Netherworld II [Concluded]

[GeneralHankerchief]

That is because you are

There is a difference between calling names and stating a fact.

Why exactly am I petty? How is it a fact?

Summarize your case against me.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I am not sure I agree wholeheartedly with your logic regarding who murdered you and why. Was Andres even here and active at the time? As for me, I am begging your indulgence to just trust me that I didn't murder you. Give me a round of benefit of the doubt, or just for the sake of argument.

Sasaki could have avoided killing you, but that smacks of cowardice. Frankly I think they gave it to AVSM so that it would mess with our brains. But we got AVSM right away, didn't we?

I could make your case in-thread, but I feel you're the best qualified person. I consider Andres' contributions to be lackluster this game. I don't think he was even here to do the murders. I think he skipped out to avoid detection. Tincow and GH are high on my list, but GH sounds like he's the detective or the spokesman for the detective, and as such, he's out. YLC has been revealed, so it's not possible for him to have done it. Chaotix, it's possible...

My next top suspect is actually splitpersonality.

Who are you even talking to? This makes no sense.

[Andres]

Who are you even talking to? This makes no sense.

Let's see:

a) it's new year, so many people are now suffering from a hang-over;
b) it's day 1 in a large mafia game
c) something else
d) some other stuff
e) nonsense

And you expect him to make sense?



Unvote : Sigurd; Vote : Sasaki


For expecting people to make sense.

And there are five good reasons to make that vote, so don't say that I'm not making sense here!

[Thermal]

vote: winston hughes

Not only unusual kill choices, but a dead khazzar, which is a player winston hughes always votes for, in other mafia games at least.

[TinCow]

How can I remember words that you said after the fact?

1. If he's controlling my mind, how am I to remember anything he doesn't tell me to.
2. He already controls my mind!

Would you kindly kill Chaotix?

[ULC]

Who are you even talking to? This makes no sense.

I honestly do not understand why you posted this from another thread in here.

[Diamondeye]

Okay, unvote:YLC. I'm giving you the benefit of doubt. vote:GH

[GeneralHankerchief]

I honestly do not understand why you posted this from another thread in here.

You respond to Sasaki's post, which came chronologically after mine, before you come to my post, which was addressed directly at you.


You[']r[e] trying to avoid me, Mr.[YLC], and my reasoning - why?

[Splitpersonality]

Would you kindly kill Chaotix?

but of course master TC

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Let's see:

a) it's new year, so many people are now suffering from a hang-over;
b) it's day 1 in a large mafia game
c) something else
d) some other stuff
e) nonsense

And you expect him to make sense?



Unvote : Sigurd; Vote : Sasaki


For expecting people to make sense.

And there are five good reasons to make that vote, so don't say that I'm not making sense here!

I saw this before you edited out the picture. For shame Andres, for shame.

[Andres]

I saw this before you edited out the picture. For shame Andres, for shame.

What picture?





You're being weirder than me.

[Thermal]

What picture?





You're being weirder than me.

Well your post was edited....

[Andres]

Well your post was edited....

To add the line:

"And there are five good reasons to make that vote, so don't say that I'm not making sense here!"

Not to remove a picture.

Sasaki is acting weird.

Unvote : Sasaki

Vote : Tincow

[scottishranger]

he's controlling my mind

There we have it, a confession!

Tincow is controlling split!

[Splitpersonality]

There we have it, my confession!

Tincow is controlling me!

What's that, mafia scum?

[scottishranger]

What's that, Im mafia scum!

This is a very odd first day.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I have the heart of Osiris in this amulet of evil! YOU'LL NEVER STEAL MY MAGIC AMULET!!!

[Splitpersonality]

I AM MAFIA EVERYONE NEEDS TO LYNCH ME RIGHT NOW, IF YOU DON'T IT'S YOUR FAULT CAUSE I'M MAFIA.

I concur.

[ULC]

You respond to Sasaki's post, which came chronologically after mine, before you come to my post, which was addressed directly at you.


You[']r[e] trying to avoid me, Mr.[YLC], and my reasoning - why?

I was more shocked by Sasaki's post and wanted to follow up immediately on it - also, I was busy at the moment and couldn't properly respond to you.

To answer why and how you've been petty - maybe I am confusing you with TC, not sure - your responses just sound so alike. I mean, you literally copied each others posts at one point only changing perspective so they made sense. Your going at me as if, both of you, that I am some how a pest, and using tactics like trying to defame me instead of arguing the point.

[Winston Hughes]

vote: winston hughes

Not only unusual kill choices, but a dead khazzar, which is a player winston hughes always votes for, in other mafia games at least.

Surely a noob (such as myself) would go for the more visible (and obviously experienced) people, like ATPG or GH, rather than people who rarely post. More vocal and experienced mafiosi, on the other hand, might have a good reason for taking out quiet ones, since killing other vocal and experienced players would lead to the question of why they hadn't been targeted themselves.

And as for Khazaar, it's true that I have voted for him repeatedly in another game. But for that very reason, if I were a villain here, it would seem very foolish to kill Khazaar on the first night, since (as has indeed come to pass) it would seem likely to draw unnecessary attention to me.

[GeneralHankerchief]

To answer why and how you've been petty - maybe I am confusing you with TC, not sure - your responses just sound so alike. I mean, you literally copied each others posts at one point only changing perspective so they made sense. Your going at me as if, both of you, that I am some how a pest, and using tactics like trying to defame me instead of arguing the point.

Referring to the "I copied his post" point, I was already playfully poking fun of that exact point you were making at that time. Try digging closer to the source.

Also, Winston, you're using a WIFOM defense. Anybody could say they'd do X in a certain position while in reality doing Y to deliberately confuse someone. WIFOM defenses generally hold little water around here, so try again.

[Thermal]

unvote
vote: Tincow

His power to control the game is scary, seeing as we don't know if its mafia or town hes benefiting. Although I haven't read thoroughly enough to know if this is true.

[Beskar]

WIFOM defense = Lynch me, I'm the Mafia!

[Winston Hughes]

so try again.

Why bother? Anything I say could be lies. The question is not whether it's possible I'm trying to mislead you, but whether I sound like I'm trying to mislead you. Do I?

In any case, since I think my reasoning is sound on the first point, I wonder if I haven't touched a nerve here. vote: GeneralHankerchief

[Captain Blackadder]

Random vote AVSM

[Beefy187]

Unvote, Vote: Winston Hughs

The last few post of yours are extremely scummy to the point of me wanting to unvote and vote for you... ON ROUND 1.

[Winston Hughes]

The last few post of yours are extremely scummy to the point of me wanting to unvote and vote for you... ON ROUND 1.

If I sound this guilty when I'm innocent, imagine how easy it's going to be to catch me when I'm actually guilty.

[Askthepizzaguy]

You're not a "noob" Winston... Give yourself more credit... before I switch my vote to you.

P.S. terms like noob technically not welcome in the gameroom (here) which is different from what you're used to Winston. So, don't be such a noob, get with the program.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Am I allowed to do that? Am I allowed to make a joke?

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Plz don't ban me.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

*banned*

[GeneralHankerchief]

Why bother? Anything I say could be lies. The question is not whether it's possible I'm trying to mislead you, but whether I sound like I'm trying to mislead you. Do I?

In any case, since I think my reasoning is sound on the first point, I wonder if I haven't touched a nerve here. vote: GeneralHankerchief

Hey, I was just trying to help a newbie out with a friendly bit of advice. I don't think you're guilty, just using a bad defense.

[Seon]

If I sound this guilty when I'm innocent, imagine how easy it's going to be to catch me when I'm actually guilty.

Oh I do know that feeling :p