch phase).

**Askthepizzaguy** · 10-08-2009, 02:17

So, Jolt, should I post our conversation then? I am not sure why you would say this was all lies.

Look even if you were a townie, you're not playing as such. You're intentionally trying to sabotage the ship and you voted for a trustworthy officer. It doesn't MATTER if you've been recruited yet or not. The simple fact remains you are plotting our destruction. Confessing such doesn't help your case for being innocent.

I read the rules and I didn't see a rule against posting chatlogs, which is basically the same as posting PMs from other players. So here it is.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read:

I really hate MSN chatlogs. Too much useless info.

**Sasaki Kojiro** · 10-08-2009, 02:24

You seriously started a bandwagon based on that?

"I'm a townie, but I'm bored and hope I get recruited by the mafia. I won't participate in prot groups but I will in vig groups"

I would say Jolt is much less likely to be mafia on the basis of that.

Lynch mafia, not townies

**Centurion1** · 10-08-2009, 02:30

lol, i do not think i am scum. don't trust me sure.

Oh and i am not trying to suck up to sasaki, i am not really worried about him to be honest.

jolt why would a townie try to lynch a townie?

Please explain. WE KNOW ATPG is pro town

**Centurion1** · 10-08-2009, 02:31

yes but sasaki why would atpg lie?

sorry for double post by the way

**Tratorix** · 10-08-2009, 02:32

Despite his best efforts, the Cult of PizzaGuy seems to be around in this game as well. You guys do realize that Jolt is a townie and has no control over whether or not he is recruited, right?

**Askthepizzaguy** · 10-08-2009, 02:34

You seriously started a bandwagon based on that?

Sorry, I could just say "sasaki is guilty, my gut told me". I dunno, I'd rather lynch someone who wants the town to lose. Call me crazy.

He does state he's presently a townie. He also states that he wants to be recruited, and he's voting for someone we know to be innocent. Sorry, I just don't see a helpful "townie" here, I see a person who wants to betray us like someone in Capo. He is townie in name only.

**Centurion1** · 10-08-2009, 02:40

aye he may not have any control but now he painted a big target on his head saying, PICK ME, PICK ME

**Tratorix** · 10-08-2009, 02:41

Originally Posted by Centurion1

aye he may not have any control but now he painted a big target on his head saying, PICK ME, PICK ME

And why would they recruit someone who's already painted a target on himself? Justify it however you want, lynching someone you know is a townie is just a waste.

**Askthepizzaguy** · 10-08-2009, 02:45

So do we have someone we know is mafia? Or do we want to chance it and possibly randomly hit someone important to the town, as opposed to a townie who wants town to lose.

By all means, point at a known mafioso and make him walk the plank. I'm open to suggestion. What's really pointless is sudden random bandwagons based on "my gut" and nothing else.

Thread: Pirate Ship Mafia [Concluded]

Thread Tools

Display

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Re: Pirate Ship Mafia

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions