StarWars: Return of the Sith [Concluded]

[Methos]

There is a big problem with that TinCow, I am not going to reveal any other results (which were pure with the light, basically) so the Sith can get them, it is only that I haven't revealed.

Even then, my results ATPG is in conflict and (very) suspectible, the problem with this, he is still a "townie" and hasn't been converted yet, so he can't explain himself as he probably doesn't know this himself.

Talk about manipulative. You toss out his name as someone who can be converted, thereby giving the Sith an excellent target. All of us here realize that we can't take the chance of letting ATPG be converted, so thereby you've subtly informed everyone to switch to ATPG. Let's not forget, you also mention that you don't wish to give out the other names for fear the Sith will use it to their advantage.

[Secura]

Talk about manipulative. You toss out his name as someone who can be converted, thereby giving the Sith an excellent target. All of us here realize that we can't take the chance of letting ATPG be converted, so thereby you've subtly informed everyone to switch to ATPG. Let's not forget, you also mention that you don't wish to give out the other names for fear the Sith will use it to their advantage.

Someone who Beskar investigates to be pure and just is going to be an easy target for the Sith to kill though, right?

[Methos]

This correlates with Beskar's own claims and give him a bit more credence.

Several days back this was already mentioned, in that I had agreed with what Beskar had claimed, so I find it odd that you bring it up again. While our powers are the same, his abilities are much more extensive then mine. I had one and he has three?

[Beskar]

Talk about manipulative. You toss out his name as someone who can be converted, thereby giving the Sith an excellent target. All of us here realize that we can't take the chance of letting ATPG be converted, so thereby you've subtly informed everyone to switch to ATPG. Let's not forget, you also mention that you don't wish to give out the other names for fear the Sith will use it to their advantage.

I had no choice. Read closer to the phase, they wanted my results and "no" wasn't an answer they wanted, so I gave them exactly what they wanted, my night action for the round. It will also shut them up about my ability to investigate showing that it wasn't a ruse.

Don't blame me, blame the haters.

[seireikhaan]

Vote: Beskar

Die.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I don't trust him.

We'll see, I'll have to reread today's posts.

But right now, Pizza has to be lynched. He's recruitable.

[Beskar]

Several days back this was already mentioned, in that I had agreed with what Beskar had claimed, so I find it odd that you bring it up again. While our powers are the same, his abilities are much more extensive then mine. I had one and he has three?

The Holocron, remember? Me and another Jedi Master, then the next round, the Expedition Leader, and two other Jedi? etc etc Random choice of gaining more abilities.

[Kagemusha]

Talk about manipulative. You toss out his name as someone who can be converted, thereby giving the Sith an excellent target. All of us here realize that we can't take the chance of letting ATPG be converted, so thereby you've subtly informed everyone to switch to ATPG. Let's not forget, you also mention that you don't wish to give out the other names for fear the Sith will use it to their advantage.

That pretty much makes sense. With your reveal Beskar. You just signed ATPG´s death warrant guilty or not.Now the town cant let him live.Can we wait something similar to happen each round after this one?

[seireikhaan]

To clarify- the investigation is worthless. Cooperation only when under threat of the noose is no sign of a townie. Plus, frankly, you also deserve it on the basis of principle for the "send me all your roles" attempt.

[Secura]

Several days back this was already mentioned, in that I had agreed with what Beskar had claimed, so I find it odd that you bring it up again.

I didn't see any post such as that, I'm afraid... apologies.

I had one and he has three?

He had four total after the holocron.

[Beskar]

The town asked for it, I gave what they wanted. Don't blame me, don't keep requesting investigation results if you don't want to hear the answer. I hope it teaches you that asking an investigator to reveal results is infact, a very bad thing, unless they found a Mafia. Also, it proves that I never killed Methos, as I was investigating, it also proves i never killed Andres either, which also proves I am not a Sith.

I could go on, but this lynch on me is a stupid mistake.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

That pretty much makes sense. With your reveal Beskar. You just signed ATPG´s death warrant guilty or not.Now the town cant let him live.Can we wait something similar to happen each round after this one?

You'd think if the Sith can recruit, then they'd have checked pizza. The correct move is for that to be revealed as soon as he is investigated, and for us to lynch him, unless we have something much better.

