StarWars: Return of the Sith [Concluded]

[Niklas]

Here, have a tally:

Beskar 7: (Subotan, pever, Niklas, Diamondeye, autolycus, khaan, Thermal)
ATPG 5: (Secura, GeneralH, Kage, TinCow, Sasaki)
Subotan 1: (Psycho)

[TinCow]

Obi-wan given a list of 26 people in the game out of the blue, on the list are names like Palpatine. (True blood Sith)

Someone is claiming to have investigated 26 people already? I suggest you name this person, because that it absurd.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Presumably he's claiming to have the role names, not to have them assigned to players.

Obi-Wan should not be named in the thread

[Beskar]

Someone is claiming to have investigated 26 people already? I suggest you name this person, because that it absurd.

I believe it is a different investigation to me. As you saw with my result, there are no names in it, just their force-alignment.

Majority of the list were in write-ups, it is roughly 12 or so, possibly some were behind the scenes reveals.

I am giving them a chance to at least give me the name of who Palpatine was (for obvious reasons), I don't want this person killed if they were actually Obi-wan Kenobi and a pro-town, but it doesn't mean I believe them at face value either.

Here is the list of names, as there are no users attached (except for the ones we know), I think it is safe to reveal them, as I doubt it would help the Sith in any way.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Obi-Wan Kenobi
Count Dooku
Yoda
Kenth Hamner
Dhidal Nyz
Aayla Secura
Sifo Dyas
Atris
Barrison Draay
Kyp Durron
Corran Horn
Tahiri Veila
Qui-Gon Jinn
Palpatine
Luke Skywalker
X2
Jacen Solo
Galen Marek
Galleros Nul
Daye Azur-Jamin
Den Siva
Eeth Koth
Hoth
Barriss Offee
Anakin Skywalker
Mace Windu

Presumably he's claiming to have the role names, not to have them assigned to players.

Obi-Wan should not be named in the thread

Indeed, I am not going to reveal them. He claimed it is part of his ability, what ability, I don't know. trying to get more information and hopefully lynch Palpatine.

[Askthepizzaguy]

More like accused of working towards being a Sith somehow.

No, Beskar was very clear. I am susceptible to becoming a Sith. It didn't say I was working toward it at all. I have no powers or abilities, and I can't choose to become Sith. Something needs to happen to me first, which is beyond my power. Given how lynch-bait I am, I have my doubts I'll be converted ever.

[Methos]

Obi-wan given a list of 26 people in the game out of the blue, on the list are names like Palpatine. (True blood Sith)
Beskar posted this, saying he has requested the name. (Which means Obi-wan won't get revealed in public, and Beskar will give name out by proxy)
Beskar has no proof this is actually Obi-wan giving this information.
This is apparently scummy, because beskar doesn't trust everyone who claims to be they are asap like jedi Master Guil ible.

You're original statement didn't say 26 people, just named two, of which you mentioned accusing one of them. The fact its 26 makes more sense.

I would like to see that list Obiwan.

[Secura]

unvote: Pizza.

[TinCow]

Those results do not appear to be faked, I doubt there's any way someone could have gotten that many names of roles without a real ability.

If Luke Skywalker is in this game, then he could be the expedition leader instead of Yoda. He is, after all, a bit short to be a stormtrooper.

Ignore the above, totally missed that Yoda was actually on the list as well. I'm not very good at reading today...

[Niklas]

Looking at Beskar's list of names, they fall under three categories:

Confirmed in thread:

Count Dooku
Kenth Hamner
Dhidal Nyz
Aayla Secura
Barrison Draay
Kyp Durron
X2
Jacen Solo
Galen Marek
Galleros Nul
Daye Azur-Jamin
Den Siva
Eeth Koth
Hoth
Barriss Offee
Mace Windu

Hot shots easily guessible:

Obi-Wan Kenobi
Yoda
Qui-Gon Jinn
Palpatine
Luke Skywalker
Anakin Skywalker

Randoms I have never heard of:

Sifo Dyas
Atris
Corran Horn
Tahiri Veila

Not saying it's significant in any way, just that I "did the maths" and might as well put it up there for the rest of you as well, in case anyone finds it useful.

[Beskar]

I only heard of Corran Horn when Csargo falsely claimed that role to me.
Some one claimed Tahiri Veila to me.
Person claiming to be the Expedition Leader to me mentioned they were Yoda.
Obi-wan is the person who sent the list is claiming.
etc

Atris is from KOTOR2.
Sifo Dyas is mentioned in the 2nd film, never seen.


I got a question for you Niklas, who is claiming Garen Marak? i haven't seen anyone claim him.

[Subotan]

Nevermind, Niklas beat me to it.

[TinCow]

trying to get more information and hopefully lynch Palpatine.

So, do you actually have any evidence against Palpatine, or are you pushing for his lynch just because of his name? From where I'm sitting it seems pretty odd for you to try and convince us that name means nothing in this game to save yourself, and then go after Palpatine just because of his canon role.

[atheotes]

So, do you actually have any evidence against Palpatine, or are you pushing for his lynch just because of his name? From where I'm sitting it seems pretty odd for you to try and convince us that name means nothing in this game to save yourself, and then go after Palpatine just because of his canon role.

