Rampage Out of Space

[NANOOK]

There we go, a funny and witty joke successfully made with zero hiccups or false steps

[hollowkatt]

still think hk looks good though, just seems weird re:Tims

why am I weird re;Tims?

[Garden Gnome]

Are you still happily clueless? You didn't vote in the last lynch.

No, I didn't. Kind of by accident. My Wednesday evenings are super busy, and EOD occurred when I wasn't able to post. I intend to vote today, and it does look like people are saying more than they did yesterday.

[El-ahrairah]

No, I didn't. Kind of by accident. My Wednesday evenings are super busy, and EOD occurred when I wasn't able to post. I intend to vote today, and it does look like people are saying more than they did yesterday.

I liked you better when you were a snake.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

[pzelda]

Before fully catching up, let me tell one thing. I think Tim flipping scum makes HK town for correctly calling out his meta. I think is important, because it was just meta and not HK going head on against Tim.

[pzelda]

Since I wasn't here for Twilight:

I wanted to vote Rask, but I didn't like Csargo on Rask's wagon, so that put me off voting there.

I voted Dolby because of that post I quoted yesterday, where Dolby said "My issue with Rask is..." and then rattled off some issues. It felt very out of the blue, like "Ahh, Rask is getting some heat, I better prepare a valid reason for suspecting him in case I need to vote him"

And even though I was SRing Rask at the time, I SR'd Dolby more for that.

So,

Vote: Dolby

I'll do a proper re-read when I get to work, I only skimmed a few posts between my last post and EOD.

I don't know what to think about this post. Dolbster looks like an easy townread for me this game. His posts feels like genuine solving and he's not super reliant on meta. All of his findings make sense. Sticking to this read feels weak from you.

[pzelda]

Probably also worth reminding everyone that this game was advertised as 'slightly bastard' and that Monty is a cunning devil.

Hottake, this guy ain't town. He's too interested in mechanics and the game being bastard.

[El-ahrairah]

I don't know what to think about this post. Dolbster looks like an easy townread for me this game. His posts feels like genuine solving and he's not super reliant on meta. All of his findings make sense. Sticking to this read feels weak from you.

And yet I'm not losing any sleep over it.

[pzelda]

HK maybe. Gnome is null, Csar is meh.

Interesting to see you don't have a Gnome read.

[pzelda]

I need to reread d1, because I'm slightly confused by two totally different groups of reads happening right now.
I wonder if I should stick to rask/csargo w/v impression from page 1.
Gnome/Winston both feel like possible anti-towns. From their early interaction, I got a feeling that they might have a private chat together.
Dolby, HK, Lewwyn feels like towns, but I need to reread or pay more attention to new content from them to confirm this with evidence.
Borg Argon def town.
Ibn and Panda are under radar for me. Panda's posts felt like low impact "safe" posts. Ibn just posted without explaining a lot.
I don't remember a single post from Vroendal.
Nanook is sus, but I'm also currently influenced by Dolby's post.
El feels somehow lacking so far, but I'm sure he can pick it up, if town.

[El-ahrairah]

El feels somehow lacking so far, but I'm sure he can pick it up, if town.

Doubtful, I'm juggling 3 jobs and haven't had a day off in 12 days.

It's kinda weird that you say I can pick it up "if town" - in my last game I was highest poster and was scum, so it's not like a massive splurge of energy and WIM from me would be AI in any way. I'm just doing what I can with the little time I have at a PC.

[Csargo]

why am I weird re;Tims?

lack of interactions, easy tr, I just remember thinking you were hands off early game with tims kinda like you didn't want to engage there.

skimming your iso, I think this might be wrong though, and I'm misremembering things.

[Csargo]

lack of interactions, easy tr, I just remember thinking you were hands off early game with tims kinda like you didn't want to engage there.

skimming your iso, I think this might be wrong though, and I'm misremembering things.

The easy tr part I might be misremembering.

[hollowkatt]

lack of interactions, easy tr, I just remember thinking you were hands off early game with tims kinda like you didn't want to engage there.

skimming your iso, I think this might be wrong though, and I'm misremembering things.

ok, so the exact opposite of what you thought then, got it :)

[Csargo]

ok, so the exact opposite of what you thought then, got it :)

[El-ahrairah]

I think if anyone gave Tim an easy TR it was me tbh

[Laurentus]

Hey, guys, I apologise for my tardiness. Catching up and getting to know the forums.

[pzelda]

Doubtful, I'm juggling 3 jobs and haven't had a day off in 12 days.

It's kinda weird that you say I can pick it up "if town" - in my last game I was highest poster and was scum, so it's not like a massive splurge of energy and WIM from me would be AI in any way. I'm just doing what I can with the little time I have at a PC.

I'm not really looking for amount of content, but for moments, which clearly sell you to me as town. I know that you're capable of posting a lot, but you should know that I'm trying to have a different base than pure meta too.

[hollowkatt]

I think if anyone gave Tim an easy TR it was me tbh

Do you still think he's town?

[pzelda]

We kill tim with fire, I hear you loud and clear

It seems quite abstract from pzelda , he starts reading wolf based on nothing. D1 reads seems quite out of place to me .

