The Settlement [Concluded]

[Sasaki Kojiro]

hmm, since TinCow is claiming such a high duel score, perhaps we should have him challange a lurker. Better yet would be to have two lurkers challange each other. Maybe Lord Winter and CountArach? Would be good to eliminate some of these lurkers through duel rather than lynch.

[taka]

the problem with that is that you need th lukers to be online for them to challenge each other....

[TinCow]

hmm, since TinCow is claiming such a high duel score, perhaps we should have him challange a lurker. Better yet would be to have two lurkers challange each other. Maybe Lord Winter and CountArach? Would be good to eliminate some of these lurkers through duel rather than lynch.

I am not claiming any duel score, I'm simply talking smack.

[seireikhaan]

The option to challenge is not yours alone
Fortunately for you, since your butt I would own.
Therefore I must decline your offer to fight
For the corpse of a poet is not a delight.
I Reject: seireikhaan in the Thunderdome.

Oh no, fear not, for the Gods are with me.
Last night, the Gods issued forth a decree
They reached out their blessed hand
And made me yet more grand
So if you have honor left, do not flee!

[Askthepizzaguy]

You can beat me up, Seireikhaan. I might be dead, but I'll fight you!

[Jolt]

If TinCow is the sorcerer, I bet if he duels he'll have to use spells, which will give out his role, something he surely doesn't want it to happen. I will post something here soon enough concerning TinCow, as soon as I talk to a certain person.

[TinCow]

Is this person named AsktheSeamaki?

[Askthepizzaguy]

I had nothing to do with it this time. I wash my hands.

[Reenk Roink]

I am not claiming any duel score, I'm simply talking smack.

Thank you all for making reading the copious posts in this game worthwhile.

[seireikhaan]

TinCow clearly values his life too much,
Any townsperson would not do as such
He should not hide from me
And show us what he be
Come, let's see who fights the best in the clutch.

[Jolt]

Is this person named AsktheSeamaki?

Edit: bleh.

[White_eyes:D]

Unvote:Ichigo Vote:TinCow I am with Khaan on this one....TinCow is acting weird....and since I feel lynching a guy with three posts for this entire game is kinda sad....I will not help

[FactionHeir]

Its kinda sad that there is a challenge function but no one so far has accepted any challenge. The conditional acceptance seems to spoil the fun of it..

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I feel that white_eyes is a little to wild in his voting.

[Jolt]

I'll call TinCow out to explain himself tomorrow, as I'm very sleepy and must go to sleep. (2:30 AM here)

[Seamus Fermanagh]

A posting scan on Tincow:

72 of 1064 here, for 2.67ppp

127 of 2224 in G3 (townie), for 2.27ppp ended up lynched

110 of 1105 in Eph (townie), for 3.93ppp ended up lynched

45 of 823 in Chi (townie), for 2.14ppp ended up lynched

88 of 153 in Mid2 (jotun), for 2.25ppp won

80 of 1187 in M8 (townie), for 2.67 ended up lynched


If anything this reveals a slight trend to decrease posting a bit when mafia -- but Tincow's overall rate is pretty similar across the board.



Voting wise, he voted for Ares D2 (after voting for FH), voted for Pizza D3, Andres on D4, and is voting for Jolt now.

This voting pattern is inconclusive as well.


EDIT: Hey, I got the Battle of Hastings post!

[Askthepizzaguy]

I think that TinCow can be given one round of benefit of the doubt, while Ichigo still hasn't participated. I think he deserves less.

[Yoyoma1910]

Heh? What's with all these rhymes!

Don't you little whippersnappers know:


Poetry
Which Rhymes
Is for those
That need
Crutches.

[Yoyoma1910]

Vote:Ichigo


How dare this... man feel that he is too good to post in this thread.

[CountArach]

hmm, since TinCow is claiming such a high duel score, perhaps we should have him challange a lurker. Better yet would be to have two lurkers challange each other. Maybe Lord Winter and CountArach? Would be good to eliminate some of these lurkers through duel rather than lynch.

I'm not lurking because that implies I'm able to post. I was drunk thursday night and friday night and I worked 8am-5pm on Saturday and Sunday. I just got back from that shift and I'm incredibly tired. I'll try to get something up then.

[_Tristan_]

Vote : Tincow

I felt something scummy about him all along and already ALMOST voted for him, so here goes one more time, hoping this does the trick..

[naut]

Weekend was crazy.

Vote: abstain

[FactionHeir]

Seamus, if we don't take into account the pre-day 1 posts and posts made after game conclusion, what would those numbers be?

