Lololol
Reading through the thread now. Will report when done so.
Printable View
Lololol
Reading through the thread now. Will report when done so.
The thread isn't that long Seon to go over.
But I'm not interested in looking at you yet.
Now YLC may have killed off Captain Blackadder as he voted for YLc on day 1, and perhaps he was worried that CB would return to vote for him.
However YLC was on the Joooray bandwagon reasonably early, and I have a feeling that Morpheus may be mafia. (At least I feel it more likely than Popeye as mafia)
Now moving on, classical_hero came in with a very late vote change. Perhaps he wanted to blend in on the lynch wagon, seeing as Joooray was a gonner anyway. It's a regular move to come in and vote for a mafia buddy if he's going down.
For this reason I'll vote: classical_hero
Ah yes Robbie, I have gone through all the posts made by everyone, analyzed all their hidden intents, examined all the kills, made a chart, compared many of the players to characters from Edgar Allen Poe Novel, and came up with nothing in particular, but I think I am still going to vote for Vote: Diamondeye. Because if he's not guilty, I am going to burn my hands.
Atpg, do cover roles stay intact on death?
Robbiecon, I'm assuming cover roles stay intact on death, since scum are not revealed on death. Therefore, conclusions based on what character anyone came up when lynched are founded on sand.
Cover roles stay intact on death.
Good point autolycus, I didn't consider that perhaps the dead scum are revealed as their cover roles. I assumed it would be purely for claiming purposes.
But remember there was no picture for Morpheus in the write up.
That's an oversight on my part.Quote:
Originally Posted by robbiecon
https://i205.photobucket.com/albums/...uy/SP/SP22.png
This looks like the face of pure evil.Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Nah, evil is much more decisive looking.Quote:
Originally Posted by robbiecon
I still think woad is a good lynch.
vote: Death is yonder
Snarf
If the second half of this day is anywhere near as quiet as the first, we're in big trouble. Come on folks, wake up and take positions. Please!
vote:DiamondEye
@robbiecon, my vote for Jooray never counted anyway, plus this is the vote I really wanted to have happen, but I realised it was never going to happen, so it hopefully going to happen now.
Winston, are you only able to say "Snarf" and vote? Could anyone with greater knowledge on the Southpark universe elaborate on whether its possibly an IC compulsion, or whether it could be just a tactic to get by the game while saying little?Quote:
vote: Death is yonder
Snarf
If your reasoning is based on that early game situation with GE and vote switching, I don't know about you, but this is what I thought about that situation early game, just reiterating.Quote:
Ah yes Robbie, I have gone through all the posts made by everyone, analyzed all their hidden intents, examined all the kills, made a chart, compared many of the players to characters from Edgar Allen Poe Novel, and came up with nothing in particular, but I think I am still going to vote for Vote: Diamondeye. Because if he's not guilty, I am going to burn my hands.
IMO didn't feel to me like he was trying to pop in to save his scum buddy, especially now that CB was night killed and it would be rather silly to interact with autolycus like that in the early game. Unless you have a gut feeling you would care to elaborate on. I think its a cheap cop-out vote.Quote:
I think that it is likely that if DE was vote switching to save CB, he would have continued voting autolycus, rather than switch randomly to JHT. Unless he was trying to save auto then, but as he said, it would be rather weird if he voted his mafia partner just to switch out at the last moment.
Vote: Seon
:yes:Quote:
If the second half of this day is anywhere near as quiet as the first, we're in big trouble. Come on folks, wake up and take positions. Please!
No, I can Snarf normally. Just so long as I remember to Snarf Snarf.Quote:
Originally Posted by Death is yonder
Otherwise I'll Snarf.
Any reason for the vote on Seon, DiY? I'll give the thread a once over after I've had some sleep.
Well for starters, Seon seemed convinced of Diamondeye's guilt based on in thread analysis reasons.
Quote:
I have gone through all the posts made by everyone, analyzed all their hidden intents, examined all the kills
From my perspective, the main thing that one would take a look at in relation to Diamondeye if specifically re-reading to analyze every player (which seon said he did) would be that of the last minute vote switch in the first round, concerning him, GE, as well as Autolycus.Quote:
Because if he's not guilty, I am going to burn my hands.
