Gameroom statistics [revisited]

[Romanic]

Alright, classical_hero has been removed from The Order of the Stick. He's one win down, but his mafia ratio is higher.

[Romanic]

Added The Campground, even though I'm still worried this is a fake ending.

Renata winning two games in a row seems abnormal.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Added The Campground, even though I'm still worried this is a fake ending.

My work here is done.

[naut]

This is an amazing set of stats. Name changes must be annoying though: For example I've won two games as Mafia: Family Guy Mafia as Rythmic and more recently when my team won (all down to Joooray), in IIRC Shadow Fort. Looking at these ratios, seems I'm 50/50 regardless of role and 25% survival rate at best.

[Romanic]

This is an amazing set of stats. Name changes must be annoying though: For example I've won two games as Mafia: Family Guy Mafia as Rythmic and more recently when my team won (all down to Joooray), in IIRC Shadow Fort. Looking at these ratios, seems I'm 50/50 regardless of role and 25% survival rate at best.

Name changes are not so bad since you can spot them when looking back at old thread. For example, in that Family Guy game, your posts are made as Psychonaut even though you were playing as Rythmic at the time, so it's easy to figure who changed his name. I already had this game in your records and Rythmic as an alias.

Here's the list of games I have you for:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Games played by Psychonaut

2011-03-03 (+) BuffyVerse Mafia: Apocalypse Now - Town - Replaced
2010-12-27 (+) Star Wars: Fall of the Order - Mafia - Loss
2010-07-28 (+) Star Fox - Lylat Wars - Town - Win
2010-06-21 (+) All Those Pretty Stars - Town - Loss
2010-06-18 (+) Beefdom will rise once more - Town - Loss
2010-06-03 (+) Daggers in the Night - Town - Loss
2010-05-18 (+) Star Wars: Return of the Sith - Mafia - Loss
2010-05-08 (+) The Revenge of Inishmore - Town - Loss
2010-04-20 (+) The Rock & Roll Hall of Fame - Town - Win
2010-04-19 (+) Chinese Zodiac Mafia - Town - Loss
2010-04-15 (+) The Shadow Fort - Mafia - Win
2010-04-06 (+) Mafia IX: Triumph of the Mafia - Town - Win
2010-02-10 (+) Netherworld II - Neutral - Loss
2009-12-20 (+) [Council of Villains Series] The Koopa Troop - Town - Win
2009-10-21 (+) Pirate Ship Mafia - Town - Win
2009-10-08 (+) Capo di Tutti Capi III - Town - Win
2009-05-18 (+) The Council of Villains- Large Mafia Game - Neutral - Loss
2009-05-12 (+) Swords in the Moon - Town - WOG
2009-05-04 (+) Large Simpsons Mafia Game - Town - Loss
2009-04-07 (+) The Settlement - Town - Win
2009-04-06 (+) The fight for Inishmore - Town - Win
2009-03-26 (+) Psycho Mafia - Town - Win
2009-03-15 (+) Capo de Tutti Capi - II - Town - Loss
2009-03-03 (+) The Godfather, Part 3 - Town - Win
2009-02-25 (+) The Abused Potatoes - Town - Win
2009-01-27 (+) The Scourge of Ephesus - Town - WOG
2008-12-30 (+) Family Guy Mafia - The Teddy Snatcher - Town - Loss
2008-12-29 (+) Fillet Royale - Town - Win
2008-12-06 (+) The Prometheus - Town - Loss
2008-11-29 (+) The Full Monty: Simpsons Mafia - Town - Loss
2008-10-15 (+) Kung Fu Mafia II - Town - Loss
2008-09-20 (+) Spirit Mafia - Town - Loss
2008-08-26 (+) The Midgard Saga II - Town - Loss
2008-08-07 (+) The Brothel - Town - Loss
2008-07-29 (+) Soviet Mafia - Town - Loss
2008-06-28 (+) Mafia VIII: Return of the Recommencement of the Revenge of the Mafia - Town - Win
2008-05-25 (+) The Good, The Bad and The Ugly - Neutral - Win
2008-05-22 (+) Trapped in Taormina - Town - Loss
2008-05-07 (+) Pre School Mafia - Town - Win
2008-04-07 (+) Netherworld Mafia - Town - Loss
2007-03-06 (+) Mafia VI: Night of the Day of the Dawn of the Return of the Mafia - Town - Win
2007-03-04 (+) The Legend of Davenport - Mafia - Loss
2007-02-23 (+) The 3 Sons of Algamar - Neutral - Loss
2006-06-30 (+) Mafia - Town - Loss

Let me know if you spot an error. Family Guy is obviously one, I must have misread the roles because I had you as Town, but I see now that this is wrong. The role list isn't very clear in this one (role list) and I had the mafia team as Quintus, White_Eyes and khaan. Can you confirm who the mafiosi were?

