Printable View
Damn it... keep forgetting him from my list...
Da list:
Still alive:
shlin28 - Me :yes:
Glenn - No posts on the org for 3 days
GeneralHankerchief
pevergreen - Captain
Rythmic - lurking...
Sarathos - semi-lurking...
woad&fangs - Captain
Tratorix - inactive... says GH
Mithrandir
That leaves:
shlin28
GH
Rythmic
Sarathos
Mithrandir
Edit: I do not think Mithrandir is the best choice for lynch, if there is only one killer left, I think Sarathos would be a better choice.
vote: Sarathos random.org said so.
No clue on who to lynch actually.
Vote: Sarathos
He needs to be lynched.
Vote: Sarathos
because the voices told me to :candle:
Its Mithrandir teh best choice.
I don't think so.
Vote: shlin28
Based on a hunch, but that list came out of nowhere.
So, you ignore the clownish Mithrandir to focus on shlin28 based on... "a hunch"?Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
Maybe GeneralHankerchief should be the lynch of today...
I strongly agree that shlin should be the lynch for today.
Came out of nowhere? That list was made from the alive list 2 days ago, got changed a lot, all of its progressions can be seen in the thread and it "came out of nowhere"? So I can't even make list of people now... :inquisitive:Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
Vote: GH
Yep.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
I would go for pever and woad for blatant bandwagoning but that would be a waste. My order right now is shlin > Rythmic > Sarathos > Mithrandir.
(edited to remove a redundancy)
So the reason to vote shlin28 is "a hunch".Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
Why Rythmic and Sarathos? And why are they more suspicious then Mithrandir?
Also hunches? Are you from Paris perhaps?
I'm not sure pever and W&F stories add up either. Strikes me they aren't really townies until they lynch the other one--until then I bet they'd be willing to ally with the mafia.
Surely that point emphasis had nothing to do with your lawyer background. :laugh4:Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
Also, I think Mithrandir is innocent. You can cry "WIFOM" all night until the cows come home, but I just can't see a mafioso acting like that.
Yes, and let's ignore your "cases" against Rythmic and Sarathos...Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
Care to explain to us why they are so high on your suspects list?
(Does somebody have an "alive" list?)
They're not. It's process of elimination.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
The alive list is as follows:
shlin28
Glenn
GeneralHankerchief
pevergreen
Rythmic
Sarathos
woad&fangs
Tratorix
Mithrandir
Cross Glenn and Tratorix off because they're inactive. Cross pever and woad off because they're Captains*.
This leaves:
shlin28
GeneralHankerchief
Rythmic
Sarathos
Mithrandir
Now, I'm off the list because I'm a townie. I know there's no way of proving it to you until the game's over, but for purposes of discussion we'll continue down this path. That leaves us with four. I think Mithrandir's innocent and I think shlin's guilty. That's how I ended up with Rythmic and Sarathos in 2nd and 3rd places.
*There is a chance that pever and woad could be lying, especially after the last couple of rounds where they haven't voted each other. Now, this may be possibly in hopes that someone will kill their counterpart off. Of course, there's always the chance that they could have claimed so we'd back off their trail, but this is highly unlikely and if it is the truth, then they've pulled off a brilliant deception and deserve to win the game.
Funny, when shlin28 does that (less eloquently then you, I'll grant you that), you talk about a list coming out of nowhere :inquisitive:
Anyway, instead of just working down your list of 4 suspects, don't you think it's better to keep discussion going and to force everybody to talk?
Saying "here's the list, let's lynch in that order" kinda kills discussion, doesn't it?
So, what do you think of Rythmic and Sarathos, regardless of the process of elimination? And I don't quite agree with your assumption of Mith's innocence because of his weird behaviour.
