Log in

View Full Version : A Tale of Beer and Old People! - New Mafia [Concluded]



Pages : 1 [2]

Sarathos
09-30-2007, 00:18
Vote: FactionHeir for starting the vote on being alive. (Plus you are alive)

Beefy187
09-30-2007, 03:26
I cant really play coz im in NZL

Be back in tommorow (or in 2 days)

Haudegen
09-30-2007, 08:28
Well, if I tried to apply a variant of the "third on bandwagon rule": Sigurd is the third player in this day phase to vote someone for the reason of being alive. :inquisitive:

However Husar seems somehow scummy, too. He made a thinly veiled revenge vote after several others have used the "alive argument". Not sure if he only wanted to carry on a running gag, but my gut feeling tells me, that this line of reasoning is a good hiding spot for the mafia.

And FactionHeir has given other reasons for his vote on Husar: he accused him of strange behaviour in the first day phase.

I guess I´ll stick with Husar.

Vote: Husar

Husar
09-30-2007, 11:56
There we go...strange behaviour in the first day phase...
Or shall I say, strange behaviour before even the first kills were posted?
Did you expect a serious analysis? :wall:

Andres
09-30-2007, 18:15
Oh come on guys, you can't be serious. So you are going to lynch Husar because 1) he behaved "strange" (could somebody explain the strangeness of his behaviour to me please?) 2) he is still alive.

:wall:

FactionHeir
09-30-2007, 18:17
For all we know Andres might be trying protect his only living mafia companion.

Andres
09-30-2007, 18:19
For all we know Andres might be trying protect his only living mafia companion.

I got killed by the mafia...

Haudegen
09-30-2007, 20:41
I got killed by the mafia...

CA hasn´t revealed much so far. It might have been the serial killer as well.

Andres
09-30-2007, 21:16
So, instead of a) realising that Husar is getting killed for actually no reason at all or b) trying to convince us that there actually is a reason, you guys are discussing the innocence/guilt of a dead player?

:inquisitive:

FoS Haudegen and FactionHeir for trying to suppress discussion.

Husar
09-30-2007, 22:43
There doesn't seem to be a lot of discussion anyway and Faction Heir's insistance on my guilt for behaving weird and staying alive is very suspicious in itself if you ask me. Maybe he doesn't realize that his constant voting for me is what makes the mafia keep me alive. It's not that hard to figure out, is it? But maybe he doesn't want anyone to figure that out.:inquisitive:

Just keep talking about round one where nobody had an idea yet so maybe noone will get an idea ever.:wall:

pevergreen
10-01-2007, 02:43
No one suspects the Spanish Inquisition Post Count Analysis!


First off, the low posters

RoadKill 4
Garcilaso de la Vega el Inca 4
Proletariat 3
kamikhaan 3
Brave_Sir_Robin 3
Twilightblade 2
Tiberius of the Drake 2
Myrddraal 1
sapi 1


Prole has been away (check the Teutonic PBEM in the Throne Room for conformation) and will be away until the 6th.

Where is everyone else? :whip:

Andres 19

Fourth highest post count (including host) from a dead player... a role perhaps?

Beefy187 31
Zain 28
CountArach 20

Hang on...wheres Ichigo?

Ichigo 13

Unvote: Husar, Vote: Ichigo

You are normally the top poster. What's changed scummy boy? :whip:

Csargo
10-01-2007, 03:04
So, I herd you liek mudkips...

pevergreen
10-01-2007, 03:07
No. Bulbasaur.

Csargo
10-01-2007, 03:12
mudkips pwns all other pokemon!!!! I Demand A Apology!!!!

pevergreen
10-01-2007, 05:09
No way!

:focus:

Twilightblade
10-01-2007, 05:56
WOW Im not wogged

Ok I got new computer so thats why I havent been around
Vote: Abstain cause I havent had time to read every post yet

Beefy187
10-01-2007, 11:06
Im back from NZL. Not in very good mood but the trip was great.. Anyhow This is a disgrace townies!! Ive been away for 6 days (had a opportunity to post 2wice) and theres only been 2 pages worth of discussion. And those votes been random like in the first round. (Sorry for voting for you Omanes. Youre probebly innocent seeing as you got lynched with just 2 votes.)

Reply to Shlin: If my "Strange behavior" is my lack of participation then that is because I was in NZL.

So far if what Pever and Twilight says is true then Prole and Twilight is off the suspect list. Pever can get off as well for good work.

Ok thats all settled. Now the suspect. Suspect seems to be willing to make the game somewhat more quiet by killing off the active players which is fine tactic but less entertaining and harder to analyse. Sapi, Caius, BSR and Roadkill being less active seems a little strange to me. Sarathos can live because his funny. Haudegen seems alot more active then the last game and same goes for Factionheir. Ichigo seems bumming around like always but I like it when he does that. If theres a vote on him ill vote for Sigurd for being alive this long but since theres none Factionheir seems to be a good lynch option. I will vote for him eventhough that will make me a 3rd to vote.

