Printable View
Montreal is Lower Canada not Upper Canada.
Upper Canada is Ontario, the Great lakes and Niagara falls, Lower Canada is where the Province of Quebec is including Montreal and Quebec City.
The St-Laurence flows downwards...to the sea, even if geographically that is north direction... Like Lower Egypt(north) and upper Egypt (south), due to the Nile...you know :book:
Losing points on geography here CA :whip:
But that is why we are here right? :)
I don't really remember the map, but I think that the Montreal region extends down to the great lakes, making them right. :P
If you look at the territories instead of the cities, they actually have "Upper Canada" for (more or less) Upper Canada (post-1791) and "New France" for "Lower Canada" (post-1791.) What they've changed is putting Montreal - which, like Quebec City, was in Lower Canada historically - in Upper Canada. That lets them have both Montreal and Quebec as regional capitals on the map and makes Upper Canada - at this time pretty desolate - a functioning territory for France at the game's start.
It seems more like a calculated design decision than anything else. I'm just ticked that they don't have Halifax as at least a town in Acadia. No Halifax, damnit?
Halifax didn't exist back then, foo'
Oh man you a fan boy or what? Learn your history before making comments like that. I am French Canadian, and I happen to Live in Montreal too, don't insult me please.Quote:
Originally Posted by A Very Super Market
Suggested reading for you :)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_France
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lower_CanadaQuote:
The Province of Lower Canada (French: Province du Bas-Canada) was a British colony on the lower Saint Lawrence River and the shores of the Gulf of Saint Lawrence (1791-1841). It covered the southern portion of the modern-day Province of Quebec, Canada, and the Labrador region of the modern-day Province of Newfoundland and Labrador.
and:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/QuebecQuote:
After the Constitutional Act of 1791, the territory was divided between Lower Canada (present day Quebec) and Upper Canada (present day Ontario), with each being granted an elected Legislative Assembly.
Enjoy.
Neither did St. Petersburg, but that doesn't seem to bother them :PQuote:
Originally Posted by A Very Super Market
No, you misunderstood.
I'm not sure, but I think that the region that Montreal is the region capital of, extends downwards to the Great Lakes, and where Toronto is now. Montreal itself is at the extreme edge of the region, and I've no idea why CA did that.
The region that Quebec is the capital of, encompasses the majority of Lower Canada, but they've named it New France, leaving Upper Canada with no Lower Canada.
I'm Canadian, just not French, so don't take me as ignorant.
Ahh I see, I understand what your saying now, you were giving the "technical" explanation here yes?.Quote:
Originally Posted by A Very Super Market
Still it is inaccurate geographically and historically, I think we agree on that.
Cheers!
Oh yes, totally. I'm rather confused by the whole thing as well, but I suspect it is a gameplay issue, since you would need to have Montreal and Quebec in the game, while there are no big cities in Upper Canada at that point.
Ca wanted to keep province number to a minimum so it's obvious that they need to put together several distinct region. What about the silly "central italian states" that replace 4 (four!) different states?
But CA has always done that. They never wanted to have huge maps with 200 provinces, so I can't really complain. A lot of the complains from the community is about design choices that have been around at least since Rome. :sweatdrop:
Oh I have no problem with not making all of the Provinces, but if your gonna make a city of one make at least sure that it is accurate.Quote:
Originally Posted by beatoangelico
Montreal is not in Upper Canada, it is in Lower Canada, and since they Put Quebec in "New France" region, they can Correct Montreal to "Lower Canada" instead of the Incorrect "Upper Canada"..that region that Montreal is on can be (should have been) called Lower Canada instead.
They made a Mistake, we are the Fans, we point it out so they can correct it, not a biggy...mistakes are human..and we are all but human..(including CA).
There is no reason to try to deny or find justifications of the mistake..a simple name change can go in the next patch.