South Park: Imaginationland [Concluded]

[robbiecon]

Ha, ATPG's limerick for the win.

Anyway, me thinks perhaps classical_hero might be who you're looking for.

[ULC]

Ha, ATPG's limerick for the win.

Anyway, me thinks perhaps classical_hero might be who you're looking for.

Why? Why not W&F for his flip flop? Why not Winston who is also implicated along with classical?

[Death is yonder]

vote: Death is Yonder
My vote last round on warman was an attempt to find the mafia. The nuecromancer is obviously Butters in disgise and the revived are obviously innocent. Only a mafioso or someone who did not watch the epic imagination land episodes would think otherwise. While no one voted for Warman, DiY wanted warman to elaborate on his resurrection. In my mind, this makes him a highly unlikely candidate to be Butters. Seeing as I am innocent(trust me), Warman is innocent, GE is innocent, and the unknown Butters is innocent, we have a 50/50 chance of lynching a mafioso if we lynch DiY.

:thunder and lighting and whatnots:

I'm not exactly in a country where watching all these shows like South park are common place (South East Asia just to be more specific), if you didn't notice throughout the thread, which I will now quote because I admit that these sort of games (South park, Futarama etc) aren't exactly things I watch and hence, I ask other players to elaborate if this is something born out of show lore. [I don't even watch much simpsons]

In addition, the townie role pm doesn't exactly provides contextual lore relevant to my character or anything, and my school has just begun again and is piling on work fast, I don't exactly have oodles of free time to read through articles on role play and lore]

Winston, are you only able to say "Snarf" and vote? Could anyone with greater knowledge on the Southpark universe elaborate on whether its possibly an IC compulsion, or whether it could be just a tactic to get by the game while saying little?

RE: Underlined And Bolded Sections [Quote]

1. So basically you make an assumption that every player playing knows about the game universe (South park) [you expect it to be common knowledge], before using this "axiom" to create your argument.

2. Warman was revived unexpectedly by an unknown entity (in my perspective) [And since he was the first to be resurrected, for all I knew it could be a one shot anti-town ability {GE's resurrection changes this view}], and he did not say anything about his resurrection, would it not be expected in this drought of information to question further so that, if he was scum, there would be more possibility for analysis (in that off chance), or conversely to judge whether he is likelier to be innocent.

3. Then you tell us to "trust you" in a game where there is nothing to link you to innocence, then you wave a statistic about that doesn't make any sense that if I am lynched, there is a 50/50 chance that the town catches a mafia. So let me ask you this W&F, if by your logic lynching me results in a 50/50 chance of catching a mafia, who is your other suspect and why have you ignored him? If you have a pretty good reason for lynching me, and the chances are even, then it follows that you have a good reason for the other suspect to, for us to be comparable.

-----------------------

However, I will cautiously note that Winston has voted me for three rounds straight with no reason other than "Snarf" and stuff.

I followed earlier advice, and googled Snarf and checked the wiki and this is what I found:

Snarves are known to end their sentences with the squeaking exclamation for which they are named - "snarf, snarf!"

From this extract, Winston shouldn't be neglecting to elaborate, only that he adds on to what he's saying with "Snarf".

For three rounds straight (or four?) this has continued, Winston saying nothing substantial despite seemingly not being required to only say Snarf (only just put a snarf at the end of his sentences).

This just reinforces my earlier suspicion that:

it could be just a tactic to get by the game while saying little

For now W&F should answer for himself.

Vote: Winston Hughes

However I will admit with the latest write up that it is extremely likely that the revived individuals are innocent, as being able to resurrect dead townies as scums (two of them so far, on successive nights too) in a small game is way too excessive and imbalanced should they be revived as anti-town so I think its too improbable.

[Death is yonder]

Quick note: From this post onward to the end of the phase (and 13 more hours after that) questions asked of me will not be answered (by virtue of timezone and daylight obligations).

As such, any queries directed towards me should be posted with intent of a non-immediate response.

[Winston Hughes]

I see W&F and Winston immediately gang up on DIY, Winston going first before the case is even put forward. Odd, and thus deserving of a vote.

As he himself points out, I've been voting for Diy for several days.

From this extract, Winston shouldn't be neglecting to elaborate, only that he adds on to what he's saying with "Snarf".

I mentioned long ago that I could say more than just Snarf:

No, I can Snarf normally. Just so long as I remember to Snarf Snarf.