Hm, I kind of think this duo hides at least one wolf. Nanook responding in that way to Tim's first post is something I need to further think about. It feels slightly artificial, especially with turning it into a tr.
Panda, I'm biased obv, but I dislike that they're dismissing stuff in their first post without creating anything of their own.

So: early reads...these are obviously subject to development, but will be decisive. Nulls are for wimps.

Argon: in first, claims cop, claims ridiculous n0 check on me, uses avatar basically open referencing that he is a wolf...just another day in the life for him...if he is a wolf he has partners and at least some of those partners would be saying "WTF dude?" because they don't know him. No sign of that discomfort; Argon town.

Chessguy: lots of posts, creates image of "let's get started" by picking at gif posters but doesn't say anything really, overeager to be read on this; probs just a wolf.

Csargo: throwing them gif, but a LOT of them, then shifted to words and stayed overbusy for Csargo; probs a wolf.

Raskol: Emphasizing "disappointed by the rand" which is code for "I claim village," doesn't mention me until he finds a way to be agreeable instead of challenging immediately so trying to stay off radar; probs a wolf.

Dolby: meaningless paragoning of Argon, early read of Chessguy that I disagree with, challenged and stuck to it in a good way. Town.

Hollowkatt: comes in swinging to draw attention, early targeting on Raskol so reval as potential w/w there, seems to be worried about me an appropriate amount. Town

Nanook: enters by establishing slanker cred, immediately threatens to kill the person that helps him. Town


Winston: entry by Hardclaim, no additional posts. lean town

Lewynn: entry is softballed off previous post, but second post indicates reading of full thread, then back to softballing off another entry. Probs wolf

Pzelda: opens with a developed reads post which he just got wolf bombed for last time I saw him and he didn't get bombed for it here. May just have done a better job of it, but... Probs just town.

Panda: points out Pzeldas read post as unique, which is accurate, but wolfs it just for that without challenging the reads. Wolf

Many not posted yet. Gnome, Ibn, Laurentus, El, Vro...get your stuff together.

These three feel the thinnest and as possible fake reads of wolf buddies. Nanook and Panda might be pocket attempts, but there's no reason to tr town winston for his entrance.

Hi, I'm here. Are you town?

This feels like a very shy thread. Anyone could be a scummy scum scum. I read it all and am happily clueless.

I also am without the clues, Queen Gnome. Maybe they all are scum?

The whole GG/Winston conversation feels fake. I can't get over some wording in Gnome's posts such as scum scum and her asking other player if they're town.

[pzelda]

LA is a paragon, sorry I don't make the rules


fine


Why?


Not really?


this is bleh. Like, it feels like you're picking at the post for the reason that it happens to exist and that I gave the first read.


I feel mildly fine with him. Just vibes


I like Lewwyn for Lewwyn liking me for me liking Chessguy :p



Felt that I could get something in here but not really. I guess it's a good look that he's probably looking in the right spot for page 1, but as Pzelda says, not much to talk about yet. I guess I don't like that there's more scum potential than villa leans but w/e?


I think that Tims has only really made declarative statements?


Talk about these more pls


Bad

So here's my problem with Rask. It feels like he's mashing his mouthparts together and expecting something substantial to come out, but it's not. We've got his second sussing Csargo, that I was writing off as a joke until I saw this



literally everything Tims made at that point was declarative statements which didn't show any process, just an "ok I think that these three people are bad". He makes a "separate post" about Csargo which is all about him wanting to go full throttle for ??? reasons. I can write off the HK and Winston stuff as rask just doing whatever, but it feels like activity for activities sake

We also have this


This is just asking a question for it's own sake. Why would c4 change his read on me? I hadn't posted since

Ok, I need to see how this developed, but it's possible that Dolby tmi-ed Tim scum in his case on Rask.

[El-ahrairah]

Do you still think he's town?

I'm gonna go with no

[Csargo]

Ok, I need to see how this developed, but it's possible that Dolby tmi-ed Tim scum in his case on Rask.

Could you expand on what you mean here?

[El-ahrairah]

Sat in the garden drinking beer, AMA

[El-ahrairah]

Could you expand on what you mean here?

Do you have any thoughts about my EZ TR of Tim yesterday?

[Csargo]

I think if anyone gave Tim an easy TR it was me tbh

Are you the type of player who gives easy TRs to your woof partners?

[pzelda]

Tim can certainly confirm , can he not ?

Panda possibly forcing an interaction with Tim

[pzelda]

Could you expand on what you mean here?

I meant the way he attacked Rask for townreading Tim by pinning down very precisely the problematic nature of Tim's early posts. I don't think anyone else talked about them at that point. It could be a good eye, but in that case we should see more sussing of Tim in Dolby's iso later.

[pzelda]

Sat in the garden drinking beer, AMA

Confirmed lupine

[Winston Hughes]

Can you explain the reasons now? Or is this part of Monty being a bastard?

I meant that it was a gut reaction (or, more literally, some unconscious heuristic I had yet to identify).

When I reread later on, I'll see if I can figure out what I was seeing there.