I'll fix the data when I come back from work tonight.

[naut]

NLet me know if you spot an error. Family Guy is obviously one, I must have misread the roles because I had you as Town, but I see now that this is wrong. The role list isn't very clear in this one (role list) and I had the mafia team as Quintus, White_Eyes and khaan. Can you confirm who the mafiosi were?

Family Guy Mafia, the Mafia were myself and Quintus, although we only found out we were partners half-way through. khaan was a neutral who had the choice of being Town or Mafia, he picked Mafia. White_Eyes was neutral.

[Romanic]

Thanks Psychonaut. I updated Family Guy with this new info.

[Romanic]

Added The Copa Clash, and I am treating it as a normal game even though it was anonymous. Statistic wise, I don't think they should be treated differently.

[Renata]

Added The Campground, even though I'm still worried this is a fake ending.

Renata winning two games in a row seems abnormal.

Haha.

[Romanic]

Added ATPG Mafia 2 & Music Mafia.

[Chaotix]

Hey Romanic, I should be on the list for most wins in a row at 5, right? Though losing music mafia broke that streak...

[Zack]

Most often (%) town list, that's right.

[Romanic]

Hey Romanic, I should be on the list for most wins in a row at 5, right? Though losing music mafia broke that streak...

You got a streak of five wins in a row, yes, but that list is showing the top 20 streaks, using the date it happened as a tie breaker, so you're at the bottom of those who had a streak of 5. The actual list, if I was to include all the 5 wins in a row would be:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

(# of wins) (player name) (date end)

iStreak sPlayerName dtEnd
9 taka 07-Apr-09
8 Kommodus 01-Apr-07
7 Sigurd 26-Jan-07
7 GeneralHankerchief 20-Oct-07
7 Tratorix 15-Jan-08
7 Beefy187 04-May-09
7 Seon 17-Jun-11
7 Romanic ongoing
6 Peasant Phil 26-Jan-07
6 Sasaki Kojiro 06-Feb-07
6 Thermal Mercury 01-Apr-09
6 Sigurd 12-May-09
6 Beefy187 10-Nov-09
6 Captain Blackadder 20-Apr-10
6 Diana Abnoba 03-Jun-10
5 Sir Moody 26-Jan-07
5 Pannonian 11-Jun-07
5 Csargo 05-May-07
5 Crazed Rabbit 20-Oct-07
5 Psychonaut 04-May-09
5 shlin28 04-May-09
5 Sasaki Kojiro 02-Oct-09
5 gibsonsg91921 21-Oct-09
5 Khazaar 13-Oct-09
5 Beskar 13-Oct-09
5 Yaropolk 26-Oct-09
5 Askthepizzaguy 10-Nov-09
5 Yaropolk 08-May-10
5 Chaotix 17-Jun-11
5 Reenk Roink ongoing

I chose to limit the list only to the top 20, but it's not clear, I realize that. Perhaps I should put "15 players with a streak of 5 wins" instead of listing only those who makes the first 20, it would be clearer.

[classical_hero]

Excellent working keeping this up to date.

[Choxorn]

Most often (%) town list, that's right.

If I get one more game as town, I'll be tying you there.

[Romanic]

Added The Crazy Game & Mafia X.

A note about Mafia X, Bruno (Ibn-Khaldun) and Luigi (glyphz) are considered to have survived to the end since the game should have been stopped after Bertha's lynch, with 3 Town, 2 Mafia and 2 upcoming kills for the mafia, but GH let the game run for suspense.

[Zack]

The Crazy Game ruined my perfect town record!

Although I was a jester, and so were the vast majority of the players.

[Choxorn]

Mine too, and it also dropped me down to third on the winning percentage list!

Okay, so I wasn't on it until now, but still!

[TheLastDays]

Shouldn't the jester roles be counted as neutral?

[Choxorn]

They are counted as neutral. Check my stats and Zack's- it's the first time either one of us have been anything but town, and we currently have our stats listed as a lot of town, 1 neutral, 0 mafia.

[TheLastDays]

Ah ok I thought you were talking about a perfect win record as town...

[Choxorn]

I don't have a perfect win record as town, or even enough games to be on the town winning percentage list.

On the "everyone" winning percentage list, I have a .650, which puts me at third.

[Renata]

Shouldn't I be counted as having survived in The Revengening?