Otherwise I'll Snarf.

Why is it only now that you find it worthy of a vote, when somebody else has started to suspect you? Is it perhaps that you were saving the vote on me for just such an occasion?

Snarf

[woad&fangs]

unvote:DiY; vote: abstain
Your defense is convincing. Unfortunately, that leaves me without suspects. Butters is a real boy in Imaginationland. He can bring characters back to life by imagining them.

[woad&fangs]

:rides back into thread on a cloud:
Khazaar has not posted in nearly a week which makes him unlikely to be mafia in my eyes. This leaves Winston, Classical_hero, and YLC left on my list of suspects for today.
inny..minny....vote: classical_hero

[Winston Hughes]

unvote; vote: woad&fangs

Snarf

[woad&fangs]

Triple post ftw!
unvote: classical_hero; Vote: DiY
After reading your response again, all I am convinced of is that you are not Butters. For me, the odds are good enough.

[ULC]

Unvote: Vote: W&F

You sir are far too interested in finding Butters.

[Askthepizzaguy]

overslept gotta go to work; round is over. Writeup will be delayed until I get home.


DIY: Woad
Winston: DIY
Woad: Winston, YLC

[Askthepizzaguy]

Darth Vader: "Who is this person you claim is guilty?"

Zeus: "I'm the God of Thunder! I can shoot lightning from my fingers!"

Darth Vader: "Good... the dark side must be strong with you. Any last words?"

Zeus: "Uh.... I'm not a witch?"

*vwoooom*

Zeus' head landed on the cobblestone path with a sickening thud.


Darth Vader: "Sometimes sacrifices have to be made for the greater good."

woad&fangs - Zeus

Alive: [7/17]


classical_hero
Khazaar
Death is yonder
Winston Hughes
YLC
Warman
God Emperor


Dead: [10/17]

Johnhughthom- Popeye
Joooray- Morpheus
Captain Blackadder- Al Gore
Secura- Wonder Woman
Diamondeye- Mayor of Imaginationland
Autolycus- Glinda, the Good Witch
Sprig- Luke Skywalker
Robbiecon- Strawberry Shortcake
Seon- Lollipop King
woad&fangs- Zeus


Orders please.

[Diamondeye]

So guys, how's lynching Winston and Classical going?

[God Emperor]

Do you have a reason at all for wishing those two dead?

[Diamondeye]

Do you have a reason at all for wishing those two dead?

None except the hunch that they're guilty.

[Death is yonder]

As he himself points out, I've been voting for Diy for several days.

True that, but you've been evading the point about why you've been doing so without any reasoning whatsoever than "Snarf", literally.

I mentioned long ago that I could say more than just Snarf:

My post was a statement of how you seemed to censor/replace words with Snarf despite upon looking up the character profile so to speak, the "role obligations" seemingly only requiring you to add on rather than replace your words. Hence I felt it unlikely that it was role compulsion that resulted in your lack of substantial information/thoughts.

Why is it only now that you find it worthy of a vote, when somebody else has started to suspect you? Is it perhaps that you were saving the vote on me for just such an occasion?

As I had said, my suspicion was only reinforced to an extent where it became vote worthy after your behavior was repeated THRICE.

Snarf

Comments in bold.

On a different note, this post is fully what I was expecting from Winston the moment I read the "Snarves" profile on wikipedia, where he should post normally with the exception of adding the word "snarf" at the back, not replacing information or having posts of not much substance.

Which is precisely why I am suspecting him as he has cruised by almost the whole game with this behavior.

[classical_hero]

So guys, how's lynching Winston and Classical going?

What did I ever do to you?

[Winston Hughes]

Snarf

True that, but you've been evading the point about why you've been doing so without any reasoning whatsoever than "Snarf", literally.

In the first place, I did it to stick my tongue out at pizza for giving me the most annoying role I've ever seen. As I continued to get away with it, I felt obliged to continue for reasons of comedy.

Which is precisely why I am suspecting him as he has cruised by almost the whole game with this behavior.

I never expected to get as far as I did just saying Snarf. From a town perspective, I should have been properly challenged on it much earlier. But it's not unusual here at the org for players who say little to survive largely unchallenged. I won't claim I was trying to make that point by saying only Snarf (as that was mere silliness), but it's clear enough that that's how things have worked out in this game.

[woad&fangs]

At least you didn't lynch Butters.