Vote: Factionheir

PS: Magikarp is the best pokemon in the world

Csargo
10-01-2007, 13:08
Sigurd is obviously guilty...

Andres
10-01-2007, 13:18
Sigurd is obviously guilty...

He should make a few more posts, to say the least :inquisitive:

Stop lurking Sigurd. Talk! :whip:

Beefy187
10-01-2007, 13:19
Bah but I want to lynch factionheir:whip:

Csargo
10-01-2007, 13:21
So, I herd, who has the most votes, you liek mudkips.

pevergreen
10-01-2007, 13:24
lol

we can has tally?

CountArach
10-01-2007, 13:29
FactionHeir was right in the thick of the crunch of old people. He was hurling abuse at anyone within his range. This had given him the ire, and the votes, of those people who were around him.

"FactionHeir, will you please step forward?"

He complied with the request, but continued stepping forward, eventually crushing down on the Constable's toe. The Constable flinched.

"I really hope you are the Hooligan, because I want to beat you so bad right now..."

Alive (16):
Ichigo
Sarathos
pevergreen
Beefy
Warmaster Horus
Sigurd
Haudegen
shlin
Brave Sir Robin
greaterkhaan
RoadKill
Twilightblade
Inca
sapi
Proletariat
Husar

Lynched (3):
Omanes
Zain
Factionheir

Killed (6):
Andres
GH
Stig
Tib of the Drake
Crazed Rabbit
Hepcat

Sigurd
10-01-2007, 14:00
WHAT????

We really need a running tally here. I had no idea that FactionHeir was in the lead.
This puts a BIG FOS on those who voted him...
If any of you had bothered paying attention you would see that FactionHeir revealed things from the townie pm way before CountA actually posted it... WAY TO GO TOWN (me included)!!!! NOT!!!!

Husar
10-01-2007, 14:15
I you had been paying more attention to this thread, you could have told us before we lynched him.:inquisitive:

Or maybe it wasn't in your interest to stop us and you now saw your perfect chance to appear pro-town by telling us how stupid we are to have lynched him while secretly you laugh about that free kill you and your mate just got.:inquisitive:

But then I don't only think this game lacks tallies, some list of players alive, players lynched and players killed would be nice as well, Count Gamehost. ~;)

pevergreen
10-01-2007, 14:38
Alive:
Omanes
Andres
Ichigo
Sarathos
pevergreen
Beefy
Warmaster Horus
Sigurd
Stig
Haudegen
shlin
Hepcat
Brave Sir Robin
greaterkhaan
RoadKill
Tiberius
Twilightblade
Inca
sapi
Proletariat
Husar

Killed:
Hanky
Crazed Rabbit
Hepcat

Lynched:
FactionHeir
Zain

Wogged:


Correct list of players.

Stig
10-01-2007, 15:49
I believe I'm dead

Omanes Alexandrapolites
10-01-2007, 17:18
Wasn't I lynched on Day II pevergreen?

shlin28
10-01-2007, 17:34
Im back from NZL. Not in very good mood but the trip was great.. Anyhow This is a disgrace townies!! Ive been away for 6 days (had a opportunity to post 2wice) and theres only been 2 pages worth of discussion. And those votes been random like in the first round. (Sorry for voting for you Omanes. Youre probebly innocent seeing as you got lynched with just 2 votes.)

Reply to Shlin: If my "Strange behavior" is my lack of participation then that is because I was in NZL.

So far if what Pever and Twilight says is true then Prole and Twilight is off the suspect list. Pever can get off as well for good work.

Ok thats all settled. Now the suspect. Suspect seems to be willing to make the game somewhat more quiet by killing off the active players which is fine tactic but less entertaining and harder to analyse. Sapi, Caius, BSR and Roadkill being less active seems a little strange to me. Sarathos can live because his funny. Haudegen seems alot more active then the last game and same goes for Factionheir. Ichigo seems bumming around like always but I like it when he does that. If theres a vote on him ill vote for Sigurd for being alive this long but since theres none Factionheir seems to be a good lynch option. I will vote for him eventhough that will make me a 3rd to vote.

Vote: Factionheir

PS: Magikarp is the best pokemon in the world

I was asking why you were so aggresive, and why YOU havnt been lynched it? (We have to get it right sometimes...)



No one suspects the Spanish Inquisition Post Count Analysis!


First off, the low posters

RoadKill 4
Garcilaso de la Vega el Inca 4
Proletariat 3
kamikhaan 3
Brave_Sir_Robin 3
Twilightblade 2
Tiberius of the Drake 2
Myrddraal 1
sapi 1


Prole has been away (check the Teutonic PBEM in the Throne Room for conformation) and will be away until the 6th.

