Your post this time is a lot more helpful to the town, I commend you for it.

I believe that a no lynch at this point is critical. As you pointed out (and as I admitted) we can't just not lynch throughout the game. That does leave it to the Mafia (or the pro-town roles which I'll get to) to do the work for us, and is too passive an approach, I agree.

But in this round, is anyone really even somewhat convinced that one of Andres, Sarathos, Quintus, glyphz, or myself is Mafia? Note that the probability that one or more of us is a Mafia is high, but the fact that we have named 5 different people with really no evidence is just poor.

I did not feel Andres's suspicious play earlier was enough to offset the harm of lynching an innocent at this stage. Would I feel differently if there were 5 left? Yes. But at this point, I believe that we have a better shot at letting pro town roles have one or two more shots (an interviewer (roleblocker?) and someone who goes through garbage (detective?) were present in the write ups, and this watcher guy seems to say he does investigations). It's better then shooting wildly in the dark.

Also, I at least am using this time to figure out who is doing what. I suggest other members read the thread, especially Beefy's offical posts. For example, I cannot be the roleblocker and could not be active last night...this kind of data is needed.