His reasoning is that Palpatine has never been a Jedi

[Beskar]

So, do you actually have any evidence against Palpatine, or are you pushing for his lynch just because of his name? From where I'm sitting it seems pretty odd for you to try and convince us that name means nothing in this game to save yourself, and then go after Palpatine just because of his canon role.

Please show me where Palpatine has ever been a Jedi.

Exactly.

Where as Dooku was converted in lore, he was a Jedi Master before that, plus the fact it states quite clearly in my role-pm that I am a Jedi Master. Palpatine was raised a Sith from birth, thus it could easily make sense for the starting mafia to actually be the true-blooded sith. There are many other roles like mine on that list where they were Dark-side some time or another, but Palpatine is some one on that list that has never been on the Light side.

[Kagemusha]

So can we please get some sense to this game. Currently we are lynching Beskar while simultaneosly people are revealing themselves to him privately.Or are we lynching ATPG for being able to be recruited by the Sith? while that might be the case with majority of us.

[atheotes]

Please show me where Palpatine has ever been a Jedi.

Exactly.

Where as Dooku was converted in lore, he was a Jedi Master before that, plus the fact it states quite clearly in my role-pm that I am a Jedi Master. Palpatine was raised a Sith from birth, thus it could easily make sense for the starting mafia to actually be the true-blooded sith. There are many other roles like mine on that list where they were Dark-side some time or another, but Palpatine is some one on that list that has never been on the Light side.

Thing is...Palpatine is just a name! It need not be the emperor...

[Secura]

Randoms I have never heard of:

Sifo Dyas
Atris
Corran Horn
Tahiri Veila

In the films, Sifo Dyas was the Jedi who ordered the Clone Army from the Kaminoans; he was apparantly a close friend of Dooku's.

Atris, as stated, was a Jedi Master in KOTOR2; she falls to the Dark Side after extensive studying of Sith holocrons and the Exile has to defeat her before heading off to fight Darth Nihilus, I think.

[Askthepizzaguy]

So can we please get some sense to this game. Currently we are lynching Beskar while simultaneosly people are revealing themselves to him privately.Or are we lynching ATPG for being able to be recruited by the Sith? while that might be the case with majority of us.

Due to the fact you guys have no real suspects and I am going to be lynched eventually, I'm fine with it this round.

At least here you have confirmation I'm a potential threat, if not a real one yet. That beats the Sasaki "lynch yourself" thing.... that would have driven me nuts for a year.

[Beskar]

Thing is...Palpatine is just a name! It need not be the emperor...

As if that is believible.

Anakin Skywalker? I can buy it.
Galen Marak? I can buy it.
Atris? I can buy it.
List of other names...


Palpatine?! No way.

[Kagemusha]

Due to the fact you guys have no real suspects and I am going to be lynched eventually, I'm fine with it this round.

At least here you have confirmation I'm a potential threat, if not a real one yet. That beats the Sasaki "lynch yourself" thing.... that would have driven me nuts for a year.

Well thats why my vote is on you.Though im playing with a thought of lynching Beskar just to stop this chaos we are in right now.

[Niklas]

I got a question for you Niklas, who is claiming Garen Marak? i haven't seen anyone claim him.

Galen Marek was promoted to Padawan in the Round 2 - Day update.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'm totally neutered and completely powerless. I have too much reek of scum on me, and now reek of potential scum on me. My ability to contribute positively to the town has been compromised.

I should have just gone quietly the other round, but I couldn't help but fight for my life. I was pissed off.

[atheotes]

Well thats why my vote is on you.Though im playing with a thought of lynching Beskar just to stop this chaos we are in right now.

Agree that we have no clear direction right now... as seen by the no. of posts without any vote...
I guess we are just waiting for this Ben-Kenobi and Palpatine distraction to clear out.

[Beskar]

Galen Marek was promoted to Padawan in the Round 2 - Day update.

Well, I think that proves if Galen Marek is a Jedi, that I am telling the truth too.

Galen Marek was Starkiller, he was pretty much Darth Vaders apprentice untill he decides in the last moments, to turn to the Light-side and sacrifice himself to save the Rebel Alliance leaders.

[Renata]

Argh Beskar why do you keep doing this? There's no reason to suspect you based on your role name, I agree.

However I have to point out there's nothing anywhere to suggest that the sith (presumably in the form of their cover roles) cannot be promoted, nor that they cannot be "called". Most likely they can, and possibly they have been. In other words, Galen Marek may be a Jedi, or he may be a sith cover role, and there is no way to tell based on that write-up. Similar reasoning applies to you, I'm sorry you don't like it, I know you don't like it, but it's still true!

[TinCow]

This round is giving me a headache, I think we need to focus more on actions and in-thread behavior and less on the gibberish information we're getting about roles and night actions. I feel like we're starting to get into some serious confusion which could be avoided if we stuck to classic mafia-detection techniques.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Yes, the case on beskar seems to be night kill wifom and "he keeps saying he's confirmed innocent, lynch him!".

Belisarius would probably have been better, but now we have to lynch pizza of course.

[Beskar]

Would be easier if the town didn't keep trying to lynch off pro-town roles out of spite.

Belisarius would probably have been better, but now we have to lynch pizza of course.

Agreed, I suspected him, unfortunately, when i got to the thread, there were 3 pages on me.

[Thermal]

unvote
vote: thermal mercury

Because I want no part of the ATPG/Beskar thingy.

[autolycus]

Beskar has satisfactorily answered my questions. Therefore, unvote, vote: atpg.