[robbiecon]

Snarf

[Winston Hughes]

Snarf

That really should have been my response to post 153.

Snarf

[Askthepizzaguy]

In the morning, the remaining Imaginary creatures looked and they saw the lifeless bodies of Jesus and Gandalf, broken and twisted, piled together in a big mess in the middle of the courtyard. They were bleeding from every orifice, and their intestines had been ripped out and used for some diabolical purpose, then shoved down their throats.

Warman - Jesus





God Emperor - Gandalf

Alive: [5/17]


classical_hero
Khazaar
Death is yonder
Winston Hughes
YLC


Dead: [12/17]

Johnhughthom- Popeye
Joooray- Morpheus
Captain Blackadder- Al Gore
Secura- Wonder Woman
Diamondeye- Mayor of Imaginationland
Autolycus- Glinda, the Good Witch
Sprig- Luke Skywalker
Robbiecon- Strawberry Shortcake
Seon- Lollipop King
woad&fangs- Zeus
Warman- Jesus
God Emperor- Gandalf

[classical_hero]

Clearly it is vote: Death is yonder that is mafia. I think we should lynch him.

[Diamondeye]

guys, you really need to lynch Winston or Classical today. Last shot, guys...

[robbiecon]

I must say it was a great choice of night kill, that way there are no confirmed innocents going into the last 5, and everyone is a possible lynch.

[Khazaar]

I´ll Vote: WINston just because I thought that "noise" was about the Jersey Shore episode. That freaky monster... No offense

[classical_hero]

I think I have had a change of heart. I will now instead unvote, vote:Winston Hughes

[Diamondeye]

I think I have had a change of heart. I will now instead unvote, vote:Winston Hughes

Watch if he [Classical] flinches when it boils down to brass tacks.

[Death is yonder]

Clearly it is vote: Death is yonder that is mafia. I think we should lynch him.

Unsubstantiated posts just like Winston throughout the game. Just finished packing and its late and I got a trip early in the morning so I'll just pop in and say that I'll echo Diamondeye in that I think that Winston and classical are the remaining two. One of the mafia probably got lynched already if not the game would be over at this point and pizza is just poking fun at us, either W&F or Joooray.

Vote: Winston Hughes

I´ll Vote: WINston just because I thought that "noise" was about the Jersey Shore episode. That freaky monster... No offense

Khazaar, this is like the end game stage. You've been gone for most of the game, have you been paying attention?
----------------------
General thoughts on: Players Alive

Khazaar -- Inactive/Lurking most of the game, I have no idea what his recent explanation for his latest vote is, but while unsure whether he hasn't been paying attention or just plain lurking, since I suspect Winston to be a mafia, I don't think he would bus his partner in the critical round, much less last minute switch his vote, which would bring unwanted attention.[If classical wasn't mafia]

Winston -- His behavior so far has been unhelpful despite a usual track record of at least chiming in with insightful thoughts. In conjunction with my view of his actions so far leads me to believe that he is one of the scumbags left

YLC -- Has been gone for quite a few rounds now. While he stated earlier in response to Secura that he was busy with Chaotix's game, he is dead as of quite a while, and hence this shouldn't be the case. He said he would be back after some sleep but hasn't popped in since. I don't think he's the likeliest suspect. YLC as mafia wouldn't just lurk to victory, he'll relish his mind games and seek to mess around with the town's heads and outsmart the town to victory.

classical -- Just a gut feeling. He so far hasn't done really anything controversial just mostly stayed out of the spotlight as if intentionally being the proper townie. And his latest vote just stinks of desperate because he obviously can't leave his vote lying on his likely scumbuddy Winston, and as such tries to discredit and vote for the person leading the chase on Winston

IMO I would concur largely with Diamondeye's view that its classical and Winston, but I'm more inclined to go with Winston first, as my suspicion on classical largely depends on him being Winston's buddy and as such having no choice but to try to lynch me this round.

Anyway, consider this my last proper post, or second last if you will, because after this I'll be overseas and any posts will be a vote post from a borrowed smart phone for the next phase if I'm still alive and not night killed.

(Just about to post, then previewed and noticed classical's vote switch). Interesting, are you going to switch at the end of the phase? Just something to put scrutiny on.

[Diamondeye]

Death Is Yonder: Wisdom! But be advised; posting from a phone is a 100% scumtell so far in Gameroom history