Where is everyone else? :whip:

Andres 19

Fourth highest post count (including host) from a dead player... a role perhaps?

Beefy187 31
Zain 28
CountArach 20

Hang on...wheres Ichigo?

Ichigo 13

Unvote: Husar, Vote: Ichigo

You are normally the top poster. What's changed scummy boy? :whip:
Why isnt my name on the list? :thumbsdown:

Warmaster Horus
10-01-2007, 18:04
I'd ask the same thing.

Sigurd
10-01-2007, 18:46
I you had been paying more attention to this thread, you could have told us before we lynched him.:inquisitive:
This is a Tu quoque fallacy... I did pay attention.
Even though I gave you the heads up at the start of the game... you didn't catch on. Andres I believe caught on .. and yet being active, never spoke out against a lynching of an innocent. I believe Beefy too caught the gist at the start of the game... yet he too voted FactionHeir.

HOOLIGANS the lot of you!!!!

FactionHeir
10-01-2007, 18:59
I bet that Husar will get away killing all townies because of their senility....

Both Sigurd and myself are/were not Mafia as per first two posts if anyone bothered reading.

Andres
10-01-2007, 19:02
This is a Tu quoque fallacy... I did pay attention.
Even though I gave you the heads up at the start of the game... you didn't catch on. Andres I believe caught on .. and yet being active, never spoke out against a lynching of an innocent. I believe Beefy too caught the gist at the start of the game... yet he too voted FactionHeir.

HOOLIGANS the lot of you!!!!

I did not vote for FactionHeir.

But feel free to lynch me if you really want to. I have to remind you though, that I am already killed.

And if CA would be so kind to finally post the write-up for the events mentioned in this post (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showpost.php?p=1690667&postcount=235), it would be clear to everybody that I got killed by the mafia.

You can stop your attempts at making a confirmed innocent look guilty.

Csargo
10-01-2007, 19:14
ANDRES IS TEH GUILTY!!!!VOTE:ANDRES

Husar
10-01-2007, 19:45
This is a Tu quoque fallacy... I did pay attention.
Then why did you post just half an hour after the lynch and not somewhen in the 48 hourse before the lynch? I remember there was something before CA posted the townie PM but since I never really got what it was, I simply forgot about it. :shrug:


I bet that Husar will get away killing all townies because of their senility....
Oh, I think someone has analysed my evil mind and will come up with lots of really convincing evidence from the first round soon.:dizzy2:

So far I couldn't really debunk all the evidence you came up with like "you acted weird" or "you are still alive".:sweatdrop:

Andres
10-01-2007, 19:50
Sigurd, why didn't you post to save FactionHeir?

Csargo
10-01-2007, 22:52
I got killed by the mafia...

^^^Serial Killer

FactionHeir I think was a good lynch.

Sigurd is acting extremely strange, though I think that's why he's still alive, but maybe not.

Sigurd
10-01-2007, 23:37
First of all... I must say I don't like this 48 Hour business. It screws up the rythm of a mafia game.
Secondly. I am not keeping a spreadsheet for this game = don't know the current tally.
I didn't realise FactionHeir was in danger of being lynched until I came home today from attending meetings all day (No Access to a computer).
Why would I point out the exchange FactionHeir had in the early game? He would have been Mafia bait. I could have saved him by voting Husar... I think. But hey, that would have been a retaliation vote for him getting me lynched in the Hospital game. :yes:

I don't really have any real suspicions towards particular players in this game but there are a heck of a lot of players that do not contribute. Since Andres who even commented on the weird edits in the start of the game didn't spot the clear innocent FactionHeir... It is plausible that Husar didnt either.

Beefy on the other hand should have noticed... unless he didn't get a townie pm... :oops:

Beefy187
10-01-2007, 23:37
I read the first day phase again. I remember factionheir posting something about bad eyesight before the townie pm got posted by CA. I would like to say, that would make him a townie but then again I cannot clear the possibility that theres is some lines which says something like that in the mafia pm. Since I really dont like changing my vote to other people I would like to stick with my vote. Just incase his the cunning one.

Mafia seems to win more when they are quiet in the first half then aggresive in the second half. And hey! Thats exactly how im playing. But I play like this because I like being townie and I think its my duty to post more eventhough half of my post doesnt make sense. Ill be more quiet next game (perhaps in Ichigos) so detective dont have to waste night phase searching me and so I can find other things to do.

Oh and I did notice at the start. Just didnt think that was Factionheir

RoadKill
10-01-2007, 23:49
This is going pretty slow.

FactionHeir
10-02-2007, 00:30
Neither Sigurd nor I were guilty, as anyone could have read from the early posts.

Looking how Ichigo is acting, I think he is very scummy. Next to Husar of course.

So FoS: Ichigo, Husar

Husar
10-02-2007, 00:55
Sigurd is dead?