Neutral: 3 games (2 wins, 1 loss, 0 draw, 0 WOG, 0 replaced) - Survived 0 time

I'm curious how bad my survival percentage is, in absolute terms; it's currently listed as 6 of 36, and a (very) quick glance didn't show anyone worse. Reenk's survived almost a third of the time!

[Zack]

If you don't count the Crazy Game, since it ended after Day 1, your survival rate is only ~1.5% worse than mine (2/11).

[Askthepizzaguy]

Indeed, Renata should be counted as a survival in Revengening.

[Choxorn]

HA! I've survived 2 out of 10 times! :D

[Romanic]

Shouldn't I be counted as having survived in The Revengening?

Aye, you should, my mistake. I forgot your special role and strictly counted the players who were around at the end. Fixed.

I'm curious how bad my survival percentage is, in absolute terms; it's currently listed as 6 of 36, and a (very) quick glance didn't show anyone worse. Reenk's survived almost a third of the time!

There's worse (see spoiler below). Among players who played at least 10 games, you are ranked 84 of 120. Look at poor Jolt, survived once in 26 games. He's systematically killed/lynched in every game.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

#1 doc_bean 0.600 ( 6 in 10 )
#2 Xiahou 0.467 ( 7 in 15 )
#3 Cowhead418 0.455 ( 5 in 11 )
#4 Joooray 0.429 ( 12 in 28 )
#5 gibsonsg91921 0.412 ( 7 in 17 )
#6 Methos 0.400 ( 8 in 20 )
#7 Stig 0.385 ( 10 in 26 )
#8 spL1tp3r50naL1ty 0.382 ( 21 in 55 )
#9 Double A 0.378 ( 17 in 45 )
#10 taka 0.367 ( 11 in 30 )
#11 Yaropolk 0.356 ( 16 in 45 )
#12 sapi 0.350 ( 7 in 20 )
#13 Sasaki Kojiro 0.349 ( 30 in 86 )
#14 Centurion1 0.342 ( 13 in 38 )
#15 Reenk Roink 0.340 ( 16 in 47 )
#16 Askthepizzaguy 0.337 ( 29 in 86 )
#17 Warmaster Horus 0.333 ( 14 in 42 )
#18 Romanic 0.333 ( 8 in 24 )
#19 ByzantineKnight 0.333 ( 6 in 18 )
#20 scottishranger 0.333 ( 4 in 12 )
#21 Elite Ferret 0.333 ( 7 in 21 )
#22 Sprig 0.333 ( 5 in 15 )
#23 Secura 0.316 ( 12 in 38 )
#24 Craterus 0.316 ( 6 in 19 )
#25 Dutch_guy 0.310 ( 9 in 29 )
#26 Proletariat 0.308 ( 8 in 26 )
#27 Caius 0.308 ( 24 in 78 )
#28 A Very Super Market 0.306 ( 19 in 62 )
#29 YLC 0.306 ( 15 in 49 )
#30 Tratorix 0.302 ( 19 in 63 )
#31 Divine Wind 0.300 ( 3 in 10 )
#32 atheotes 0.294 ( 20 in 68 )
#33 Drisos 0.294 ( 5 in 17 )
#34 Quintus JC 0.294 ( 10 in 34 )
#35 Kagemusha 0.293 ( 12 in 41 )
#36 ArpeggiateTHIS 0.286 ( 4 in 14 )
#37 Crazed Rabbit 0.286 ( 14 in 49 )
#38 glyphz 0.286 ( 4 in 14 )
#39 FactionHeir 0.281 ( 16 in 57 )
#40 Diana Abnoba 0.280 ( 7 in 25 )
#41 slashandburn 0.278 ( 5 in 18 )
#42 Cultured Drizzt Fan 0.273 ( 12 in 44 )
#43 Tiberius of the Drake 0.273 ( 9 in 33 )
#44 Csargo 0.267 ( 28 in 105 )
#45 Beefy187 0.266 ( 25 in 94 )
#46 Kralizec 0.263 ( 5 in 19 )
#47 Death is yonder 0.260 ( 13 in 50 )
#48 Omanes Alexandrapolites 0.256 ( 10 in 39 )
#49 Zack 0.250 ( 3 in 12 )
#50 Yoyoma1910 0.250 ( 5 in 20 )
#51 Husar 0.250 ( 5 in 20 )
#52 Northnovas 0.250 ( 3 in 12 )
#53 Khazaar 0.250 ( 8 in 32 )
#54 Captain Blackadder 0.246 ( 16 in 65 )