Because as far as I can recall, it's uncharacteristic of him. If someone can find me evidence to the contrary (when he was innocent, preferably in a smaller game like this one) then I shall move my vote elsewhere.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
I just gave people something to discuss with my last post. They can agree with it; disagree with it; say someone should be farther up/farther down, etc. Whether they do anything with this prodding is up to them.Quote:
Anyway, instead of just working down your list of 4 suspects, don't you think it's better to keep discussion going and to force everybody to talk?
Saying "here's the list, let's lynch in that order" kinda kills discussion, doesn't it?
I think they're a bit too quiet, but otherwise fine. Sarathos seemed like he wasn't paying attention when he briefly came alive last round; there were three kills that round so I doubt it's him. Rythmic would be more likely to be scum.Quote:
So, what do you think of Rythmic and Sarathos, regardless of the process of elimination? And I don't quite agree with your assumption of Mith's innocence because of his weird behaviour.
When did you first post (in a post that hasn't been edited after this game started :grin:) a list and based your vote on the process of elimination?
I probably haven't.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
But then again, I'm usually not alive at this point in the game either, and if I am there's somebody else directing things. I'm more of a "support townie" ; taking charge of things when I'm scum is more my forte.
-edit- And I'm taking the lead now because nobody else is and this game deserves better.
I think if we're at a loss (doesn't seem to be real evidince on shlin or sarathos) we ought to vote out W&F, since he and pever are acting anti town atm.
And I do vote based on gut feelings a lot.
Mithrandir and Shlin. I'm pretty confident that at least one of them is mafia. Mithrandirs behaviour seems consistent with his style in other games, but it is a style that can be used as a facade to hide bad intentions.
Shlin does seem more "listy" then usual. "listing" is another style which is easy to hide behind.
I think you made a typo. Surely instead of "Shlin" you meant Sarathos, seeing as you're voting for him...Quote:
Originally Posted by woad&fangs
Is GH listy or is he more hunchy?Quote:
Originally Posted by woad&fangs
And what about Sarathos? Is he voicy?
u guys r dorky. :laugh:
If anyone doesnt believe that I'm the captain, I can post the pm log between me and the host asking if i can get the name of the other captain.
Sarathos is the best lynch for today.
Now back to my schoolwork :no:
They may be anti-town, but they're live bodies that the scum need to kill in order to win.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro
So... who is the BAd and who the Ugly? Sasaki the Bad, GH the Ugly? or viceversa?
I am voicy, now that I have time to pay proper attention to this game.
Many things have happened since I last posted and I do apologise for my absence. I put the .Org on high priority but my education does rank a little higher, I have to study so I may continue to participate on the .Org.
A few things I must get straight:
1.Quote:
Originally Posted by peverpink
My only question, why? There is really no reason for me to be lynched apart from the fact that I am semi-lurker but it is explainable and rather unavoidable. You however, have made no attempt at giving a reason and claim to be doing school work yourself, perhaps you need to be lynched?Quote:
Originally Posted by peverpink
Also, you automatically assume you are safe because you have claimed you are the Union Captain. I am starting to doubt that because you said to prove it you will post a pm log. Now normally that would be fine, but you are asking for the other Captain's names which completely defeats the purpose of the game as your victory condition is to get him killed. You are a seasoned mafia player so why on earth would you even ask that...?
Vote:Peverpink
2.Now I consider myself a very junior mafia player in comparison to many other players here but that has to be the biggest bandwagon I have ever seen. You voted me beause Mithrandir and Pever voted me. Fair enough that Mithrandir used Random.org but Pever is just being himself and hasn't even given a reason for voting me yet you seemed to be fully convinced. No one has 'told' you to do anything yet you still vote, when the two other voters have next to no reason, which is very scummy. You bandwagon which is extra scummy and to ice things off, you are the third on that very bandwagon, that = you x scummy^2.Quote:
Originally Posted by Woads&Fangs
Just a question to Myrddraal, is there going to be WOGing in this game or not?
Originally neither myself or W&F were given each others names.
Think about it, how am I meant to make the town lynch the opposite captain, if I dont know who that is?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Myrddraal
There you go.