I haven't seen a decent tally for ages(pever's seems to be wrong or what?) and the game is so slow, I easily forget what's going on anyway.:dizzy2:

Csargo
10-02-2007, 00:59
Neither Sigurd nor I were guilty, as anyone could have read from the early posts.

Looking how Ichigo is acting, I think he is very scummy. Next to Husar of course.

So FoS: Ichigo, Husar

How do you prove that???

pevergreen
10-02-2007, 03:15
I thought we were on night 2

Searching for CA's posts so i can do a correct one.


Edit:


Alive:
Ichigo
Sarathos
pevergreen
Beefy
Warmaster Horus
Sigurd
Haudegen
shlin
Brave Sir Robin
greaterkhaan
RoadKill
Twilightblade
Inca
sapi
Proletariat
Husar

Lynched:
Omanes
Zain
Factionheir

Killed:
Andres
GH
Stig
Tib of the Drake
Crazed Rabbit
Hepcat

CountArach
10-03-2007, 08:25
Beefy was looking out over the verandah. It was days like this that he loved being in the Old Folk's home. The sunset was out there and had as many different shades of yellow, orange and red as there were in the rainbow... so not that many. Which was good, Beefy hated the sun.

These Hooligans had been a real menace lately, but he knew that there was still good in the world. Take the hooded man who had come up to him earlier. he had given him the blue balloon that was just now sitting right in front of him.

Suddenly, the balloon popped, spraying two things everywhere. The first was bits of blue rubber. The second was a small, fine powder. Anthrax, to be more specific.

Some landed on Beefy's nose and there was no saving him. He died content knowing that the last sunset he ever saw was a truly horrible one.

------------------------------

Sigurd was sitting down on his old man rocking chair, about to go to sleep. This was just too good a target for the cloaked man behind him. I simply walked up to him and shouted something incoherent.

Sigurd's heart skipped a beat, and he started to seize up. He was having a heart attack, he knew it. He reached down as quickly as he could to the button next to him on the wall and pressed it.

Alarm bells started to go off downstairs in the Nurse's quarters. The one who was on duty ran into action, sprinting up the stairs. It was a literal race against the metaphorical clock.

She grabbed the nearby Defribulator, a horrible word to spell, and opened it. She rubbed the shock paddles together and yelled out "Clear!", then applied them to Sigurd's still chest.

Nothing.

She rubbed them together again, wishing that the insane doctor were here to help here now, and shouted out again. She applied the shock paddles again.

Still nothing.

"Don't die on me you bas-"

Just then, there was movement in the chest. A small movement, but movement none-the-less.

She had saved his life.

Alive (15):
Ichigo
Sarathos
pevergreen
Warmaster Horus
Sigurd
Haudegen
shlin
Brave Sir Robin
greaterkhaan
RoadKill
Twilightblade
Inca
sapi
Proletariat
Husar

Lynched (3):
Omanes
Zain
Factionheir

Killed (7):
Andres
GH
Stig
Tib of the Drake
Crazed Rabbit
Hepcat
Beefy

It is now Day 4 - 48 hours for a lynch

CountArach
10-03-2007, 08:27
In addition to that update, I have caught up all of the older fluff things I owed you guys. They can be read here:
https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showpost.php?p=1688664&postcount=230

https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showpost.php?p=1690667&postcount=235

https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showpost.php?p=1693609&postcount=273

Sigurd
10-03-2007, 08:51
Thank you my guardian angel ... and thank you Mafia for proving me innocent.

48 hours to lynch? ...

Andres
10-03-2007, 08:53
Bah, I got killed by Heineken :no:

REVENGE! I want REVENGE!

CountArach
10-03-2007, 09:06
48 hours to lynch?
Yes, that is how it has been the whole time.

Beefy187
10-03-2007, 10:35
:furious3:

I wasnt lynched I was killed!!??

Oh thats it mafia thats it.. Your getting my hug:laugh4:

pevergreen
10-03-2007, 10:55
Seems we have mafia, doctor and a serial killer.

CountArach: Was Stig's kill written by the person or yourself?

Csargo
10-03-2007, 20:03
Vote:RoadKill

Obvious lurking is obvious

shlin28
10-03-2007, 20:54
Vote Ichigo

He says some extremely weird stuff like "Sigurd is obviously guilty", for no reason, as well as posting three posts on a pokemon.

Andres
10-03-2007, 21:01
Vote Ichigo

He says some extremely weird stuff like "Sigurd is obviously guilty", for no reason, as well as posting three posts on a pokemon.


Well, that's the Ichigo I know :shrug:

Csargo
10-03-2007, 21:08
Vote Ichigo

He says some extremely weird stuff like "Sigurd is obviously guilty", for no reason, as well as posting three posts on a pokemon.

He was... You don't liek mudkips?

CountArach
10-03-2007, 22:15
CountArach: Was Stig's kill written by the person or yourself?
The killers send me a basic outline of their kills. I write whatever is not sent to me.

pevergreen
10-04-2007, 02:43
Ok.