A townie Pizza
Does not post in one game and
not in the other

[Beskar]

Plus, frankly, you also deserve it on the basis of principle for the "send me all your roles" attempt.

Yet it was a idea which was only suggested, which no one did it anyway. So you are actively saying you are metagaming? You should be lynched out of principle.

[Methos]

He had four total after the holocron.

Four?

1. Investigate
2. Vig/Serial Killer
3. Lynch safe (one shot ability)

What's the fourth? I'm talking about abilities, not powers.

[Kagemusha]

The town asked for it, I gave what they wanted. Don't blame me, don't keep requesting investigation results if you don't want to hear the answer. I hope it teaches you that asking an investigator to reveal results is infact, a very bad thing, unless they found a Mafia. Also, it proves that I never killed Methos, as I was investigating, it also proves i never killed Andres either, which also proves I am not a Sith.

I could go on, but this lynch on me is a stupid mistake.

And if all the rest of us are capable of being recruited to Sith.Your investigation results are nothing but a distraction to the town.I am starting to get tempted to handle this issue the old fashioned way.Forget about any shady investigation results and trust only my instincts. This would mean that you have become a distrction and thus should be lynched. I havent made up my mind, but im starting to lean into that direction.

[Kagemusha]

You'd think if the Sith can recruit, then they'd have checked pizza. The correct move is for that to be revealed as soon as he is investigated, and for us to lynch him, unless we have something much better.

A townie Pizza
Does not post in one game and
not in the other

Like i said already.Now we dont have any other logical route other then to string up Pizza. What im thinking is that maybe the next one to hang high should be mister Dooku.

[Secura]

1. Investigation
2. Night Kill
3. Lynch Immunity
4. Self Protect.

[Methos]

1. Investigation
2. Night Kill
3. Lynch Immunity
4. Self Protect.

What exactly is his self protect ability?

[seireikhaan]

Yet it was a idea, which no one did it anyway. So you are actively saying you are metagaming? You should be lynched out of principle.

Great news, I know who to tell GH who he should be sending infraction points to.

I fail to see how I'm metagaming. You attempted a strategy which is, at best, a poor idea, and at worst, an attempt by a mafioso to harness and sniff out roles. Further, you then give us a worthless investigation result that is utterly unprovable and which anyone could come up with only when you're in line for the lynch. I fail to see any reason you shouldn't be lynched.

[Secura]

What exactly is his self protect ability?

It does exactly what it says on the tin... :S

[pevergreen]

Yet it was a idea which was only suggested, which no one did it anyway. So you are actively saying you are metagaming? You should be lynched out of principle.

As my favourite fictional TV character based on a real life criminal, and that I've seen the actor in person and taken a picture of with friends, Mark 'Chopper' Read says:

Settle the down. Here eat this, pretend its got kids in it or something.

Hands Beskar a Sumo Salad.

Aww here you go, have a bite of Neville Tomatos.

[Methos]

It does exactly what it says on the tin... :S

Beskar, care to expand on this? You can do so in private if you wish.

[Beskar]

I fail to see how I'm metagaming. You attempted a strategy which is, at best, a poor idea, and at worst, an attempt by a mafioso to harness and sniff out roles. Further, you then give us a worthless investigation result that is utterly unprovable and which anyone could come up with only when you're in line for the lynch. I fail to see any reason you shouldn't be lynched.

Well, if you leave around, myself I can get a Sith, instead of constantly having to watch my back because some one trying to get me lynched left-right-centre. People demanded what I did last night, trying to suggest I killed some one, so I revealed what I did, proving that I didn't infact kill anyone, and you are now complaining.

I fail to see any reason why I should be lynched, I am a known pro-town role and i just proved that I had nothing to do with tonights murders.

On the otherhand, what have you done this game, opposed to attempting to lynch a pro-town role? Sounds perfectly Sithy to me.

[pevergreen]

Beskar, care to expand on this? You can do so in private if you wish.

Thats just silly.

I've a good mind to go for you after Beskar.

[seireikhaan]

Well, if you leave around, myself I can get a Sith, instead of constantly having to watch my back because some one trying to get me lynched left-right-centre. People demanded what I did last night, trying to suggest I killed some one, so I revealed what I did, proving that I didn't infact kill anyone, and you are now complaining.