IMO, with retrospective knowledge, CB was night killed, and hence innocent, and the only reason for DE to have been voting Autolycus if he was his mafia partner would be to distance both of them.
However, I don't think that if a mafia was trying to distance himself from his partner, he would change his vote last minute. I do believe that Diamondeye is at the very least a good player as mafia, and this last minute vote changing which did cause a lot of attention that would definitely be unwanted as a mafia (and avoided in the first place).
Additionally, Autolycus's behavior does not seem scummy, so I'm disinclined to think that DE is scum for those reasons (AKA popped in to save his partner)
All of these combined with Seon's stated reason implied as being "in thread analysis", makes me think its a cheap excuse to be voting DE, maybe hopping onto a free vote to get by the round and survive.
OTOH I could be wrong on some of these accounts, which is why I asked him to elaborate further if it was a gut feeling (like posts that tweaked his gut etc)
Quick summary because I need to go out for dinner and probably won't be back in time to answer anymore questions soon:
Seon says that it is through in thread analysis that he strongly believes DE to be guilty. My take on the matter is that the thread stuff doesn't seem to shout "DE is scum" that strongly as Seon claimed once you re-examine the logic behind the actions in retrospect. So I think that Seon's vote is an excuse to get by the round because the reasoning behind it is flawed.
I hope that will suffice, do feel free to inquire more should you see fit.
Umm... I never said that it was through in-thread analysis?
What part of "and came up with nothing in particular" do you not understand?
I just voted for Diamondeye because he looks evil. If he isn't, he must be trying to backstab us all.
Google snarf, Diy.
Statisstically speaking, it's a good bet (I mean, I am the player who is mofia most often), but it's going to hurt. You'll want to keep some ice handy.Quote:
Originally Posted by Seon
Snarf. Vote:WHQuote:
Originally Posted by Winston Hughes
Another hard-to-deny argument:Quote:
Originally Posted by Seon
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
YLC: AUTO
Classical: Robbie
DIY: Winston
DE: Classical
Seon: DIY
WH: DE
SUDDEN DEATH.
WHEN A PLAYER REACHES 2 VOTES, THEY ARE LYNCHED.
But Monsieur pizzagod, I did vote: DE
Did you? I just woke up, and my eyes are extremely tired.Quote:
Originally Posted by Seon
:shame:
Oh well, DE is lynched then. Writeup commencing
Mayor of Imaginationland: "What? Me? Why, I'm not guilty at all! I'm the Mayor."
Darth Vader: "Do you have any proof that you're not guilty?"
Mayor of Imaginationland: "Why sure! All you have to do is listen to my song, and you'll know!"
<object style="height: 390px; width: 640px"><param name="movie" value="https://www.youtube.com/v/eW4tY8mQ_1o?version=3"><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"><param name="allowScriptAccess" value="always"><embed src="https://www.youtube.com/v/eW4tY8mQ_1o?version=3" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowfullscreen="true" allowScriptAccess="always" width="640" height="390"></object>
*Darth Vader ignites his red lightsaber and cuts off the Mayor's head*
Darth Vader: "I don't care if you're guilty or not, that song was starting to annoy me."
Alive: [11/17]
Sprig
Seon
God Emperor
classical_hero
Khazaar
Death is yonder
Winston Hughes
Robbiecon
woad&fangs
YLC
Autolycus
Dead: [6/17]
Johnhughthom- Popeye
Warman- Jesus
Joooray- Morpheus
Captain Blackadder- Al Gore
Secura- Wonder Woman
Diamondeye- Mayor of Imaginationland
24 hours to send in actions.
Good going, guys. Do we have a "cigar" smilie on here?
Also; Do you want me to try and contribute, or keep quiet since my innocence is not guaranteed?
http://www.twcenter.net/forums/image...bigboss5jj.gifQuote:
Originally Posted by Diamondeye
Here's one from TWCenter.
I wouldn't be too upset yet DE - please continue with your analysis, I am sure at some point in time it'll bear fruit.