The mention of Dallas makes me very sure that the serial killer reads the NFL thread.

Beefy187
10-04-2007, 02:55
Is NFL the Australian one?:help:

Csargo
10-04-2007, 03:02
Ok.

The mention of Dallas makes me very sure that the serial killer reads the NFL thread.
:huh:

pevergreen
10-04-2007, 05:19
:shrug: I dunno. Something makes me think that the serial killer is american

Beefy187
10-04-2007, 08:48
Just went to NFL thread. Right its American one Im sorry dont bash me yet.

Right suspect is most likely a lurking mafia. Most likely its one of my friend. Otherwise theres no reason to take me out just when I was getting suspecious. So I would say go for TB or Sarathos.

Csargo
10-04-2007, 18:31
:/....

pevergreen
10-04-2007, 21:28
I will be away until Sunday, as will Sarathos.

CountArach
10-05-2007, 08:58
Alright 48 hours is up with about 10 posts...

It is now between RoadKill and Ichigo

shlin28
10-05-2007, 17:33
Unvote, Vote RoadKill

Lurker :shame:

Csargo
10-05-2007, 17:52
I'll vote the same as earlier.

Vote:Roadkill

In one of the mini games Roadkill chose to lurk, he was mafia that game.

Andres
10-06-2007, 17:00
I'll vote the same as earlier.

Vote:Roadkill

In one of the mini games Roadkill chose to lurk, he was mafia that game.

What are your toughts on the other suspect, Ichigo?

Csargo
10-06-2007, 17:24
What other suspect? ME!!?!?!?!?! He's really scummy...

shlin28
10-06-2007, 18:32
So... is Roadkill (LURKER!!! :furious3:) lynched yet?

RoadKill
10-06-2007, 18:57
What the heck, I thought I was lynched before, why am I being lynched again?

shlin28
10-06-2007, 19:28
You've been lynched before??? :inquisitive:

RoadKill
10-06-2007, 19:58
Nevermind, I thought I got lynched before, so I didn't check the thread after that, but oh well I'm getting lynched now anyways.

CountArach
10-07-2007, 08:27
The Constable called forward for any votes. None were forthcoming. 'Stupid old people', he thought, 'Never willing to participate in anything. Well anything fun at any rate.'

Eventually a couple of votes did come forward and they seemed to cry out for one person.

RoadKill.

RoadKill stepped forward. Even with his bad hearing he knew what was going on.

"You're coming away with me," the Constable said, "And don't try anything funny."

It is now Night 4 - PMs Please
WARNING: THE END OF THE NEXT DAY PHASE WILL BE A WOG!

Alive (14):
Ichigo
Sarathos
pevergreen
Warmaster Horus
Sigurd
Haudegen
shlin
Brave Sir Robin
greaterkhaan
Twilightblade
Inca
sapi
Proletariat
Husar

Lynched (4):
Omanes
Zain
Factionheir
RoadKill

Killed (7):
Andres
GH
Stig
Tib of the Drake
Crazed Rabbit
Hepcat
Beefy

Zain
10-07-2007, 19:29
Man, it seems like this certain mafia is being very... long-winded.

Did you guys have a delay or something?

pevergreen
10-08-2007, 01:06
He said 48 hour phases. I disagree. 24 hours if you can please.

Sarathos
10-08-2007, 02:37
I think it would be safer having 48 hours

You will just have to wait pever...

Andres
10-08-2007, 08:41
He said 48 hour phases. I disagree. 24 hours if you can please.

The host is boss in his own game. Feel free to discuss duration of night/day phases in the Mafia rules thread though.

CountArach
10-08-2007, 09:09
Alive (12):
Sarathos
pevergreen
Warmaster Horus
Sigurd
Haudegen
Brave Sir Robin
greaterkhaan
Twilightblade
Inca
sapi
Proletariat
Husar

Lynched (4):
Omanes
Zain
Factionheir
RoadKill

Killed (9):
Andres
GH
Stig
Tib of the Drake
Crazed Rabbit
Hepcat
Beefy
Ichigo
shlin

shlin and Ichigo have been killed! Fluff will come later.

Now, for the WoG rules - I have decided to change them somewhat. This will be a 48 hour day phase, as with all the other ones, however EVERYONE MUST POST. Failure to post, will result in a WoG of you! Alternately, you can PM me.

shlin28
10-08-2007, 16:42
Got killed in both mafia games in one day :furious3:

Looks like someone got a grudge against me... *Glares at Pever*

Andres
10-08-2007, 17:24
Now, for the WoG rules - I have decided to change them somewhat. This will be a 48 hour day phase, as with all the other ones, however EVERYONE MUST POST. Failure to post, will result in a WoG of you! Alternately, you can PM me.

