Netherworld Mafia [Concluded]

[TinCow]

Pretty sure Abstain is not allowed,

Read the rules.

I do not allow Vote: No Lynch as an option. Period. You may abstain, however.

[gibsonsg91921]

Haha, there's three for Caius for meatball or no reasons. Shameless bandwagons!

Meatballing shouldn't lead to bandwagons, that's not the point.

Vote: Sasaki

Bandwagoner for meatballing.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Bandwagoning = discussion = more material to go back on later in the game when determining guilt.

[Hannibalbarc]

Vote: gibsonsg91921

[Beefy187]

Vote: Hannibalbarc

For not stating the reason.

[Hannibalbarc]

Vote: Hannibalbarc

For not stating the reason.

Bandwagoning = discussion

[Northnovas]

The first round is hard and I won't bandwagon, yet!

I vote: Abstain

[Beefy187]

Bandwagoning = discussion

its not bandwagon if you are the first one to vote.

Why gibson?

[FactionHeir]

vote: Proletariat

Dunno, just feel like it.

And there have been 3 kills with similar waeapons. 3 mafia = 3 kills or 2-4 mafia with 2 kills and a serial killer with 1?

[CountArach]

Vote: Hannibalbarc

For not stating the reason.

Unvote: Sasaki
Vote: Beefy

This is the first round, reasons are not really needed at all.

[Caius]

Unovte:Mouza
Vote:Sasaki

He wrote my name bad! I feel insulted! Ban Sasaki!

[Hannibalbarc]

It seems I missed a portion of page three (on my set up). Regardless of the Holmes reading, it's more on the reason I stated before really - he seemed too willing to follow GH's theory that a bandwagon equalled higher discussion levels without actually understanding what it meant. This could be a new player trying to follow a more experienced one, but I do doubt it.

I though bandwagoning meant to vote for some one without a reason, so what I was trying to saying, voting without a reason=discussion, and I didn't follow GH, none of us had a real reason for voting then, and when I voted, beefy replied with this,

Vote: Hannibalbarc

For not stating the reason.

So I answered with this, telling him we didn't need a reason.

Bandwagoning = discussion

[Caius]

Its pretty hard to reply to someone when I'm sleeping.

My vote on Caius was not because I believed him to be responsible in a series of Capo-vengeance killings, it's because he hadn't said anything of consequence. This is still the case. Thus, my vote stays

Well, some mafiosi from Capo is killing Prole, shlin, who were the last survivors of the town of Capo II.

[Drisos]

nice! I actually lived trough night 1

discussion = more material to go back on later in the game when determining guilt.

Indeed. on other forums I play mafia, people discuss lots less, and even in later game, no one has a clue who to vote. that's not the way to go.

and CA, someone has to be lynched, right? (I thought No Lynch wasn't an option in this game, to be precise) it's a matter of creating discussion/following intuition etc..

btw, my vote:

Beefy I think he acted pretty scummy, seamus already mentioned all.

btw, why all those 'random' votes on sasaki? I bet that's a 'just in case'.. hehe

[Mouzafphaerre]

.
Vote: Seamus

He tricked with the tally.
.

[seireikhaan]

Folks, we currently have a tie between Sasaki and Beefy187. The first of either of them to receive another vote will be lynched.

Current tally:

Sasaki: 5- Caius, CrazedRabbit, Gibsonsg91921, Fahad I, Ichigo

Beefy187: 5- CountArach, Seamus Fermanagh, Makanyane, Twilightblade, Drisos

Caius: 1- GeneralHankerchief

CrazedRabbit: 1- Woad and Fangs

Bananna Bob: 1- Tratorix

Gibson: 1- Hannibalbarc

HannibalBarc: 2- Omanes Alexandrapolites, Beefy187

Northnovas: 1- Proletariat

Proletariat: 1- FactionHeir

True Praetorian: 1- Rythmic

Makanyane: 1- Sasaki

Yaropolk: 1-Elite Ferret

TinCow: 1-Andres

Seamus Fermanagh: 1- Mouzafphaerre

Abstain: 2- Northnovas, Tincow

Not voting- Everyone else.

Also, I'm going to issue a warning to Seamus Fermanagh for his error in the tally. However, there was a long span between the previous tally(which he also did), so I'm going to issue a pardon and assume it was mere accident. However, I'd like to point to the spoiler right here.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

ALSO, PLEASE, PLEASE UPDATE THE TALLY WHENEVER YOU VOTE! IT WILL MAKE THIS RUN MUCH SMOOTHER!

Please take note of the spoiler. ^^^^^^^^^^^^

Also, I may be unable to access a computer for the next few hours, so once the tie is broken, that person is considered lynched, though the writeup for it may take a bit to get up. Night will begin immediately once either Sasaki or Beefy187 is lynched.

[gibsonsg91921]

Eenie, meenie, miny moe.

Vote: Sasaki

[pevergreen]

Read the rules.

my mistake, I thought it was the other way around.

[Andres]

Well, what can I say?

Congratulations Hades-guys

I told you guys to lynch TinCow, even before his reveal:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

- post 152:

Vote : TinCow

Sounds way too neutral. Also, it's too much explanation for a 1st round abstain vote.

- post 221:

I still don't like this post of TinCow:

With no information to go on, my natural instinct is to vote Sasaki, since I doubt I'll ever trust him anyway. That seems cheesy, though, and there's really no evidence to go on so far except for the numerous people claiming to have not received a PM. Some are probably telling the truth, but I would bet that at least one of them said that intentionally to make us think they were town. With nothing more to go on, I will wait and see if any evidence comes out. For now...

Vote : abstain

Hence why I voted him round 1:

Vote : TinCow

Sounds way too neutral. Also, it's too much explanation for a 1st round abstain vote.

My vote was ignored by TC.

And now you vote GeneralHankerchief because he misread the write-ups That's an awfully bad reason.

Neutral sounding post; very much unnecessary explanation, voting for a bad reason.

Vote : TinCow

My friend, I suspect you know more than you let on.

Oh come on Kommodus. Fahad is fairly new to mafia games and your reason for voting him is bad.

FoS : Kommodus

As for me being less active: I went to the Ardennen Friday, came back Sunday afternoon. And there's also Easter and the magic 30

Nobody ever listens to me

Thanks for hosting this one kamikhaan. This game was a blast

[shlin28]

*sigh*

I wish I wasn't just a simple townie...

But it was a very good game to watch

[Ferret]

dang....and I trusted you...

[Drisos]

Gah. Well done TC. I knew that town would most likely lose when W&F died.. they were waaay off on their lynches.

q- GH, why didn't you explain more. You guys had no clue who was anti-town, and I vouched for you to be lynched. If you had explained more I would've started shouting about lynching someone else.

q- Pever, why on earth did you mention any names at all when infiltrated in TC's town group? You should've just accepted your own death.. you knew the names of the detectives already anyway, right? instead of only you dying, you took the last two mafia W&F and Mak with you.. Not too brilliant.

Too bad that we were wiped out so soon... bad luck that we had one wogged, (WH) not brilliant play by me, because TC recognized my behaviour as supicious and so I got myself killed, makanyane was suspected by some all along as well, along with pever. W&F might've held out longer, if only pever wouldn't have mentioned names..

[naut]

Well done Hades...

Well like I said, I'd rather be played the fool by TC... turned out I was.