And sorry for not getting back in time, my sleep schedule is screwed right now so I'm awake from about 1500-0400.
I'm not upset, actually. I just want to know whether I can skip the commitment if noone'll be listening anyway.Quote:
Originally Posted by YLC
I'll be listening intently - isn't that enough?Quote:
Originally Posted by Diamondeye
Well, I'll be reading it, but I don't know if that's going to be much consolation as I'm dead as well so it would only function as something for me to read and think about rather than something that might influence voting or whatnot.Quote:
Originally Posted by Diamondeye
This game deserves more activity than it's getting; I hate dying and seeing this happen to games. >.<
When I looked at that post of yours, this seemed to be the phrasing:Quote:
Originally Posted by Seon
Rather than the whole paragraph.Quote:
compared many of the players to characters from Edgar Allen Poe Novel, and came up with nothing in particular
Apologies then :bow:
If everyone who was dead just kept totally silent, and especially so in a small game, it would be pretty darn silent, and less fun too :/Quote:
I just want to know whether I can skip the commitment if noone'll be listening anyway.
It's Sprig and Winston. Prove me wrong, nightkillers.
Snarf :sweatdrop:Quote:
Originally Posted by Diamondeye
The good creatures of Imaginationland were fast asleep.
The old man woke to the sound of scratching at his door.
Gandalf: What in the world could be so important? Don't you realize what time this is?
Unknown: We're starting the meeting early today! Something terrible has happened mister! You're going to be late for the meeting!
Gandalf: A wizard his never late. He is never early. He arrives precisely when he means to.
*Gandalf opens his door*
Unknown: "Gee mister, are you sure you're never..... late?"
With red eyes glowing, the furry creature shot lasers from its eyes, and Gandalf's head exploded.
Glinda woke to the sound of someone crying. Being a good witch, she felt it was her duty to find out what was wrong. She hurried to the door and went out into the cobblestone streets, looking for the distressed creature.
Unknown: "Boo hoo...... boo hoo....."
Glinda: "Hello? What seems to be the trouble, little one?"
Unknown: "One of the good imaginary characters.... she... she.... died!"
Glinda: "Oh no! What happened?"
Unknown: "Someone dropped a house on her. It was terrible. All I could do is stand there and watch it happen."
Glinda: "Wait, this sounds familiar."
Unknown: "The worst part about all of it was.... I never got to tear out her eyeball and give her AIDS like I was supposed to! I wanted her to die real slow like...."
The furry thing swiped at a nearby rope, and a small house suspended above Glinda's head came crashing down on her.
Just before dawn, a smallish figure approached the body of the fallen Jesus, and examined his wounds. Concentrating very hard, a light soon came over the body of Jesus, and he rose from the dead.
Alive: [10/17]
Sprig
Seon
classical_hero
Khazaar
Death is yonder
Winston Hughes
Robbiecon
woad&fangs
YLC
Warman
Dead: [7/17]
Johnhughthom- Popeye
Joooray- Morpheus
Captain Blackadder- Al Gore
Secura- Wonder Woman
Diamondeye- Mayor of Imaginationland
God Emperor- Gandalf
Autolycus- Glinda, the Good Witch
24 hours to post and vote.
Jesus Christ!
vote: Death is yonder
Snarf
vote: Death is yonder
Be cool, Be cool.
While classical_hero was the person who instigated yesterdays lynch of Diamondeye, and said it was the lynch he had wanted the previous day, I'm gonna
Vote : Seon , something doesn't seem right with him, and he put the nail in Diamondeye's coffin.
:laugh4: That's Seon for you.Quote:
Originally Posted by robbiecon
Snarf
Ah... I Snarf what you mean. That's off, even for Seon.
vote: Seon
Someone just made Jesus rise frm the dead? Epic!
Hey you killed me :(
I think not. If you remember, you will notice that I voted for Diamondeye BEFORE classical hero did. Pizza merely overlooked that vote.Quote:
Originally Posted by Winston Hughes
Therefore, it is not me, but classical hero who put the nail on Diamondeye's coffin. Therefore, Robbie's logic fails.