Since Sigurd is confirmed innocent, I suggest only he posts in the thread. This will result in = everybody dead except one townie = Townie Victory :bounce:

shlin28
10-08-2007, 17:31
Sigurd is innocent??? Wow I missed a lot...

Caius
10-08-2007, 23:03
Vote:WH

What are u doing? why arent you posting here?

Husar
10-08-2007, 23:07
No idea. :shrug:

Sarathos
10-08-2007, 23:31
Alternatively, Sigurd could be mafia, his buddy just failed in an attempt to kill him. Or its just a cover and the whole thing was planned to make him look innocent, if that is possible........

Sarathos
10-08-2007, 23:33
Actually no thats stupid, just ignore me :shame: :hanged:

Twilightblade
10-08-2007, 23:37
Good to see that your back to your normal lurk spam lurk self sarathos

Sarathos
10-09-2007, 00:04
Good to see that your back to your normal lurk spam lurk self sarathos

Not quite, Im posting big for Andres, plus trying to think outside the box and provide an alternative view.

Csargo
10-09-2007, 00:46
DOUBLE POST LYNCH SARATHOS!!!!!

Sarathos
10-09-2007, 03:01
Oh not again... :no:

Tratorix
10-09-2007, 03:06
Vote: Sarathos

Lynch the spammer! :laugh4:

I've honestly got nothing better to go on.:shame:

Sarathos
10-09-2007, 03:23
Come guys this is BS, I dont spam or double post, I used to but not anymore.

Plus didnt you get lynched BSR???

Honsetly do you guys have any evidence at all apart from the crap excuse that I spam (which I dont)

This also smells like a bandwagon.....

pevergreen
10-09-2007, 03:24
You do spam. 3 posts in a minute...

Twilightblade
10-09-2007, 03:27
Sarathos you spam just accept it

Sarathos
10-09-2007, 05:04
Negative

Csargo
10-09-2007, 05:39
Just accept it.

Beefy187
10-09-2007, 07:05
Townies if you lynch Sarathos for being what he is your gonna loose this game. Sarathos is one of the poor chap who gets lynched for lurking and for spamming when his just trying to be more active. Give hiim a pat on the head for trying to be active. I know how busy Sarathos is. His trying his best to post more. So try go for someone alse.

(Ignore what I just said above. Spammings bad. Lynch him!:skull: )

pevergreen
10-09-2007, 07:37
Busy? Instead of working he is on here...

CountArach
10-09-2007, 07:53
Plus didnt you get lynched BSR???
Not by my list:
https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showpost.php?p=1701696&postcount=328

People who are currently WoG bait:
Warmaster Horus
Sigurd
Haudegen
greaterkhaan
sapi
Proletariat

I shall PM them.

Twilightblade
10-09-2007, 08:21
sounds good to me cuz then we'll more disscussion (I hope)

Sarathos
10-09-2007, 08:25
So let me get this straight, if I dont post I get lynched for lurking but if I so post I get lynched for spamming.What the hell is going on :huh:

:sharky:

Andres
10-09-2007, 08:28
So let me get this straight, if I dont post I get lynched for lurking but if I so post I get lynched for spamming.What the hell is going on :huh:

:sharky:

:spammer:

FactionHeir
10-09-2007, 08:30
So let me get this straight, if I dont post I get lynched for lurking but if I so post I get lynched for spamming.What the hell is going on :huh:

:sharky:

You don't post, you get WoGed.
You double/triple/etc post, you get lynched.
You post once like everyone else does, you are fine.

Beefy187
10-09-2007, 10:50
Well said Factionheir.:2thumbsup:

But in Sarathys case even he post normally someone will come up with diffrent reason to lynch him.:laugh4:

Ok back to topic. Whats all the players thoughts on the kills made so far?

pevergreen
10-09-2007, 11:21
Well the Serial Killer either:
Is dead
Forgot to send in kills
Limit on the role (2 nights then 1 night with no kill)
Is framing someone, so is pretending to be dead to survive.

Haudegen
10-09-2007, 15:50
Vote: pevergreen

you seem too concerned about the serial killer. It´s a secondary target.

Warmaster Horus
10-09-2007, 19:07
Here I am. At that moment, Garcilaso, I was sleeping. And before, I was working.

Hmm. As for the game itself, I haven't been following it very well. I guess, though, that Sigurd is innocent, since he was attacked and saved. The save description was that of a female nurse, I believe (haven't time to check, sorry). So...

pever is too concerned about that role. And so, because we don't really have much else to go on: vote:pever. Sorry, but this game really isn't active enough to get good suspicions about a player. Strange behaviour is the best we could go for.

FactionHeir
10-09-2007, 19:13
Me still thinks you guys should lynch Husar.

shlin28
10-09-2007, 20:58
My current suspects are Pever or Warmaster :juggle2:

CountArach
10-09-2007, 22:09
Sigurd, kamikhaan and Prol still to post here.

