View Full Version : Joan of Arc
Mount Suribachi
08-16-2004, 18:52
In the words of Winston Churchill
If it wasn't a miracle, then it surely deserved to be
Discuss.
The Blind King of Bohemia
08-16-2004, 21:46
Although she no doubt inspired some of France to fight, i think it undermines the hard work of others, Gilles De Rais, Jean Count of Dunois for example who fought much more than Joan did and i feel sorry for her being burnt but the way people talk about her totally turning the tide against the english is insane.
Even by the time of the siege of Orleans, the engish lines couldn't surround the whole of orleans and the morale was very low after the Earl of sailsbury being killed. Normandy was being over taxed and was in near rebellion reinforcements were always trickling through to Orleans and in actual fact the defenders considerable outnumbered the besiegers and not to mention the lacklustre allies in the Burgundians who left leaving huge gaps in the siege lines.
vBulletin® v3.7.1, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.