Vote: Warman
Hades is not very happy about this and I don't trust zombies. They have a habit of being converted mafia.
Kill woad. If the mafia can resurrect innocents as mafia, we're basically sunk already. I thought Secura was off with her persecution of him, but I've changed my mind.
Although Warman has said nothing about his resurrection other then a vote, I'd like to hear more before I even think of voting him. But a FoS: Woad for immediately throwing suspect on the newly living.
For now, I will follow DE's judgment about the mafia. Vote: Sprig we haven't heard anything at all from the man, and it's what Day 4? Why isn't he close to WoG yet?
I don't have a replacement player for him.Quote:
Originally Posted by YLC
I am quite busy right now, but I will vote:Seon
In that case, ignore Sprig. Classical and Winston, it is. :bow:
I could take his role if you like.Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
No.... I have been sleepy but never fear, At one with the force I am and i shall detect that baddies amoung you.Quote:
Originally Posted by Secura
vote: Winston Hughes
(Apologies Pizza!)
You jump in just in time to save yourself don't you Sprig?
Seon just clarified his forgotten vote. I don´t think that that makes him scummy, I´ll Vote: Sprig for the saved by the bell award.
After many rounds of IIRC nothing more than your sign up post you suddenly pop in the very round that attention is first turned to you?Quote:
Originally Posted by Sprig
Vote: Sprig
Btw Winston, you forgot to unvote me :bow:
And Warman, you've just been raised from the grave, care to elaborate more than just a single vote?
Save myself from what? I saw the thread iminginationland and i was like oh man wish i had been here earlier to sign up for this one. Imagine my shock when i click on the link and opening post to find myself in the list of players.
So I scoll through the thread expecting myself to be dead or wog'd already. It is coincidence that my turning up now coincided with people questioning why I haven't been wog'd.
Pizza made it clear i thought that i would have been wog'd if he had a replacement. He wouldn't have needed to consider it had I been active behind the scenes.
The reason for my vote on Winston at this stage is because I am active on one of the other forums to which some of you belong, yet nobody gave me a bump over there to ask why I was not active here. That gives me suspicion on all the cfc players here.
unvote; vote: sprig
OMGUSnarf
This is the last vote to be counted. Round ended after this post. Tallying now.Quote:
Originally Posted by Death is yonder
DIY: Winston, Warman
Seon: Robbie, Classical
Warman: Woad
Sprig: YLC, Khazaar, DIY
Winston: Sprig
Looks like Sprig is lynched.
Quote:
Originally Posted by YLC
I don't know what happen, some nice person revived me and I got a PM from ATPG about it :clown:.
Darth Vader: I sense something..... a presence I have not felt since....
Luke Skywalker: Yes, father. I have learned the ways of the Force and become a Jedi Knight.
Darth Vader: Good, you have controlled your fear. Now, allow me to complete your training...
*sound of lightsabers igniting*
Luke Skywalker and Darth Vader engage in the most epic lightsaber battle of all time. It is truly something magnificent to watch. Oh, you really have to see this. It's sooooo awesome. I wish I had a camcorder.
WOW!!! Did you see that?
I can't even describe it, it's just so.... I mean WOW! How did he do that? How was it even POSSIBLE???
Oh, look out! look out! He's got a..... oh good, he missed.
Get him! Get him!!!
Man this is so amazing. I think I just wet my pants, and I don't even care. YOU REALLY GOTTA SEE THIS!!!
Ouch, that's gotta hurt.
No, not over the boiling river of lava! Not over the river of lava!
YOWZA!!!
That's gonna hurt come winter!
It's not over, it's not over, Luke Skywalker is coming back, he's got Vader on the ropes, pummeling him! It looks like Vader is down! No wait, what's this?
OH HOW HORRIBLE!
I CANNOT BELIEVE THAT JUST HAPPENED!!
Wow. They won't be showing THAT again on television, that's for darn sure.
If you're just tuning in, what you've just seen..... can never be un-seen.
It was the most breathtaking, heartfelt, action-packed, and devastating event ever to be witnessed.... by humans.
I think it goes without saying, this was the most awesome write-up of all time. I really wish you could have seen it.