I fail to see any reason why I should be lynched, I am a known pro-town role and i just proved that I had nothing to do with tonights murders.

On the otherhand, what have you done this game, opposed to attempting to lynch a pro-town role? Sounds perfectly Sithy to me.

Thing is, you didn't prove anything. As I pointed out, anyone could come up with saying that pizza's recruitable. Not a hard concept, it's Star Wars, I'm willing to bet a decent number can be swayed to the dark side. Something you admitted to yourself, and yet you want to be scott free when the very reason that you want Pizza lynched applies to yourself as well. Not buying it.

[Husar]

Two things:

1. Yaseikhaan still acting weird, explanation minimalist, doing everything GH does, not very helpful IMFGO(In My Force-Ghostly Opinion).

2. Pizzaguy plays assassin-droid, supposed investigation result by Beskar mentions susceptible to dark side of force, are droids susceptible to force at all, if not, isn't that weird?

3. (because I can't count) Write-up always mentions a name, Sith would most likely have cover roles, if someone role-blocked a Sith and the write up said "Palpatine got roleblocked" blocking would equal investigation.

4. (getting worse now) if it was a conversion attempt as Beskar claims, revealing in private, then converting would mean death by town most likely, would also indicate that conversions may not always be voluntarily?!?

5. (oh man, I'm stretching it) if there can be only two Sith, yet a conversion attempt could be made, ?

6. (I know, I know, it's three-times two by now) if there were two kills and one conversion attempt, then how many baddies are there and how many actions can they do per night?

7. (I give up) if it was actually not a conversion attempt but a roleblock and we still got two kills, Dooku can't be guilty, right, if it was one, then he can't be guilty either, right?

[Beskar]

Thing is, you didn't prove anything. As I pointed out, anyone could come up with saying that pizza's recruitable. Not a hard concept, it's Star Wars, I'm willing to bet a decent number can be swayed to the dark side. Something you admitted to yourself, and yet you want to be scott free when the very reason that you want Pizza lynched applies to yourself as well. Not buying it.

No it doesn't apply to myself. as even Mace Windu said himself, it is only kill me or him killed anyone, we become suspectible, if you didn't skim posts, you would have seen this mentioned over 9000 times already.

I never said for Pizza to be lynched, I only put up his result. Go and check, at which point did I even remotely suggest that or even vote for him?

Also, it is pretty obvious I didn't make up that result.

[Andres]

No. I wasn't unable to investigate and I was able to be lynched. Beskar claims several more abilities than myself. My only ability was to vig, but if I did so, I had a chance of moving to the Dark Side, so I never did it.

So, Beskar claims Master, but the other Master (confirmed innocent, since Methos got night killed) says he doesn't have the abilities Beskar has. So, we have a confirmed innocent with the same role as Beskar and he says something is wrong with what Beskar is claiming.

What more does the town need to lynch somebody?

Beskar stated he received a holocron with additional abilities.

How very convenient, isn't it?

We'll see, I'll have to reread today's posts.

But right now, Pizza has to be lynched. He's recruitable.

That's what Beskar says. And very conveniently, he adds that ATPG doesn't know he's recruitable...

Also, isn't "recruitable or not recruitable" the sort of result you'd expect the Sith to get?

You attempted a strategy which is, at best, a poor idea, and at worst, an attempt by a mafioso to harness and sniff out roles. Further, you then give us a worthless investigation result that is utterly unprovable and which anyone could come up with only when you're in line for the lynch. I fail to see any reason you shouldn't be lynched.

Master 'khaan is right

[Methos]

Thats just silly.

I've a good mind to go for you after Beskar.

You might want to read the update again. If you do, you'll notice that I, Mace Windu, was murdered. If you also read the thread for today, you'll notice that many people have been posting about that very thing.

[pevergreen]

You might want to read the update again. If you do, you'll notice that I, Mace Windu, was murdered. If you also read the thread for today, you'll notice that many people have been posting about that very thing.

Yeah I kinda skimmed over page 12. As per usual, didn't really read the write up.


Well...count yourself lucky chum. Cause if you were alive, I woulda got you. I woulda got you so hard, you'd be really got.