[Jolt]

Anyways, as everyone by now knows, FactionHeir was an investigator which was killed by the Mafia last night. Now, in the night he was killed, he investigated TinCow and according to his investigation results, it seems that TinCow has many books and odd contraptions in his tent, which may or may not be related to sorcery or alchemism. If so, then TinCow might just be our friendly neighbour Sorcerer. I must underline that FactionHeir can't quote the result PMs since he's dead.
TinCow's taste for books or contraptions might be added his odd behaviour which some townies have been noticing, ranging from his staunch defence of Ares (A confessed Serial Killer of Vode) to rejecting the duel of sereikhaan, which could give out his role. Now I have come forward in private for him to explain himself if he could, but he would want non of it, and has "allowed" me to put forth this evidence for public discussion. I hope that since this information is now public, TinCow can explain himself so we can see if he is the sorcerer or not. TinCow, you have the floor.

[Reenk Roink]

Its kinda sad that there is a challenge function but no one so far has accepted any challenge. The conditional acceptance seems to spoil the fun of it..

Yeah, I'll work on this should I host again...

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Seamus, if we don't take into account the pre-day 1 posts and posts made after game conclusion, what would those numbers be?

I have not really gone to the trouble of calculating things that way, assuming that the pre/post phases are more or less a wash as they tend to be fairly similar from game to game.

This pre phase was a bit longer than usual, however, at about 150 posts.

Just checked. Reenk opened play at post 162. Tincow had 8 posts during the 161-post prequel phase. That would give hime 64 of 903 or a rate of 2.78ppp. Please note, I have NOT done a baseline comparison with other games. The only thing unusual of note was that his posts jumped on the 12th before play began. Excited by contents of his PM? Just having lots of fun with the Marxist debate at the time?


Jolt:

Word has already spread pretty broadly about those detective results -- though no one has a full quote for the rules reasons you mention. Unfortunately, while they almost certainly confirm that Tincow has a role -- possibly a major role -- they bring us no closer to knowing the role intent. Sasaki's observations about Tincow's changed style (we've seen that frequency is pretty constant) very much support the idea that Tincow is a major role. But for whose side?

We've already seen that Reenk has things nicely twisted for us to unravel, so it's making some of us reticent to just jump up and target him.

This is not to say that your implications are off-base. You may well be dead on target. I'm still cogitating it.

[White_eyes:D]

I feel that white_eyes is a little to wild in his voting.

It's what I do, when I am townie....
ATPG and alot of others can confirm this......but I could also by mafia trying to hide behind it...WIFOM

[TinCow]

Anyways, as everyone by now knows, FactionHeir was an investigator which was killed by the Mafia last night. Now, in the night he was killed, he investigated TinCow and according to his investigation results, it seems that TinCow has many books and odd contraptions in his tent, which may or may not be related to sorcery or alchemism. If so, then TinCow might just be our friendly neighbour Sorcerer. I must underline that FactionHeir can't quote the result PMs since he's dead.
TinCow's taste for books or contraptions might be added his odd behaviour which some townies have been noticing, ranging from his staunch defence of Ares (A confessed Serial Killer of Vode) to rejecting the duel of sereikhaan, which could give out his role. Now I have come forward in private for him to explain himself if he could, but he would want non of it, and has "allowed" me to put forth this evidence for public discussion. I hope that since this information is now public, TinCow can explain himself so we can see if he is the sorcerer or not. TinCow, you have the floor.

An investigation result? On moi? Why would anyone investigate someone who is as clearly innocent as I am? Hmmm... I seem to have misplaced my own role PM somewhere and cannot seem to recall my own identity. Not surprising, as too much poetry rots the brain. Surely a proper investigation result from a detective would indicate whether I was guilty or innocent. Perhaps you can enlighten me as to whether I am good or evil by informing us all whether that investigation result said I was guilty or innocent.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Now that, right there, is reason enough to chuckle and leave TinCow alive for one round.



But we should lynch him eventually. Probably soon.

[Jolt]

An investigation result? On moi? Why would anyone investigate someone who is as clearly innocent as I am? Hmmm... I seem to have misplaced my own role PM somewhere and cannot seem to recall my own identity. Not surprising, as too much poetry rots the brain. Surely a proper investigation result from a detective would indicate whether I was guilty or innocent. Perhaps you can enlighten me as to whether I am good or evil by informing us all whether that investigation result said I was guilty or innocent.

I can't because I don't know since I haven't seen the Investigation results. FH, which has the investigation results, however seems to think you might be the sorcerer. And since he can't quote the results of his investigation, I'll just have to take his word for granted. If there is any other Pro-town investigator, then maybe he can investigate you. Since you can't explain yourself, I'll have to deduce you have something to hide. As such, the benefit of the doubt I gave you when you defended Ares is now expired.

Unvote: taka
Vote: TinCow