Stig
10-09-2007, 23:21
WoG Prole, she's on holiday

RoadKill
10-09-2007, 23:44
-nevermind-

pevergreen
10-10-2007, 01:04
Prole isnt on holiday anymore..i think.

How have i been acting different? Look at Heiniken mafia, i tried to find out the Serial Killer there.

Too many people are inactive to judge this properly.

I think Husar is the best lynch.

Vote: Husar

Husar
10-10-2007, 01:21
I agree

Vote: Husar

Alternatively I could just suicide and you can all stop voting for me and vote for someone who's actually guilty. If CA accepts this, it's fine with me.

Sarathos
10-10-2007, 02:10
So you want to suicide for being innocent???

Caius
10-10-2007, 04:09
Unvote:WH
Vote:pever

Keep the tie.

CountArach
10-10-2007, 05:55
No suiciding when you have votes on you.

pevergreen
10-10-2007, 06:48
Do you not have anything better to say Caius?

Some people are voting for bad reasons, and not backing it up.

Beefy187
10-10-2007, 07:08
Take the votes off Husar if his really willing to suicide. Thats the best chance of Townies winning

Twilightblade
10-10-2007, 07:52
tally anyone?

Sarathos
10-10-2007, 08:20
Take the votes off Husar if his really willing to suicide. Thats the best chance of Townies winning

Depends Beefy, what if Husar is mafia and he is just using tactics to try and avoid being lynched....

Your not that good Husar :pimp2:

Beefy187
10-10-2007, 08:29
CA needs to confirm this but if Husar is really willing to then we can make sure CA kills him off

CountArach
10-10-2007, 08:44
If Husar is truly willing to suicide then he should PM me. He cannot have any votes on him when he does.

CountArach
10-10-2007, 09:01
pevergreen was at the front of the crowd, yelling loudly, trying to put his view forward.

But to no avail.

"Will the man named pevergreen please come forward?" the Constable said, being careful to not pronounce the capitalisation of the name.

"Like hell!" pevergreen screamed. He made a leap for the window, much more lithe than most people his age were supposed to be. He reached the window.

"So long suckers!" He reached to open the window.

Damn! Locked!

"You are coming with me, old man," the Constable said.

"Don't you see, you blind moron? I am the young one! I did it all! I'm damn proud of it too! This place was built on my favourite skatepark! I hate you all, and everything you stand for!"

TOWNIE VICTORY!
:2thumbsup:
Alive (11):
Sarathos
Warmaster Horus - Nurse
Sigurd
Haudegen
Brave Sir Robin
greaterkhaan
Twilightblade
Inca - Constable
sapi
Proletariat
Husar

Lynched (5):
Omanes
Zain
Factionheir
RoadKill
pevergreen - Hooligan

Killed (9):
Andres - Crazed Doctor (Serial Killer)
GH
Stig
Tib of the Drake
Crazed Rabbit
Hepcat - Hooligan
Beefy
Ichigo
shlin

A decent game guys, not much posting though. A couple of great behind-the-scene moments. Hepcat was killed by Andres on night one, effectively hamstringing the Mafia. Congrats Andres, by the way for thinking up the most horrific kills I have read in a while.

Then on the night Sigurd was attacked, he was:
1. Attacked
2. Protected
3. Investigated

In other words, every possible role had been directed at him!

pevergreen
10-10-2007, 09:23
Uggghhhh.

I have no idea how suspicion came onto me.

I thought that round had another 24 hours to go, otherwise i would have made a defence, for a lynching that makes no sense.

Lucky Break is all i will say.

Beefy187
10-10-2007, 09:35
I thought the rounds gonna last bit longer too.. Congrats townies!! Havnt had a townie victory in the large game for a while. Pever lynch was just random. So you got lucky
(like Pever said)

Didnt like the 48 hour system too much. We couldve talked alot more. But good game CA thank you for hosting!

CountArach
10-10-2007, 09:37
I wouldn't do the 48 hours again - people get complacent and say "I'll post tomorrow", then they don't.

Warmaster Horus
10-10-2007, 09:53
Smart. I remember Stig's game, where there were a heck of a lot of posts, in just 24 hours. And where suspicion could be directed because of posting time. That was nice.

Anyway, congrats town! And thanks CountArach for hosting this!

Andres
10-10-2007, 10:02
I was a bit disappointed about getting killed so soon. Serial Killer is a fun role.

Good game town :bow: And thanks for hosting, CA :bow:

Husar
10-10-2007, 10:14
Oooops. :shrug:

Haudegen
10-10-2007, 15:37
Cheers! It´s finally done.

I want to apologize to Husar for joining a half baked bandwagon against him. After that day you seemed very desinterested in this game. In fact the majority of players seemed to have lost interest in reasonable postings (pokemon stuff, anyone?) for quite some time. :embarassed:

One thing I´d like to ask pevergreen: Why is it in the town´s interest to hunt the serial killer? In the two big mafia games I took part in, the serial killer was actually helpful for the town because he took out one of the mafia guys. That´s why I think I had a rather good reason to vote for you.