Alive: [9/17]
Seon
classical_hero
Khazaar
Death is yonder
Winston Hughes
Robbiecon
woad&fangs
YLC
Warman
Dead: [8/17]
Johnhughthom- Popeye
Joooray- Morpheus
Captain Blackadder- Al Gore
Secura- Wonder Woman
Diamondeye- Mayor of Imaginationland
God Emperor- Gandalf
Autolycus- Glinda, the Good Witch
Sprig- Luke Skywalker
24 hours to send in actions.
Ehem...:rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Strawberry Shortcake was sleeping when she heard the sound of pots and pans banging and clattering in the kitchen.
She rolled out of bed and went to see what was going on.
Strawberry Shortcake: "What's going on here?"
Unknown: "I got a little hungry.... I needed a midnight snack!"
Strawberry Shortcake: "EEEEK!!!"
The Lollipop King was sleeping as well, when he heard a knock at the door. He tried to roll out of bed, but his head was stuck to the pillow and blanket. He ended up in a tangled mess on the floor. Sometimes he hated being a lollipop.
Lollipop King: "Come on in, the door is unlocked."
Unknown: "Gee mister, it looks like you're in a sticky situation!"
Lollipop King: "Har har har. Could you help me up, please!"
Unknown: "Sure thing mister. I just have one question.... how many licks does it take to get to the center of a Lollipop King?"
Lollipop King: "What? No.... no.... get away! Get away! AAAAAAAAAUUUUGGGHHHHH!!!! It's licking me! It's licking me! It's licking me and it HURTS!!! AAAAAAAUUUUGGGHHH!!!!"
Just before dawn, a hooded figure approached the body of the fallen Gandalf, and concentrated. In a flash, Gandalf was restored to his former glory, and he thanked his savior.
Alive: [8/17]
classical_hero
Khazaar
Death is yonder
Winston Hughes
woad&fangs
YLC
Warman
God Emperor
Dead: [9/17]
Johnhughthom- Popeye
Joooray- Morpheus
Captain Blackadder- Al Gore
Secura- Wonder Woman
Diamondeye- Mayor of Imaginationland
Autolycus- Glinda, the Good Witch
Sprig- Luke Skywalker
Robbiecon- Strawberry Shortcake
Seon- Lollipop King
24 hours to post and vote.
Winston and Classical, Winston and Classical.
Also, our reviver has good taste; first Jesus and then Gandalf? Epic.
What kind of townie ghost names two suspects, despite there being no chance of lynching both at the same time, thus telling the villains who not to kill? On one occasion, I think you even did it at night, didn't you?Quote:
Originally Posted by Diamondeye
vote: Death is yonder
Snarf
vote: Death is Yonder
My vote last round on warman was an attempt to find the mafia. The necromancer is obviously Butters in disguise and the revived are obviously innocent. Only a mafioso or someone who did not watch the epic imagination land episodes would think otherwise. While no one voted for Warman, DiY wanted warman to elaborate on his resurrection. In my mind, this makes him a highly unlikely candidate to be Butters. Seeing as I am innocent(trust me), Warman is innocent, GE is innocent, and the unknown Butters is innocent, we have a 50/50 chance of lynching a mafioso if we lynch DiY.
:thunder and lighting and whatnots:
Robbiecon's Lollipop King? NO! That's... that's IMPOSSIBLE!!!!
Hey I am back ! :) time to review the thread :bow:
Vote: DIY
But FoS:W&F and Winston
You're Snarf from thundercats, and no one likes Snarf, and Snarf knows this, so logically, you're a mafioso.
Unvote:, Vote: Winston
I see W&F and Winston immediately gang up on DIY, Winston going first before the case is even put forward. Odd, and thus deserving of a vote.
That's what I was thinking.Quote:
Originally Posted by Seon
Did I miss an inside joke somewhere?
OH DERP.
:laugh4:
Okay, I get it. I switched them by mistake. Fixing...
Great big globs of cheesy pizza's sleepy brains
Can't remember people's names
Gets em backwards its insane
And such mistakes are really really really lame
And me without much shame.
Ha, ATPG's limerick for the win.
