Polandball Mafia [Concluded]

[BSmith]

In that case, you'd already have lost.

True. I haven’t paid that close attention to the numbers, but that is absolutely correct. Why do you think the others would have picked me to kill over any of the other three? What does visor gain by leaving me alive?

[Winston Hughes]

Two kills per night in that one though.

True, but the relative kill rate for the scum is still higher here.

[Winston Hughes]

True. I haven’t paid that close attention to the numbers, but that is absolutely correct. Why do you think the others would have picked me to kill over any of the other three? What does visor gain by leaving me alive?

You're actually contributing to discussion, and he needs someone else to try and convince the others, since there's little chance they'd have paid much heed to any arguments coming from his direction.

[BSmith]

Alright. I can see that line of logic. I need to let it sit for a bit. Hopefully others will contribute to this discussion. We could very easily be at LYLO and I'd rather not muck this up if we can avoid it.

[Winston Hughes]

Aye, that makes sense.

As it stands, you're pretty much lock town (which is to say, if scum you richly deserve the win), whilst Visor looks scummy on several counts.

The problem is that the other three survivors have given pretty much nothing in the way of content on which to make a judgement. Given that at least one - and possibly all - of them are town, the prospects of an innocent win still look rather bleak at this stage.

[El Barto]

BSmith, yuo of teamings up with Visorscum?

[BSmith]

Well, in the absence of any real further discussion (Winston not included), I'll go back to plan A: unvote; vote: Visor. I can see Winston's point and there are a few holes in my seon/AA/Jarema thought line. Gonna be pissed with myself if seon is indeed scum though.

Something is wrong when I am the most vocal player... just sayin.

[El Barto]

Yuo is of most vocal living player. Am angry, if not of killed, I would of most vocal living player.

[Double A]

going all in with BS
vote: Visor

[GeneralHankerchief]

Voting closed.

Visor has been lynched, stand by for the comic. Feel free to send in orders in the meantime.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Day 5


https://i.imgur.com/sYE2jbD.png

Day 5 tally:

Visor: 4 (Seon, Jarema, Double A, BSmith) :skull:
Seon: 1 (Visor)

It is now Night 5! The phase will conclude Saturday, May 21, at 20:00 US Eastern time.



Killed:
atheotes - Turkey
Winston Hughes - Japan
edse - Italy
Punisher - Ireland

Executed:
johnhughthom - Germany
El Barto - Somalia
Golden1Knight - Spain
Sooh - Finland
Visor - Russia

Wrath of God:
seireikhaan - USA

Still alive: (4)
Double A - France
BSmith - Serbia
Seon - Poland
Jarema - Brazil

[Double A]

Je have le last laugh, Russie! Hon hon hon!

[Winston Hughes]

I'm left hoping for a Tak/BSmith scum team, so at least we got beat by actual players. ~;p

[El Barto]

Je have le last laugh, Russie! Hon hon hon!
Of realitis? He of impeded use of your stronza ghigliottina.

I'm left hoping for a Tak/BSmith scum team, so at least we got beat by actual players. ~;p
Would of courseings like to comply, but is of improbable. You cannot into right this one, Winston.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Night 5


https://i.imgur.com/hJwMhCJ.png

Final results:

Killed:
atheotes - Turkey
Winston Hughes - Japan
edse - Italy
Punisher - Ireland

Executed:
johnhughthom - Germany
El Barto - Somalia
Golden1Knight - Spain
Sooh - Finland - MAFIA
Visor - Russia - MAFIA

Wrath of God:
seireikhaan - USA

Survived: (4)
Double A - France
BSmith - Serbia
Seon - Poland
Jarema - Brazil

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Congratulations to the town and thanks for playing! :medievalcheers:

[GeneralHankerchief]

Have to head out so I'll have more to say later, but in the meantime, I hope you enjoyed this game because there probably won't be a sequel anytime soon. :laugh4: I should really stick to writing.

[BSmith]

Oh thank God...


Edit: that was a reference to the game result. Not the post right above.

[Double A]

FRANCE ALWAYS RIGHT

[Jarema]

I really liked the drawings.

As for the game, I was lost. I forgot how much I dont like games with no reveal...

[El Barto]

Am of happy! Felicitá!

Oh thank God...


Edit: that was a reference to the game result. Not the post right above.
Of sureties. (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/SuspiciouslySpecificDenial)

[Winston Hughes]

@GH

Loved the theme, loved the art, loved every aspect of the game under your control. :2thumbsup:


@Tak & BSmith

:bow: CFC boys towned this one good.


Visor

Defeated on easy mode with time to spare, eh. *sucks air through teeth* ~;)

[El Barto]

@GH

Loved the theme, loved the art, loved every aspect of the game under your control. :2thumbsup:
Is why am of criticisings. Non-sucky Polanball is not of true Polanball. Criticising is of compliments.

In factuals, I can into suggestion: This game of being uploaded into Polanball comics. Is of worthy.

@Tak & BSmith

:bow: CFC boys towned this one good.
Is of true ^_^
Dead town is of win!

Visor

Defeated on easy mode with time to spare, eh. *sucks air through teeth* ~;)
Shots is of fired! huehuehue

[Golden1Knight]

Yay town is of winnings

Gracias!

[GeneralHankerchief]

Host's thoughts, in no particular order:

1) I originally put this game and its concept on the queue on Thanksgiving weekend, while drunk (or possibly nursing a hangover, or both). As it turns out, doing this is a bad idea. :laugh4:

2) I tried to hold my drawings as close as possible to the official submission rules (https://www.reddit.com/r/polandball/wiki/index/policies/submission_rights) on /r/polandball, but sometimes I couldn't be bothered to use the exact colors of the flag or draw stuff individually without copypasting (see: stars on my American flags). That said, on your role PMs, I made certain to make your individual countryballs as Polandball-correct as possible

3) Obviously the meta in recent times has moved far, far away from what I originally made my bones with back in the day. At first I was contemplating adding more roles, powers, etc to mimic the countries drawn, but eventually decided to just revert to what I know best: a nice vanilla game, with no reveals and talking after death.

4) Due to the extreme lack of practice this userbase (i.e. you guys) has had with this style of game in recent times, I was worried that posting would be way down, and the mafia would have an easy walk to victory. The former came true but the latter did not, which I'm quite pleased about.

5) I'm not sure if the tradeoff of "no reveals but dead are allowed to post" intrinsically favors one faction or the other. Obviously there's far more ambiguity that the town has to muddle through, but the mafia can't fall back on busing as much, and they also have to worry about people remaining influential after death. All in all, I see no reason for me to make the switch that everyone else seems to have done at this time.

6) Late in the game, Winston (I think it was him) made reference to my previous games, hoping to find an inclination of the mechanics. Winston had a good idea, but I based this game's "mechanics" - really, if there were truly any - off The Campground (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php?135271-The-Campground-Concluded) and not Mafia X. Incidentally, this game was originally designed for 17 players - the exact same amount that Campground had, and that game came down to a Lylo at final 3 (featuring an excellent Mexican standoff to boot).

7) Our mafiosi have yet to appear in this thread postgame, but from what I've seen of their kills most if not all of them were designed to kill off the inactive players - a strategy for which I'm grateful, as a host. The exception was the Winston kill, which was designed to frame El Barto.

8) Once again, I hope you all had fun, and thanks for playing! :bow:

[Double A]

no reveals are worse than GH's art