@ Andres: Now I know why you were convinced that the mafia killed you, before any townie could really know for sure :beam: By the way, what were the objectives of your role?

And thanks to our host, Count Arach!

Andres
10-10-2007, 15:41
@ Andres: Now I know why you were convinced that the mafia killed you, before any townie could really know for sure :beam: By the way, what were the objectives of your role?


Your win conditions are incredibly difficult. You are required to be the last remaining player with a special role left alive. This means that both Hooligans, the Nurse, the Constable and anyone with a special role must be killed or arrested.

:bow:

Warmaster Horus
10-10-2007, 16:53
I think, Haudegen, that the danger about a Serial Killer is mainly the potential to kill innocent townies, or worse, pro-town roles.

Of course, remember that here, pever was a mafioso, and SK is very dangerous to mafiosi.

shlin28
10-10-2007, 19:54
I totally predicted Pever's guiltyness (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showpost.php?p=1702052&postcount=329):laugh4:

Haudegen
10-10-2007, 20:38
I think, Haudegen, that the danger about a Serial Killer is mainly the potential to kill innocent townies, or worse, pro-town roles.

Of course, remember that here, pever was a mafioso, and SK is very dangerous to mafiosi.

And vice versa.

I have never had the chance to play as a serial killer, but if I had, I´d probably go for the mafiosi first. Because they have more "firepower" than the townies (2 kills vs. one lynch). And their behaviour is usually less predictable, which means that a good performance in the thread won´t keep me safe from them.

On the potential dangers: We, the townies, killed far more innocents than the serial killer. And we were probably just lucky to have not lynched the nurse or the detective. Just curious: Has a serial killer ever won a game here? I think, the role pm, Andres quoted above, is correct. It´s incredibly difficult for him to win. That´s why I think the serial killer is a potential benefit for the town. The mafia had better chances in a game without a serial killer.

Caius
10-11-2007, 00:17
I knew the role of Andres, but I have never thought of a SK role. Or maybe I misread it.

Well, I had a pro-town role. I was keeping a low profile, so I would not be a mafia target, but I investigated all the wrong people.

CountArach
10-11-2007, 00:43
Yeah Inca seemed to investigate people who were attacked that same night - I can think of at least twice. With the Andres investigation I subtely hinted that he was a Doctor of some kind, without giving anything away.

seireikhaan
10-11-2007, 03:58
Umm, hooray for town?! Meh, I honestly lost interest in the game pretty soon in. In fact, I was going to be wog'd for the first time if the game hadn't ended that turn. So any and all credit for townie victory goes to everyone but me, I guess.

Hepcat
10-11-2007, 06:32
I was annoyed that with my first Mafia role I got done in by the end of day 1. I really should have killed Andres in the first round like I was planning to, but pever said I should chose someone who is less active. :wall:


Andres is there any particular reason why you chose me for your first target?

pevergreen
10-11-2007, 07:25
Strategy:

Kill of all posters that are active and believeable. Leave lurkers, suspicious and RL friends alone. Kill CR asap.

Beefy187
10-11-2007, 07:44
Aww... Im your RL friend arent I:sweatdrop:

Zain
10-11-2007, 18:55
So in other words, I got lynched first for NO REASON?

Oh well, I'm more experienced and smarter because of it.

Sigurd
10-12-2007, 09:48
Alive (11):
Sarathos
Warmaster Horus - Nurse
Sigurd
Haudegen
Brave Sir Robin
greaterkhaan
Twilightblade
Inca - Constable
sapi
Proletariat
Husar

Lynched (5):
Omanes
Zain
Factionheir
RoadKill
pevergreen - Hooligan

Killed (9):
Andres - Crazed Doctor (Serial Killer)
GH
Stig
Tib of the Drake
Crazed Rabbit
Hepcat - Hooligan
Beefy
Ichigo
shlin

A decent game guys, not much posting though. A couple of great behind-the-scene moments. Hepcat was killed by Andres on night one, effectively hamstringing the Mafia. Congrats Andres, by the way for thinking up the most horrific kills I have read in a while.

Then on the night Sigurd was attacked, he was:
1. Attacked
2. Protected
3. Investigated

In other words, every possible role had been directed at him!

Sorry about the inactivity people... I suddenly had too much going on at the same time this month.
I think this would have been a great game had there been 24 hour cycles.

Heh... so I was attacked? .. By whom?
Nice collaboration there by the pro-townies. You rock!!!
This is a Total Town Victory with 11 alive and all pro-town roles also alive.
GOOD JOB!!!

pevergreen
10-12-2007, 09:51
I attacked you.

Caius
10-13-2007, 00:27
I thought Sigurd was mafia because he is a common target for mafia.