So who needs to die next?
Printable View
I feel we should take a closer look at the people who were on Dolby's wagon. There is a good chance there might have been a wolf on the wagon.
I have no idea what about half the game thinks and no take on them
I question how solid of a read I actually have on hk. Dolby's probably pretty close to locktown for me. Lewwyn is also solidly town for me
still think hk looks good though, just seems weird re:Tims
I liked Winston for the post everyone hated.
Hi Csar
Any susses? What are your hottest takes rn?
How have your reads majorly changed since Tims died, or are all of me/Lewwyn/HK reads because of that?
It's kinda hard, since quite a few people don't have much. think pzelda could be a woof, sort of feels meh as well tbh. there's just a lot of people on the threshold like GG/Nanook basically quite a few.
I don't think tims changes much, makes me slightly more sus of hk, and reinforces my read on you.
My closest thing to a hot take is Winston I guess, but that doesn't really feel like a hot take to me, just kinda :mad:
Since I wasn't here for Twilight:
I wanted to vote Rask, but I didn't like Csargo on Rask's wagon, so that put me off voting there.
I voted Dolby because of that post I quoted yesterday, where Dolby said "My issue with Rask is..." and then rattled off some issues. It felt very out of the blue, like "Ahh, Rask is getting some heat, I better prepare a valid reason for suspecting him in case I need to vote him"
And even though I was SRing Rask at the time, I SR'd Dolby more for that.
So,
Vote: Dolby
I'll do a proper re-read when I get to work, I only skimmed a few posts between my last post and EOD.
The flavour leaves little room for doubt that the Tim kill was an SK.
There's also stuff in there about the remaining bionics and their weapons that might prove relevant in future.
Not to mention that it's a great read just for its own sake. :bow:
why was I the only one who used twilight lol
Probably also worth reminding everyone that this game was advertised as 'slightly bastard' and that Monty is a cunning devil.
I think that El's reasoning for me is kinda bleh, since it ignores the issues that I had with Rask's posts, which I assume that also had, but I'm going to hold off on him until he rereads
As mentioned yesterday, I picked up a hint of possible scum theatre from Tim vs. Lewwyn.
I have to head off to work now (wouldn't have posted at all if it wasn't for everyone missing the alien werewolf slavering in the corner), but that's certainly something I'll be looking more closely at this evening.
Oh, and in case this game has a lie detector role:
I am town ;)
I think that Winston's strech of activity 3 hours before EoD is overall towny
I don't know who Vro is but he's probably not W with Tim here.
Winston also never W with Tim, these interactions are not theatre.
Is there any way to bookmark posts here?
The scum "gotta have a reason prepped for voting someone" is pretty classic sure but Dolby has been commenting on everyone, and in that particular post he gave short reads on a lot of different people. I don't particularly agree with his point but in the end... Dolby was commenting on how Rask was lacking substance, but specifically calling out Rask for clearing Tim, which at this point looks like a bad call by Rask. Unless you think Dolby attacking a townie that was TRing Tim was part of the wolfing strat. I don't particularly see this as a set up on Rask, rather as a defined read.
This interaction between C4 and Panda:
Response:
Response:
I don't particularly agree with C4's eventual opinion on Panda being misguided. Panda's interaction feels a bit obfuscatory, also claiming "didn't you see the mistake I made? you must be scum" is like a bad gotcha moment. I don't think Panda moves on from this from the rest of the day. I would like to hear Panda's take on C4's innocence.
Lew white-knighting Dolby a LOT since pretty early D1 and continuing now. Might be worth looking into if Dolby flips V
I'm just gonna give Gnome a pass for today.
If I post the same joke again without skipping a word can we all just pretend it never happened
There we go, a funny and witty joke successfully made with zero hiccups or false steps
Before fully catching up, let me tell one thing. I think Tim flipping scum makes HK town for correctly calling out his meta. I think is important, because it was just meta and not HK going head on against Tim.
I need to reread d1, because I'm slightly confused by two totally different groups of reads happening right now.
I wonder if I should stick to rask/csargo w/v impression from page 1.
Gnome/Winston both feel like possible anti-towns. From their early interaction, I got a feeling that they might have a private chat together.
Dolby, HK, Lewwyn feels like towns, but I need to reread or pay more attention to new content from them to confirm this with evidence.
Borg Argon def town.
Ibn and Panda are under radar for me. Panda's posts felt like low impact "safe" posts. Ibn just posted without explaining a lot.
I don't remember a single post from Vroendal.
Nanook is sus, but I'm also currently influenced by Dolby's post.
El feels somehow lacking so far, but I'm sure he can pick it up, if town.
Doubtful, I'm juggling 3 jobs and haven't had a day off in 12 days.
It's kinda weird that you say I can pick it up "if town" - in my last game I was highest poster and was scum, so it's not like a massive splurge of energy and WIM from me would be AI in any way. I'm just doing what I can with the little time I have at a PC.
I think if anyone gave Tim an easy TR it was me tbh
Hey, guys, I apologise for my tardiness. Catching up and getting to know the forums.
Hm, I kind of think this duo hides at least one wolf. Nanook responding in that way to Tim's first post is something I need to further think about. It feels slightly artificial, especially with turning it into a tr.
Panda, I'm biased obv, but I dislike that they're dismissing stuff in their first post without creating anything of their own.
These three feel the thinnest and as possible fake reads of wolf buddies. Nanook and Panda might be pocket attempts, but there's no reason to tr town winston for his entrance.
The whole GG/Winston conversation feels fake. I can't get over some wording in Gnome's posts such as scum scum and her asking other player if they're town.