Anyway, me thinks perhaps classical_hero might be who you're looking for.
Why? Why not W&F for his flip flop? Why not Winston who is also implicated along with classical?Quote:
Originally Posted by robbiecon
I'm not exactly in a country where watching all these shows like South park are common place (South East Asia just to be more specific), if you didn't notice throughout the thread, which I will now quote because I admit that these sort of games (South park, Futarama etc) aren't exactly things I watch and hence, I ask other players to elaborate if this is something born out of show lore. [I don't even watch much simpsons]Quote:
Originally Posted by woad&fangs
In addition, the townie role pm doesn't exactly provides contextual lore relevant to my character or anything, and my school has just begun again and is piling on work fast, I don't exactly have oodles of free time to read through articles on role play and lore]
RE: Underlined And Bolded Sections [Quote]Quote:
Originally Posted by Death is yonder
1. So basically you make an assumption that every player playing knows about the game universe (South park) [you expect it to be common knowledge], before using this "axiom" to create your argument.
2. Warman was revived unexpectedly by an unknown entity (in my perspective) [And since he was the first to be resurrected, for all I knew it could be a one shot anti-town ability {GE's resurrection changes this view}], and he did not say anything about his resurrection, would it not be expected in this drought of information to question further so that, if he was scum, there would be more possibility for analysis (in that off chance), or conversely to judge whether he is likelier to be innocent.
3. Then you tell us to "trust you" in a game where there is nothing to link you to innocence, then you wave a statistic about that doesn't make any sense that if I am lynched, there is a 50/50 chance that the town catches a mafia. So let me ask you this W&F, if by your logic lynching me results in a 50/50 chance of catching a mafia, who is your other suspect and why have you ignored him? If you have a pretty good reason for lynching me, and the chances are even, then it follows that you have a good reason for the other suspect to, for us to be comparable.
-----------------------
However, I will cautiously note that Winston has voted me for three rounds straight with no reason other than "Snarf" and stuff.
I followed earlier advice, and googled Snarf and checked the wiki and this is what I found:
From this extract, Winston shouldn't be neglecting to elaborate, only that he adds on to what he's saying with "Snarf".Quote:
Snarves are known to end their sentences with the squeaking exclamation for which they are named - "snarf, snarf!"
For three rounds straight (or four?) this has continued, Winston saying nothing substantial despite seemingly not being required to only say Snarf (only just put a snarf at the end of his sentences).
This just reinforces my earlier suspicion that:
For now W&F should answer for himself.Quote:
it could be just a tactic to get by the game while saying little
Vote: Winston Hughes
However I will admit with the latest write up that it is extremely likely that the revived individuals are innocent, as being able to resurrect dead townies as scums (two of them so far, on successive nights too) in a small game is way too excessive and imbalanced should they be revived as anti-town so I think its too improbable.
Quick note: From this post onward to the end of the phase (and 13 more hours after that) questions asked of me will not be answered (by virtue of timezone and daylight obligations).
As such, any queries directed towards me should be posted with intent of a non-immediate response.
:bow:
As he himself points out, I've been voting for Diy for several days.Quote:
Originally Posted by YLC
I mentioned long ago that I could say more than just Snarf:Quote:
Originally Posted by Death is yonder
Why is it only now that you find it worthy of a vote, when somebody else has started to suspect you? Is it perhaps that you were saving the vote on me for just such an occasion?Quote:
Originally Posted by Winston Hughes
Snarf
unvote:DiY; vote: abstain
Your defense is convincing. Unfortunately, that leaves me without suspects. Butters is a real boy in Imaginationland. He can bring characters back to life by imagining them.
:rides back into thread on a cloud:
Khazaar has not posted in nearly a week which makes him unlikely to be mafia in my eyes. This leaves Winston, Classical_hero, and YLC left on my list of suspects for today.
inny..minny....vote: classical_hero
unvote; vote: woad&fangs
Snarf
Triple post ftw!
unvote: classical_hero; Vote: DiY
After reading your response again, all I am convinced of is that you are not Butters. For me, the odds are good enough.
Unvote: Vote: W&F
You sir are far too interested in finding Butters.