#55 Twilightblade 0.238 ( 5 in 21 )
#56 TheFlax 0.235 ( 8 in 34 )
#57 GeneralHankerchief 0.234 ( 15 in 64 )
#58 issaikhaan 0.232 ( 22 in 95 )
#59 Kommodus 0.231 ( 6 in 26 )
#60 classical_hero 0.231 ( 3 in 13 )
#61 Zain 0.231 ( 3 in 13 )
#62 Subotan 0.231 ( 6 in 26 )
#63 El Diablo 0.227 ( 5 in 22 )
#64 shlin28 0.221 ( 17 in 77 )
#65 johnhughthom 0.218 ( 12 in 55 )
#66 LittleGrizzly 0.217 ( 5 in 23 )
#67 Chaotix 0.216 ( 11 in 51 )
#68 Greyblades 0.214 ( 6 in 28 )
#69 RoadKill 0.214 ( 6 in 28 )
#70 Robbiecon 0.211 ( 4 in 19 )
#71 Winston Hughes 0.208 ( 5 in 24 )
#72 TinCow 0.208 ( 5 in 24 )
#73 Sigurd 0.208 ( 11 in 53 )
#74 White_Eyes:D 0.207 ( 12 in 58 )
#75 Orb 0.200 ( 3 in 15 )
#76 Sir Boo 0.200 ( 2 in 10 )
#77 Gobbledygook 0.200 ( 2 in 10 )
#78 Seamus Fermanaugh 0.200 ( 5 in 25 )
#79 civplayah 0.200 ( 2 in 10 )
#80 Choxorn 0.200 ( 2 in 10 )
#81 AggonyDuck 0.200 ( 3 in 15 )
#82 woad&fangs 0.196 ( 9 in 46 )
#83 Renata 0.194 ( 7 in 36 )
#84 Discovery1 0.190 ( 4 in 21 )
#85 TevashSzat 0.190 ( 4 in 21 )
#86 pevergreen 0.190 ( 19 in 100 )
#87 Thermal Mercury 0.184 ( 9 in 49 )
#88 Beskar 0.183 ( 11 in 60 )
#89 boudica 0.182 ( 2 in 11 )
#90 Psychonaut 0.178 ( 8 in 45 )
#91 Skooma Addict 0.176 ( 3 in 17 )
#92 Diamondeye 0.171 ( 6 in 35 )
#93 Autolycus 0.167 ( 4 in 24 )
#94 Iskander 3.1 0.167 ( 3 in 18 )
#95 Motep 0.167 ( 3 in 18 )
#96 Ibn-Khaldun 0.167 ( 2 in 12 )
#97 Sarathos 0.163 ( 7 in 43 )
#98 Seon 0.158 ( 3 in 19 )
#99 Kukrikhan 0.154 ( 2 in 13 )
#100 CountArach 0.145 ( 8 in 55 )
#101 a completely inoffensive name 0.133 ( 2 in 15 )
#102 Peasant Phil 0.133 ( 2 in 15 )
#103 UltraWar 0.133 ( 2 in 15 )
#104 Andres 0.127 ( 10 in 79 )
#105 Lord Winter 0.109 ( 6 in 55 )
#106 Warluster 0.105 ( 2 in 19 )
#107 Landlubber 0.100 ( 1 in 10 )
#108 Alexander the Pretty Good 0.100 ( 1 in 10 )
#109 Pannonian 0.100 ( 1 in 10 )
#110 Gaius Scribonuis Curio 0.100 ( 1 in 10 )
#111 Evil_Maniac from Mars 0.100 ( 1 in 10 )
#112 B_Ray 0.100 ( 1 in 10 )
#113 Killfr3nzy 0.091 ( 1 in 11 )
#114 ELITECubKingWarman88 0.087 ( 2 in 23 )
#115 Ignoramus 0.067 ( 2 in 30 )
#116 The Stranger 0.067 ( 1 in 15 )
#117 Tran 0.063 ( 1 in 16 )
#118 Glenn 0.063 ( 1 in 16 )
#119 God Emperor 0.050 ( 1 in 20 )
#120 Jolt 0.038 ( 1 in 26 )

[Choxorn]

I don't think doc bean surviving more often than he dies will last very long.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I don't think doc bean surviving more often than he dies will last very long.

I think it will. I predict he will be exactly where he is for a good long time.

[Romanic]

I don't think doc bean surviving more often than he dies will last very long.

I think it will, doc_bean's last mafia game was four years ago.

Many times I considered changing the all-time leaders to show only active players. Eventually perhaps I'll do that. It doesn't make much sense to have doc_bean, for example, leading this category if he's been away for 4 years, or perhaps it make sense a little, but it's surely not as interesting as having only active players listed.